Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems performance analysis over 16Km Aerial Fibers

arXiv:2503.03436 · cs.CR · Submitted 2025-03-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Security Radio. Generated commentary on the latest security and cryptography papers.

Nadia: We're looking at the paper: "Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems performance analysis over 16Km Aerial Fibers".

Elias: Here's the gist of the paper. We report on the impact of aerial optical fiber on QKD systems performance by applying two QKD systems with different encoding methods The TBP system encoding system was able to produce keys for longer time periods than the PB system, highlighting the increased sensitivity of polarization encoding to environmental fluctuations in aerial fiber.

Nadia: System Comparison and Encoding Methods The experimental testbed featured two commercially available QKD systems, both implementing the BB84 protocol The ThinkQuantum QUKY with polarization-based encoding and the IDQuantique Clavis XG with time-bin and phase encoding at its X and Y base respectively were used.

Elias: The TBP QKD system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses.

Nadia: On the other hand, the PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding.

Title and authors: Nadia: This paper is basically comparing two different ways to encode quantum states, time-bin phase and polarization, over a specific distance of sixteen kilometers of aerial fiber >

Elias: The core idea is testing which encoding method holds up better when you introduce the unpredictable changes that happen in the air >

The paper's summary: Nadia: They set up two systems, a TBP system and a PB system, both using different methods to send those quantum keys >

Elias: The TBP system uses both time-bin encoding and phase encoding on one base of the BB84 protocol, while the PB system relies only on polarization encoding >

The paper's improvements: Nadia: The authors tested these systems under different attenuation levels, specifically testing the TBP system at ten, twenty-three and thirty decibels of loss >

Elias: And they focused a lot on how the aerial fiber really impacts the key generation rate when you move from a controlled lab setup to that aerial link >

Conclusion: Nadia: So what we see is that the TBP system showed greater stability across those different attenuation levels compared to the PB system, which is pretty telling when you're dealing with real-world fiber environments >

Elias: The paper shows that the PB system got really disrupted, for example, it stopped generating keys for ten point eight hours in a mixed setup with an aerial segment because it was stuck trying to reset its bases >

Priya: I just want to know what that disruption actually means for the data we're getting; does that downtime mean we lose enough secure key material to matter?

Nadia: Well, the paper shows that for the PB system, during those disruptions, the system spent most of its time in a base agreement stage trying to reinitialize its QBER bases while secure key generation stopped completely >

Elias: And they found that for higher attenuation levels of thirty decibels, the TBP system's secret key rate dropped by fifty percent when compared to when it was tested in a controlled lab fiber setup >

Priya: That drop in the TBP system sounds significant because it shows that even with a more stable protocol, high loss still hurts the final output rate over aerial fiber >

Nadia: Exactly; and they pointed out that this degradation correlates with service channel loss from logs, which they linked to reflections from things like circulators or patch cords used in the setup >

Elias: So what this tells us for the real world is that terrestrial fibers generally seem more stable than aerial setups because of those unpredictable changes in the state of polarization >

Nadia: Right, and when you look at the whole picture with this "Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems performance analysis over 16Km Aerial Fibers," it's clear that choosing the right encoding method is actually critical for surviving environmental stress > <ref:2503.03436#pg1,Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems performance analysis over 16Km>

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens · GRNET S.A – National Infrastructures for Research and Technology

cs.CR

Submitted: 2025-03-05

Updated: 2025-03-05

Journal ref: Proceedings of the 2025 30th OptoElectronics and Communications Conference (OECC) and 2025 International Conference on Photonics in Switching and Computing (PSC), 2025

DOI: 10.23919/OECC/PSC62146.2025.11111151

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 68/100

The gist: We report on the impact of aerial optical fiber on QKD systems performance by applying two QKD systems with different encoding methods The TBP system encoding system was able to produce keys for…

Key concepts

Polarization Encoding
This method encodes quantum information using the orientation of light's electric field, specifically its polarization direction (like horizontal or vertical). The paper notes this method is highly vulnerable to sudden changes in the fiber's State of Polarization (SOP), which causes errors.
Time-bin Encoding
This encoding uses the arrival time difference between two pulses to represent quantum information. The TBP system uses this alongside phase encoding, providing a more robust method because it is less sensitive to polarization changes compared to purely polarization-based systems.
Secret Key Rate (SKR)
SKR measures how many secure bits can be generated per unit of time. A higher SKR indicates better performance and security for the QKD system. The paper shows that the TBP system maintained a higher SKR under stressful conditions like high attenuation compared to the PB system.
QBER (Quantum Bit Error Rate)
QBER is a metric that quantifies how many errors occur during the quantum key generation process. A high QBER means more noise and lower security. The paper observed that the PB system's QBER increased significantly, indicating its vulnerability to polarization changes.

Terminology

Summary

We report on the impact of aerial optical fiber on QKD systems performance by applying two QKD systems with different encoding methods The TBP system encoding system was able to produce keys for longer time periods than the PB system, highlighting the increased sensitivity of polarization encoding to environmental fluctuations in aerial fiber. p. 0

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the polarization-based system also managed to achieve stable performance, requiring however more frequent initialization process of the protocol. Each configuration was tested for 40 hours, and the results indicate that the TBP system encoding system was able to produce keys for longer time periods than the PB system, highlighting the increased sensitivity of polarization encoding to environmental fluctuations in aerial fiber.

System Comparison and Encoding Methods

The experimental testbed featured two commercially available QKD systems, both implementing the BB84 protocol The ThinkQuantum QUKY with polarization-based encoding and the IDQuantique Clavis XG with time-bin and phase encoding at its X and Y base respectively were used. The TBP QKD system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This is further confirmed by increase of QBER in both bases as shown in Fig. Overall, the increased stability of the TBP system can be attributed to the employed protocol: The TBP system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses [11].

On the other hand, the PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Even though polarization changes can affect the time-bin base because of changes in SOP, the other base in not affected since the same effect will occur in both consecutive pulses. On the other hand, the PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding.

Performance Under Different Attenuation Levels

The TBP system showed greater stability under varying conditions, which is why it was tested across multiple attenuation levels to assess its performance under stress. The QKD system using the phase and timebin (TBP) encoding was tested at three different attenuation levels (10, 23 and 30 dB). p. 0

Where the paper says it

8 dB of attenuation), consisting of 16 km of aerial fiber and 14 km of subterranean fiber, achieving SKR up to 6 kbps. The QKD system using the phase and timebin (TBP) encoding, with a power budget of 30 dB, was tested at three different attenuation levels (10, 23 and 30 dB), while the polarization-based (PB) QKD system, with a nominal operational limit of 20 dB, was only tested at 15 dB of line attenuation.

The PB system was only tested at 15 dB of line attenuation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

8 dB of attenuation), consisting of 16 km of aerial fiber and 14 km of subterranean fiber, achieving SKR up to 6 kbps. The QKD system using the phase and timebin (TBP) encoding, with a power budget of 30 dB, was tested at three different attenuation levels (10, 23 and 30 dB), while the polarization-based (PB) QKD system, with a nominal operational limit of 20 dB, was only tested at 15 dB of line attenuation.

TABLE I presents the mean values for SKR and QBER metrics for all tested scenarios. p. 2
Where the paper says it

70 PB 15 dB 1458. 69 To make a direct comparison between the mixed fiber setup and in-lab setup TABLE I presents the mean values for SKR and QBER metrics for all tested scenarios.

Impact of Aerial Fiber on Key Generation

The SKR performance for each scenario is shown in Fig. 2a-d. During operation, the quantum key generation for the PB-system over the aerial fiber was disrupted 35 times accounting for 24. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The SKR performance for each scenario is shown in Fig. During operation, the quantum key generation for the PB-system over the aerial fiber was disrupted 35 times accounting for 24.

82% of the total operation time due to SOP changes. p. 1
Where the paper says it

During operation, the quantum key generation for the PB-system over the aerial fiber was disrupted 35 times accounting for 24. 82% of the total operation time due to SOP changes.

In contrast, the in-lab fiber setup exhibited perfect stability without any disruptions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

82% of the total operation time due to SOP changes. In contrast, the in-lab fiber setup exhibited perfect stability without any disruptions.

For the TBP system, the SKR performance degrades with higher attenuation and stable operation is observed in every tested attenuation level, both for the aerial and in-lab fiber setups. p. 2
Where the paper says it

from the circulators and the fiber patch cords used. As expected, for the TBP pair performance degrades with higher attenuation and stable operation is observed in every tested attenuation level, both for the aerial and in-lab fiber setups.

Conclusion on System Sensitivity

The TBP system's increased stability can be attributed to the employed protocol. The PB system operation was disrupted for 10. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The SKR performance for each scenario is shown in Fig. During operation, the quantum key generation for the PB-system over the aerial fiber was disrupted 35 times accounting for 24.

8 hours in the mixed fiber with aerial segment setup. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As expected, for the TBP pair performance degrades with higher attenuation and stable operation is observed in every tested attenuation level, both for the aerial and in-lab fiber setups. On the other hand, the PB pair successfully produced keys in the in-lab setup, but in the mixed fiber with aerial segment setup the operation was disrupted for 10.

This period showed that the system spent most of the time in base agreement stage attempting to reinitialize the QBER bases while secure key generation ceased, producing zero values. p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the PB pair successfully produced keys in the in-lab setup, but in the mixed fiber with aerial segment setup the operation was disrupted for 10. In this period the system spent most of the time in base agreement stage attempting to reinitialize the QBER bases while secure key generation ceased, producing zero values as shown in Fig.

Overall terrestrial fibers demonstrate greater stability than the corresponding aerial fiber setups in every encoding method, due to unpredictable SOP changes. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Each configuration was tested for 40 hours, and the results indicate that the TBP system encoding system was able to produce keys for longer time periods than the PB system, highlighting the increased sensitivity of polarization encoding to environmental fluctuations in aerial fiber. Overall terrestrial fibers demonstrate greater stability than the corresponding aerial fiber setups in every encoding method, due to unpredictable SOP changes.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The QBER performance for both systems is monitored in Fig. 3. The PB system exhibited an increase of QBER in both bases as shown in Fig. p. 2

Where the paper says it

This is further confirmed by increase of QBER in both bases as shown in Fig. Overall, the increased stability of the TBP system can be attributed to the employed protocol: The TBP system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses [11].

3c,d. This suggests the increased vulnerability of the polarization-based system to steep polarization changes. p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding. This could result in increased vulnerability to steep polarization changes, requiring a fast polarization compensation to correct basis misalignment.

The TBP system's performance degradation corresponds to a 50% drop of SKR for the 30 dB attenuation level when compared to in-lab fiber. This indicates that higher attenuation levels negatively affect the TBP system's key rate over aerial fiber. The PB system performance drop during operation phase also drops by 50% in the mixed fiber with aerial segment setup. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For the PB system, the performance drop during operation phase also drops by 50%, but as the system performance was disrupted for 24. 82% of the testing time it indicates greater sensitivity to the aerial setup conditions.

This indicates greater sensitivity to the aerial setup conditions. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For the PB system, the performance drop during operation phase also drops by 50%, but as the system performance was disrupted for 24. 82% of the testing time it indicates greater sensitivity to the aerial setup conditions.

Where the gains come from

The TBP system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses. Even though polarization changes can affect the time-bin base because of changes in SOP, the other base in not affected since the same effect will occur in both consecutive pulses. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Overall, the increased stability of the TBP system can be attributed to the employed protocol: The TBP system utilizes a combination of time-bin and phase encoding, where one base uses timebin encoding while the other encodes the relative phase between two consecutive pulses [11]. Even though polarization changes can affect the time-bin base because of changes in SOP, the other base in not affected since the same effect will occur in both consecutive pulses.

This protocol choice contributes to its greater stability compared to the polarization-based system. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The TBP QKD system showed greater stability under varying conditions, which is why it was tested across multiple attenuation levels to assess its performance under stress. On the other hand, the polarization-based system also managed to achieve stable performance, requiring however more frequent initialization process of the protocol.

The TBP system's initialisation procedure remained consistent at all attenuation levels, lasting approximately 10 minutes in both cases. This consistency suggests a more robust operational mechanism under environmental stress. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The QKD system using the phase and timebin (TBP) encoding, with a power budget of 30 dB, was tested at three different attenuation levels (10, 23 and 30 dB), while the polarization-based (PB) QKD system, with a nominal operational limit of 20 dB, was only tested at 15 dB of line attenuation. The TBP QKD system showed greater stability under varying conditions, which is why it was tested across multiple attenuation levels to assess its performance under stress.

How the training signal is built

The PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding. This reliance on a single encoding method results in increased vulnerability to steep polarization changes requiring a fast polarization compensation to correct basis misalignment. p. 2

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the PB system encoder relies only on polarization encoding. This could result in increased vulnerability to steep polarization changes, requiring a fast polarization compensation to correct basis misalignment.

The TBP system's performance degradation is attributed to service channel loss correlated from logs, which is attributed to the instability of the service channel over the aerial fiber potentially caused by reflections both from the circulators and the fiber patch cords used. This highlights that environmental factors, such as reflections, impact even more stable systems like TBP. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In QKD systems, fluctuations in SOP lead to unpredictable polarization basis misalignments [2], which in turn increases the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER). The impact of PMD is more pronounced in aerial fibers due to environmental factors.

The PB system's disruption of 10.8 hours is primarily due to the system spending most of its time in base agreement stage attempting to reinitialize the QBER bases while secure key generation ceased. p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the PB pair successfully produced keys in the in-lab setup, but in the mixed fiber with aerial segment setup the operation was disrupted for 10. In this period the system spent most of the time in base agreement stage attempting to reinitialize the QBER bases while secure key generation ceased, producing zero values as shown in Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Adaptive QKD System Tuning: The improved AI system can dynamically adjust QKD parameters in real-time based on measured environmental factors like wind-induced movements and temperature changes affecting State of Polarization (SOP). This allows the system to proactively compensate for rapid SOP fluctuations, potentially reducing the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) caused by dynamic SOP changes.

  2. Encoding Method Selection: The AI can assess the specific fiber link conditions—such as attenuation levels and environmental stability—to automatically select the optimal QKD encoding method, such as Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems versus polarization-based systems. This selection ensures that the system operates in its most stable configuration, maximizing the Secret Key Rate (SKR) under varying stress.

  3. Predictive Error Mitigation: The AI can use historical data on SOP fluctuations to predict future basis misalignment events before they occur. This predictive capability allows for preemptive adjustments or initiation of fast polarization feedback modules, thereby minimizing the time spent in the base agreement stage and preventing key generation disruptions observed in the PB system.

Abstract

We analyze the performance of Time-bin Phase and Polarization based QKD systems on mixed 14Km underground and 16Km of aerial fiber using plug-and-play commercial QKD systems.

Related papers