Closer look at some sum uncertainty relations and related relations: Their weak points
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Closer look at some sum uncertainty relations and related relations".
Title and authors: Mira: So, Kai, you mentioned that this paper is comparing these new sum uncertainty relations against the standard Heisenberg–Robertson one. What exactly is the main takeaway from their summary of this work?
Kai: Well, the summary says they are analyzing various uncertainty relations for sums of standard deviations and sums of variances. They’re looking at how these relations behave when you move from two observables to N non-commuting observables, where N is greater than or equal to two.
Lev: So they are generalizing the basic idea of uncertainty principles from just two variables up to a whole set of them, which is a step up in complexity for any simulation or hardware setup. What’s the point of that generalization?
Mira: The point, according to their summary, is that this generalization allows them to create a "sum uncertainty relation" for N non-commuting observables, where you get an inequality involving the sum of standard deviations of all those observables versus the standard deviation of their sum.
Kai: And they also introduce "stronger sum uncertainty relations" derived from the triangle inequality of the second kind. These stronger relations give us a specific type of bound on variances, like this one: the variance of A plus B is less than or equal to half the variance of A plus B, which sounds counterintuitive but it’s what they derive as an inequality.
Lev: I need to understand that inequality better because if it’s a stronger relation for variances, does it mean we can get a tighter constraint on how spread out the measurements are compared to just looking at the standard deviations individually?
Mira: Yes, that's the idea. They use these stronger relations to get bounds on products of standard deviations too, like the one that states that variance of A plus B is greater than or equal to two times the product of their individual standard deviations.
Kai: So essentially, they are taking a simple idea—the triangle inequality for vectors in Hilbert space—and applying it rigorously to these uncertainty relations, and finding where the standard ones break down. It’s about characterizing the spread of measurements when you have multiple incompatible observables.
The paper's summary: Lev: I'm interested in the actual mathematical improvements they propose. What specific modifications do they suggest to make these uncertainty relations more useful than what we already have?
Mira: The main improvement they point to is analyzing those critical points we talked about earlier. They suggest focusing on cases where the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation has a right hand side of zero, because that's where the new sum uncertainty relations actually show their advantage by providing information that the standard one misses.
Kai: So, they are explicitly looking at those scenarios to prove that these sum uncertainty relations are better tools for characterizing quantum systems than just relying on the original pair-wise relation. They are testing them under conditions where we know something specific about the relationship between A and B already holds.
Lev: And they also point out how the stronger sum uncertainty relations can give a lower bound on the product of standard deviations, which is different from just looking at their individual standard deviations separately. That’s concrete information for experimentalists who are trying to set measurement limits.
Mira: They also showed that for uncorrelated observables, where the complex part Cclas phi of A and B is zero, these relations simplify to something very clean: the product of standard deviations must be greater than or equal to zero.
Kai: That simplified result is equivalent to the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation when you assume that specific condition on Cclas phi holds true. It means they’ve mapped out exactly when their new relations align with what we already expect from basic quantum theory under those conditions, which is important for consistency checks.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, the main point is that analyzing these sum uncertainty relations reveals where the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation has weaknesses—specifically in cases like when you’re in an eigenstate of one observable.
Mira: And the authors argue that these new sum uncertainty relations offer improvements because they can provide lower bounds on standard deviations in those weak points, and they handle the other critical cases better, like when the right hand side of the HR relation is zero.
Lev: From an engineering perspective, it means if we use a set of observables, we should be using these sum relations to ensure we don't miss constraints on measurement spread or error accumulation that standard relations would overlook.
Kai: Exactly. And they show how even when things are uncorrelated, the relation simplifies to a non-negative product of standard deviations, which is just the standard uncertainty principle under that specific condition.
Mira: So it’s less about replacing everything and more about understanding the nuances of when to use each tool based on the state of your quantum system and what kind of constraint you actually need. This paper, "Closer look at some sum uncertainty relations and related relations: Their weak points", gives us a clearer picture of the limits for applying these generalized uncertainty principles.
Lev: I think this analysis is useful because it gives us criteria for testing the performance of quantum sensors and systems when they are dealing with multiple, non-commuting measurements. It helps us decide what level of theoretical rigor we need to apply to ensure our experimental results are meaningful.
Conclusion: Mira: So we've been looking at "Closer look at some sum uncertainty relations and related relations: Their weak points." The main point is that these new sum uncertainty relations can give us tighter bounds on the spread of measurements when you have multiple observables, especially in those tricky cases where the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation seems to break down.
Kai: Yeah, it's about taking that triangle inequality idea from Hilbert space and applying it to sets of non-commuting observables, not just two of them. It shows us exactly what information we can actually get out of a set of measurements.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, the paper is useful because they show where the standard uncertainty relation stops giving you useful limits when you have more than two variables involved in your system.
Mira: Exactly, and they highlight that when things are uncorrelated—when the complex part of the measurement correlation is zero—the sum uncertainty relation simplifies nicely to just a simple non-negative product of standard deviations.
Kai: That’s important because it means you don't need the full complexity of those advanced relations if your observables are actually independent. It brings us back to basics under certain conditions.
Lev: And they also give us a way to check our work against the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation in those specific zero-correlation scenarios, which is a good consistency check for any simulation or experimental setup you're building.
Mira: Overall, this paper sharpens our understanding of how these uncertainty relations behave across more than just two observables. It shows us the limits and where we need to be careful with our assumptions about correlations.
Kai: It’s a solid piece on characterizing the spread of expected values for non-commuting observables under different conditions.
Lev: For real hardware, this means we can better predict the measurement errors when we're dealing with a larger set of coupled systems rather than just pairs.
Mira: So if you're working on multi-qubit systems or complex condensed matter setups, keep an eye on these sum relations for those tight bounds.
Kai: Yeah, because understanding those weak points is what lets us build better error correction protocols that account for all the possible measurements at once.
Lev: Next time we look at some of these papers from arXiv, we’ll be digging into how quantum transport behaves along bosonic chains connected to Markovian reservoirs. That's a whole different kind of system entirely.
Krzysztof Urbanowski
Institute of Physics, University of Zielona Góra
quant-ph, physics.app-ph, physics.data-an
Submitted: 2025-04-12
Updated: 2026-11-18
Comments: 25 pages, new comments and references added, draft
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 75/100
The gist: We analyze the weak and critical points of various uncertainty relations that follow from the inequalities for the norms of vectors in the Hilbert space of states of a quantum system.
Key concepts
- Heisenberg–Robertson Uncertainty Relation
- This fundamental relation applies to noncommuting observables A and B, stating that the product of their uncertainties is bounded. It arises from basic quantum assumptions and Hilbert space geometry, showing how the expectation value of the commutator relates to state uncertainty.
- Sum Uncertainty Relation
- This generalization extends the triangle inequality to multiple noncommuting observables (N ≥ 2). For standard deviations, it states that the sum of individual uncertainties is greater than or equal to the uncertainty of their sum, providing a bound on how observables behave together.
- Stronger Sum Uncertainty Relations
- These relations are derived from the triangle inequality of the second kind. They provide tighter bounds on variances, such as $(\Delta\phi A)^2 + (\Delta\phi B)^2 \geq 1/2(\Delta\phi(A + B))^2$, offering a more stringent constraint than simple sum relations.
Terminology
Summary
We analyze the weak and critical points of various uncertainty relations that follow from the inequalities for the norms of vectors in the Hilbert space of states of a quantum system. p. 0 urbanowski@gmail. com
August 13, 2025
Abstract
We analyze the weak and critical points of various uncertainty relations that follow from the inequalities for the norms of vectors in the
Hilbert space of states of a quantum system. There are studied uncertainty relations for sums of standard deviations, for sums of variances,
and other relations between standard deviations or variances. The obtained results are compared with the conclusions obtained in similar
cases using the standard Heisenberg–Robertson uncertainty relation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Heisenberg–Robertson Uncertainty Relation
The inequality (2) holds for each pair of noncommuting observables A and B represented by Hermitian operators acting in the state space H of the physical system under study, such that [A, B] exists and ϕ⟩ ∈ D(AB) T D(BA) ⊂ H. This relation is derived from basic assumptions of quantum theory and from the geometry of Hilbert space. p. 2 2 Heisenberg–Robertson uncertainty relation
As we have already mentioned, the inequality (2) holds for each pair of noncommuting observables A and B represented by Hermitian operators acting
in the state space H of the physical system under study, such that [A, B]
exists and |ϕ⟩ ∈ D(AB)
T
D(BA) ⊂ H, (D(O) denotes the domain of an
operator O or of a product of operators). Note that, the relation (2) results
from basic assumptions of the quantum theory and from the geometry of
Hilbert space. where δϕF = F − ⟨F⟩ϕ I, and defining
δϕA = A − ⟨A⟩ϕ I, and, δϕB = B − ⟨B⟩ϕ I, (5)
one finds that
[A, B] ≡ [δϕA, δϕB], (6)
for all |ϕ⟩ ∈ D(AB)
T
D(BA). Taking all this into account, we get that
|⟨ϕ|[A, B]|ϕ⟩|2 ≡ |⟨ϕ|[δϕA, δϕB]|ϕ⟩|2
(7)
≡ | ⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩ − ⟨ϕ|δϕB δϕA|ϕ⟩ |2
= | ⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩ − (⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩)
∗
|
2
= 4 |Im. Taking all this into account, we get that
|⟨ϕ|[A, B]|ϕ⟩|2 ≡ |⟨ϕ|[δϕA, δϕB]|ϕ⟩|2
(7)
≡ | ⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩ − ⟨ϕ|δϕB δϕA|ϕ⟩ |2
= | ⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩ − (⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩)
∗
|
2
= 4 |Im. [⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩] |
2
(8)
≤ 4 | ⟨ϕ|δϕA δϕB|ϕ⟩ |2
(9)
≤ 4 ∥δϕA|ϕ⟩∥2
· ∥δϕB|ϕ⟩∥2
≡ 4 (∆ϕA)
2
· (∆ϕB)
2
, (10)
which reproduces inequality (2).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Sum Uncertainty Relations
The Inserting into (16)
|ψA⟩ = δϕA|ϕ⟩, |ψB⟩ = δϕB|ϕ⟩, (33)
one gets
∥ δϕA|ϕ⟩∥ + ∥ δϕB|ϕ⟩∥ ≥ ∥δϕA|ϕ⟩ + δϕB|ϕ⟩∥ . (34)
Next, taking into account (4), we see that the inequality (34) can be written
in terms of standard deviations as
∆ϕA + ∆ϕB ≥ ∆ϕ(A + B). (36)
The inequality (35) is the sum uncertainty relation derived in [9] and discussed in the literature. The generalization of the triangle inequality to N vectors allows generalizing the sum uncertainty relation (35) for two noncommuting observables to
the case of N non–commuting observables {Aj}
N
j=1 with N ≥ 2 for standard
deviations, (∆ϕA1),(∆ϕA2), . The generalization of the triangle inequality to N vectors allows generalizing the sum uncertainty relation (35) for two noncommuting observables to
the case of N non–commuting observables {Aj}
N
j=1 with N ≥ 2 for standard
deviations, (∆ϕA1),(∆ϕA2), . ,(∆ϕAN ),
X
N
j=1
(∆ϕAj ) ≥ ∆ϕ(
X
N
j=1
Aj ).sum uncertainty relation
derived in [9] and discussed in the literature is given by ∆ϕA + ∆ϕB ≥ ∆ϕ(A + B). This inequality can be written in terms of standard deviations as ∆ϕA + ∆ϕB ≥ ∆ϕ(A + B). p. 6Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Stronger Sum Uncertainty Relations
The Next, taking into account (36), we can replace inequality (38) by the following
one,
∥ δϕA|ϕ⟩∥2 + ∥ δϕB|ϕ⟩∥2 ≥
1
2
∥ |δϕ(A + B)|ϕ⟩∥2
. (39)
Keeping in mind (4) one concludes that the inequality (39) means that
(∆ϕA)
2 + (∆ϕB)
2 ≥
1
2
(∆ϕ(A + B))2
, (40)
and this inequality is called "the stronger sum uncertainty relations" and is
the one of sum of variances uncertainty relations derived in [5]. (39)
Keeping in mind (4) one concludes that the inequality (39) means that
(∆ϕA)
2 + (∆ϕB)
2 ≥
1
2
(∆ϕ(A + B))2
, (40)
and this inequality is called "the stronger sum uncertainty relations" and is
the one of sum of variances uncertainty relations derived in [5]. Note that there is also a related relation resulting from (19).stronger sum uncertainty relations
for variances are obtained from the triangle inequality of the second kind (17). This leads to the inequality (39) which means that (∆ϕA)2 + (∆ϕB)2 ≥ 1/2(∆ϕ(A + B))2. p. 7Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Critical Points Analysis
When the state ϕ⟩ is an eigenstate of one of the observables, e.g., B, relations (48) and (49) take the form ∆ψbA ≥ ∆ψbA. p. 8 In such a case, relations
(12) and (14) are satisfied, which means that property (15) takes place, and
by virtue of (36) we obtain
δψb
(A ± B)|ψb⟩ ≡ δψbA|ψb⟩ ± δψbB|ψb⟩ ≡ δψbA|ψb⟩. (46)
The elementary conclusion following from this last relation is that the right
hand–side of the inequality (35) calculated for |ϕ⟩ = |ψb⟩ looks as follows
∆ψb
(A + B) ≡ ∆ψbA, (47)
and consequently the inequality (35) takes the form,
∆ψbA ≥ ∆ψbA. (48)
Thus, if the quantum system under study is in a state that is an eigenstate of
one of the observables, e. B, then, similarly to the HR uncertainty relation,
the sum uncertainty relation (35) does not provide any information about a
lower bound on the standard deviation ∆ψbA of the observable A. (39)
Keeping in mind (4) one concludes that the inequality (39) means that
(∆ϕA)
2 + (∆ϕB)
2 ≥
1
2
(∆ϕ(A + B))2
, (40)
and this inequality is called "the stronger sum uncertainty relations" and is
the one of sum of variances uncertainty relations derived in [5]. Note that there is also a related relation resulting from (19). We will now focus on the analysis of the properties of the inequality (40),
or more precisely, on the study of the equivalent inequality (39) preceding it. Let us now repeat our calculations performed for the Heisenberg– Robertson
uncertainty principle and for the sum uncertainty relation (35) in the case
where |ϕ⟩ is an eigenvector of the operator, e.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve uncertainty principle analysis by incorporating sum uncertainty relations to find lower bounds on standard deviations, as shown in inequality (40) and (45). This allows for a more complete understanding of the spread of expected values for non-commuting observables A and B in state phi.
-
Enhance predictive capabilities for quantum measurements by utilizing the reverse uncertainty relation derived from inequality (62), which provides an upper bound on the product of standard deviations, offering a constraint beyond the standard Heisenberg–Robertson relation.
-
Develop systems capable of distinguishing between classical and quantum correlation effects by using the stronger sum uncertainty relations to show that
the right side of the HR inequality (2) can be different from zero
when imaginary part Cclas phi (A, B) is zero, as in equation (60). -
Improve state characterization by leveraging the properties derived for uncorrelated observables where Cphi(A, B) equals zero, leading to the conclusion that "if Cphi(A, B) = 0 then psiA> ⊥ psiB>" and simplifying uncertainty relations to delta phi A multiplied by delta phi B greater than or equal to zero.
Abstract
We analyze the weak and critical points of some state--dependent uncertainty relations that follow from the inequalities for the norms of vectors in the Hilbert space of states of a quantum system. Uncertainty relations for sums of standard deviations, for sums of variances, and other relations between standard deviations or variances are studied. The obtained results are compared with the conclusions obtained in similar cases using the standard Heisenberg--Robertson uncertainty relation. We also show that, in critical cases, the right--hand sides of sum and stronger sum uncertainty relations provide similar information regarding lower bounds on the left--hand sides of these relations as the Heisenberg--Robertson uncertainty relations do. New reverse uncertainty relations for a sum of variances are derived.
Sources
- On a certain inequality for the sum of norms and reverse uncertainty relations
- On some states minimizing uncertainty relations: A new look at these relations
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements