Features of Charged Lepton Flavor Violation in an A 4 Symmetric Neutrino Mass Model
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Features of Charged Lepton Flavor Violation in an A 4 Symmetric Neutrino Mass Model".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Neutrino flavour oscillations imply that there must be charged lepton flavour violation (CLFV) also Different neutrino mass models predict different patterns of CLFV decays In this work, we find that the meson CLFV decay amplitudes are not correlated to the corresponding radiative CLFV amplitudes, unlike in the case of see-saw models The branching ratios of radiative CLFV decays are predicted to be negligibly small in this model, but those of the meson CLFV decays can be large enough to be observable in the near future.
Kai: Model Description and Symmetry The model considered is based on the standard model (SM) gauge group but also has an additional A4 discrete symmetry The group A4, the alternating group of order four, consists of all even permutations of four elements.
Mira: A very attractive feature of this model is that it generates a TBM form for the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) matrix purely from symmetry and symmetry breaking.
Kai: The charged fermion content of this A4 model
6: is identical to that of the SM, with the same gauge quantum numbers.
Paper summary: Kai: So to recap, this paper is looking at a specific neutrino mass model based on A four symmetry that naturally produces a tri-bimaximal neutrino mixing matrix through symmetry breaking <ref:2507.23747#pg1>. The main point they make is that in this setup, the meson flavor changing neutral interaction amplitudes don't correlate with the radiative ones, which is unlike what you see in standard see-saw models <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Mira: And they go on to predict that while the radiative flavor changing neutral current decays will be practically unobservable, the meson flavor changing neutral current decays can have branching ratios large enough to be seen in the near future <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Lev: They also found that the A four symmetry forbids tree level mixing of neutral mesons, but they say that CLFV decays of mesons are possible at tree level in this model <ref:2507.23747#pg3>.
Kai: That's a big deal because it means we're not just looking at loop-level effects for meson decays; tree level is possible here, which opens up new avenues for searching <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Mira: The paper also predicts two very specific and unique CLFV decays of the tau lepton, specifically tau minus to mu minus mu minus e plus and tau minus to e minus e minus mu plus <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Lev: They put an upper limit on the branching ratio for both of those modes at about ten to the power of negative fourteen, which is six orders of magnitude smaller than the current experimental bound of one point five times ten to the negative eight <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Kai: So while they predict these specific tau decays are tiny, they also note that flavor violation in the charm sector is negligible in this model <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the title, "Features of Charged Lepton Flavor Violation in an A four Symmetric Neutrino Mass Model," it really highlights that we're looking at how a specific symmetry structure dictates the patterns of flavor violation across different types of decay processes <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Kai: And the authors are Pravesh Chndra Awasthi, Jai More, Akhila Kumar Pradhan, Kumar Rao, Purushottam Sahu and S. Uma Sankar from the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay <ref:2507.23747#pg1>. It's interesting how they tie a specific mathematical symmetry like A four to observable physical phenomena in lepton flavor violation <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Lev: The implication for us is that if this model is right, we should be looking for these specific meson CLFV decays, like the KL to mu plus e minus or B zero s to mu plus e minus, because the paper says those upper bounds are accessible at the next generation of experiments <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Kai: Right. So we're looking for these specific signatures in meson decays because the model suggests that other types of flavor violation might be too small to see right now <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Mira: And the whole point is that this A four symmetric neutrino mass model gives us a distinct prediction—that meson CLFV can be large enough to observe, while radiative CLFV is suppressed—which helps us narrow down what we should prioritize in our experimental searches <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Lev: So if we build experiments looking for these specific decays, finding them would give us a strong indication that this A four symmetric model is the correct framework describing neutrino mass generation <ref:2507.23747#pg1>.
Pravesh Chndra Awasthi, Jai More, Akhila Kumar Pradhan, Kumar Rao, Purushottam Sahu, S. Uma Sankar
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
hep-ph
Submitted: 2025-07-31
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: 22 pages, 3 figures, 6 Tables, Accepted in EPJC
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: Neutrino flavour oscillations imply that there must be charged lepton flavour violation (CLFV) also Different neutrino mass models predict different patterns of CLFV decays In this work…
Key concepts
- A4 Discrete Symmetry
- This mathematical symmetry group, the alternating group of order four, is added to the Standard Model. It plays a crucial role in generating the neutrino mixing matrix (PMNS) purely through symmetry breaking. This symmetry dictates many properties of the model's interactions and decay patterns.
- PMNS Matrix
- This matrix describes how neutrino flavors mix when they propagate through space. In this model, the A4 symmetry naturally leads to a 'tribimaximal' form for this matrix through specific symmetry breaking mechanisms involving scalar fields. This structure is key to understanding neutrino oscillations.
- Radiative vs. Meson CLFV
- The study compares two types of CLFV decays: radiative (involving photons) and meson (involving particles like kaons or B mesons). The A4 symmetry strongly suppresses radiative decays, making them nearly unobservable. However, the model allows for meson CLFV at tree level with branching ratios potentially large enough for near-future experiments to detect.
- Scalar Sector Fields
- The model includes several scalar fields ($\phi_0$, $\phi_i$, and $\chi_i$) which are necessary to achieve the desired PMNS matrix structure. These scalars interact with quarks, leading to flavor-changing neutral interactions (FCNI). The A4 symmetry restricts these couplings, forbidding tree-level neutral meson mixing but allowing CLFV decays.
Terminology
Summary
Neutrino flavour oscillations imply that there must be charged lepton flavour violation (CLFV) also Different neutrino mass models predict different patterns of CLFV decays In this work, we find that the meson CLFV decay amplitudes are not correlated to the corresponding radiative CLFV amplitudes, unlike in the case of see-saw models The branching ratios of radiative CLFV decays are predicted to be negligibly small in this model, but those of the meson CLFV decays can be large enough to be observable in the near future. p. 0
Model Description and Symmetry
The model considered is based on the standard model (SM) gauge group but also has an additional A4 discrete symmetry The group A4, the alternating group of order four, consists of all even permutations of four elements. A very attractive feature of this model is that it generates a TBM form for the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) matrix purely from symmetry and symmetry breaking. p. 3 The charged fermion content of this A4 model [6] is identical to that of the SM, with the same gauge quantum numbers. p. 3 Three right-handed neutrinos are added to the model to generate neutrino masses. p. 3
Scalar Sector and Mass Eigenstates
The model contains multiple scalar fields, which are needed to generate PMNS matrix in TBM form. These fields consist of ϕ0, which is an SU(2) doublet but an A4 singlet, ϕi (i = 1, 2, 3), which are SU(2) doublets and form an A4 triplet and χi (i = 1, 2, 3), which are SU(2) singlets but form an A4 triplet. p. 3 The complete field content of the model, along with their gauge and A4 quantum numbers, are summarised in table 1. p. 3 The minimisation of the Higgs potential with respect to the scalar field leads to the following relations between µ21, µ22 and the vevs of the scalar fields. p. 7
Flavor Changing Neutral Interactions (FCNI)
The flavour-changing couplings of the heavy neutral scalars to down-type quarks is of the form gij d¯diLdjRΦ02 + ˜gij d¯diLdjRΦ03 + gji d∗¯diRdjL Φ02∗ + ˜gji d∗¯diRdjL Φ03∗. The A4 symmetry of the model imposes the restriction that half of the FCNI couplings must be zero. p. 8 This implies that there is no neutral meson mixing at tree level, as discussed in the next section. p. 8
CLFV Decay Predictions
The analysis of the full scalar potential led to the proper determination of the mass eigenstates of the neutral scalars. p. 3 Among these, two neutral scalars have purely flavour-conserving couplings to fermions, while the other two have purely flavour-violating interactions. p. 8 The A4 symmetry of the model forbids the mixing of neutral mesons at tree level However, CLFV decays of mesons are possible at tree level. p. 2 The calculated upper bounds for the three decays, KL → µ+e−, B0s → µ+e− and B+ → K+µ+e−, are accessible at the next generation of experiments. p. 9 p. 9 p. 9
Radiative vs. p. 0 Meson Decays
The analysis shows that the radiative CLFV decays are extremely suppressed, to the extent of being practically unobservable, while the meson CLFV decays can occur with branching ratios large enough to be within reach of near-future experiments. This distinctive feature, arising due to the A4 symmetry, was also observed in our previous work [7]. p. 2 The model predicts two very interesting and unique CLFV decays of τ lepton, τ− → µ−µ−e+ and τ− → e−e−µ+. p. 1 p. 1 The calculated upper limit on the branching ratio for both these modes is of the order of 10−14, which is six orders of magnitude smaller than the present experimental bound of 1. p. 15 × 10−8 [37]. The CLFV in the charm sector is negligibly small. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 The flavour-violating decays of the top quark can be substantial in this model because the amplitudes will be proportional to the large top quark Yukawa coupling. p. 2 p. 2
Conclusion on Observability
The A4 symmetry of the model forbids the mixing of neutral mesons at tree level However, CLFV decays of mesons are possible at tree level. The calculated upper bounds for the three decays, KL → µ+e−, B0s → µ+e− and B+ → K+µ+e−, are accessible at the next generation of experiments. An observation of this decay in future experiments can be an indication of the validity of this model. p. 2 The calculated upper bound on the branching ratio for the order of 10−18 is obtained for some semi-leptonic decays. p. 2 The CLFV in the charm sector is negligibly small.
Summary of Key Findings
The A4 symmetry of the model forbids the mixing of neutral mesons at tree level However, CLFV decays of mesons are possible at tree level. The A4 symmetry of the model is a salient feature that naturally leads to the tribimaximal form of the PMNS matrix through symmetry breaking. p. 3 The analysis of the full scalar potential led to the proper determination of the mass eigenstates of the neutral scalars. The model predicts a distinctive charge selection rule of meson CLFV decays, for example, if M0 → l+ml−n is allowed then M0 → l−ml+n is forbidden. p. 2 The calculated upper bounds for the three decays, KL → µ+e−, B0s → µ+e− and B+ → K+µ+e−, are accessible at the next generation of experiments. The model predicts two very interesting and unique CLFV decays of τ lepton, τ− → µ−µ−e+ and τ− → e−e−µ+. The CLFV in the charm sector is negligibly small. The flavour-violating decays of the top quark can be substantial in this model because the amplitudes will be proportional to the large top quark Yukawa coupling. The branching ratios of radiative CLFV decays are predicted to be negligibly small in this model. p. 0 The meson CLFV decays can occur with branching ratios large enough to be observable in the near future. p. 0
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
A4 symmetry constrained flavour-changing neutral couplings to quarks can be used to predict specific zero couplings in Table 2, allowing AI systems to rapidly screen and prioritize potential experimental signals based on these symmetry constraints.
-
The model predicts that
the branching ratios of radiative CLFV decays are predicted to be negligibly small,
which allows AI systems to immediately discard or de-prioritize search channels for meson CLFV decays if the radiative decay channel is prioritized as a null result. -
AI systems can utilize the calculated upper bounds in Table 4 and Table 5, such as the
calculated upper bounds, predicted by the model,
to set tighter, theoretically informed limits on experimental searches for specific neutral meson CLFV decays like KL to mu plus e minus. -
The constraint that
if M0 (qiqj) → l+ml-n is allowed then M0 → l-ml+n is forbidden
can be incorporated into simulation models to test the validity of observed decay modes against the model's symmetry predictions. -
The analysis of the full scalar potential, including terms like
V (Φ, ϕ) = ρ1(Φ†Φ)1 (ϕ†ϕ) + ρ2(ϕ†ϕ)(ϕ†Φ),
enables AI to model complex new physics interactions beyond simple tree-level calculations for CLFV processes.
Sources
- A search for $\mu^+\to e^+\gamma$ with the first dataset of the MEG II experiment
- COMET Phase-I Technical Design Report
- Technical design of the phase I Mu3e experiment
- Neutrino Mass Models
- Charged Lepton Flavour Violating Meson Decays in Seesaw Models
- A_4 flavour symmetry breaking scheme for understanding quark and neutrino mixing angles
- Signatures of $A_4$ symmetry in the charged lepton flavour violating decays in a neutrino mass model
- Finite flavour groups of fermions
- NuFit-6.0: Updated global analysis of three-flavor neutrino oscillations
- Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
- The mu - e Conversion in Nuclei, mu --> e gamma, mu --> 3e Decays and TeV Scale See-Saw Scenarios of Neutrino Mass Generation
- Search for heavy neutral Higgs bosons decaying into a top quark pair in 140 fb$^{-1}$ of proton-proton collision data at $\sqrt{s}=13$ TeV with the ATLAS detector
- Search for lepton flavour violating decays of a neutral heavy Higgs boson to $\mu\tau$ and e$\tau$ in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s} =$ 13 TeV
- New Limit on Muon and Electron Lepton Number Violation from $K^0_L \to \mu^\pm e^\mp$ Decay
- Search for the lepton-flavour violating decays $B^0_{(s)} \rightarrow e^\pm \mu^\mp$
- Search for the lepton-flavour-violating decays $B^{0}_{s}\to\tau^{\pm}\mu^{\mp}$ and $B^{0}\to\tau^{\pm}\mu^{\mp}$
- Search for $B^{0} \to \tau^\pm \ell^\mp$ ($\ell=e,\mu$) with a hadronic tagging method at Belle
- Search for $B{}^0_s \rightarrow \ell^{\mp} \tau^{\pm}$ with the Semi-leptonic Tagging Method at Belle
- $K \to \pi$ semileptonic form factors with $N_f=2+1+1$ Twisted Mass fermions
- Lepton flavor violation in exclusive $b\to d\ell_i\ell_j$ and $b\to s\ell_i\ell_j$ decay modes
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses