Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow".
Title and authors: Kai: So what does this paper actually do in terms of simulation? It moves from the theoretical discussion to applying this new set of equations to actual experimental data.
Mira: They perform numerical simulations using a fluid description based on these relativistic Navier-Stokes equations, and they use it to describe the transverse momentum distribution of hadrons measured in central lead lead collisions at the LHC.
Lev: That means they are feeding the output from these equations into a model that spits out data matching what ALICE measured in those Pb to Pb collisions at two point seven six terates new.
Kai: And they use this specific numerical setup, which is boost invariant and axially symmetric, to model how the quark-gluon plasma expands radially after the collision.
Mira: They also determine a freezout surface where they switch from treating the fluid as a continuous medium to treating it as individual particles using what's called the Cooper-Frye prescription.
Lev: So they are taking this numerical evolution and then applying that particle conversion method to generate a transverse momentum distribution of hadrons, which is what they compare to the experimental results.
The paper's summary: Kai: The core of what they’re saying here is that relativistic Navier-Stokes offers a more robust description than the established MIS theories because it has better local well-posedness properties fundamentally.
Mira: They explain this by framing hydrodynamics as a gradient expansion, where ideal hydrodynamics is the zeroth order, and dissipative effects are higher order corrections.
Lev: They point out that the system enters what they call the effective field theory regime when those gradient corrections become small, which they expect to happen when there's a large separation between the microscopic scale of quantum chromodynamics and the macroscopic scale of our system.
Kai: They also do an analysis of how different contributions to the stress tensor behave over time; they find that as time progresses, the system enters deeper into this effective field theory regime.
Mira: And they introduce a criterion to check if using different hydrodynamic frames changes their results, concluding that relativistic Navier-Stokes gives a prediction that is robust regardless of the frame you choose.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests several things for future work. They point out that the contribution from the bulk viscosity term is actually small compared to what the shear term contributes in terms of energy density, when you look pointwise in spacetime.
Lev: That’s interesting because it simplifies things a bit; they are focusing more on the shear part of the stress tensor for their main results.
Mira: They also mention that they didn't explicitly check frame independence using Type I frames in their current work, saying that’s something they plan to do later.
Kai: The paper does suggest extending the dynamics to two plus one dimensions and incorporating additional physics happening in the later stages of the collision, like hadronic physics.
Lev: And they also recommend building similar numerical codes specifically for the relativistic Navier-Stokes equations, which would be a big step for running this on real hardware.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, they conclude that while bulk viscosity is small compared to shear viscosity in their setup, the overall description remains consistent with experimental data when using these equations.
Mira: The main implication is that relativistic Navier-Stokes provides a mathematically better foundation for describing the quark-gluon plasma than some of the prior viscous hydrodynamic formulations.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we want to build codes that can accurately capture this behavior on real hardware, we need to focus on implementing those specific well-posedness conditions they derived.
Kai: So the paper "Relativistic Navier-Stokes description of the quark-gluon plasma radial flow" shows a new way forward by addressing causality issues in viscous hydrodynamics through a better formulation of relativistic Navier-Stokes equations.
Yago Bea
Departament de Física Quántica i AstrofΡsifica and Institut de Ciónces del Cosmos (ICC), Universitat de Barcelona
hep-ph, hep-th, nucl-th
Submitted: 2025-03-04
Updated: 2026-11-16
Importance score: 81/100
The gist: The relativistic viscous hydrodynamic description of the quark-gluon plasma by MüllerIsrael-Stewart formulations has been very successful, but despite this success…
Key concepts
- Relativistic Navier-Stokes Equations
- These are a set of equations used to describe the fluid dynamics (hydrodynamics) of the quark-gluon plasma when relativistic effects are important. They include terms for fluid motion, pressure gradients, and viscous stresses that account for internal friction within the plasma.
- Local Well-posedness
- This is a mathematical property ensuring that a differential equation has a unique and stable solution at every single point in spacetime. The paper claims relativistic Navier-Stokes equations possess better local well-posedness than MüllerIsrael-Stewart (MIS) theories, meaning they are mathematically more reliable for simulation.
- EFT Regime
- The Effective Field Theory (EFT) regime describes the physical conditions where the system is strongly coupled and its behavior can be accurately modeled by simplified field theories. The paper uses this concept to quantitatively determine when the QGP dynamics transition into this regime based on stress tensor contributions.
- Frame Independence
- This refers to whether the physical results of a calculation remain unchanged even if you choose a different coordinate system or 'frame' for observing the fluid flow. The authors test this by comparing two different hydrodynamic frames and an ideal evolution, showing that relativistic Navier-Stokes predictions are robust against frame changes.
Terminology
Summary
The relativistic viscous hydrodynamic description of the quark-gluon plasma by MüllerIsrael-Stewart formulations has been very successful, but despite this success, these theories present limitations regarding well-posedness and causality Using this novel theory, we perform numerical simulations of a quark-gluon plasma fluid that we use to describe experimental data on the transverse momentum distribution of hadrons from central Pb–Pb collisions measured at the LHC. p. 0
Limitation of Previous Theories
The relativistic version of the Navier-Stokes equations as originally written many decades ago by Eckart [7] and Landau and Lifshitz [8] was observed to present severe causality issues and instabilities The idea of this approach is to consider the hydrodynamic expansion up to second order in gradients, and then promote the dissipative part of the stress tensor to be a new variable with its own evolution equation; the new set of equations exhibits better properties, alleviating the problems present in first-order viscous hydrodynamics. Despite this success, these problems are not completely solved. p. 1
Advantage of Relativistic Navier-Stokes
We argue that relativistic Navier-Stokes has better properties of local well-posedness than MIS theories, which is an advantage at a fundamental level. In MIS theories the properties of well-posedness depend on the local energy density, and they must be checked pointwise in spacetime for every evolution, allowing for possible violations as the ones presented above. p. 2 On the contrary, for relativistic Navier-Stokes a hydrodynamic frame can be chosen such that good properties of well-posedness are ensured at every point of spacetime for every evolution. p. 2
Numerical Implementation and Validation
We perform real-time numerical evolutions of the relativistic Navier-Stokes equations with a QCD equation of state and transport parameters that we use to describe the QGP created in central heavy-ion collisions. We consider a boost invariant, axially symmetric system to model the hydrodynamic radial flow expansion of the QGP. p. 2 We determine the freezout surface at which we perform the conversion from the fluid to particles by using the Cooper-Frye prescription, obtaining a transverse momentum distribution of hadrons that we use to describe experimental data of central Pb–Pb collisions at center of mass energy √sNN = 2. p. 276 TeV measured by ALICE [41]. p. 3
Effective Field Theory Analysis
We perform an EFT analysis of our solutions, evaluating if a solution is in the EFT regime because if it is not, there is, in principle, no argument to expect that it will provide a good description of QCD. We measure the different contributions to the stress tensor (2. p. 19) and conclude that as time progresses, the system enters deeper into the EFT regime. p. 8 Furthermore, we define a criterion to assess the effect of using different hydrodynamic frames, concluding that relativistic Navier-Stokes provide a robust prediction which is independent of the arbitrarily chosen frame even if the system is initially not deep in the EFT regime. p. 3
Conclusion and Future Work
We conclude with some final remarks, observing that the contribution by the bulk viscosity term is small compared to the contribution by the shear term. We emphasize that in this paper we do not explicitly check frame independence in evolutions using frames of type I, and we leave this for future work. p. 5 p. 5 There are several natural extensions of the present work, including extending the dynamics to 2+1 dimensions and incorporating additional late-stage hadronic physics. We suggest constructing similar well developed codes for the relativistic Navier-Stokes equations. p. 7
Numerical Code Details
Our numerical code is implemented in Mathematica, and we use finite differences of order 6 for the spatial derivatives and a multi-step Adams-Bashforth method of order 4 for time integration. We include Kreiss-Oliger dissipation of order 6 with a coefficient σKO = 0. p. 14. The polar coordinates used in the transverse plane introduce a singularity at the origin, which we included in the grid and used L’Hôpital’s rule obtaining a non-singular expression. p. 6
Well-posedness Conditions
The conditions for well-posedness and not faster than light propagation for the stress tensor (B. p. 51) were determined in [30], and our specific subset of frames (2. p. 612) satisfies these conditions. p. 6 We observe that the characteristic velocities of the PDEs (2. p. 610) are ci = ±s/c 2s + 2a1 ±p a1(a1 + 3a2(a1 + a2)c 2s) 3a1a2. p. 6 We consider the following frame (2. p. 614) for which the characteristic velocities are ci = ±1, ±3/5 c 2s. p. 0
Experimental Data Comparison
We find that a set that provides a good description of the experimental data is τi = 0.6 fm, ϵi = 100 GeV/fm3, Tf = 0. p. 912 GeV. The result of using the Cooper-Frye formula (3. p. 27) for a numerical evolution of the relativistic Navier-Stokes equations with parameters (3. p. 28) is plotted in Fig. p. 9 4 in red dashed lines, fitting the three curves with the same parameters, finding good agreement. p. 3 The corresponding evolution is presented in Fig. p. 2 2.
General Stress Tensor Analysis
The most general stress tensor to first order in the hydrodynamic expansion compatible with Poincare symmetry for a non-conformal fluid can be found in [30] eq. (1). The conditions for well-posedness and not faster than light propagation for the stress tensor (B.1) were determined in [30]. Our specific subset of frames (2. p. 6 p. 612) satisfies these conditions, and correspond to χ1 = χ2 = a1(η + 3/4ζ), χ3 = a1c 2s(η + 3/4ζ), χ4 = a1c 2s(η + 3/4ζ) − ζ, λ = a2(η + 3/4ζ). p. 5 p. 5 The most generic stress tensor (B. p. 01) has 5 parameters and the most generic field redefinition (2. p. 211) has 3 parameters. p. 2
Well-posedness Criteria
The conditions for well-posedness and not faster than light propagation for the stress tensor (B.1) were determined in [30]. Our specific subset of frames (2.12) satisfies these conditions, and correspond to χ1 = χ2 = a1(η + 3/4ζ), χ3 = a1c 2s(η + 3/4ζ), χ4 = a1c 2s(η + 3/4ζ) − ζ, λ = a2(η + 3/4ζ). It is assumed that 0 ≤ c 2s ≤ 1. p. 7
Discussion on Frame Independence
We perform two evolutions using two different hydrodynamic frames, and a third evolution using ideal hydrodynamics with similar initial data, and now we compare the difference between the two viscous evolutions and the difference of one of the viscous evolutions and the ideal evolution. We observe that this ratio is of the order of 1%, concluding that relativistic Navier-Stokes provides a robust prediction which is independent of the arbitrarily chosen frame even if the system is initially not deep in the EFT regime. p. 3
Convergence Test Results
We show a convergence test of the solution used to describe the experimental data presented in Fig. 2, finding good properties of convergence. p. 2 According to our numerical scheme, the expected convergence factor is 4, however we find slightly lower values, closer to 3, in some regions of the time domain.
Stress Tensor Contribution Analysis
We plot the ideal term, ϵuru r + p∆rr, in solid black and the viscous term, −ησrr −ζ∇·u∆rr, in solid blue, in absolute value. At τ = 0.6 fm/c, the ratio is 32%. This ratio quickly decays below 20% at τ = 1.2 fm/c, 10% at τ = 2.8 fm/c and 3% at τ = 6.0 fm/c, indicating that the system is entering deeper into the EFT regime. p. 1
Frame Dependence Comparison
We plot the ratio of these quantities in Fig. 6, this ratio is of the order of 1%, and consequently, the effect of using different frames has an impact on the evolution which is about a hundred times smaller than the effect of introducing viscosity in the hydrodynamic description. p. 3 The physics should be also invariant under these change of frames, even if the evolved variables ϵ, ur will have a different physical meaning; this just corresponds to a different parametrization of the stress tensor which describes the same physics. p. 5
Final Remarks on Viscosity
We observe that the contribution by the bulk viscosity term is small compared to the contribution by the shear term, by evaluating pointwise in spacetime. We emphasize that in this paper we do not explicitly check frame independence in evolutions using frames of type I, and we leave this for future work. Finally, a standard approach is to include a hadron cascade after freezout, which captures the subsequent hadron resonance decays. p. 3
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Incorporate a robust well-posedness check for any hydrodynamic model used in simulations to ensure
good properties of local well-posedness
at every point of spacetime, as this is a major advantage over MIS theories. -
Develop numerical codes specifically tailored to solve the relativistic Navier-Stokes equations using frames satisfying condition (2.12), such as frame (2.14), which ensures characteristic speeds do not exceed the speed of light and provides a constant characteristic speed equal to light, allowing for
the description of arbitrarily strong shockwaves.
-
Implement an EFT analysis routine that systematically measures the ratio of the L1 norms of viscous and ideal terms in the stress tensor component, allowing for a quantitative determination of when
the system is entering deeper into the EFT regime,
moving beyond qualitative observations. -
Create a framework to compare different hydrodynamic frames by running two simulations with different frames and an ideal evolution, quantifying the
ratio of these quantities
to prove thatthe prediction of relativistic Navier-Stokes is robust under changes of frames.
Sources
- Relativistic Fluid Dynamics In and Out of Equilibrium -- Ten Years of Progress in Theory and Numerical Simulations of Nuclear Collisions
- Heavy Ion Collisions: The Big Picture, and the Big Questions
- Viscous Hydrodynamics and the Quark Gluon Plasma
- Hydrodynamic Description of the Quark-Gluon Plasma
- Relativistic viscous hydrodynamics, conformal invariance, and holography
- Derivation of transient relativistic fluid dynamics from the Boltzmann equation
- A hyperbolic theory of relativistic conformal dissipative fluids
- Numerical simulations of divergence-type theories for conformal dissipative fluids
- 3+1D hydrodynamic simulation of relativistic heavy-ion collisions
- Elliptic and triangular flow in event-by-event (3+1)D viscous hydrodynamics
- The production of photons in relativistic heavy-ion collisions
- Particle spectra and HBT radii for simulated central nuclear collisions of C+C, Al+Al, Cu+Cu, Au+Au, and Pb+Pb from Sqrt(s)=62.4-2760 GeV
- The iEBE-VISHNU code package for relativistic heavy-ion collisions
- Nonlinear Constraints on Relativistic Fluids Far From Equilibrium
- Causality violations in realistic simulations of heavy-ion collisions
- Exploring theoretical uncertainties in the hydrodynamic description of relativistic heavy-ion collisions
- Causality violations in simulations of large and small heavy-ion collisions
- Causality and existence of solutions of relativistic viscous fluid dynamics with gravity
- Nonlinear causality of general first-order relativistic viscous hydrodynamics
- First-Order General-Relativistic Viscous Fluid Dynamics
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses