ManiTaskGen: A Comprehensive Task Generator for Benchmarking and Improving Vision-Language Agents on Embodied Decision-Making

arXiv:2505.20726 · cs.RO · Submitted 2025-05-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: I'm Rosa.

Dev: And I'm Dev, here with Taro.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "ManiTaskGen: A Comprehensive Task Generator for Benchmarking and Improving Vision-Language Agents on Embodied Decision-Making".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Building embodied agents capable of accomplishing arbitrary tasks is a core objective toward achieving embodied artificial general intelligence (E-AGI).

Rosa: Existing work in this area often suffers from limitations in training and evaluation, as policies are frequently restricted to specific scenes and limited instruction sets, with benchmarks relying heavily on manual annotation.

Dev: The authors argue that exploring the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene is crucial for both extensive evaluation and agent improvement.

Rosa: To address this, they introduce ManiTaskGen, a novel system designed to automatically generate comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for any arbitrary scene.

Title and authors: Rosa: So we're talking about this paper called "ManiTaskGen: A Comprehensive Task Generator for Benchmarking and Improving Vision-Language Agents on Embodied Decision-Making." It sounds like they’re trying to solve the problem where training and testing robots is really hard because you usually only test them in one specific place or with a few pre-made instructions.

Dev: Right. The core idea here seems to be that the way we currently make tasks for these embodied agents is too manual, which means we can't properly check if an agent actually knows how to do something new or general across different environments.

Taro: It feels like they are trying to build a system that can create a huge variety of scenarios automatically, so you don't have to spend all your time drawing up every single test case by hand.

Rosa: That’s right. They introduce this novel system called ManiTaskGen which is designed to generate comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for any scene, whether it's simulated or real-world.

Dev: So, what makes these tasks comprehensive? I mean, do they cover everything an agent might need to learn?

Rosa: They cover two main types of instructions. First, process-based instructions which are like specific sequences of actions, such as "move object from X to Y." Then they have outcome-based instructions which are more abstract goals, like "clear the table."

Taro: So we’re not just testing if an agent can follow a single path, but if it can achieve a bigger objective without being told the exact steps.

Dev: That makes sense. And how do they figure out what those tasks should look like when they are in an arbitrary scene? That’s where the magic has to happen.

Rosa: They formalize the problem space first, defining scene states based on object poses and containment states, and then they build a Receptacle-Aware three dee Scene Graph <ref:2505.20726#pg1>. This gives them a structured way to see all the objects and figure out where things are in relation to each other.

Taro: A three dee scene graph sounds like it would be really helpful for an agent because it means the system understands the relationships between all the objects, not just where they are individually placed <ref:2505.20726#pg1>.

Dev: Exactly. And then they generate those tasks in two ways: process-based tasks come from sampling and composing feasible action sequences using logical connectors like "THEN," which creates complex, multi-step trajectories reflecting an agent's whole interaction cycle.

Rosa: And the second way is outcome-based tasks, where they use a hybrid approach to create abstract targets. They take a dataset of two hundred pre-made templates and then use an ensemble of vision language models to vote on whether each generated instruction is actually executable in that scene.

Taro: Using an ensemble of vision language models to check executability sounds like a clever way to filter out the instructions that are just impossible for the agent to do, which saves a lot of time.

Title and authors: Dev: So, the contribution here seems twofold: first, they propose this universal system for generating tasks across any scene, and second, they show how you can use these automatically constructed benchmarks to evaluate existing vision language models very thoroughly.

Rosa: And finally, they suggest using these ManiTaskGen tasks not just for testing but actually for improving the agents themselves through a proposed inference-time reinforcement learning method.

Taro: That last part about using it during inference sounds really important because it means the agent can learn something while it's trying to solve a task in real time, like methods inspired by Reflexion and ReAct.

Dev: So, if I’m thinking about what this means for us in terms of real-world testing, the fact that they generate so many more tasks than existing datasets, like the ManiTaskGen-RAS-40K example which has substantially more tasks than other benchmarks, suggests a much better way to test agent capability <ref:2505.20726#pg1>.

Rosa: That’s a big number. It really points to how much more ground we can cover when we move away from relying on manually annotated tasks confined to finite sets of scenes or instructions.

Taro: So, the main thing I hear is that this framework facilitates both rigorous benchmarking and the improvement of embodied decision-making agents by giving us access to a full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene.

Dev: And that leads us into how this actually changes things for someone who just listens to the show. It means we can start using these generated benchmarks to automatically test and filter our current vision language models, which is a huge step compared to having to design every single test manually.

Rosa: We’re going to wrap up now and summarize what this paper, "ManiTaskGen: A Comprehensive Task Generator for Benchmarking and Improving Vision-Language Agents on Embodied Decision-Making," actually gives us.

Taro: It moves us past the limitation of relying on manual task annotation in specific scenes by providing a universal system that generates both process and outcome based tasks for any scene.

Dev: And it shows how we can use these generated tasks to conduct extensive evaluations of current vision language models, and even enhances agent capabilities through an inference time reinforcement learning method inspired by methods like Reflexion and ReAct.

Rosa: So, the implication is that instead of having a limited set of tests, we can generate a massive amount of diverse tests for any given scene to rigorously evaluate how well these agents make decisions in the real world.

Taro: It’s about creating a dynamic evaluation platform instead of relying on static, limited datasets when you want to push the boundaries of embodied agent capabilities.

Dev: That’s what this work suggests, and it sets up a path for us to get better agents by giving them much richer training and testing objectives across every possible scene.

Rosa: We’ll be moving on now, but this framework for generating comprehensive tasks for arbitrary scenes is definitely something we need to keep an eye on as we build these more general agents.

The paper's summary: Rosa: So, to wrap up what we just heard, this paper introduces ManiTaskGen as a way to automatically create a huge variety of mobile manipulation tasks for any scene.

Dev: Right, and the main point is that instead of manually writing every single test case, you can generate these comprehensive tasks that cover both specific action sequences and abstract goals.

Rosa: Exactly. They use this system to build benchmarks that are way bigger than what we have right now, which lets us really test how capable these vision language models are across different environments.

Dev: And they don't just stop at testing; they propose a method to actually use those generated tasks to make the agents better through an inference time reinforcement learning approach.

Rosa: So the big picture is that this moves us away from having small, limited test sets and towards a universal framework for both rigorous evaluation and agent improvement.

Dev: It means we can push these current vision language models much further than before, because we are giving them a much richer set of objectives to learn from in every possible scene.

Rosa: What this really means for the world is that we’re building tools that help us create more general agents, and the way they learn from those tasks helps us understand how they actually make decisions when things get messy outside of a perfect lab setting.

Dev: And this whole process of generating these diverse tasks and then using them for training feedback is going to be key for making embodied AI more robust in the real world.

Rosa: It sets up a lot of exciting work moving forward, especially with how they use those tasks to fine-tune the models on the fly during operation.

The paper's improvements: Taro: So we’ve looked at how ManiTaskGen works to create tasks, and now let's talk about what they suggest we do with this framework to actually make agents better.

Dev: They propose using these generated tasks for an inference time reinforcement learning method, which is basically letting the agent learn while it's actually trying to solve a problem in real time.

Rosa: Right, so instead of just testing the agent after it’s already been trained on a static set of instructions, you use those dynamic tasks to give it feedback while it’s running.

Taro: This is interesting because the paper mentions using a self-reflection model to generate verbal summaries for long term memory, which helps the agent remember what happened during a complex task.

Dev: That means the agent gets feedback on how well it handled the execution process of that specific task, allowing it to optimize its behavior based on that direct experience.

Rosa: It shifts the focus from just getting a right answer to understanding *why* a sequence of actions worked or failed in a specific situation.

Taro: So, the improvement here is making the agent more adaptive and capable of handling unexpected situations because it’s learning from its own mistakes during execution.

Dev: This gives us a safety case, you know? We’re not just checking if it gets to the end state; we’re checking how gracefully it navigates the messy middle of things.

Rosa: It really emphasizes that the value isn't just in having a big number of tasks, but in using those tasks to create a more intelligent learning loop for the agent itself.

Taro: And it suggests that by using these specific task types, we can push the boundaries of what these embodied agents are capable of doing when things go sideways.

Conclusion: Rosa: So we’re wrapping up this look at ManiTaskGen, which is essentially their universal task generation framework for arbitrary scenes, designed to help benchmark and improve vision language agents on embodied decision making.

Dev: The implication here is that we can finally move away from just testing agents in one specific room or one pre-written scenario and start testing them across the full spectrum of feasible tasks in any scene.

Rosa: And what it means for us is that we have a much more rigorous way to evaluate these models, which should help us build agents that are truly general purpose, not just experts in one narrow thing.

Dev: The safety case comes from this because if we can generate enough diverse tasks automatically, we can be more certain about the agent's decision making when it encounters something it hasn't seen before.

Taro: I think the real change is seeing how they use these generated tasks during inference to enhance capabilities, which means the agent gets on-the-fly training based on how well it handled a task.

Rosa: That’s right, so we’re not just giving them a test; we’re giving them active learning opportunities while they are performing their actual job in the field.

Dev: It really changes how we think about agent improvement, moving it from slow, offline training to something more dynamic and reactive during operation.

Taro: If these models can learn and adapt that way using these comprehensive tasks, then the robustness of those systems in unpredictable real-world environments could improve significantly.

Rosa: So, ManiTaskGen gives us a way to create massive test sets and a mechanism for agents to improve themselves on the fly during testing.

Dev: It’s a solid framework that moves embodied AI closer to being able to handle the messy reality of the physical world without needing every single thing pre-programmed.

Liu Dai, Haina Wang, Weikang Wan, Hao Su

University of California, San Diego

cs.RO

Submitted: 2025-05-27

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: Project Website: https://manitaskgen.github.io/

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Building embodied agents capable of accomplishing arbitrary tasks is a core objective toward achieving embodied artificial general intelligence (E-AGI).

Key concepts

Process-based Tasks
These are detailed instructions that guide an agent through a sequence of specific actions, such as 'move object from X to Y'. They are created by systematically sampling and combining basic atomic actions using logical connectors to form complex, multi-step trajectories that mimic a real interaction cycle.
Outcome-based Tasks
These tasks define abstract goals rather than specific steps, like 'clear the table'. ManiTaskGen creates these by using a template dataset and having an ensemble of VLMs vote on whether the generated instruction is practical for the given scene, ensuring diverse abstract targets.
Receptacle-Aware 3D Scene Graph (S)
This is a structured representation of a scene that encodes how objects are positioned and contained. It helps the system understand object relationships and identifies available empty spaces or 'receptacles' around objects, which is crucial for planning movement actions.
Inference-time Reinforcement Learning
This proposed method uses the generated ManiTaskGen tasks during an agent's decision-making process to improve its performance. It is inspired by methods like Reflexion and ReAct, allowing the agent to use feedback from task execution to generate verbal summaries for long-term memory and unsupervised optimization.

Terminology

Summary

Building embodied agents capable of accomplishing arbitrary tasks is a core objective toward achieving embodied artificial general intelligence (E-AGI). p. 0

Where the paper says it

ManiTaskGen: A Comprehensive Task Generator for Benchmarking and Improving Vision-Language Agents on Embodied Decision-Making Liu Dai∗ Haina Wang∗ Weikang Wan Hao Su University of California, San Diego {l2dai, haw120, w2wan, haosu@ucsd. edu} Project Website Abstract Building embodied agents capable of accomplishing arbitrary tasks is a core objective towards achieving embodied artificial general intelligence (E-AGI).

Existing work in this area often suffers from limitations in training and evaluation, as policies are frequently restricted to specific scenes and limited instruction sets, with benchmarks relying heavily on manual annotation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

While recent work has advanced such general robot policies, their training and evaluation are often limited to tasks within specific scenes, involving restricted instructions and scenarios. Existing benchmarks also typically rely on manual annotation of limited tasks in a few scenes.

The authors argue that exploring the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene is crucial for both extensive evaluation and agent improvement. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Existing benchmarks also typically rely on manual annotation of limited tasks in a few scenes. We argue that exploring the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene is crucial, as they provide both extensive benchmarks for evaluation and valuable resources for agent improvement.

To address this, they introduce ManiTaskGen, a novel system designed to automatically generate comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for any arbitrary scene. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We argue that exploring the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene is crucial, as they provide both extensive benchmarks for evaluation and valuable resources for agent improvement. Towards this end, we introduce ManiTaskGen, a novel system that automatically generates comprehensive, diverse, feasible mobile manipulation tasks for any given scene.

These generated tasks encompass both process-based instructions (e. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Towards this end, we introduce ManiTaskGen, a novel system that automatically generates comprehensive, diverse, feasible mobile manipulation tasks for any given scene. The generated tasks encompass both process-based, specific instructions (e.

g., specific sequences of actions like move object from X to Y) and outcome-based instructions (e.g., abstract goals like clear the table). ManiTaskGen is applied across both simulated and real-world scenes, demonstrating the validity and diversity of its generated tasks. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, "clear the table"). We apply ManiTaskGen to both simulated and real-world scenes, demonstrating the validity and diversity of the generated tasks.

The contributions of this work are threefold: (1) The proposal of ManiTaskGen, a universal system for generating comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for arbitrary scenes. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Finally, we design an improvement method based on Inference-time Reinforcement Learning [26, 27] to leverage ManiTaskGen tasks for enhancing the decision-making abilities of existing VLM agents. In summary, this work makes the following contributions: (1) We propose ManiTaskGen, a universal system for generating comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for arbitrary scenes.

(2) Leveraging these automatically constructed benchmarks to conduct an extensive evaluation of the embodied decision-making capabilities of current vision-language models (VLMs). p. 1
Where the paper says it

In summary, this work makes the following contributions: (1) We propose ManiTaskGen, a universal system for generating comprehensive and diverse mobile manipulation tasks for arbitrary scenes. (2) Leveraging the automatically constructed benchmarks based on the generated tasks, we conduct an extensive evaluation of the embodied decision-making capabilities of current VLMs.

(3) Demonstrating the utility of ManiTaskGen tasks for enhancing embodied decision-making in current VLMs through a proposed inference-time Reinforcement Learning (RL) method. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2) Leveraging the automatically constructed benchmarks based on the generated tasks, we conduct an extensive evaluation of the embodied decision-making capabilities of current VLMs. (3) We demonstrate the utility of the ManiTaskGen tasks for enhancing embodied decision-making in current VLMs through a proposed inference-time RL method.

The system operates by first formalizing the problem space, defining scene states S based on object poses and containment states, and categorizing atomic actions A as parameterized object relocation operations. p. 2

Where the paper says it

1 Premise and Formalization We first formalize the problem space for generating comprehensive mobile manipulation tasks solvable by an agent equipped with fundamental navigate, pick, and place capabilities. We define the scene state S by the states of all objects O = {o1, .

A Receptacle-Aware 3D Scene Graph (S) is then constructed to provide a structured representation of the scene, encoding object relationships and identifying available receptacles by segmenting free space around objects. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2 Receptacle-Aware 3D Scene Graph Construction We construct a scene graph S which serves as a structured representation of the scene, encoding both objects and available receptacles. The input scene information includes: object poses, object bounding boxes, and object mesh models (optional for extracting interior receptacles within objects).

Task generation proceeds in two main ways:

  1. Process-based Tasks: These are generated by systematically sampling and composing feasible action sequences from the derived atomic action set A, using logical connectors (like THEN) to form complex, multi-step trajectories that reflect the agent's interaction cycle.

  2. Outcome-based Tasks: To generate abstract target states, a hybrid approach is used. They instantiate a manually curated dataset of 200 outcome-based task templates (MANITASKOT-200) with scene-specific objects and then employ an ensemble of VLMs to vote on the executability of each generated instruction, filtering for practicality. p. 4

    Where the paper says it

    " Given a scene, we generate outcome-based tasks by instantiating MANITASKOT-200 templates with scene-specific objects. To ensure task feasibility, we then employ an ensemble of VLMs to vote on the executability of each generated instruction, filtering out impractical tasks and refining the final set.

The evaluation phase involves using ManiTaskGen tasks to automatically construct benchmarks, thoroughly assessing the decision-making capabilities of existing VLM agents. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We apply ManiTaskGen to both simulated and real-world scenes, demonstrating the validity and diversity of the generated tasks. We then leverage these tasks to automatically construct benchmarks, thoroughly evaluating the embodied decision-making capabilities of agents built upon existing vision-language models (VLMs).

Furthermore, they propose an inference-time RL method that utilizes these ManiTaskGen tasks to enhance agent capabilities, inspired by methods like Reflexion and ReAct. p. 8
Where the paper says it

steps (Sec. 1), we adopt an inference-time RFT policy to enhance agent capabilities inspired by Reflexion [26] and ReAct [27].

Experiments on both simulated and real-world scenes show that ManiTaskGen generates significantly more tasks than existing datasets, such as ManiTaskGen-RAS-40K containing substantially more tasks than other benchmarks. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We apply ManiTaskGen to both simulated and real-world scenes, demonstrating the validity and diversity of the generated tasks. We then leverage these tasks to automatically construct benchmarks, thoroughly evaluating the embodied decision-making capabilities of agents built upon existing vision-language models (VLMs).

Overall, the work presents a universal task generation framework that facilitates both rigorous benchmarking and the improvement of embodied decision-making agents. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, we propose a simple yet effective method that utilizes ManiTaskGen tasks to enhance embodied decision-making. Overall, this work presents a universal task generation framework for arbitrary scenes, facilitating both benchmarking and improvement of embodied decision-making agents.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Universal Task Generation Framework: ManiTaskGen provides a universal task generation framework for arbitrary scenes, facilitating both benchmarking and improvement of embodied decision-making agents. This allows agents to be evaluated on an extensive benchmark for evaluation across any scene, overcoming the limitation of manual task annotation in specific scenes.

  2. Comprehensive Task Diversity: The system generates both process-based tasks, such as move object from X to Y, by sampling and composing atomic action sequences, and outcome-based tasks, like clear the table, using a hybrid template-based approach combined with VLM voting mechanism. This ensures agents are tested on the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene.

  3. Automated Benchmark Construction: The framework enables the automatic construction of benchmarks using generated tasks to assess embodied agent decision-making capabilities, and conducts extensive evaluations of existing VLMs using this benchmark. This provides a dynamic evaluation platform rather than relying on static, limited datasets.

  4. Inference-time Reinforcement Learning Enhancement: A simple yet effective method leverages ManiTaskGen tasks to enhance embodied decision-making through an inference-time Reinforcement Learning method inspired by Reflexion and ReAct, utilizing a self-reflection model to generate verbal summaries for long-term memory. This optimizes agent capabilities by leveraging feedback of task execution process for unsupervised optimization.

Abstract

Building embodied agents capable of accomplishing arbitrary tasks is a core objective towards achieving embodied artificial general intelligence (E-AGI). While recent work has advanced such general robot policies, their training and evaluation are often limited to tasks within specific scenes, involving restricted instructions and scenarios. Existing benchmarks also typically rely on manual annotation of limited tasks in a few scenes. We argue that exploring the full spectrum of feasible tasks within any given scene is crucial, as they provide both extensive benchmarks for evaluation and valuable resources for agent improvement. Towards this end, we introduce ManiTaskGen, a novel system that automatically generates comprehensive, diverse, feasible mobile manipulation tasks for any given scene. The generated tasks encompass both process-based, specific instructions (e.g., "move object from X to Y") and outcome-based, abstract instructions (e.g., "clear the table"). We apply ManiTaskGen to both simulated and real-world scenes, demonstrating the validity and diversity of the generated tasks. We then leverage these tasks to automatically construct benchmarks, evaluating high-level embodied decision-making through a grounded skill interface for agents built upon existing vision-language models (VLMs). Furthermore, we propose a simple yet effective method that utilizes ManiTaskGen tasks to enhance embodied decision-making. Overall, this work presents a cross-scene task generation framework facilitating both benchmarking and improvement of embodied decision-making agents. Our code is available at https://manitaskgen.github.io.

Sources

Related papers