Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and 1+1D field theory

arXiv:2506.21540 · cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.quant-gas, cond-mat.str-el, hep-th · Submitted 2025-06-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and 1+1D field theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ground states of 1D spin chains can spontaneously break U(1) “easy-plane” spin rotation symmetry, via true long-range order of (S x, S y), at the phase transition between two quasilong-range-ordered phases The critical point can be reached by tuning a single parameter in a Hamiltonian with the same symmetry as the XXZ model, without further fine-tuning Equivalently, it can arise in systems of bosons with particle-hole symmetry, as a long-range-ordered transition point between two quasi-long-range-ordered superfluids Our approach is to start with the continuum field theory of the isotropic Heisenberg ferromagnet and consider generic perturbations that respect easyplane symmetry We argue for a renormalization-group flow to a critical point where long-range order in (S x, S y) is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of S z These results show that it is much easier to break continuous symmetries in 1D than standard lore would suggest The failure of standard intuition for 1D chains (based on the quantum–classical correspondence) can be attributed to Berry phases, which prevent the 1+1D system from mapping to a classical 2D spin model Symmetry Breaking Mechanism The mechanism for long-range order is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of S z at the critical point.

Kai: This critical point separates a phase with conventional quasi-long-range order in (S x, S y) from a phase where quasi-long-range order in (S x, S y) coexists with “Ising”–like long-range order in S z.

Mira: At the critical point, S z is critical, while (S x, S y) becomes longrange ordered, breaking U(1) symmetry.

Kai: This transition can be accessed by perturbing the isotropic Heisenberg Hamiltonian via H = −J X i Si.Si+1 + λ H′, where the term H′ breaks the SO(3) of the isotropic model down to that of the easy-plane model.

Title and authors: Kai: They start by taking the continuum field theory of the isotropic Heisenberg ferromagnet and adding generic perturbations that respect that easy-plane symmetry <ref:2506.21540#pg1>. It sets up this whole framework before getting into the actual critical point analysis.

Mira: The core idea is showing a renormalization group flow to a critical point where long-range order in S x and S y becomes possible because of these coexisting critical fluctuations in S z <ref:2506.21540#pg1>. It's about how the system flows towards that specific point <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Lev: If we think about implementing this, the theory says higher-order terms in the renormalization group expansion become irrelevant for these Goldstone modes <ref:2506.21540#pg3>. That means we only really need to worry about the leading terms in our calculations <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Kai: They also bring up the Berry phase term in their imaginary-time Lagrangian as a key difference from standard Lorentz invariant theories, which is why intuition from things like the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem doesn't apply here <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

Mira: So, to summarize the summary, they explain that these Berry phases are what distinguish the field theories of one dimensional quantum spin systems below from those describing two dimensional classical spin models <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

Lev: It means that when we look at their phase diagram topology, like the schematic one in Figure one they're focusing on the transition between the two upper phases and that critical point <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper suggests that their approach of starting with the continuum field theory and considering generic easy-plane symmetry perturbations is a way to tackle this <ref:2506.21540#pg1>. It's not just a guess; it’s a structured way to look at it.

Mira: They are showing that if you tune the coupling lambda in the perturbation term H', you can get coarse structure using mean field theory, and then they have to use renormalization group flow to properly handle the gapless regions <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means we need a way to map those mean field predictions onto what's actually runnable on real hardware, because the RG part is where the complexity really lands <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Kai: They also discuss how if the parameter lambda is small or if the spin size S is large, this process should give quantitatively accurate locations for those phase boundaries <ref:2506.21540#pg3>. That's a specific condition for getting good numbers.

Mira: The paper also points out that the universal results are robust even when you don't assume that small parameter lambda is tiny <ref:2506.21540#pg3>. That’s a strong statement about the underlying physics being solid, not just an approximation <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Lev: What they aren't explicitly stating clearly enough for implementation is how to rigorously handle the Berry phase term in a way that works for finite system sizes <ref:2506.21540#pg3>. That’s a practical hurdle for any experimental setup <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, to wrap up the paper "Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and one plus1D field theory," they propose that easy-plane magnets can spontaneously break U(one) symmetry at zero temperature phase transitions between quasi-long-range ordered phases <ref:2506.21540#pg1>.

Mira: The main implication is that this happens through the coexistence of critical fluctuations in S z, which leads to long-range order in S x and S y at the transition point <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

Lev: For us, it means we need to figure out how this transition actually manifests when we look at the real hardware constraints and the error correction overhead involved <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Kai: The paper points out that Berry phases are what make this difference between one dimensional spin path integrals and two dimensional classical spin models <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

Mira: The work shows how the critical point separates a phase with conventional quasi-long-range order in S x and S y from a phase where that quasi-long-range order coexists with Ising like long range order in S z <ref:2506.21540#pg2>.

Lev: And the limitation they mention is that the method doesn't fully detail how to rigorously handle the Berry phase term for finite system sizes <ref:2506.21540#pg3>. That’s a gap we have to fill in practice <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Kai: That’s where we go from here, figuring out the practical realization of this critical point and how it relates to what we can actually build with qubits <ref:2506.21540#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper on "Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and one plus1D field theory" shows that easy-plane magnets can break U(one) symmetry at zero temperature phase transitions between quasi-long-range ordered phases <ref:2506.21540#pg1,Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and>.

Mira: Exactly. The key mechanism is that long range order in the x and y directions becomes possible because of these critical fluctuations in the z direction right at the transition point.

Lev: And for us, it means we need to figure out how this works when we try to actually build something on real hardware, because mapping those theoretical predictions onto physical systems is where most of our work lands.

Kai: The paper also highlights that Berry phases are what distinguish these one dimensional spin path integrals from the theories used for two dimensional classical spin models.

Mira: That’s important because it tells us why standard intuition from things like the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem doesn't apply in this context.

Lev: It suggests we need to be careful about how we treat those phase diagrams, especially the transition between the two upper phases and that critical point they describe.

Kai: Overall, it’s a lot of work showing a way to get these results using renormalization group flow on generic perturbations respecting easy-plane symmetry.

Mira: It’s a solid framework for understanding how continuous symmetries can break in one dimensional systems even when you only have U(one) and spatial symmetries.

Lev: The paper’s main limitation, which is what we need to keep in mind, is that it doesn't fully detail how to rigorously handle the Berry phase term for finite system sizes.

Kai: That’s a gap we have to fill when we talk about making this work on actual chips or in experiments.

Mira: Anyway, this paper shows us that even in one dimension, the physics can be quite rich when you look at these types of transitions.

Lev: It gives us a concrete place to look for new models and experimental setups that might show this kind of behavior.

Laboratoire de Physique de l’Ecole Normale Sup´erieure, CNRS, ENS & Universit´e PSL · Sorbonne University · University of Paris City

cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.quant-gas, cond-mat.str-el, hep-th

Submitted: 2025-06-26

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: Updated to the version submitted to journal in Sept 2025. Minor changes. 7 pages + appendices

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Ground states of 1D spin chains can spontaneously break U(1) “easy-plane” spin rotation symmetry, via true long-range order of (S x, S y)…

Key concepts

U(1) Easy-Plane Spin Rotation Symmetry
This refers to the rotational symmetry around the axis perpendicular to the easy plane of an anisotropic spin system. The paper investigates how this specific continuous symmetry can be spontaneously broken, leading to long-range order in the (S_x, S_y) components at certain critical points in 1D spin chains.
Coexisting Critical Fluctuations
The key mechanism enabling the breaking of U(1) symmetry is the presence of critical fluctuations in the S_z component alongside quasi-long-range order in (S_x, S_y). At the critical point, S_z is fluctuating critically, while (S_x, S_y) develops true long-range order.
Berry Phases
These are a crucial feature of the 1+1D spin path integral formulation that distinguishes it from classical 2D models. Berry phases prevent the system from mapping directly to a classical 2D spin model, playing a fundamental role in the mechanism that allows for long-range order in (S_x, S_y) at these transitions.

Terminology

Summary

Ground states of 1D spin chains can spontaneously break U(1) “easy-plane” spin rotation symmetry, via true long-range order of (S x, S y), at the phase transition between two quasilong-range-ordered phases The critical point can be reached by tuning a single parameter in a Hamiltonian with the same symmetry as the XXZ model, without further fine-tuning Equivalently, it can arise in systems of bosons with particle-hole symmetry, as a long-range-ordered transition point between two quasi-long-range-ordered superfluids Our approach is to start with the continuum field theory of the isotropic Heisenberg ferromagnet and consider generic perturbations that respect easyplane symmetry We argue for a renormalization-group flow to a critical point where long-range order in (S x, S y) is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of S z These results show that it is much easier to break continuous symmetries in 1D than standard lore would suggest The failure of standard intuition for 1D chains (based on the quantum–classical correspondence) can be attributed to Berry phases, which prevent the 1+1D system from mapping to a classical 2D spin model

Symmetry Breaking Mechanism

The mechanism for long-range order is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of S z at the critical point. This critical point separates a phase with conventional quasi-long-range order in (S x, S y) from a phase where quasi-long-range order in (S x, S y) coexists with “Ising”–like long-range order in S z. p. 1 At the critical point, S z is critical, while (S x, S y) becomes longrange ordered, breaking U(1) symmetry. p. 1 This transition can be accessed by perturbing the isotropic Heisenberg Hamiltonian via H = −J X i Si. p. 1Si+1 + λ H′, where the term H′ breaks the SO(3) of the isotropic model down to that of the easy-plane model. p. 1

Field Theory Formulation

The analysis starts from the coherent states path integral for the spin chain, mapping it to an interacting 1+1D field theory (one formulation is as a Lifshitz-like field theory). The imaginary-time Lagrangian for the SO(3) ferromagnet includes a crucial Berry phase term. p. 6 The quadratic expansion of the action gives SG = S Z dxdt i ψ∂tθ + D squared (∇θ)2 + (∇ψ)2. p. 1

Critical Theory and Flow

The critical theory is studied by considering the Lagrangian L = LG + λ 1 ψ squared + λ 4 ψ 4, where LG includes the Gaussian derivative terms in SG. The Q-QL transition occurs when the (renormalized) value of λ 2 is tuned to zero. p. 3 The resulting 1+1D theory flows to an interacting fixed point describing the Q-QL transition line (for positive λ 4), where LRO in θ (which selects some arbitrary ordering direction θ0) coexists with nontrivial fluctuations on top of the ordered state. p. 3

Phase Diagrams and Order

The mean-field phase diagram shows three phases depending on whether the minimum for ψ squared is at its maximum value, at its minimum value 0, or at an intermediate value. The transition between the θ–QLRO phase and the phase with both θ–QLRO and ψ–LRO is referred to as the Q–QL transition. p. 2 Within mean field theory, all three phases have LRO — in ψ, in θ, or in both — but fluctuations will replace LRO in θ with quasi-LRO within these phases. p. 2

Multicritical Points and Universality

If two dimensionless couplings g1 and g2 can be tuned independently, one may tune to the multicritical point (the origin of Fig. 1) where the field-theory couplings λ 2 and λ 4 both vanish. p. 4 The existence of LRO at these multicritical points is even simpler: the leading interactions are now RG–irrelevant or marginally irrelevant, so that in the IR the Goldstone modes are governed by the Gaussian theory. p. 4

Model Realization and Implications

The paper suggests that models with only U(1) and spatial symmetries can access the universality class of the continuous transition discussed in this paper, if two parameters are tuned (and if a model lies in the right part of parameter space). The resulting theory describes the critical endpoint of a first-order line in the (λ 2, λ 3) plane. p. 5 This transition occurs within the QLRO phase since there is no longer a symmetry that reverses S z. p. 5 The critical point is also possible in systems of itinerant bosons with density-density interactions, potentially seen in cold atom experiments. p. 5

Conclusion

We have proposed that easy-plane magnets can spontaneously break U(1) symmetry at zero-temperature phase transitions between quasi-long-range-ordered phases. Berry phases are part of the mechanism for longrange order at these transitions, and they are the basic distinction between the 1+1D spin path integrals discussed here and field theories for 2D classical spin models. p. 5 Many models could be explored, both clean and disordered. p. 5

Acknowledgments

I am very grateful to J. Chalker for useful feedback on the draft, to K. p. 5 Wiese for helpful discussions of RG, and to X. p. 5 Cao, F. Essler, D. Kovrizhin, R. p. 6 Verresen, and H Watanabe for useful discussions

Appendix A

For the SO(3) ferromagnet this gives an action with a crucial Berry phase term. If we assume the fluctuations of θ to be small, then θ(x, t) does not contain spacetime vortex singularities, which implies that mx = m is independent of the site, so that Stotal deriv. p. 6 = −i2πSL m. p. 6

Appendix C

The one-loop Wilsonian RG computation is completely parallel to that for standard ϕ 4 theory [30]. At lowest order in λ 4, the RG equations coincide with those of the isotropic model in 4 − ϵ dimensions. p. 8

Appendix D

The self-consistency equation determines the two-point function (ψ = ∇h). The critical point (λ 2)∗ is where t = 0: (λ 2)∗ = −Λ/π√D λ 4. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0

Appendix B

The symmetry actions describe the action of various possible symmetries on the coherent states Lagrangian. The modified time-reversal symmetry T' imposes: T': L[θ, nz, ∂t, ∂x] = L[-θ, nz, −∂t, −∂x].

The action in (A3) has terms of all orders in ψ. The resulting quadratic theory (D = J S) has trivial equal-time correlators but has nontrivial nonequal-time correlators. p. 6

The RG equations in the standard form coincide with those of the isotropic model in 4 − ϵ dimensions. The leading-order results are evidence for the existence of the nontrivial fixed point, but of course cannot guarantee it. p. 3

The scaling dimension of (∇h)2 is 2 rather than the engineering value ∆MF(∇h)2 = 1. The critical point (λ 2)∗ is where t = 0: (λ 2)∗ = −Λ/π√D λ 4.

The crossover lengthscale for this behavior is ξ ∝ p/D or ξ ∝ λ 4 / π√D δλ 2. The scaling dimension of (∇h)2 is ∆(∇h)2 = 2 rather than the engineering value ∆MF(∇h)2 = 1. p. 8 p. 8

The crossover lengthscale for this behavior is ξ ∝ δλ−ν 2 then ν = 1. The scaling dimension of (∇h)2 is ∆(∇h)2 = 2 rather than the engineering value ∆MF(∇h)2 = 1.

The scaling dimension of (∇h)2 is ∆(∇h)2 = 1. p. 3 The critical point (λ 2)∗ is where t = 0: (λ 2)∗ = −Λ/π√D λ 4.

The crossover lengthscale for this behavior is ξ ∝ p/D or ξ ∝ λ 4 / π√D δλ 2. The scaling dimension of (∇h)2 is ∆(∇h)2 = 1.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform renormalization group flow analysis on generic 1D spin chain Hamiltonians to locate critical points where long-range order in Sx and Sy is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of Sz.

  2. Improved AI can analyze the phase diagram topology, such as the mean-field phase diagram shown in Figure 1, to predict which phases have true long-range order and which exhibit quasi-long-range order (QLRO).

  3. Improved AI can determine the universality class of the Q–QL transition by analyzing the flow of dimensionless couplings lambda 2 and lambda 4 in a field theory approach, predicting whether it flows to an interacting fixed point.

  4. Improved AI can calculate scaling dimensions for critical exponents such as delta theta and delta psi at the interacting fixed point, providing quantitative predictions beyond mean-field results.

  5. Improved AI can use the large N approximation to predict correlation functions for N component vector fields, allowing for qualitative understanding of the physics in higher dimensions like d=2.

Sources

Related papers