From macro to micro: Economic complexity indicators for firm growth

arXiv:2507.21754 · econ.GN, q-fin.EC · Submitted 2025-07-29 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Economics. The day in economics: theory, mechanisms and the evidence beneath them.

Ruth: I'm Ruth.

Warren: And I'm Warren, here with Iris.

Ruth: We're looking at the paper: "From macro to micro".

Warren: Here's the gist of the paper. A rich theoretical and empirical literature investigated the link between export diversification and firm performance This paper examines which characteristics of a firm’s export basket predict future performance Core Research Question The central question addressed is which characteristics of a firm’s exported products anticipate firm growth This investigation seeks to bridge the gap between macroeconomic capability-based approaches and micro-level analyses of corporate performance The study focuses on two main dimensions: whether exporting products exported by wealthier countries is positively associated with future growth, and whether diversification within or outside a firm’s core production area matters for growth.

Ruth: Product Productivity as a Growth Predictor The authors propose that firms exporting products associated with higher levels of productivity tend to exhibit higher future Growth and Profit per Employee This is measured using the EXPY index, which is defined as the weighted average of logPRODY of all products exported by a company.

Warren: The intuition behind this metric is that high-GDP countries are, on average, more productive than low-GDP ones, and one of the ingredients of their high productivity is given by the products they focus on.

Ruth: Diversification Structure Effects The study introduces novel measures of in-block and out-of-block diversification based on algorithmically-detected production blocks The results reveal a stark contrast: diversification within the core (in-block) is negatively associated with firm growth, while diversification beyond the core (out-of-block) is positively associated.

Paper summary: Ruth: We’ve talked about what they claim—that product productivity and the structure of diversification matter—but let's summarize the main thrust of "From macro to micro: Economic complexity indicators for firm growth."

Warren: The paper uses a dataset of twelve thousand eight hundred fifty-two Italian firms, combining their export records with financial information from ORBIS > <ref:2507.21754#pg1>

Iris: They analyze which characteristics of a firm’s exported products predict future performance by focusing on whether products from wealthier countries matter and how diversification within or outside a core production area affects growth >

Ruth: The main finding is that the EXPY index, which measures the weighted average of product productivity across all exports, predicts both profit per employee and growth >

Warren: But it’s not just about that index; the structure of diversification matters too. They found a stark contrast: diversification within the core is negatively associated with firm growth, while diversification beyond the core is positively associated with growth >

Iris: This suggests that growth depends not only on how much a firm diversifies but also on specific strategies related to those production cores >

Ruth: It’s an attempt to take economic complexity theory, which is usually applied at the country level, and apply it down to the individual firm level >

Warren: The paper claims its contribution lies in developing methods for this complexity theory at the firm level, specifically using modularity maximization to define those in-block and out-of-block diversification measures >

Iris: They used community detection algorithms instead of standard sectoral classifications to identify these blocks, and they found that this algorithmic approach is more effective at capturing the structural effects >

Ruth: So what this means for us is that firm growth isn't just random chance or luck; it can be anticipated by looking at how a firm’s export basket is structured in terms of its core and its periphery >

Conclusion: Warren: Looking at the paper again, "From macro to micro: Economic complexity indicators for firm growth," the authors are essentially saying that firm growth isn't just about finding a good niche randomly.

Ruth: That’s right. They argue that it can be anticipated by looking at whether a firm exhibits high degrees of diversification both within and outside its defined production block >

Iris: The implication is that firms need to be strategic about where they diversify; diversifying away from their core activities seems to be the key driver for growth in this model >

Warren: So if you're thinking about a company, you look at its export mix. If it's too focused on its current area, that in-block diversification hurts performance according to their findings >

Ruth: And if they’re expanding into new areas outside that core cluster, that’s what actually predicts future growth >

Iris: The paper acknowledges a limitation there; it says the average complexity of products isn't associated with economic growth, and weakly associated with profit per employee >

Warren: So they are careful not to claim that every single product feature matters, just the overall productivity measure they defined >

Ruth: It gives us a framework where we can start identifying these structural effects using network analysis for real firm data instead of just relying on broad macroeconomic indicators like GDP >

Valerio De Stefanoa, Maddalena Mulab, Manuel Sebastian Marianid, Andrea Zaccariae

Department of Engineering and Science, Universitas Mercatorum · Department of Economics and Finance, Tor Vergata University of Rome · Enrico Fermi Research Centre · Department of Business Administration, University of Zurich · Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi (ISC-CNR), UoS Sapienza

econ.GN, q-fin.EC

Submitted: 2025-07-29

Updated: 2026-11-02

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 67/100

The gist: A rich theoretical and empirical literature investigated the link between export diversification and firm performance This paper examines which characteristics of a firm’s export basket predict…

Key concepts

EXPY index
This index measures a company's export product productivity by calculating the weighted average of logPRODY across all exported products. The idea is that products from countries with higher GDP are generally more productive, and this metric captures that advantage in a firm's export mix.
In-block diversification
This refers to diversifying a firm's exports within its existing core production area or 'block.' The research found this type of diversification is negatively linked to future firm growth, suggesting sticking closely to the core may hinder growth.
Out-of-block diversification
This measures the extent to which a firm diversifies its exports into areas outside its primary production block. The study demonstrated that this type of diversification is positively associated with firm growth, implying expanding beyond the core is beneficial for growth.
Community Detection Algorithms
These are advanced mathematical methods used to identify distinct groups or 'blocks' within a complex network of products and firms. The paper uses them instead of standard classifications to more accurately define a firm's core production area, leading to better results.

Terminology

Summary

A rich theoretical and empirical literature investigated the link between export diversification and firm performance This paper examines which characteristics of a firm’s export basket predict future performance

Core Research Question

The central question addressed is which characteristics of a firm’s exported products anticipate firm growth This investigation seeks to bridge the gap between macroeconomic capability-based approaches and micro-level analyses of corporate performance The study focuses on two main dimensions: whether exporting products exported by wealthier countries is positively associated with future growth, and whether diversification within or outside a firm’s core production area matters for growth.

Product Productivity as a Growth Predictor

The authors propose that firms exporting products associated with higher levels of productivity tend to exhibit higher future Growth and Profit per Employee This is measured using the EXPY index, which is defined as the weighted average of logPRODY of all products exported by a company. The intuition behind this metric is that high-GDP countries are, on average, more productive than low-GDP ones, and one of the ingredients of their high productivity is given by the products they focus on. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The intuition behind this metric is that high-GDP countries are, on average, more productive than low-GDP ones, and one of the ingredients of their high productivity is given by the products they focus on. Even if the logPRODY metric is not explicitly connected with the concept of capabilities, we can, however, expect that it to contain some information about them, given its correlation with economic complexity measures of products’ sophistication (Angelini et al.

Diversification Structure Effects

The study introduces novel measures of in-block and out-of-block diversification based on algorithmically-detected production blocks The results reveal a stark contrast: diversification within the core (in-block) is negatively associated with firm growth, while diversification beyond the core (out-of-block) is positively associated. This suggests that growth may depend not only on how much a firm diversifies but also on specific diversification strategies with respect to the respective production cores. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Surprisingly, our results reveal a stark contrast: diversification within the core (in-block) is negatively associated with firm growth, while diversification beyond the core (out-of-block) is positively associated. These findings suggest that growth may depend not only on how much a firm diversifies but also on specific diversification strategies with respect to the respective production cores.

Key Findings and Implications

The regression analysis shows that EXPY predicts both Profit per Employee and Growth, going beyond previous works Coherence exhibits a significant positive association with Profit per Employee but not with Growth. Furthermore, only the out-of-block diversification is positively associated with Growth, while in-block diversification exhibits a negative association These findings call for a data-driven identification of production areas or blocks based on complex network methodologies and community detection. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This is revealed by introducing novel measures of in-block and out-of-block diversification, based on algorithmically-detected production blocks. Our findings suggest that growth is driven not just by how many products a firm exports, but also by where these products lie within the production ecosystem, at both local and global scales.

Methodological Contributions

The research develops methods of economic complexity theory—traditionally applied at the country level—for the firm level It introduces in-block and out-of-block diversification indicators based on modularity maximization to distinguish between diversification within and outside a firm’s core block. The use of community detection algorithms is shown to be more effective than standard sectoral classifications for identifying these structural effects. p. 7

Where the paper says it

A standard method to achieve this objective is the maximization of bipartite modularity, for which several optimization algorithms have been introduced in network science (Fortunato and Hric, 2016). Here we apply the BRIM algorithm (Bipartite Recursively Induced Modules) because of its wide use, efficiency, and known reliability in bipartite graphs (Barber, 2007) – we refer to Appendix B for definitions and implementation details.

Data and Context

The study leverages a unique longitudinal dataset covering export and financial data for 12,852 Italian firms This dataset combines detailed firm-level export records from ISTAT with financial information from ORBIS. The Italian context is ideal because it allows the observation of firm-level growth patterns across a wide range of industries. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Moreover, Italy provides an ideal empirical context: as a country with high economic complexity and broad export diversification across sectors (Tacchella et al. , 2012), it allows us to observe firm-level growth patterns across a wide range of industries.

Conclusion

The results suggest that firm growth is not merely the result of idiosyncratic opportunities, but it can be anticipated by looking at whether the firm exhibits a high degree of diversification within and outside of its block The findings offer valuable insights into how export level of productivity (EXPY) and firm-level diversification strategies can influence economic performance. This work contributes to the discussion of firm growth and profit, offering a perspective on how export-basket composition and diversification patterns are associated with firm economic performance. p. 4

Where the paper says it

, 2013), and (ii) are worthwhile and advantageous from a market perspective. Adapting this reasoning to the firm level, firms exporting products associated with higher-income countries are likely to possess more complex and valuable capabilities and/or make strategic diversification choices, which may signal a stronger foundation for future growth and profit gains.

Acknowledgements

We thank Andrea Mazzitelli for useful discussions M.S.M. acknowledges support from the Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant No. p. 4

Where the paper says it

, 2013), and (ii) are worthwhile and advantageous from a market perspective. Adapting this reasoning to the firm level, firms exporting products associated with higher-income countries are likely to possess more complex and valuable capabilities and/or make strategic diversification choices, which may signal a stronger foundation for future growth and profit gains.

100013–207888) A.Z. acknowledges the PRIN project No 20223W2JKJ “WECARE”, financed by the Italian Ministry of University and Research (MUR). p. 0
Where the paper says it

From macro to micro: Economic complexity indicators for firm growth Valerio De Stefanoa , Maddalena Mulab,c, Manuel Sebastian Marianid , Andrea Zaccariae,c aDepartment of Engineering and Science, Universitas Mercatorum, Rome, I-00186, Italy bDepartment of Economics and Finance, Tor Vergata University of Rome, Rome, I-00133, Italy cEnrico Fermi Research Centre, Via Panisperna 89 A, Rome, I-00184, Italy dDepartment of Business Administration, University of Zurich, Zurich, CH-8032, Switzerland e Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi (ISC-CNR), UoS Sapienza, Rome, I-00185, Italy Abstract A rich theoretical and empirical literature investigated the link between export diversification and firm performance. Prior theoretical works hinted at the key role of capability accumulation in shaping production activities and performance, without however producing product-level indicators able to forecast corporate growth.

Appendix Details

The Sapling Similarity is defined as a function of co-occurrences, degrees, and the total number of firms in the bipartite network The BRIM algorithm was applied to partition the firm-product bipartite graph into communities to maximize modularity. The average complexity of products is not associated with economic growth, and weakly associated with Profit per Employee. p. 4

Where the paper says it

To answer this question, we test whether the indicator EXPYf , defined as the weighted average of logPRODYp of all products exported by a company, is significantly and positively associated with Growth and Profit per Employee at the firm level. In doing so, our objective is to identify a firm-level indicator inspired by the economic complexity framework that is significantly related to future firm growth, which is lacking in previous work.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

To answer this question, we test whether the indicator EXPYf , defined as the weighted average of logPRODYp of all products exported by a company, is significantly and positively associated with Growth and Profit per Employee at the firm level. In doing so, our objective is to identify a firm-level indicator inspired by the economic complexity framework that is significantly related to future firm growth, which is lacking in previous work.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

To answer this question, we test whether the indicator EXPYf , defined as the weighted average of logPRODYp of all products exported by a company, is significantly and positively associated with Growth and Profit per Employee at the firm level. In doing so, our objective is to identify a firm-level indicator inspired by the economic complexity framework that is significantly related to future firm growth, which is lacking in previous work.

The in-block and out-of-block diversification measures computed directly using the Harmonized System sectoral classifications are not significantly associated with firm growth, at odds with the results for the in-block and out-of-block diversification calculated through the BRIM algorithm. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Products are classified using Harmonized System codes with a six-digit resolution level, for a total of 5, 203 different products in our dataset. This high level of product resolution enables a detailed mapping of the export portfolios of firms and is crucial to constructing our network-based indicators, particularly the in-block and out-of-block diversification measures.

The average complexity of products is not associated with economic growth, and weakly associated with Profit per Employee. The average complexity of products is not associated with economic growth, and weakly associated with Profit per Employee.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Predictive Capability Index for Firm Growth: The improved system can estimate future firm growth by calculating EXPY, defined as the weighted average of logPRODYp of all products exported by a company, which is positively associated with both Growth and Profit per Employee.

  2. Diversification Strategy Optimization: The system can determine optimal diversification strategies for firms by distinguishing between in-block and out-of-block diversification using community detection algorithms, as the findings show that diversification outside of a firm’s core production area is positively associated with future growth, whereas diversification within the core is negatively associated with firm growth.

  3. Performance Predictor for Profit per Employee: The system can predict profit per employee by incorporating coherence metrics, as Coherence exhibits a significant positive association with Profit per Employee, suggesting that firms that focus on highly-related products can focus on similar capabilities, which allows them to increase their efficiency and reduce production costs.

Abstract

A rich theoretical and empirical literature has investigated the link between export diversification and firm performance. Prior theoretical works hinted at the key role of capability accumulation in shaping production activities and performance, without however producing product-level indicators able to forecast corporate growth. Building on economic complexity theory and the corporate growth literature, this paper examines which characteristics of a firm's export basket anticipate future performance. We analyze a unique longitudinal dataset that covers export and financial data for 57,586 Italian firms. We find that firms exporting products typically exported by wealthier countries -- a proxy for products characterized by a greater level of productivity and sophistication -- tend to experience higher growth and labour productivity. Crucially, where firms diversify matters: Across firms, only diversification outside of a firm's core export area is positively associated with future growth, whereas diversification within the core is negatively associated. This is revealed by introducing novel measures of in-block and out-of-block export diversification, based on algorithmically-detected blocks. Our findings suggest that growth is associated not just with how many products a firm exports, but also with where these products lie within the production ecosystem, at both local and global scales.

Sources

Related papers