Quark and lepton mixing in the asymptotically safe Standard Model

arXiv:2507.18304 · hep-ph, gr-qc, hep-th · Submitted 2025-07-24 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quark and lepton mixing in the asymptotically safe Standard Model".

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now called "Quark and lepton mixing in the asymptotically safe Standard Model". We just touched on how this framework connects quark and lepton mixing, but let's talk about who did the heavy lifting here.

Mira: The authors are Eichhorn, Gyftopoulos, and Held. They bring different strengths to this problem: one is working on quantum hardware stuff, another is a theorist focused on condensed matter systems, and the third is an error correction researcher for real hardware.

Lev: That combination helps them see how these high-energy concepts translate down into something that might actually be testable in terms of computational feasibility or physical constraints.

Kai: I'm interested in how they connect the CKM matrix structure, which is near-diagonal, with the PMNS matrix structure, which is much less so.

Mira: That difference in structure between the two mixing matrices is what makes this a problem for alternative theories because their renormalization group flows are determined by similar equations.

Lev: So they have to find a way to break that equivalence for the lepton sector, which they do by saying some condition has to be violated at all scales.

The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what this paper says about the CKM matrix and PMNS matrix in this asymptotically safe Standard Model, it shows that both can be explained by a fixed-point cascade starting from a true ultraviolet completion of the Standard Model.

Mira: This cascade has three stages: first, there's a bottom-dominated fixed point in the very deep ultraviolet, then there's a top-dominated regime at Planck scale up to some intermediate scale, and finally, we get to the Standard Model regime with its well-established renormalization group flow without gravity.

Lev: The fixed point cascade itself comes from the interplay between top and bottom Yukawa couplings with that Abelian hypercharge, which determines what happens to all those other Yukawa couplings and mixing matrices.

Kai: And in terms of results, they found some specific testable things. First, the relation Vud squared plus Vus squared equals one is already an infrared attractive relation in the bottom-dominated regime, whereas a similar one for CKM doesn't hold quite as strongly <ref:2507.18304#pg1>.

Mira: They also noted that experimental data fit their expectations because they show those relations holding with much higher accuracy than we might have expected based on naive estimates.

Lev: And crucially, they found that neutrino Yukawa couplings are limited in size because the critical exponents in this fixed-point cascade are tiny all along the way, leading to dynamically limited neutrino Yukawa couplings.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out some things they think we should look at more closely, suggesting improvements to their framework. For instance, they suggest that the relation Vud squared plus Vus squared equals one is an infrared attractive relation already in the bottom-dominated regime, while Vcd squared plus Vcs squared does not follow that same trend <ref:2507.18304#pg1>.

Mira: They also suggest that for the PMNS matrix, because of how their evolution equations work, the equivalent condition has to be violated at all scales, meaning the sum of neutrino mass squared terms divided by the mass difference times Yukawa coupling must be smaller than one everywhere.

Lev: That violation implies that the tau Yukawa coupling cannot be large over a very wide range of scales and that the overall mass scale for Dirac neutrinos shouldn't be too high. It sets a constraint on those couplings.

Kai: And they also found some concrete predictions about the fundamental parameters of asymptotically safe quantum gravity, suggesting how to fix things like fg, fy, and lambda by using the cascade features.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up this paper on "Quark and lepton mixing in the asymptotically safe Standard Model", they found that combining the Standard Model with a parameterization of asymptotically safe quantum gravity allows them to fix parameters so that they get a fixed-point cascade that agrees with experimental data for SM couplings within three sigma and within the matching prescription.

Kai: This leads to bounding the gap between top and bottom mass from above, which is good, and it confirms that neutrino Yukawa couplings are limited in their size.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this means we have a constrained space for these couplings to exist in the model that can actually be simulated on real hardware if we want to build anything based on it.

Kai: It seems like they've managed to reconcile the seemingly disparate structures of quark and lepton mixing using this fixed-point mechanism.

Mira: They've shown that this approach works for CKM matrix elements, and by extending the ideas, they can get a dynamically limited picture for neutrino Yukawa couplings.

Lev: So it’s a consistent picture where both the CKM and PMNS mixings arise naturally from the same underlying physics of an asymptotically safe Standard Model.

Astrid Eichhorn, Zois Gyftopoulos, Aaron Held

Institute for Theoretical Physics, Heidelberg University · Institut de Physique Théorique Philippe Meyer, Laboratoire de Physique de l’s École normale superieure (ENS), Université PSL, CNRS, Sorbonne Université, Université Paris Cité

hep-ph, gr-qc, hep-th

Submitted: 2025-07-24

Updated: 2026-10-09

Importance score: 69/100

The gist: The paper learns that both quark mixing (CKM) and lepton mixing (PMNS) can generically be explained within an ultraviolet completion of the Standard Model with gravity…

Key concepts

CKM Matrix
The Cabbibo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix describes quark mixing in the Standard Model. The paper notes that its elements are near-diagonal and satisfy approximate relations like $|V_{ud}|^2 + |V_{us}|^2 = 1$, which are characteristic of a fixed line in the Renormalization Group flow.
PMNS Matrix
The PMNS matrix describes lepton mixing. The analysis shows that for this matrix, the equivalent RG flow condition must be violated. This violation implies that tau-Yukawa couplings cannot be large over many scales, constraining the overall mass scale of Dirac neutrinos.
Fixed-Point Cascade Mechanism
This mechanism explains the observed mixing patterns by describing a three-stage evolution: a bottom-dominated UV regime, a top-dominated intermediate regime, and the Standard Model regime. This cascade is driven by the interplay between top and bottom Yukawa couplings and hypercharge.
Dynamically Limited Neutrino Yukawas
The ultraviolet completion of gravity dynamically limits the size of neutrino Yukawa couplings. This occurs because critical exponents in the fixed-point cascade are tiny, preventing these couplings from becoming arbitrarily large, which is necessary to avoid large neutrino mixing.

Terminology

Summary

The paper learns that both quark mixing (CKM) and lepton mixing (PMNS) can generically be explained within an ultraviolet completion of the Standard Model with gravity, which results in approximate relations between CKM matrix elements. p. 0 The ultraviolet complete theory must avoid large neutrino mixing by dynamically limiting the size of neutrino Yukawa couplings, tying large neutrino mixing to small Dirac neutrino masses and a mass gap in Standard Model fermion masses. p. 0

The CKM Matrix Constraints

The Cabbibo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix is near-diagonal, whereas the lepton mixing (PMNS) matrix is not. The experimental values approximately satisfy the relations Vud 2 + Vus2 = 1, Vcd 2 + Vcs2 = 1, i. p. 6e., due to unitarity Vub2 = 0, and Vcb2 = 0. p. 1 These relations characterize a fixed line of the Renormalization Group (RG) flow that ends in a fixed point at Vud 2 = 1 = Vcs2, etc. p. 1 The accuracy with which these hold translates into the length of asymptotically safe scaling regimes. p. 0

Explaining Lepton Mixing

The difference in structure between the CKM matrix and the PMNS matrix is a problem for alternative b) because their RG flows are determined by equivalent evolution equations. The analysis shows that for the PMNS matrix, the equivalent condition must be violated, i. p. 2e., Σm2i j/∆m2i j · y2h ≪ 1 at all scales. p. 0 This implies that the tau-Yukawa must not be large over a large range of scales and that the overall mass scale for Dirac neutrinos must not be too large. p. 2

The Fixed-Point Cascade Mechanism

The paper discovers a fixed-point cascade that realizes these mechanisms in the full Standard Model, starting from a true UV completion of the SM. This cascade consists of three stages: First, a bottom-dominated fixed-point regime in the very deep UV, second, top-dominated regime at MPlanck < k < Mtr, and third, a SM-regime with the well-established RG flow in the SM without gravity. p. 3 The fixed point cascade owes its existence to the interplay of top- and bottom-Yukawa couplings with the Abelian hypercharge which determine the fixed-point properties for all Yukawa couplings and mixing matrices. p. 3

Predictive Power and Results

The analysis yields several testable consequences, including:

  1. The relation |Vud |2 + |Vus|2 = 1 is an IR attractive relation already in the bottom-dominated regime, whereas |Vcd |2 + |Vcs|2 = 1 does not.

  2. Experimental data satisfy our expectation since they show that the relations hold with significantly higher accuracy than expected. p. 6

  3. Neutrino Yukawa couplings are limited in their size due to the critical exponents being tiny throughout the fixed-point cascade, leading to dynamically limited neutrino Yukawa couplings. p. 4

  4. The Higgs quartic coupling is an irrelevant coupling all along the fixed-point cascade, and its IR value is predicted as a prediction of [132]. p. 6

Conclusion

The combination of the Standard Model with a parameterization of asymptotically safe quantum gravity allows for fixing parameters such that we obtain a fixed-point cascade that agrees with experimental data for SM couplings within 3σ and within the matching prescription. The resulting gap between top and bottom mass is bounded from above, and neutrino Yukawa couplings are limited in their size. p. 6

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced prediction of CKM matrix element accuracy based on RG flow regimes. The improved system can predict that the relation Vud 2 + Vus 2 = 1 holds with significantly higher accuracy than Vcd 2 + Vcs 2 = 1 and that experimental data satisfy our expectation since Vud 2 + Vus 2 = 0.99999 ± 0.00044.

  2. Dynamic constraint on neutrino Yukawa couplings based on ultraviolet completion. The system can predict that asymptotically safe gravity dynamically limits the size of neutrino Yukawa couplings and that the observed large gap in the spectrum of fermion masses in the SM is both a prerequisite for significant neutrino mixing as well as a natural consequence within our fixed-point cascade.

  3. Precise determination of free parameters for asymptotically safe quantum gravity. The system can fix the parameters fg, fy, and flambda by using gY, yt and λH are accurate predictions of the cascade which we use to set fg, f y and fλ.

  4. Prediction of specific fixed-point cascade features for gauge couplings. The system can predict that the Abelian gauge coupling is constant at gY AS = 0.47 in the asymptotically safe fixed-point regime, if we fix fg = 9.749·10−3.

  5. Calculation of the scaling behavior of CKM matrix elements across different regimes. The system can predict that X + Y − 1 ∼ exp(−θi t), where i = top/bottom − dominated and Z + W − 1 ∼ exp(−θtop−dominated t).

Sources

Related papers