Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity

arXiv:2507.17862 · hep-th, gr-qc, hep-ph · Submitted 2025-07-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity investigates how Lorentzian quantum gravity modifies the infrared and ultraviolet behavior of matter spectral functions by employing a spectral renormalisation group to study photon and scalar two-point functions in a template matter sector.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The study begins with the classical action of a gravity-matter system, which includes a U(1) gauge field, a minimally coupled uncharged scalar field, and a fermionic field carrying a U(1) charge with Yukawa interaction.

Mira: The classical Einstein-Hilbert action is augmented to include gauge-fixing and ghost actions.

Kai: The metric field is split into a background and fluctuation field, where the fluctuation field has mass dimension one.

Paper summary: Mira: So, to summarize what they're doing here, they start with the classical action for gravity coupled to a U(one) gauge field, a scalar field, and fermions with a Yukawa interaction > <ref:2507.17862#pg2,a U(1) gauge field, a>.

Kai: And they augment that classical action with the Einstein-Hilbert terms plus gauge fixing and ghost actions >.

Lev: The core claim is that by using this spectral renormalisation group method in Lorentzian signature, they can determine the photon and scalar two-point functions even at strong coupling levels >.

Mira: They do this by deriving a flow equation for the spectral function, which involves taking a derivative of its KL representation with respect to RG time >.

Kai: And the result is that they get coupled integro-differential equations for these spectral functions, and they propose an ansatz for the spectral function of both the gauge and scalar fields >.

Lev: The flow equations involve terms like the derivative of the spectral function with respect to RG time plus a term from their regulator >.

Mira: They solve these under a quenched approximation, neglecting the feedback from fermion loops, and they find a unique interacting UV fixed point at specific coupling values >.

Kai: That fixed point is at one point: (g star N, mu star h, mu star A, mu star phi) equals one point zero six, minus zero point three four, minus zero point one seven and minus zero point zero one eight >.

Lev: The paper says the critical exponents for gravity and matter couplings separate out in the ultraviolet regime >.

Kai: And then those UV-IR trajectories connect this fixed point to both classical general relativity and standard particle physics in the infrared limit >.

Mira: What this means for us is that matter spectral functions no longer automatically qualify as physical observables once you put quantum gravity in there because they depend on gauge-fixing parameters >.

Kai: So, the primary impact seems to be providing a UV-completion with U(one) and Yukawa couplings settling into free or interacting fixed points > <ref:2507.17862#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at the title, "Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity," it’s about how gravity affects the energy spectrum of light or scalar particles >.

Mira: And the authors, Kher, King, Litim, and Reichert, they are investigating these two-point functions in a system that includes gauge fields and fermions >.

Lev: What this paper really points to is that the spectral functions aren't just simple numbers; they contain an on-shell delta peak plus some multi-particle continua from the quantum fluctuations of gravity and fermions >.

Kai: And there’s a specific point about the fermion contribution, which they say is universal, positive, and dominates below the Planck scale down to the fermion mass threshold >.

Mira: But then there's this interesting detail about gauge dependence arising from the one-loop graviton contribution in the deep infrared limit >.

Lev: They show a diagram with a graviton regulator insertion that is fully positive and dominates in the infrared, while another diagram with a matter regulator insertion is mostly negative and dominates in the ultraviolet >.

Kai: That sign flip leads to something important, they say it causes a divergence in the respective form factors >.

Mira: So, for someone listening to this paper, it suggests that these spectral functions aren't entirely physical observables on their own because of those gauge dependencies >.

Lev: The paper also flags a limitation: they need quantum-corrected vertices to be able to test the unitarity of quantum gravity with matter directly >.

Kai: So the main thing for the world is that this provides a framework, first key ingredients, for testing how quantum gravity interacts with matter by constructing gauge-independent spectral functions >.

Varun Kher, Brandon King, Daniel F. Litim, Manuel Reichert

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex

hep-th, gr-qc, hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-07-23

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 19 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, 106003 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/n2yv-hlq5

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity investigates how Lorentzian quantum gravity modifies the infrared and ultraviolet behavior of matter spectral functions by employing a spectral…

Key concepts

Spectral Renormalisation Group
This is a mathematical tool used to study how physical quantities change across different energy scales. It works by applying a modified dispersion relation (the Wilsonian regulator) to spectral functions, allowing researchers to track their evolution from high energies (UV) down to lower energies (IR) while preserving spectral representations.
Spectral Function
This function describes the distribution of particles and excitations in a quantum field theory. It is related to the propagator, which tells us how particles propagate. In this work, it is analyzed using coupled integro-differential equations that describe its flow under the renormalization group.
UV-IR Trajectories
These trajectories show how the system's behavior changes as energy scales vary from very high (UV) to very low (IR). The study connects a specific interacting fixed point in the UV with classical general relativity and standard particle physics in the IR, mapping out the full quantum gravity landscape.
Gauge Dependence
Spectral functions calculated in this model can depend on arbitrary choices made during calculations, such as gauge-fixing parameters. This dependence arises from loop corrections involving graviton contributions and is a key finding showing why these functions alone are not automatically physical observables.

Terminology

Summary

Matter Spectral Functions from Quantum Gravity investigates how Lorentzian quantum gravity modifies the infrared and ultraviolet behavior of matter spectral functions by employing a spectral renormalisation group to study photon and scalar two-point functions in a template matter sector. p. 0

Theoretical Framework

The study begins with the classical action of a gravity-matter system, which includes a U(1) gauge field, a minimally coupled uncharged scalar field, and a fermionic field carrying a U(1) charge with Yukawa interaction. The classical Einstein-Hilbert action is augmented to include gauge-fixing and ghost actions. p. 1 The metric field is split into a background and fluctuation field, where the fluctuation field has mass dimension one. p. 1 The matter action contains standard kinetic terms for the scalar field, fermionic field, and gauge field through the spin-covariant derivative. p. 1

Renormalisation Group Methodology

The main computational tool is the spectral renormalisation group, which is a version of functional renormalisation group based on a modified dispersion relation due to the Wilsonian regulator function Rk. This method preserves spectral representations at all RG scales while allowing access to spectral functions, including at strong coupling. p. 1 A simple Callan-Symanziktype regulator is employed, which shifts the on-shell contributions and avoids non-trivial cuts and poles in the complex propagator plane. p. 2 The flow equation for a spectral function is derived by taking a derivative of its KL representation with respect to RG time. p. 3

Spectral Function Analysis

The spectral function is related to the propagator via the relation GΦ(⃗p, p0) = Z ∞ 0 λ dλ π ρΦ(λ, ⃗p) λ squared + p squared 0. The flow of the two-point function is governed by the equation ∂tρΦ(λ) = −2 Im G Φ ∂tΓ k[Φ] + ∂tRk. p. 3 This leads to coupled integro-differential equations for the spectral functions that are solved in this work. p. 3 The ansatz for the spectral function of the gauge and scalar field is given by ρΦ = 1/Z Φ h 2πδ(λ squared − m 2ϕ) + θ(λ squared − (mϕ + mh) 2)f Φ,grav(λ) + θ(λ squared − 4mψ)f Φ,ferm(λ). p. 3

Fixed Points and Trajectories

The flow equations for the couplings are solved under the quenched approximation, where the feedback of the fermion loop is neglected. The analysis reveals a unique, interacting UV fixed point at (g∗N, µ∗h, µ∗A, µ∗ϕ) = (1. p. 606, −0.34, −0.17, −0.018). The critical exponents of gravity and matter couplings disentangle in the UV. p. 6 The UV-IR trajectories connect the fixed point with classical general relativity and standard particle physics in the IR. p. 6

Conclusions on Observables

The study shows that spectral functions of photons or uncharged scalars no longer automatically qualify as physical observables once quantum gravity is present because they depend on gauge-fixing parameters. The primary impact of quantum gravity is to provide a UV-completion with U(1) and Yukawa couplings taking free or interacting fixed points. p. 4 Matter spectral functions comprise an on-shell delta-peak and two multi-particle continua, one each from graviton and fermion diagrams. p. 5 The fermion contribution is universal, positive, and dominates below the Planck scale down to the fermion mass threshold. p. 8

Relation to Form Factors

The spectral functions translate into form factors of the quantum effective action via relations like fϕϕ(p 2) = G-1 ϕ(p 2) = Z ∞ 0 λ dλ π ρΦ(λ) λ squared + p squared-1. The form factors display a divergence around the Planck scale, becoming negative thereafter, which is linked to the negative parts in the respective spectral function. p. 8 The gauge-field spectral function is the only one remaining below the fermion mass threshold and is invariably negative for β > 3α. p. 9 The gauge dependence of spectral functions due to the one-loop graviton contribution is visible in the deep IR limit. p. 8

Fermion Dominance in UV

The fermion contribution from the fermion loop is fully positive and has two scaling regimes: ∼ λ-2 below the Planck scale, and ∼ λ η∗ Φ−2 above the Planck scale. The fermion diagram dominates in the UV only if Nf(g∗Y) squared g∗N ≳ O(100) or Nf(yt) squared g∗N ≳ O(1000). p. 8 Therefore, either a very large number of fermion flavours or a highly non-perturbative gauge or Yukawa coupling is needed to make the fermion loop dominate in the UV. p. 3 The graviton diagrams almost always dominate over the fermion loop ones in the UV. p. 8

Gauge Dependence and Sign Flip

The gauge dependence of spectral functions due to the one-loop graviton contribution is already visible in the deep IR limit. The diagram with the graviton regulator insertion is fully positive and dominating in the IR, while the diagram with the matter regulator insertion is mostly negative. p. 9 This latter diagram dominates in the UV, which explains the sign flip in the full spectral function. p. 9 The sign change leads to a divergence in the respective form factors (Fig. p. 3 7).

Future Directions

The work provides a framework and first key ingredients for testing the unitarity of quantum gravity with matter by constructing gauge-independent spectral functions that encode physical scattering processes. These require quantum-corrected vertices to allow for direct tests of unitarity for quantum gravity with matter. p. 0 The study looks forward to more extensive studies in the future. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced ability to predict ultraviolet behavior of matter spectral functions by utilizing asymptotic safety trajectories for gauge and Yukawa couplings, as shown in Figure 2. This allows AI systems to determine if a UV completion exists for Standard Model-like sectors without relying solely on perturbative renormalizability.

  2. Capability to analyze the sign flip in matter spectral functions around the Planck scale based on graviton contributions versus fermion contributions, as detailed in Section VI C and Figure 4. This helps distinguish between physical observables and non-physical results derived from quantum gravity effects.

  3. Functionality to estimate bounds on graviton anomalous dimensions, such as eta h gauge less than 0.3 or scalar less than-54, based on positivity conditions for spectral functions, as mentioned in Section VI D and equation (41). This provides a quantitative assessment of the required corrections for spectral positivity.

  4. Precision in calculating the infrared behavior of matter spectral functions by comparing results from functional renormalisation group flow with effective field theory findings, as noted in Section VI A and C. This improves the AI's ability to predict long-distance particle properties under quantum gravity corrections.

  5. Ability to derive gauge dependent spectral functions using the one-loop graviton contribution formulas in equation (37). This allows for a more nuanced understanding of how gauge fixing parameters affect observable quantities, such as photon and scalar spectral functions, in the deep infrared limit.

Sources

Related papers