Causal Fermion Systems: Spacetime as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system

arXiv:2504.19272 · math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2025-04-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Causal Fermion Systems".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Causal fermion systems can be understood as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system This argument highlights that causal fermion systems is a completely relational theory We also explain how our perception of a background (spacetime) emerges in the limit where the number of states taken in consideration goes to infinity This thereby constitutes a complete viable ontology for causal fermion systems which are not reliant on the continuum limit A key insight is the fact that in a relevant subset of causal fermion systems, which includes the continuum limit of the Minkowski vacuum spacetime, minimization of the causal action can be understood as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime.

Kai: The Fundamental Ontology The fundamental ontology proposed in this paper integrates concepts and analogies from various fields, tailoring them to the requirements of CFS First, from information theory, Shannon’s sampling theorem provides intuition for reconstructing information in CFS by adding more and more wave functions Second, we recall that it is a standard feature of many theories that one imagines the behavior of a test object to trace out the properties of the physical system of interest.

Mira: Finally, based on Kempf et al., we assume a correspondence between correlation strength and causal distance.

Kai: The ontology for CFS states that the information of a system is encoded entirely in the two-point correlation strength and the position observables of the states in the Hilbert space.

Paper summary: Kai: So looking at this paper, "Causal Fermion Systems: Spacetime as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system," the authors propose a complete way to understand spacetime as a correlation web in quantum systems.

Mira: They argue that causal fermion systems are relational theories, and that our view of spacetime emerges only when we consider an infinite number of states.

Lev: The implications are that classical gravity and the standard model fields become emergent observables derived from these underlying correlations, which is a significant conceptual shift for how we approach unification.

Kai: The authors suggest this framework is viable because it works within its own structure, relying only on the continuum limit as a tool to encode information rather than being strictly reliant on it.

Mira: It also offers specific predictions, like the idea that fermionic condensate dark matter could explain galactic rotation curves and MOND.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I see the challenge as bridging that gap between these abstract correlation descriptions and the actual physical systems we can build or simulate with finite resources.

Kai: So while it’s a deep ontological framework, it provides a concrete structure where we can look for specific emergent behaviors in our physical experiments.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve seen how this paper looks at spacetime not as something smooth, but as this web of correlations in a many-body quantum system.

Mira: Yeah, and they call it causal fermion systems, which suggests everything is totally relational within that system itself.

Lev: From what I'm seeing in the setup they propose, the core idea is that information isn't stored in fixed points but in the strength of how states are correlated with each other.

Kai: Exactly, and they lay out this fundamental ontology where all those gauge fields we see are just emergent things you infer from how fermions move.

Mira: So it’s not about finding a background spacetime first, but about that spacetime structure actually arising from the way these quantum particles interact.

Lev: The causal action principle they use, with that Lagrangian involving the product of those correlation operators, is what drives the dynamics, and in this paper it connects to standard gravity in a very specific way.

Kai: They say if you take that continuum limit, which is like taking an infinite number of states, then those equations actually give us the equations for general relativity and the standard model fields.

Mira: That’s a big claim because it means they aren't just guessing; they’re saying the structure of spacetime has a mathematical origin in this fermionic system.

Lev: But I gotta ask, how do you actually measure that correlation strength in a real experiment? What would be the experimental signature for this web of correlations?

Kai: That’s the million-dollar question, and that leads us right into how we might test these ideas with current quantum hardware.

Fakultat für Mathematik, University of Regensburg · Fakultat für Mathematik, TU Chemnitz

math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2025-04-27

Updated: 2025-04-27

Journal ref: Class. Quantum Grav. 43, 045005 (2026)

DOI: 10.1088/1361-6382/ae2379

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 66/100

The gist: Causal fermion systems can be understood as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system This argument highlights that causal fermion systems is a completely relational theory We also…

Key concepts

Fundamental Ontology
The core idea is that all physical information is encoded solely in two-point correlation strengths and the positions of states within a Hilbert space. Other perceived concepts, like gauge fields, are emergent properties inferred from how fermion positions change.
Causal Action Principle
This principle uses a specific Lagrangian to describe the dynamics of causal fermion systems. Minimizing this action mathematically defines the system's evolution. In the continuum limit, this minimization corresponds to minimizing fluctuations within the causal structure of spacetime itself.
Spacetime as Correlation Map
Local points in classical spacetime are identified with operators in a set representing many fermion states. Spacetime is defined by the support of a measure, meaning physical locations are fundamentally encoded as linear operators that capture local correlation information.

Terminology

Summary

Causal fermion systems can be understood as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system This argument highlights that causal fermion systems is a completely relational theory We also explain how our perception of a background (spacetime) emerges in the limit where the number of states taken in consideration goes to infinity This thereby constitutes a complete viable ontology for causal fermion systems which are not reliant on the continuum limit A key insight is the fact that in a relevant subset of causal fermion systems, which includes the continuum limit of the Minkowski vacuum spacetime, minimization of the causal action can be understood as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This thereby constitutes a complete viable ontology for causal fermion systems which are not reliant on the continuum limit. A key insight is the fact that in a relevant subset of causal fermion systems, which includes the continuum limit of the Minkowski vacuum spacetime, minimization of the causal action can be understood as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime.

The Fundamental Ontology

The fundamental ontology proposed in this paper integrates concepts and analogies from various fields, tailoring them to the requirements of CFS First, from information theory, Shannon’s sampling theorem provides intuition for reconstructing information in CFS by adding more and more wave functions Second, we recall that it is a standard feature of many theories that one imagines the behavior of a test object to trace out the properties of the physical system of interest. Finally, based on Kempf et al. p. 3

Where the paper says it

This is another case where working with an auxiliary Hilbert space makes it easier to connect to established frameworks. Finally, based on Kempf et al.

, we assume a correspondence between correlation strength and causal distance. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Finally, based on Kempf et al. [74, 61], we assume a correspondence between the correlation strength and the causal distance.

The ontology for CFS states that the information of a system is encoded entirely in the two-point correlation strength and the position observables of the states in the Hilbert space. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Minimizing the action therefore leads to the principle of minimal fluctuations. In summary, the ontology for CFS that we present here states that the information of a system is encoded entirely in the two-point correlation strength and the position observables of the states in the Hilbert space.

All other physical concepts that we perceive, including all the gauge fields, are emergent observables inferred from the change in position of fermions. p. 4
Where the paper says it

CAUSAL FERMION SYSTEMS 5 (spacetime) position of fermions, these are the ‘beables’ of the theory2 . All other physical concepts that we perceive, including all the gauge fields, are emergent observables inferred from the change in position of fermions.

The Causal Action Principle

The causal action principle is defined by a Lagrangian L(x, y) = 1/4n Sum over i,j=1 to 4n λxy i - λxy j squared. This principle is mathematically well-posed if H is finite-dimensional. p. 8

Where the paper says it

CAUSAL FERMION SYSTEMS 9 under the following constraints volume constraint: ρ(Fn) = 1, trace constraint: Z Fn tr(x)dρ(x) = 1, boundedness constraint: Z Fn   X 2n j=1 λ xy j   2 dρ(x) ≤ const. This variational principle is mathematically well-posed if H is finite-dimensional (for details, see [33, Section 1.

A minimizer satisfies the Euler-Lagrange (EL) equations which describe the dynamics of the CFS. p. 8
Where the paper says it

This variational principle is mathematically well-posed if H is finite-dimensional (for details, see [33, Section 1. A minimizer satisfies the Euler-Lagrange (EL) equations which state that for suitable parameters κ,r, s > 0 (Lagrange multipliers of the boundedness, trace and volume constraints), the function ℓ : Fn → R + 0 defined by ℓ(x) := Z M L(x, y)dρ(y) + κ Z M   X 2n j=1 λ xy j   2 dρ(y) − rtr x − s (2.

In a suitable limiting case, referred to as the continuum limit, the EL equations give rise to the equations of motion for fields in standard model and GR. p. 8
Where the paper says it

7) These equations describe the dynamics of the CFS. In a suitable limiting case, referred to as the continuum limit, the EL equations give rise to the equations of motion for the fields in the standard model and GR, for details see [33].

The Lagrangian is interpreted in the continuum limit as a variance of the causal correlation operator. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Thereby, we show that the fermionic projector matches the two-point correlator familiar from standard formulations of quantum field theory in Minkowski space. Moreover, in this limit, we see that we can cast the Lagrangian in the causal action principle into a more suggestive form, namely as the variance of the two-point correlation strength.

Emergence of Spacetime Structures

The local correlation map F[gµν, Aµ,...]: M → Fn allows us to identify points in a classical spacetime M with operators in the set Fn. p. 5

Where the paper says it

2) For a more detailed motivation of this construction see e. For our purpose, the crucial point is that the map allows us to identify points in a classical spacetime M with operators in the set Fn.

The notion of spacetime in CFS is defined as the support of the measure, M:= supp ρ. Spacetime points x are linear operators on H that encode local correlation information. p. 7
Where the paper says it

PAGANINI As noted above, spacetime points x, y, · · · ∈ M ⊂ F ⊂ L(H) in CFS are linear operators on H. They encode the local correlation information and have additional structure compared to classical spacetime points, namely their eigenvalues and eigenspaces.

The causal structure is studied by examining the spectral properties of the operator product xy. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Our aim in the present paper is to expand on these inherent structures to establish a first proposal for a complete ontology of the theory that does not rely on emergent structures of the continuum limit. To define a causal structure in spacetime, we study the spectral properties of the operator product xy.

In the continuum limit, this structure coincides with the usual causal structure of Minkowski spacetime. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This thereby constitutes a complete viable ontology for causal fermion systems which are not reliant on the continuum limit. A key insight is the fact that in a relevant subset of causal fermion systems, which includes the continuum limit of the Minkowski vacuum spacetime, minimization of the causal action can be understood as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime.

Experimental Framework

To test a system that comprises the entire universe from within itself, one takes inspiration from GR by treating a small subsystem as a test body and studying its trajectory. The probe-background split is defined such that H = HP ⊕ HB and Ω = ωP + ωB. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Here, it is important to note that there is one caveat to the above statement that any subsystem can serve as a test system: it is intuitively clear that in order for an experiment to be conducted, a system needs to be suitably localized. Therefore, not every split of the system into background and probe is equally viable as a description for laboratory experiments.

The continuum limit for Minkowski space corresponds to the Dirac sea, where only negative energy solutions are occupied. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, in Section 4 we see that in the example of the Minkowski spacetime, this construction complements the Dirac sea with the positive energy solutions of the Dirac equation. Given an auxiliary Hilbert space H˜ we can return to the fundamental Hilbert space of the CFS through a projection Ω : H → H ˜ for which trH˜ [Ω] = trH [idH] = dim H = N holds.

All states in the continuum limit of Minkowski space are delocalized. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In Section 4 the continuum limit of CFS is discussed for the example of Minkowski spacetime. Thereby, we show that the fermionic projector matches the two-point correlator familiar from standard formulations of quantum field theory in Minkowski space.

Outlook and Conclusion

The paper proposes a first proposal for a full CFS ontology that works within the structures of the theory alone, relying on the continuum limit only as an efficient tool to encode information. The authors suggest that in the large N = dim H limit, a large class of CFS admit an emergent description in terms of a local correlation map and therefore in terms of classical field gµν, Aµ, etc. p. 5

Where the paper says it

For notational simplicity, we denote the image of a classical spacetime point x under the local correlation map F [gµν , Aµ, . ](x) := x with the 3Throughout the paper classical spacetime refers to a (3 + 1)-dimensional, timeorientable, Lorentzian manifold while spacetime corresponds to the structure in CFS defined below.

This suggests that the classical spacetime is the limit of equipartition of the correlation strength. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Near the continuum limit, we can make this identification of a spacetime point with the correlation information more concrete. To this end, we introduce a map from a classical spacetime3 and matter configuration into the operator manifold F reg n .

The paper also raises several open questions regarding distance notions and causal order at mesoscopic scales. The CFS framework is conceptually incompatible with some scenarios studied in the literature, such as those involving spatial superposition of macroscopic objects. p. 3
Where the paper says it

This way of constructing a background/ (quantum) reference frame is strictly incompatible with some of the scenarios studied in the context of QRF as we explain in this section. Fourth, we want to incorporate the intuition underlying many particle quantum systems [29, 111, 108] into the description of CFS.

The paper suggests that the fermionic condensate dark matter (FCDM) model could provide a natural explanation for the disparity between galactic rotation curves and MOND. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we close this gap and put forward a first proposal for a full physical interpretation of CFS that is a priori independent of the effective description in terms of classical spacetime and matter fields. We propose a concise and viable ontology of the theory, starting with the realization that the fermionic projector, which has been introduced by Finster to encapsulate the information contained in the Dirac sea; is, in Minkowski space, nothing else than the fermionic two-point correlator.

The non-interacting picture is a good approximation for the vacuum spacetime in CFS. p. 2
Where the paper says it

It is implicitly understood that in the real world, the test bodies are, of course, also part of the system and influence spacetime. For experiments, this is usually a good enough approximation as long as the test particle is sufficiently small relative to the physical system being tested1 .

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can model physical theories as many-body quantum systems using an auxiliary Hilbert space to facilitate perturbation theory and connect to condensed matter physics concepts like band structures. This allows for a more rigorous treatment of emergent fields as linearized perturbations of the fermionic system.

  2. The AI can perform calculations within the framework of causal fermion systems by minimizing the causal action, which is interpreted as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime. This means it can use variance of correlation strength to determine dynamics rather than relying solely on standard field equations.

  3. The system can be equipped with an ontology where spacetime points x, y, · · · ∈ M are linear operators on H encoding local correlation information, allowing for the study of causality via spectral properties like spacelike or timelike separation without needing a pre-defined metric.

Abstract

In this paper, we argue that spacetime in causal fermion systems can be understood as the web of correlations of a many-body quantum system.This argument highlights the fact that causal fermion systems is a completely relational theory. We also explain how our perception of a background (spacetime) emerges in the limit where the number of states taken in consideration goes to infinity. This thereby constitutes a complete viable ontology for causal fermion systems which are not reliant on the continuum limit. A key insight is the fact that in a relevant subset of causal fermion systems, which includes the continuum limit of the Minkowski vacuum spacetime, minimization of the causal action can be understood as a minimization of fluctuations in the causal structure of spacetime.

Sources

Related papers