Evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t - J - J ladder

arXiv:2507.07545 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2025-07-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t - J - J ladder".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates the evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t-J model by tuning inter-plane spin interaction and doping ratio By means of the density matrix renormalization group calculations, we obtain the quantum phase diagram of the system by tuning J⊥ in a large doping range δ = 1/8 − 1/2 We find that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer superconductivity by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states Evolution of Superconducting Phases The study systematically maps out the ground-state phase diagram of the t-J-J⊥ model using DMRG simulations By tuning doping ratio δ = 0.125 − 0.5 and J⊥, several phases are identified In the presence of a relatively large J⊥, the inter-plane SC always emerges except at the special doping level δ = 0.5 At smaller doping ranges where the two-leg ladder is in the Luther-Emery liquid, in-plane SC evolves to inter-plane SC either through an intermediate charge density wave (CDW) phase or directly, depending on doping ratio This emergent CDW phase appears to develop from the CDW state of the two-leg ladder at δ = 1/4 When in-plane SC evolves directly to inter-plane SC, DMRG data find no evidence of a coexistence At larger doping ranges when the two-leg ladder is a Luttinger liquid, strong inter-plane SC develops when the Luttinger liquids are gapped by a relatively large J⊥ In the intermediate J⊥ regime where in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, quasi-long-range inter-plane SC develops with the power exponent Kzz SC ∼ 1 Characterization of Quantum States The quantum states are characterized by computing various correlation functions such as the charge density profile, spin-spin correlation function, and single-particle Green’s function The charge density order is analyzed using the averaged charge density for each column n(x) The spin-spin correlation function F(r) is defined to characterize the spin sector The single-particle Green’s function G(r) is also computed to probe the electronic structure Specifically, for in-plane pairing correlation Pαα(r), bond orientations xx, yy, and zz are used to analyze superconductivity Coupling Scenarios and Transitions The paper explores two main coupling scenarios: coupling two Luther-Emery liquid states via J⊥ and coupling two Luttinger liquids via J⊥ When coupling two LEL states at δ = 0.1875, growing J⊥ suppresses Pyy(r) and enhances Pzz(r), leading to the inter-plane ZZ-SC phase at J⊥/J & 0.8 When coupling two single-layer LEL states at δ = 0.375, the system remains in the LEL phase up to J⊥/J ≈ 0.6 before transitioning to the ZZ-SC phase for stronger J⊥ For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ Phase Diagram Mapping The phase diagram mapping involves fitting the central charge at various doping levels to diagnose different states For δ = 0.125, 0.1875, and 0.25, the fitted central charge is close to zero, indicating a fully gapped state The CDW state of the two-leg ladder at δ = 0.25 extends to a finite doping range when two layers are coupled The results suggest that the CDW states belong to the same phase across different doping levels Coupling Three-Leg Ladders For the wider system size by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders, inter-plane SC observed near δ = 0.5 at large J⊥ is also stable at smaller doping ranges This suggests that the inter-plane SC phase can be stabilized by strong J⊥ over a large doping range Appendix B demonstrates that ZZ-SC emerges at strong J⊥ for both δ = 0.375 and δ = 0.5 when coupling two three-leg ladders A strong J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio, with CDW phases appearing at intermediate doping levels In the intermediate J⊥ regime where in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, an enhanced quasi-long-range inter-plane SC develops with Kzz SC ∼ 1 The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states Where the Gains Come From The gains come from systematically studying the ground-state phase diagram of the t-J-J⊥ model by means of DMRG simulations This approach allows for a detailed identification of emergent phases and transitions in this complex interacting system The analysis provides insights into how the interlayer coupling drives the evolution of superconductivity from intralayer to interplane states The work concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio, with CDW phases appearing at intermediate doping levels The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states Appendix A: Coupling Two C0S1 States via J⊥ At δ = 0.5, the single-layer two-leg t-J ladder is the special C0S1 state with a gapless spin mode and gapped charge mode By employing the J⊥ coupling between the twoleg ladders, one can expect the fully gapped spin mode above a critical J⊥ Since SC will not emerge, this case was not systematically studied in previous DMRG calculations Appendix B: Coupling Two Three-Leg Ladders via J⊥ For both δ = 0.375 and δ = 0.5, the ZZ-SC phase can emerge at strong J⊥ when coupling two three-leg ladders The density correlation D(r) and interlayer pairing correlation Pzz(r) exhibit power-law decay, while F(r), G(r), and Pyy(r) decay exponentially, showing the stable ZZ-SC by coupling two three-leg t-J ladders via a strong J⊥ Final Summary When the single layer sits in either the LEL or TLL phase, a strong J⊥ can always drive an inter-plane SC By coupling two LEL states, the evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states Final Summary 2 When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist Final Summary 3 For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong Final Summary 4 The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states Final Summary 5 When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist Final Summary 6 For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong Final Summary 7 The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states Final Summary 8 When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist Final Summary 9 For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong Final Summary 10 The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states Final Summary 11 When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist Final Summary 12 For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong Final Summary 13 The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states Final Summary 14 When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist Final Summary 15 For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.

Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at this paper, "Evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t - J - J ladder", the authors are essentially saying that you can always get an interlayer superconductivity if you have a strong inter-plane interaction by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states.

Mira: And they emphasize that this evolution from intralayer to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio, with CDW phases appearing at intermediate doping levels, which is where the system shows some interesting structure.

Lev: From an experimental standpoint, what this means is that you have a tool to tune J sub perpendicular to drive superconductivity into existence across different regimes of the model.

Kai: It suggests that we can use this tuning ability to explore how interlayer coupling dictates whether you get in-plane or inter-plane pairing in real materials.

Mira: The implication is that the structure you see, like those charge density waves at intermediate doping levels is a key feature to watch for when searching for these kinds of exotic superconducting states.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at this paper by Kai and Mira on "Evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t - J - J ladder."

Mira: It maps out how tuning the inter-plane spin interaction, that J sub perpendicular to the plane, can force the system to switch its pairing from happening within a single layer to happening between the two layers.

Lev: So, if you're building this on hardware right now, it means we have a way to potentially engineer interlayer coupling directly into our materials by adjusting that specific interaction parameter.

Kai: Exactly. The core idea is that strong J sub perpendicular can drive an interlayer superconductivity even when the individual layers are just in their normal liquid states, like the Luther-Emery liquid or the Luttinger liquid.

Mira: And they show this evolution isn't just one thing; it depends heavily on doping ratio, with these intermediate charge density wave phases popping up as a bridge between the two pairing types.

Lev: That’s interesting because for actual error correction schemes, knowing if you're in a stable inter-plane state versus a fluctuating CDW phase is crucial for determining how much overhead you need to deal with.

Kai: It suggests that the transition from one type of pairing to another isn't always a sharp break; sometimes it’s this gradual evolution through those density waves.

Mira: And they also found that for three-leg ladders, this robust inter-plane superconductivity stays stable over a much wider doping range when you crank up that J sub perpendicular interaction.

Lev: That stability across different coupling scenarios, whether it's two or three legs, suggests this mechanism might be quite versatile in how we can control the physics of these bilayer systems.

Kai: It really puts the focus on how interlayer interaction dictates the final superconducting state in these strongly correlated electron systems.

Mira: And what they show is that once you get strong enough coupling, you’re always looking at some form of interlayer pairing, whether it's a direct jump or through an intermediate phase.

Lev: So, the next thing we need to see is how this applies when we actually try to measure these correlations on real experimental setups.

Great Bay Institute for Advanced Study · School of Physical Sciences, Great Bay University School of Physics, Institute of Physics Chinese Academy of Sciences, State Key Laboratory of Quantum Functional Materials Guangdong Basic Research Center of Excellence for Quantum Science Southern University of Science and Technology Quantum Science Center Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2025-07-10

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, 225122 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/hhh7-fb39

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: The paper investigates the evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t-J model by tuning inter-plane spin interaction and doping ratio By means of the density matrix…

Key concepts

t-J model
This is a theoretical model used to describe strongly correlated electron systems, particularly those relevant to high-temperature superconductivity. It combines hopping (t) and on-site repulsion (J) terms, allowing physicists to study how electrons interact in materials like cuprates.
Luther-Emery liquid (LEL)
This describes a specific quantum state of the two-leg ladder where the charge sector is gapped but the spin sector remains gapless. It represents a state where in-plane superconductivity can evolve into inter-plane superconductivity depending on how strongly the layers are coupled.
Luttinger liquid (TLL)
This refers to a quantum state of one-dimensional systems where both charge and spin excitations are gapless. In this context, it describes the behavior of the ladder when doping is in a certain range, influencing how interlayer coupling affects pairing.
$J_{\perp}$
This term represents the strength of the interaction between electrons on adjacent layers (inter-plane coupling). Tuning $J_{\perp}$ is a key experimental parameter used to drive the system from purely in-plane superconductivity to a more complex interlayer superconducting state.

Terminology

Summary

The paper investigates the evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in a bilayer t-J model by tuning inter-plane spin interaction and doping ratio By means of the density matrix renormalization group calculations, we obtain the quantum phase diagram of the system by tuning J⊥ in a large doping range δ = 1/8 − 1/2 We find that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer superconductivity by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states

Evolution of Superconducting Phases

The study systematically maps out the ground-state phase diagram of the t-J-J⊥ model using DMRG simulations By tuning doping ratio δ = 0.125 − 0.5 and J⊥, several phases are identified In the presence of a relatively large J⊥, the inter-plane SC always emerges except at the special doping level δ = 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

5 and J⊥, we identify several phases as shown in Fig. In the presence of a relatively large J⊥, the inter-plane SC always emerges except at the special doping level δ = 0.

5 At smaller doping ranges where the two-leg ladder is in the Luther-Emery liquid, in-plane SC evolves to inter-plane SC either through an intermediate charge density wave (CDW) phase or directly, depending on doping ratio This emergent CDW phase appears to develop from the CDW state of the two-leg ladder at δ = 1/4 When in-plane SC evolves directly to inter-plane SC, DMRG data find no evidence of a coexistence At larger doping ranges when the two-leg ladder is a Luttinger liquid, strong inter-plane SC develops when the Luttinger liquids are gapped by a relatively large J⊥ In the intermediate J⊥ regime where in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, quasi-long-range inter-plane SC develops with the power exponent Kzz SC ∼ 1

Characterization of Quantum States

The quantum states are characterized by computing various correlation functions such as the charge density profile, spin-spin correlation function, and single-particle Green’s function The charge density order is analyzed using the averaged charge density for each column n(x) The spin-spin correlation function F(r) is defined to characterize the spin sector The single-particle Green’s function G(r) is also computed to probe the electronic structure Specifically, for in-plane pairing correlation Pαα(r), bond orientations xx, yy, and zz are used to analyze superconductivity

Coupling Scenarios and Transitions

The paper explores two main coupling scenarios: coupling two Luther-Emery liquid states via J⊥ and coupling two Luttinger liquids via J⊥ When coupling two LEL states at δ = 0.1875, growing J⊥ suppresses Pyy(r) and enhances Pzz(r), leading to the inter-plane ZZ-SC phase at J⊥/J & 0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

2(b) and 2(c), we show the pairing correlations P yy(r) and P zz(r). Clearly, the growing J⊥ suppresses P yy(r) and enhances P zz(r).

8 When coupling two single-layer LEL states at δ = 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Given the numerical challenges of DMRG simulation at weak J⊥ and identification of the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, we will not address this issue in this work. Direct transition from in-plane to inter-plane SC phase When coupling two single-layer LEL states at δ = 0.

375, the system remains in the LEL phase up to J⊥/J ≈ 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

1875, as illustrated in Fig. The system remains in the LEL phase up to J⊥/J ≈ 0.

6 before transitioning to the ZZ-SC phase for stronger J⊥ For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

0, the pairing correlation P zz(r) is much stronger than the single-particle correlation square and P zz(r) shows a quasi-long-range order with the power exponent Kzz SC ∼ 1, which strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while the in-plane Luttinger-liquid features persist. For the wider case with Ly = 3, the previous DMRG studies have shown an inter-plane SC near δ = 0.

5 is robust at strong J⊥

Phase Diagram Mapping

The phase diagram mapping involves fitting the central charge at various doping levels to diagnose different states For δ = 0.125, 0.1875, and 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

375, the phase diagram with growing J⊥ shows a notable difference from that at δ = 0. 1875, as illustrated in Fig.

25, the fitted central charge is close to zero, indicating a fully gapped state The CDW state of the two-leg ladder at δ = 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

With growing bond dimension, the entropy data increase slightly, but the fitted central charges are always close to zero, which are quite different from the LEL state of the two-leg ladder. These carefully analyzed DMRG data consistently confirm a fully gapped CDW state at small J⊥, between the in-plane SC (the LEL state) and inter-plane ZZ-SC phase.

25 extends to a finite doping range when two layers are coupled The results suggest that the CDW states belong to the same phase across different doping levels

Coupling Three-Leg Ladders

For the wider system size by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders, inter-plane SC observed near δ = 0.5 at large J⊥ is also stable at smaller doping ranges This suggests that the inter-plane SC phase can be stabilized by strong J⊥ over a large doping range Appendix B demonstrates that ZZ-SC emerges at strong J⊥ for both δ = 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

For the wider system size by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders, we find that the inter-plane SC observed near δ = 0. 5 at large J⊥ [68] is also stable at the smaller doping range, suggesting that the inter-plane SC phase can be stabilized by strong J⊥ over a large doping range.

375 and δ = 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Direct transition from in-plane to inter-plane SC phase When coupling two single-layer LEL states at δ = 0. 375, the phase diagram with growing J⊥ shows a notable difference from that at δ = 0.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Direct transition from in-plane to inter-plane SC phase When coupling two single-layer LEL states at δ = 0. 375, the phase diagram with growing J⊥ shows a notable difference from that at δ = 0.

5 when coupling two three-leg ladders

Summary of Findings

A strong J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio, with CDW phases appearing at intermediate doping levels In the intermediate J⊥ regime where in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, an enhanced quasi-long-range inter-plane SC develops with Kzz SC ∼ 1 The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states

Where the Gains Come From

The gains come from systematically studying the ground-state phase diagram of the t-J-J⊥ model by means of DMRG simulations This approach allows for a detailed identification of emergent phases and transitions in this complex interacting system The analysis provides insights into how the interlayer coupling drives the evolution of superconductivity from intralayer to interplane states

Conclusion

The work concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio, with CDW phases appearing at intermediate doping levels The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states

Appendix A: Coupling Two C0S1 States via J⊥

At δ = 0.5, the single-layer two-leg t-J ladder is the special C0S1 state with a gapless spin mode and gapped charge mode By employing the J⊥ coupling between the twoleg ladders, one can expect the fully gapped spin mode above a critical J⊥ Since SC will not emerge, this case was not systematically studied in previous DMRG calculations

Appendix B: Coupling Two Three-Leg Ladders via J⊥

For both δ = 0.375 and δ = 0.5, the ZZ-SC phase can emerge at strong J⊥ when coupling two three-leg ladders The density correlation D(r) and interlayer pairing correlation Pzz(r) exhibit power-law decay, while F(r), G(r), and Pyy(r) decay exponentially, showing the stable ZZ-SC by coupling two three-leg t-J ladders via a strong J⊥

Final Summary

When the single layer sits in either the LEL or TLL phase, a strong J⊥ can always drive an inter-plane SC By coupling two LEL states, the evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states

Final Summary 2

When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist

Final Summary 3

For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong

Final Summary 4

The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states

Final Summary 5

When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist

Final Summary 6

For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong

Final Summary 7

The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states

Final Summary 8

When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist

Final Summary 9

For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong

Final Summary 10

The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states

Final Summary 11

When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist

Final Summary 12

For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.5 is robust at strong J⊥ The stable inter-plane SC for both Ly = 2 and Ly = 3 over a wide range of doping ratio, as long as J⊥ coupling is strong

Final Summary 13

The paper concludes that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer SC by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states The evolution from in-plane to inter-plane SC depends on doping ratio The interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t-J ladders by a strong J⊥ interaction from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states

Final Summary 14

When in-plane TLL features persist, the interlayer pairing correlation could also be enhanced, showing a quasi-long-range order with Kzz SC ∼ 1 at J⊥/J = 1.0 This strongly suggests the emergence of inter-plane SC while in-plane TLL features persist

Final Summary 15

For the wider case with Ly = 3, inter-plane SC near δ = 0.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can predict whether an in-plane superconductivity will evolve into inter-plane superconductivity by tuning interlayer spin interaction J⊥ across a large doping range delta = 1/8 - 1/2, based on density matrix renormalization group calculations.

  2. The system can distinguish between different quantum phases of the bilayer t-J model, such as Luther-Emery liquid (LEL), charge density wave (CDW), and Tomonaga Luttinger liquid (TLL) states, by analyzing charge density profiles and pairing correlations.

  3. The AI can identify the conditions under which interlayer superconductivity is enhanced, specifically noting that a large J⊥ can always drive an interlayer superconductivity by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states.

  4. The system can predict if in-plane d-wave SC will coexist with interplane SC based on doping ratio, as the paper finds When the in-plane SC evolves to inter-plane SC directly, our DMRG data find no evidence of a coexistence.

  5. The AI can determine the power exponent KzzSC for quasi-long-range inter-plane order, finding that in the intermediate J⊥ regime we find that while the in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, the inter-plane superconductivity can develop an enhanced quasi-long-range order with the power exponent KzzSC ∼ 1.

  6. The system can characterize phase transitions using entanglement entropy, as it finds that the fitted central charge gets closer to 4, which supports a C2S2 state of the bilayer model when coupling two TLL states via strong J⊥.

Abstract

Motivated by the bilayer cuprate superconductors and nickelate superconductor La 3 Ni 2 O 7, we investigate the evolution from intralayer to interlayer superconductivity in finite-width bilayer t - J - J ladders, where t is the in-plane electron hopping, J is the in-plane spin interaction, and J is the inter-plane spin interaction. By means of the density matrix renormalization group calculations, we map out the quantum phase diagram of the bilayer two-leg ladders by tuning J in a large doping range δ= 1/8 - 1/2. We find that a large J can always drive an interlayer superconductivity by coupling the two layers in both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger liquid states. By coupling two Luther-Emery liquid states, the in-plane superconductivity evolves to inter-plane superconductivity either through an intermediate charge density wave (CDW) phase or directly, depending on doping ratio. This emergent CDW phase, which exists over a finite doping range, appears to develop from the CDW state of the two-leg ladder at δ= 1/4. By coupling two Luttinger liquids, the in-plane Luttinger liquids show a transition to the inter-plane superconducting phase at large J, as reported in previous literature. Interestingly, in the intermediate J regime we find that while the in-plane Luttinger-liquid features remain stable, the inter-plane superconductivity can develop an enhanced quasi-long-range order with the power exponent K zz SC about 1. At last, we show that the interlayer superconductivity is also stable by coupling the bilayer three-leg t - J ladders by a strong J interaction, from both the Luther-Emery liquid and Luttinger-liquid states.

Sources

Related papers