QCD Axion Conversion in Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars

arXiv:2506.13310 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-06-16 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "QCD Axion Conversion in Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The axion-converted-photons flux is a principal window for searching QCD axions as a dark matter (DM) candidate.

Kai: This study analyzes the impact of strong magnetic fields on neutron star cooling by employing the FPS equation of State (EoS).

Mira: The results show that the cooling rate and luminosity of axions for NSs change significantly due to the intense magnetic field.

Kai: The analysis employs the Tolman Oppenheimer Volkoff (TOV) equations by considering effects of strong fields and generating profiles.

Paper summary: Kai: So, this paper, "QCD Axion Conversion in Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars," it looks at how strong magnetic fields affect cooling in neutron stars using some specific equations. It’s trying to see if these neutron stars can be a way to find QCD axions as dark matter candidates.

Mira: Right, so the main point seems to be that this paper is looking at how the axion-converted-photon flux acts as a window for searching QCD axions, and they are testing how strong magnetic fields change the cooling rate and luminosity of these stars using the FPS equation of state.

Lev: It’s interesting because they use the Tolman Oppenheimer Volkoff equations to model this effect, assuming Cooper-pair-breaking formation and Bremsstrahlung processes happen in the core of a neutron star.

Kai: And they set their analysis at an axion mass of fifteen meV and a central magnetic field Bc equal to ten to the power seventeen gauss. That's a pretty specific setup for their calculation.

Mira: What they claim is that the cooling rate and luminosity of axions for neutron stars change significantly because of this intense magnetic field. They are using a polynomial fit function for the radial profile to analyze these effects, which is important because it means the results depend on how you model that profile.

Lev: I wonder how much overhead we’re talking about if we tried to run this kind of calculation on real hardware, especially when accounting for those strong field effects they introduce.

Kai: The paper shows that the internal temperature curve in the presence of a magnetic field stays higher than it would be without one, even at certain radial distances. They point out a significant difference in cooling curves up to four kilometers from the center.

Mira: But then as you move from the very center toward the surface of the neutron star, that percentage departure in cooling curves drops, and beyond ten kilometers, that separation becomes negligible. It seems like those specific parameters matter a lot for how much change you see depending on where you measure it.

Lev: That dependence on distance sounds like a big caveat; if we're trying to build hardware to detect these signals, knowing exactly where the signal is strongest versus where it fades is crucial for setting up the detector sensitivity.

Kai: The paper also compares different axion emission spectra from two processes: Cooper-pair-breaking formation and Bremsstrahlung. It finds that the Bremsstrahlung process dominates at lesser axion energies, within the range possible for a neutron star like PSR J1356-six thousand four hundred twenty-nine.

Mira: And they find something specific about the PBF process too; there is a significant departure in those axions’ energy spectrum when they are in the range of two kiloelectron volts to four kiloelectron volts. That suggests that different physical processes give you very different signatures for these axions.

Lev: If we're talking about building a detector, knowing which spectral shape to look for—the Bremsstrahlung one or the PBF one—is a major design constraint on what the hardware needs to be sensitive to.

Kai: When looking at the axion-converted-photon flux, they see that the impact of the magnetic field is less when you look at lower axion energies, around ten kiloelectron volts, because there’s still a higher curve in the absence of a magnetic field for that energy spectrum.

Mira: That confirms what we saw earlier about the Bremsstrahlung process dominating at lower energies; it’s not the magnetic field that completely wipes out the signal right away. However, they say the impact gets more significant in cases like Magnificent Seven stars and they've estimated this previously.

Lev: So, if we are designing a detector sensitive to these axion signals from neutron stars, we need to account for those energy dependencies; it’s not a simple one-size-fits-all scenario.

Kai: The paper concludes that including the magnetic field is necessary when you consider various axion production mechanisms and the specific equation of state you employ, which goes beyond what current calculations cover. It suggests that the conversion of axions to photons in magnetospheres might lead to radio signals that could unravel the properties of dark matter.

Mira: It sounds like they are suggesting that studying these conversion processes in strongly magnetized neutron stars is a valid way to probe dark matter properties, provided we account for those complex field effects and EoS variations.

Lev: The paper flags its limitation by saying that the analysis relies on assuming certain physics within the core, specifically Cooper-pair-breaking formation and Bremsstrahlung, and they are not including other contributions like pion or rho meson couplings to the equation of state.

Kai: So, what this means for us is that while this study gives us a baseline understanding of how magnetic fields affect axion cooling in neutron stars, it’s a starting point because we need to incorporate those more complex physics you mentioned if we want truly accurate predictions for dark matter searches.

Mira: Exactly. The paper shows that even with these specific assumptions, the magnetic field has a real effect on thermal evolution and emission spectra, which is valuable input for future theoretical work on DM candidates.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at how strong magnetic fields mess with neutron star cooling and axion emissions, and now we're going to wrap up this paper, "QCD Axion Conversion in Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars."

Mira: Basically, this research is taking those complex physics—the strong magnetic fields interacting with the core matter—and seeing if it gives us a real window into searching for QCD axions as dark matter candidates.

Lev: It’s about using the conversion of axions into photons in these magnetospheres to get a signal we could potentially detect.

Kai: The authors are focusing on how different physical processes, like Cooper-pair-breaking formation and Bremsstrahlung, produce those axions, and how the magnetic field changes that spectrum.

Mira: They found that the impact of the magnetic field is not uniform across all energies; it depends heavily on whether you're looking at a low energy or a higher energy axion.

Lev: That dependence is key for us because if we're designing an experiment, we need to know which spectral shape to prioritize when setting up our detectors.

Kai: They suggest that including the magnetic field is necessary when you consider various production mechanisms and the equation of state you use, which pushes beyond what current calculations cover.

Mira: It’s a starting point because they aren't including every single coupling in the core, like pion or rho meson stuff.

Lev: So it gives us a baseline understanding of how magnetic fields affect axion cooling, but we still need to factor in those more complex physics for really accurate predictions.

Kai: The main implication here is that the conversion of axions to photons in magnetospheres might lead to radio signals that could help unravel the properties of dark matter.

Mira: It confirms that studying these conversion processes in strongly magnetized neutron stars is a valid way to probe dark matter, provided we account for those field effects and EoS variations.

Lev: That opens up new avenues for theoretical work on DM candidates, linking neutron star physics directly to particle astrophysics.

Shubham Yadav

Oriental Institute of Science and Technology, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-06-16

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 10 pages, 24 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 70/100

The gist: The axion-converted-photons flux is a principal window for searching QCD axions as a dark matter (DM) candidate.

Key concepts

QCD Axions
These are hypothetical particles predicted by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) theory. The paper treats them as a potential dark matter candidate, meaning they could make up a large part of the universe's matter, and the study looks at how they might be produced in neutron stars.
Strong Magnetic Fields
Neutron stars possess extremely intense magnetic fields, modeled here at $10^{17}$ Gauss. The research examines how these powerful fields influence physical processes within the star's core, such as heat transfer and particle interactions, which directly impact axion behavior.
Axion-Converted-Photon Flux
This refers to the rate at which axions convert into detectable photons when passing through a neutron star's magnetosphere. Measuring this flux is a key way researchers hope to detect these hypothetical particles and gain insight into their properties as dark matter.
FPS Equation of State (EoS)
The EoS describes the relationship between pressure and density inside the neutron star. The FPS EoS is used in this study to model how the neutron star's internal structure responds to the presence of a strong magnetic field, which in turn dictates how heat escapes and how axions are produced.

Terminology

Summary

The axion-converted-photons flux is a principal window for searching QCD axions as a dark matter (DM) candidate. p. 0

Where the paper says it

arXiv:2506. 13310v1 [hep-ph] 16 Jun 2025 QCD Axion Conversion in Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars Shubham Yadav∗ Department of Basic Sciences, Oriental Institute of Science and Technology, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India (Dated: June 17, 2025) The axion-converted-photons flux is a principal window for searching QCD axions as a dark matter (DM) candidate.

This study analyzes the impact of strong magnetic fields on neutron star cooling by employing the FPS equation of State (EoS). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Neutron star (NS) cooling by neutrino/axion emissions rate constrains the astrophysical properties of superdense matter. We attempt to analyse the impact of strong magnetic fields on the emission properties of NS by employing the FPS equation of State (EoS).

The results show that the cooling rate and luminosity of axions for NSs change significantly due to the intense magnetic field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We have present the results for the energy spectrum of axions and their subsequent conversion to photons. We show that the cooling rate and the luminosity of axions for NSs change significantly due to the intense magnetic field.

Methodology and Modeling

The analysis employs the Tolman Oppenheimer Volkoff (TOV) equations by considering effects of strong fields and generating profiles. The research assumes Cooper-pair-breaking formation (PBF) and the Bremsstrahlung process occur in the core of NS. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We use the Tolman Oppenheimer Volkoff (TOV) equations by considering effects of strong fields and generating profiles. We assume Cooper-pair-breaking formation (PBF) and the Bremsstrahlung process occur in the core of NS.

A polynomial fit function of radial profile is adopted to analyze the effects of strong magnetic field. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We assume Cooper-pair-breaking formation (PBF) and the Bremsstrahlung process occur in the core of NS. We adopt a polynomial fit function of radial profile to analyse the effects of strong magnetic field.

The entire analysis is performed at an axion mass of 15 meV and central magnetic field Bc=10 17 G. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We adopt a polynomial fit function of radial profile to analyse the effects of strong magnetic field. Our entire analysis is at an axion mass of 15 meV and central magnetic field Bc=1017 G.

The core is assumed to comprise hadronic matter of the spherically symmetric magnetized NSs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our entire analysis is at an axion mass of 15 meV and central magnetic field Bc=1017 G. Our work assumes the core comprises hadronic matter of the spherically symmetric magnetized NSs.

Impact on Thermal Evolution

The internal temperature curve in the presence of a magnetic field remains higher than in the case of a no-magnetic field at all radial distances. A significant difference is seen at early distances up to 4 km. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The temperature curve in the presence of a magnetic field remains higher than in the case of a no-magnetic field at all radial distances. A significant difference can be seen at the early distances up to 4 km.

As the analysis moves from the center towards the surface of the NS, the % departure in cooling curves decreases, and separation becomes negligible beyond 10 km. p. 2
Where the paper says it

A significant difference can be seen at the early distances up to 4 km. It is evident from the results that as we move from the center towards the surface of the NS, the % departure (with/without magnetic field) in the cooling curves decreases, and the separation becomes negligible beyond the distance of 10 km.

The cooling properties strongly depend on the employed EoS. p. 2
Where the paper says it

It is evident from the results that as we move from the center towards the surface of the NS, the % departure (with/without magnetic field) in the cooling curves decreases, and the separation becomes negligible beyond the distance of 10 km. The cooling properties strongly depend on the mentioned EoS; however, the magnetic field-dependent EoS is beyond the current work.

Axion Emission Spectra Comparison

The energy spectrum of axions from the Bremsstrahlung process dominates over the PBF process at lesser axion energies, within the possible axion mass range for PSR J1356-6429 NS. For the Bremsstrahlung process, the energy spectrum of axions in the absence of a magnetic field dominates over the case of a magnetic field up to the axion energy 10 keV. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The variation of energy spectrum of axions as a function of axion energies for PBF and Bremsstrahlung process in the (presence/absence) of magnetic field for the PSR J1356-6429 NS at an axion mass of 15 meV (FPS EoS). over the case of a magnetic field up to the axion energy 10 keV.

For the PBF process, a significant departure can be seen in the axions’ energy spectrum within the axion energy range of (2 keV - 4 keV). p. 3
Where the paper says it

Beyond that, the magnetic field’s separation (with/without) becomes negligible. For the PBF process, a significant departure can be seen in the axions’ energy spectrum within the axion energy range of (2 keV - 4 keV).

Conversion Flux Dependence

The axion-converted-photon flux shows that the impact of the magnetic field is less at lower values of the axion energies ∼ 10 keV, as the curve in the absence of a magnetic field remains higher for the axion’s energy spectrum and axion-converted-photon flux. The impact of the magnetic field is more significant in the case of magnificent seven star (M7) and it has been estimated in previous work. p. 4

Where the paper says it

We report that the impact of the magnetic field is less at lower values of the axion energies ∼ 10 keV, as the curve in the absence of a magnetic field remains higher for the axion’s energy spectrum and axionconverted-photon flux. The impact of the magnetic field is more significant in the case of magnificient seven star (M7) and it has been estimated in previous work [96].

The net energy spectrum of axions from the Bremsstrahlung process dominates over the PBF process for the lesser values of the axion energies. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show that the cooling rate and the luminosity of axions for NSs change significantly due to the intense magnetic field. We report that the energy spectrum of axions from the Bremsstrahlung process dominates over the PBF process at lesser axion energies, within the possible axion mass range for PSR J1356-6429 NS.

Conclusion and Outlook

The current investigation suggests that including the magnetic field is necessary for various axion-production mechanisms and employed EoS, which is beyond the scope of current calculations. The findings indicate that the conversion of axions to photons in magnetospheres leads to radio signals which might unravel the properties of a mysterious substance in the form of DM. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The conversion of axions to photons in the magnetospheres of the strongly magnetized NSs leads to the origin of radio signals. These observed signals might unravel the properties of a mysterious substance in the form of DM.

The study on the conversion of axion to photon remains a topic of active research, particularly for the strongly magnetized NSs. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Our findings suggest that the inclusion of the magnetic field is necessary for the various axion-production mechanisms and the employed EoS, which is beyond the scope of current calculations. Therefore, the study on the conversion of axion to photon remains a topic of active research, particularly for the strongly magnetized NSs.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We thank D.Page and M. p. 5

Where the paper says it

6 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank D. Page and M.

Buschmann for answering questions regarding the NSCool code. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Page and M. Buschmann for answering questions regarding the NSCool code.

S.Yadav also acknowledge the Oriental Institute of Science and Technology, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh for research facilities and financial assistance. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Buschmann for answering questions regarding the NSCool code. Yadav also acknowledge the Oriental Institute of Science and Technology, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh for research facilities and financial assistance.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can model neutron star cooling rates by incorporating strong magnetic fields using modified TOV equations with a magnetic energy density term and a Lorentz force term L(r) as described in Section II.

  2. The improved system can generate radial distance-dependent magnetic field profiles B0(r) based on the central magnetic field Bc, allowing for an accurate study of the impact of strong fields on matter state.

  3. The AI can utilize the NSCool code to simulate thermal evolution and calculate luminosity profiles as a function of characteristic age, specifically comparing scenarios with and without a magnetic field effect.

  4. The system can analyze axion energy spectra from different production mechanisms, such as Cooper-pair breaking and formation (PBF) versus Bremsstrahlung process, showing that the energy spectrum of axions from the Bremsstrahlung process dominates over the PBF process at lesser axion energies.

  5. The AI can calculate the conversion probability of axions to photons using Equation (11), providing a framework for predicting radio signals from magnetars based on parameters like B0 and NS radius.

  6. The improved system can identify that the impact of the magnetic field is less at lower axion energies, indicating the necessity for including a magnetic field in axion-to-photon conversion mechanisms when analyzing the energy spectrum data.

Abstract

The axion-converted-photons flux plays a key role in searches of QCD axions as a dark matter (DM) candidate. In addition to solving the strong CP problem, these may explain the properties of the mysterious DM. Neutron star (NS) cooling by neutrino/axion emissions rate constrains the astrophysical properties of superdense matter. We attempt to analyse the impact of strong magnetic fields on the emission properties of axions by employing the APR, FPS, and SLY equation of State (EoS). We modify the Tolman Oppenheimer Volkoff (TOV) equations by considering effects of strong fields' and generate profiles. We assume Cooper-pair-breaking formation (PBF) and the Bremsstrahlung process occurring in the core of NS. We use the radial distance-dependent magnetic field configuration within the permissible limit of the central magnetic field. Our work explores the variations in the axion masses of 10 meV, 15 meV, and 20 meV as a cooling source for spherically symmetric magnetised NSs. We have also shown the energy spectrum of axions and their conversion to photons. Our analysis shows that the cooling rate and the luminosity of observables (axions) for NSs change significantly due to the magnetic field. The results for the luminosity of axions is quite sensitive to its mass and EoS, as the less separation is observed for SLY EoS in comparison to the FPS and APR EoS. We report that the spectrum of axions from the Bremsstrahlung process dominates over the PBF process at lesser axion energies, within the possible axion mass range for PSR J1357-6429 NS. Our results reveal that the impact of the magnetic field is less at lower axion energies, indicating the necessity for including a magnetic field in axion-to-photon conversion mechanisms. The results for the axions mass 10 meV and 15 meV as compared to 20 meV confirms the existing report of the 16 meV.

Sources

Related papers