Exotic superconducting states in altermagnets

arXiv:2507.10700 · cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2025-07-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Exotic superconducting states in altermagnets".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates magnetism and superconductivity from a fundamental symmetry perspective, utilizing irreducible co-representations (coreps) of altermagnetic spin-point groups (SPGs) to construct and tabulate all symmetry-allowed pairing functions, uncovering numerous exotic pairing states.

Kai: Three primary focuses are detailed: (i) a non-unitary superconductor exhibiting different spatial anisotropies for the spin-up and spin-down condensates; (ii) a half-and-half metal-superconductor where Cooper pairs only form from one of the two spin components; and (iii) a spin chiral superconductor characterized by spinpolarized edge states.

Mira: The construction employs two complementary methods: unitary halving groups with Dimmock indicators and direct computation from corep matrices obtained via projectors.

Kai: This analysis reveals exotic pairing states, including a spin-triplet superconductor whose spin-up and spin-down pairing functions are related by an "altermagnetic superconductor" symmetry, a "half-and-half metal-superconductor," and "spin chiral superconductors" that break the antiunitary symmetries of the normal state altermagnet.

Paper summary: Kai: So, this paper is called "Exotic superconducting states in altermagnets," and it looks at magnetism and superconductivity from a symmetry perspective using these irreducible co-representations of the spin-point groups.

Mira: It claims they construct and tabulate all symmetry allowed pairing functions for altermagnets, which uncovers numerous exotic pairing states.

Kai: They focus on three main things: first, a non unitary superconductor with different spatial anisotropies for the spin up and spin down condensates.

Lev: And second, a half and half metal superconductor where only electrons with one of the two spin components form Cooper pairs.

Mira: And third, a spin chiral superconductor characterized by spin polarized edge states.

Kai: The authors show that this first state exhibits an unusual fractional ac Josephson current for only one of the two spin polarizations.

Lev: That’s interesting because on real hardware, you need to account for those different periodicities in the current response.

Mira: And they do show how phenomenological Ginzburg Landau theories connect these results to stable minima of free energies.

Kai: The paper uses two ways to construct these basis functions: unitary halving groups with Dimmock indicators and direct computation from corep matrices using projectors.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I wonder how much overhead that complex matrix math actually lands on when you try to implement this in a real superconducting circuit.

Mira: It seems they use higher dimensional coreps to identify those spin chiral superconductors, which break the antiunitary symmetries of the normal altermagnet state.

Kai: So what does it mean when they say the spin polarized half and half metal superconductor breaks that two sigma parallel to g symmetry?

Mira: It means that by confining the gap only to one spin subspace, you’re breaking that specific symmetry, which is why Cooper pairs only form from one component.

Lev: If you have a system where only one spin component pairs up, how does that change the standard theory for Cooper pair formation?

Kai: The paper shows this state breaks the antiunitary symmetry of the collinear order, which allows those spin subspaces to possess finite Chern numbers, resulting in chiral boundary modes.

Mira: That’s significant because those chiral modes are what drive the topological response in these systems.

Lev: So if we look at topological classification in Table SVIII, they show that if antiunitary symmetry is broken by the complex order parameter, you get a Chern number computed for each spin subspace.

Kai: If you have an altermagnet where this antiunitary symmetry is symmetric, then the invariants are one and three dimensional winding numbers.

Mira: The anisotropic spin space locking they find leads to these exotic spin polarized topological responses, like those fractional ac Josephson currents for only one of the two polarizations.

Lev: That suggests that for a real device, you can design something where you only get the current from one spin channel.

Kai: They also computed the fractional ac Josephson effect for junctions between two altermagnetic superconductors with pairing potentials defined by Delta zero D plus k sub x over k F plus D minus k y over k F.

Mira: And what they found is that the spatial dependence dictated by the altermagnetic symmetry yields different periodicities depending on whether you are looking at S equals one pairs or S equals negative one pairs.

Lev: So for a spin up current, it has a four pi periodicity, but for a spin down current, it has a two pi periodicity that scales with one over Z zero squared.

Kai: That scaling with one over Z zero squared is what enables the generation of ac spin polarized superconducting currents.

Mira: It’s interesting because the spin up current shows four pi periodicity, while the spin down current is two pi periodic and scales with one over Z zero squared, which lets you generate ac spin polarized superconducting currents.

Lev: That tells us that even in a system with two components, you can have different frequency responses for each component.

Kai: The paper points to material examples like the quasi-2D organic compound family kappa BEDT TTF two X, specifically kappa BEDT TTF two Cu N C N Br, which shows altermagnetic behavior under pressure <ref:2507.10700#pg2>.

Mira: That material is important because it’s a real system where you can observe this behavior in the context of superconductivity.

Lev: From an error correction point of view, if you try to implement this on real hardware, the complexity of managing those spin polarized channels adds significant overhead.

Kai: So, to wrap up, we have an altermagnetic superconductor with a non unitary order parameter and anisotropic spatial anisotropies.

Mira: We also have a half and half metal superconductor where only one spin component forms Cooper pairs.

Lev: And finally, various spin chiral superconductors that break antiunitary symmetries.

Kai: The implication here is that we need to start investigating superconductivity in altermagnets with more than two components and designing devices that exploit spin polarization and these exotic symmetry groups.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper "Exotic superconducting states in altermagnets" looks at how magnetism and superconductivity work together using some math called irreducible co-representations of spin-point groups.

Mira: It claims they found a bunch of new pairing functions that are allowed by these symmetries, and they uncovered some really exotic states.

Kai: They focused on three main things. First, a superconductor that isn't unitary, where the up and down spin parts have different spatial shapes for their condensate.

Mira: And second, a half-and-half metal superconductor where only one of the two spin components actually forms Cooper pairs.

Lev: And third, they looked at spin chiral superconductors which have these special spin polarized edge states.

Kai: The authors show that this first state has a fractional ac Josephson current for only one of the two polarizations.

Mira: That means when you build a device, you can get a specific frequency response tied to just one spin channel, which is pretty neat.

Lev: It’s interesting because the paper connects these theoretical states to stable minima in the free energy calculation.

Kai: They use two different ways to build these basis functions—one using unitary halving groups with Dimmock indicators and another by computing them directly from corep matrices using projectors.

Mira: And they use those higher dimensional coreps to actually identify those spin chiral superconductors that break the antiunitary symmetries of the normal altermagnet state.

Lev: So what it means is that these new pairing states are breaking some fundamental symmetries of the material itself, which opens up a whole new way to think about superconductivity in these materials.

Kai: If you're thinking about building something, this suggests that we need to start looking at superconductivity in altermagnets with more than two components and designing devices that exploit these spin polarizations.

Mira: We also have some real material examples mentioned, like the kappa BEDT TTF two X family under pressure, which shows this altermagnetic behavior in a physical system.

Lev: That's good context because it grounds these mathematical concepts in something that exists outside of pure theory.

Kai: So, essentially the authors are mapping out a whole new landscape of possible superconductivity based on spin symmetry groups.

Mira: It’s about showing how the underlying magnetic structure dictates what kind of pairing you can actually have.

Kirill Parshukov, Andreas P. Schnyder

Max Planck Institute for Solid State Research

cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2025-07-14

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 72 pages, 9 figures, 130 tables

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, 254409 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/7zl4-35wd

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: The study investigates magnetism and superconductivity from a fundamental symmetry perspective, utilizing irreducible co-representations (coreps) of altermagnetic spin-point groups (SPGs) to…

Key concepts

Irreducible Co-representations (Coreps)
These are mathematical tools used to systematically construct all symmetry-allowed pairing functions by analyzing the fundamental symmetry groups of the material. By using coreps, researchers can determine which superconducting states are physically possible under the specific altermagnetic spin-point group.
Altermagnetic Spin-Point Groups (SPGs)
These are specific mathematical groups that describe the magnetic symmetries present in altermagnets. Analyzing these SPGs allows researchers to categorize and classify all possible pairing states, revealing exotic superconducting behaviors that go beyond standard models.
Spin Chiral Superconductors
These are superconductors characterized by spin-polarized edge states. They arise when the order parameter breaks antiunitary symmetries of the normal state altermagnet, leading to topological properties like finite Chern numbers and chiral boundary modes.
Fractional ac Josephson Effect
This effect describes the current flow across junctions between two altermagnetic superconductors. The study found that the spatial dependence imposed by alternamagnetic symmetry leads to different periodicities (4π or 2π), allowing for the generation of ac spin-polarized superconducting currents.

Terminology

Summary

The study investigates magnetism and superconductivity from a fundamental symmetry perspective, utilizing irreducible co-representations (coreps) of altermagnetic spin-point groups (SPGs) to construct and tabulate all symmetry-allowed pairing functions, uncovering numerous exotic pairing states. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Here, we study this interplay from a fundamental symmetry perspective using irreducible co-representations of the altermagnetic spin-point groups. We construct and tabulate all symmetry-allowed pairing functions for altermagnets, which uncovers numerous exotic pairing states.

Three primary focuses are detailed: (i) a non-unitary superconductor exhibiting different spatial anisotropies for the spin-up and spin-down condensates; (ii) a half-and-half metal-superconductor where Cooper pairs only form from one of the two spin components; and (iii) a spin chiral superconductor characterized by spinpolarized edge states. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We construct and tabulate all symmetry-allowed pairing functions for altermagnets, which uncovers numerous exotic pairing states. We focus on three of them, namely: (i) a non-unitary superconductor with different spatial anisotropies for the spin-up and spin-down condensates, (ii) a half-and-half metal-superconductor where only electrons with one of the two spin components form Cooper pairs, and (iii) a spin chiral superconductor with spinpolarized edge states.

The construction employs two complementary methods: unitary halving groups with Dimmock indicators and direct computation from corep matrices obtained via projectors. p. 0

Where the paper says it

To derive the basis functions of the superconducting orders, we employ two complementary approaches, namely, (1) by means of the unitary halving groups with Dimmock indicators [56–58], and (2) directly from the corep matrices obtained by projectors [56]. Both methods yield identical results and unveil a number of exotic pairing states, whose spin and spatial parts are interrelated in a highly nontrivial manner.

This analysis reveals exotic pairing states, including a spin-triplet superconductor whose spin-up and spin-down pairing functions are related by an altermagnetic superconductor symmetry, a half-and-half metal-superconductor, and spin chiral superconductors that break the antiunitary symmetries of the normal state altermagnet.

Phenomenological Ginzburg-Landau theories are presented to show correspondence with stable minima of free energies. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Interestingly, the first of these three superconductors exhibits an unusual fractional ac Josephson current for only one of the two spin polarizations. We present phenomenological Ginzburg-Landau theories for these unconventional superconductors and show that they correspond to stable minima of the free energies.

The study examines topological properties, the influence of small spin-orbit coupling (SOC), potential material examples, and their topological responses. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We present phenomenological Ginzburg-Landau theories for these unconventional superconductors and show that they correspond to stable minima of the free energies. We examine their topological properties, study the effects of small spin-orbit coupling, consider possible material examples, and investigate their topological responses.

The corep basis functions are constructed using both approaches (1) and (2). p. 8
Where the paper says it

First, we describe the construction of spin-point group irreducible co-representations (coreps) in Sec. Using the constructed coreps we discuss two approaches to the construction of their basis functions in Sec.

Higher-dimensional coreps lead to the identification of spin chiral superconductors. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Effect of spin-orbit coupling 6 SVI. Higher-dimensional coreps and spin chiral superconductors 7 SVII.

The superconducting order is shown to break altermagnetic symmetries: the spin-polarized half-and-half metal-superconductor breaks (2 sigmag) symmetry, confining the gap to one spin subspace. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The superconducting order can break altermagnetic symmetries. The spin-polarized half-and-half metalsuperconductor breaks (2§||g) symmetry and has the gap only in one spin-subspace.

The spin chiral state breaks antiunitary symmetry of the collinear order (T 2 sigmaE), allowing the spin subspaces to possess finite Chern numbers, which results in chiral boundary modes. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The spin-polarized half-and-half metalsuperconductor breaks (2§||g) symmetry and has the gap only in one spin-subspace. Spin chiral state breaks antiunitary symmetry of the collinear order (T 2§||E), such that the spin subspaces can carry finite Chern numbers leading to chiral boundary modes.

The fractional ac Josephson effect is computed for junctions between two altermagnetic superconductors with pairing potentials delta 0(D+k x/k F + D-k y/k F). p. 4

Where the paper says it

Fractional ac spin Josephson effect — The altermagnetic superconducting state has an exotic spatial anisotropy. For spin S = 1 and S = −1 pairing potentials, the spatial dependence is related by the alternamagnetic symmetry.

This analysis demonstrates that the spatial dependence dictated by alternamagnetic symmetry yields different periodicities: 4 pi periodicity for S=1 pairs and 2 pi periodicity for S=-1 pairs. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The phase has the time dependence φ(t) = 2eV t/ℏ, and it changes adiabatically. S = 1 pairs contribute similarly as in the 1D p-wave superconductor leading to 4π periodicity.

Specifically, the spin-up current exhibits 4 pi periodicity, while the spin-down current is 2 pi-periodic and scales with 1/Z 0 squared, enabling the generation of ac spin-polarized superconducting currents. p. 4
Where the paper says it

At the same time, the S = −1 pairs current is 2π periodic. The 4π periodicity is due to the topological boundary state in the spin-up subspace, whereas the spin-down subspace does not support the boundary modes for the chosen termination [see Fig.

Topological classification is summarized in Table SVIII. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Higher-dimensional coreps and spin chiral superconductors 7 SVII. Topological classification 9 SVIII.

If antiunitary symmetry (T 2 sigmaE) is broken by the complex order parameter, the two-dimensional invariant is a Chern number computed for each spin subspace. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The invariants are determined for each of the spin-subspaces. If the anti-unitary symmetry (T 2§||E) is broken by the complex order parameter, the two-dimensional invariant is the Chern number computed for each of the spinsubspaces.

In (T 2 sigmaE) symmetric superconductors, the invariants are one- and three-dimensional winding numbers. p. 3
Where the paper says it

If the anti-unitary symmetry (T 2§||E) is broken by the complex order parameter, the two-dimensional invariant is the Chern number computed for each of the spinsubspaces. In (T 2§||E) symmetric superconductor the invariants are one- and three-dimensional winding numbers.

The anisotropic spin-space locking leads to exotic spin-polarized topological responses, such as fractional ac Josephson currents for only one of the two spin polarizations. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The topological degeneracies and anisotropic spin-space locking lead to exotic spin-polarized topological responses, e. , fractional ac Josephson currents for only one of the two spin polarizations.

Material examples include the quasi-2D organic compound family kappa -(BEDT-TTF) 2 X, specifically kappa -(BEDT-TTF) 2 Cu[N(CN) 2]Br, which exhibits altermagnetic behavior under pressure. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Material example— κ-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu[N(CN)2]Br is a member of quasi-2D organic compound family κ- (BEDT-TTF)2X. The compound becomes altermagnetic Figure 3: (a) Quazi-two-dimensional κ-(BEDT-TTF)2X compound lattice with the magnetic order.

The key findings are: (i) an altermagnetic superconductor with non-unitary order parameter and anisotropic spatial anisotropies; (ii) a half-and-half metal-superconductor where only one spin component forms Cooper pairs; and (iii) various spin chiral superconductors that break antiunitary symmetries. These pairings establish foundations for investigating superconductivity in altermagnets, exploring novel states with more than two components, and designing superconducting devices exploiting spin polarization and exotic SPG symmetries. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The spatial fluctuations of the phases can lead to exotic topological defects [73–76], similar to phase vortices in 2D superconductors [77, 78]. (iii) Design of novel superconducting devices that exploit the spin-polarization of the Cooper pair condensates together with the exotic spin-point group symmetries.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can construct all symmetry-allowed pairing functions for altermagnets by systematically using irreducible co-representations of spin-point groups, thereby uncovering numerous exotic pairing states.

  2. The system can analyze and predict exotic superconducting states such as a non-unitary superconductor with different spatial anisotropies for the spin-up and spin-down condensates, a half-and-half metal-superconductor where only electrons with one of the two spin components form Cooper pairs, and a spin chiral superconductor with spinpolarized edge states.

  3. The system can derive phenomenological Ginzburg Landau theories for these unconventional superconductors by showing that they correspond to stable minima of the free energy functional, enabling prediction of their stability.

  4. The AI can examine topological properties of these superconducting states and study the effects of small spin-orbit coupling, allowing for investigation into their responses and possible material examples.

  5. The system can classify topological phases using invariants determined by whether the antiunitary symmetry (T 2§E) is broken by the complex order parameter, distinguishing between Chern numbers in two-dimensional superconductors and one- and three-dimensional winding numbers.

  6. The system can compute fractional ac Josephson currents for only one of the two spin polarizations in altermagnetic superconducting states by analyzing the different periodicities of the S = 1 and S = -1 pairing potentials.

Abstract

The interplay between magnetism and superconductivity is one of the central topics of condensed matter physics, which has recently been put into new light by the discovery of altermagnets. Here, we study this interplay from a fundamental symmetry perspective using irreducible co-representations of the altermagnetic spin-point groups. We construct and tabulate all symmetry-allowed pairing functions for altermagnets, which uncovers numerous exotic pairing states. We focus on three of them, namely: (i) a non-unitary ``altermagnetic superconductor'' with different spatial anisotropies for the spin-up and spin-down condensates, (ii) a ``half-and-half metal-superconductor" where only electrons with one of the two spin components form Cooper pairs, and (iii) a ``spin chiral superconductor'' with spin-polarized chiral edge states. Interestingly, the first of these three superconductors exhibits an unusual fractional ac Josephson current for only one of the two spin polarizations, even though the two condensates are symmetry related. We present phenomenological Ginzburg-Landau theories for these unconventional superconductors and show that they correspond to stable minima of the free energies. We examine their topological properties, study the effects of small spin-orbit coupling, consider possible material examples, and investigate their topological responses.

Sources

Related papers