Phenomenological revisit of the B to pi pi decays by incorporating soft color-octet contributions

arXiv:2502.12461 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-02-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Phenomenological revisit of the B to pi pi decays by incorporating soft color-octet contributions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Motivated by the ππ puzzle in nonleptonic B decays in the time of high-precision and huge-data for particle physics, we restudy the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach The COCME contributions are helpful to interpret the experimental data on branching ratios rather than CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays.

Kai: Theoretical Framework and Amplitudes The effective Hamiltonian in charge of the B → ππ decays is written as

30: Heff = GF √2 n Vub V∗ud X squared i=1 Ci Qi − Vtb V∗td X 10 j=3 Cj Oj o + h.c.

Mira: The amplitudes of the B → ππ decays can be written as A = h π π Heff B i = GF √2 n Vub V∗ud X squared i=1 Ci h π π Qi B i − Vtb V∗td X 10 j=3 Cj h π π Qj B i o,.

Kai: The QCDF factorization formula Eq.(20) makes the HME calculation become simpler and practicable in phenomenological analysis.

Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper today, "Phenomenological revisit of the B to pi pi decays by incorporating soft color-octet contributions." This work is motivated by the so-called pi pi puzzle in nonleptonic B decays, which is a bit of a persistent problem in particle physics.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are taking the standard QCD factorization approach and restudying these B to pi pi decays by adding contributions from color-octet matrix elements, which they parameterize with a new parameter called X.

Lev: From an engineering side, it sounds like they're trying to fix discrepancies in the branching ratios rather than just focusing on CP asymmetries, which is a common way theorists try to tame these kinds of puzzles.

Kai: Right. The paper suggests that these soft color-octet contributions are actually helpful for interpreting experimental data on branching ratios instead of just CP asymmetries, which is what they found in the abstract.

Mira: They show that when you fit the data using their new framework, they find a form factor F B pi zero around zero point two two and a parameter X around zero point three at the scale mb over two, which seems to align well with recent measurements from PDG, Belle, BaBar, and Belle II <ref:2502.12461#pg3,from PDG, Belle, BaBar, and Belle II>.

Lev: That's interesting because that specific value for the form factor is also favored by lattice simulations and LCSR calculations, which gives it some support outside of just this paper's fit.

Kai: So what does the paper actually propose as an improvement over previous attempts at solving this puzzle in B decays?

Mira: The authors introduce a phenomenological parameter X to parameterize the color-octet contributions, acknowledging that these are nonperturbative and should be smaller than the color-singlet current-current matrix elements. They write down the decay amplitudes by splitting them into A pi pi plus C pi pi, where C pi pi is those color-octet amplitudes.

Lev: So they're basically adding a term to their calculation that accounts for these overlooked nonperturbative effects, which should be smaller than the standard ones in many cases.

Kai: And then they show the numerical results of this fit. They find that with these optimal parameters, the calculated branching ratios agree with the latest experimental data within an error range.

Mira: But there's a bit more nuance here because they also look at CP asymmetries and find them to be more or less inconsistent with current measurements, which suggests there's still tension in that area.

Lev: That tension is something we always see, but they are suggesting that this COCME contribution can accommodate all the B to pi pi decays on the whole.

Kai: So what’s the big picture here for us who are working on high-precision measurements? What does this mean for understanding these decays?

Mira: It provides a possible fresh scheme or a solution for the pi pi puzzle, and they found that this framework can effectively enhance branching ratios specifically for the B zero to pi zero pi zero decay.

Lev: And because they also look at how X relates to the form factor F B pi zero, they show a correlation between them, about negative zero point five eight <ref:2502.12461#pg1>.

Kai: That's a concrete relationship that helps guide future theoretical work on these matrix elements and form factors.

Mira: And they point out that while the small theoretical expectation for the amplitude of B minus to pi minus zero is quite low, the observation of a large CP asymmetry for that decay mode might hint at new physics beyond the Standard Model.

Lev: It seems like they are using this framework to try and disentangle whether we need new physics or just better understanding of these nonfactorizable contributions in the Standard Model.

Kai: So to wrap up, what's the final word on what this paper offers for the community?

Mira: The main thing is that it shows how incorporating these soft color-octet contributions can help us interpret experimental data on branching ratios more effectively.

Lev: It gives us a better handle on the tension between theory and experiment by showing where those nonfactorizable effects land in terms of their impact on different decay modes.

Kai: So, we've looked at how this paper re-examines the B to pi pi decays using these color-octet contributions, and it seems like a solid step forward for fitting the data.

Mira: It definitely opens up a new avenue for exploring these puzzles by providing a specific way to incorporate nonperturbative effects into QCD factorization analyses.

Lev: We'll see if this framework holds up when we try to implement it on real hardware and see how much overhead those color-octet corrections actually add to the simulation complexity.

Kai: That sounds like the next step, checking the practical limits of these theoretical constructs against our experimental capabilities.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is essentially taking the standard way we calculate B to pi pi decays using QCD factorization and adding in these soft color octet contributions by introducing a new parameter called X to account for them.

Mira: Right. The main point here is that they are shifting the focus from just looking at CP asymmetries—those things that can be really tricky—to focusing on the branching ratios of these decays. They argue that these color-octet terms are actually helpful for interpreting the experimental data we have on those rates, not just those asymmetries.

Lev: From my side, it’s about parameterizing something nonperturbative, something you can't calculate from first principles easily right now, and they call it X. They state these contributions should be smaller than the standard color-singlet currents that we already know how to handle.

Kai: And the results show that when they fit their new framework to data from groups like PDG, Belle, and BaBar at a specific energy scale—mb over two—they find values for this parameter X around zero point three and a form factor F B pi zero of about zero point two two.

Mira: That form factor value is actually quite interesting because it lines up with what lattice simulations and those light-cone sum rule calculations have been finding, which gives it some external validation.

Lev: It means if you were to try and run this on real hardware, the overhead for these color-octet corrections isn't going to be huge, but you still need that parameter X to get the fit right.

Kai: So what does this actually change for us? They conclude that these color-octet contributions can explain all the B to pi pi decays, giving us a potential new scheme or at least a better way forward for tackling this persistent puzzle.

Mira: But they also point out that when you look at the CP asymmetries, the fit results are still not perfectly consistent with what we see experimentally right now, which means there’s still some tension there.

Lev: It seems like they're using this framework to show how these nonfactorizable effects can boost the branching ratios for one specific decay mode, like B zero to pi zero pi zero, while keeping other modes suppressed.

Kai: So it’s not a perfect fix yet, but it gives us a much more realistic picture of what those soft contributions are doing in this system. We need to see how this fits together with the CP asymmetry data next.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, basically, they suggest using a new parameter called X to describe those color-octet matrix elements instead of just ignoring them or treating them as fixed numbers.

Mira: Right. It's about adding this flexibility so the AI can fit the data based on branching ratios instead of just chasing CP asymmetries.

Lev: From my side, it's about parameterizing something nonperturbative that we can't calculate easily right now, and they call it X, but they insist these contributions should be smaller than the standard color-singlet currents that we already handle.

Kai: The results show when they fit their new framework to data from groups like PDG, Belle, and BaBar at a scale of mb over two, they find values for this parameter X around zero point three and a form factor F B pi zero of about zero point two two.

Mira: That form factor value is actually quite interesting because it lines up with what lattice simulations and those light-cone sum rule calculations have been finding, which gives it some external validation.

Lev: It means if you were to try and run this on real hardware, the overhead for these color-octet corrections isn't going to be huge, but you still need that parameter X to get the fit right.

Kai: So what does this actually change for us? They conclude that these color-octet contributions can explain all the B to pi pi decays, giving us a potential new scheme or at least a better way forward for tackling this persistent puzzle.

Mira: But they also point out that when you look at the CP asymmetries, the fit results are still not perfectly consistent with what we see experimentally right now, which means there’s still some tension there.

Lev: It seems like they're using this framework to show how these nonfactorizable effects can boost the branching ratios for one specific decay mode, like B zero to pi zero pi zero, while keeping other modes suppressed.

Kai: So it’s not a perfect fix yet, but it gives us a much more realistic picture of what those soft contributions are doing in this system. We need to see how this fits together with the CP asymmetry data next.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up on "Phenomenological revisit of the B to pi pi decays by incorporating soft color-octet contributions." Basically, they show that adding this parameter X lets them fit the branching ratios much better than before.

Mira: Right. The main implication is that we can now use this framework to better interpret experimental data on decay rates instead of just worrying about those tricky CP asymmetries.

Lev: From my side, it’s about seeing how these nonfactorizable effects land in terms of their impact on different decay modes, which is exactly what they did by showing the enhancement for B zero to pi zero pi zero.

Kai: So it means we get a much more realistic picture of what those soft contributions are actually doing in this system, even if the CP asymmetry data still has some tension.

Mira: Exactly. It’s not a complete fix yet, but it gives us a better handle on how these nonperturbative effects behave across different decays.

Lev: I just think it shows us where the real work is—figuring out those matrix elements for X—and that's something we need to nail down for any real hardware simulation to be accurate.

Kai: Yeah, we need to see how this fits together with the CP asymmetry data next, because that’s still where a lot of the tension lies right now.

Mira: That’s what we’ll be looking at in our next paper on how these same nonperturbative effects affect other decay channels.

Yueling Yang, Bingbing Yang, Junfeng Sun

Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics, Henan Normal University

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-02-18

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 33 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114, 096006 (2026)

DOI: 10.1103/wrm3-6qwv

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 69/100

The gist: Motivated by the ππ puzzle in nonleptonic B decays in the time of high-precision and huge-data for particle physics…

Key concepts

Effective Hamiltonian
This is a mathematical expression that describes the fundamental interactions governing B to pi pi decays. It combines short-distance physics (represented by Wilson coefficients) and long-distance physics (represented by hadronic matrix elements). It sets the stage for calculating decay amplitudes.
QCD Factorization (QCDF)
A theoretical framework used to simplify complex nonperturbative calculations in B decays. It separates the decay amplitude into calculable short-distance parts and long-distance parts, making it practical for phenomenological analysis by using factorization formulas.
Color-Octet Matrix Elements (COCME)
These are nonperturbative contributions arising from color-octet states that are not included in the simpler color-singlet current calculations. The paper introduces a parameter X to model these effects, suggesting they enhance branching ratios for certain decay modes.
Form Factor ($F_{B o ho}$)
This is a nonperturbative quantity representing the overlap between the initial B meson and the final state particles (like $ ho$ mesons). Determining its value is crucial for accurate predictions, and fitting experimental data helps constrain its optimal value.

Terminology

Summary

Motivated by the ππ puzzle in nonleptonic B decays in the time of high-precision and huge-data for particle physics, we restudy the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach The COCME contributions are helpful to interpret the experimental data on branching ratios rather than CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays. p. 0

Where the paper says it

12461v1 [hep-ph] 18 Feb 2025 Contributions from the color-octet matrix elements to the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach Yueling Yang,1 Bingbing Yang,1 and Junfeng Sun1 1 Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang 453007, China Abstract Motivated by the ππ puzzle in nonleptonic B decays in the time of high-precision and huge-data for particle physics, we restudy the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach. An additional contributions from the color-octet current matrix elements (COCME) which are unnoticed in almost all the previous calculation, are taken into consideration and parameterized by X.

Theoretical Framework and Amplitudes

The effective Hamiltonian in charge of the B → ππ decays is written as [30] Heff = GF √2 n Vub V∗ud X squared i=1 Ci Qi − Vtb V∗td X 10 j=3 Cj Oj o + h.c. The amplitudes of the B → ππ decays can be written as A = h π π Heff B i = GF √2 n Vub V∗ud X squared i=1 Ci h π π Qi B i − Vtb V∗td X 10 j=3 Cj h π π Qj B i o,. p. 4

Where the paper says it

O5 = ( ¯dα bα)V −A X q (¯qβ qβ)V +A, (13) O6 = ( ¯dα bβ)V −A X q (¯qβ qα)V +A, (14) O7 = ( ¯dα bα)V −A X q 3 2 Qq (¯qβ qβ)V +A, (15) O8 = ( ¯dα bβ)V −A X q 3 2 Qq(¯qβ qα)V +A, (16) O9 = ( ¯dα bα)V −A X q 3 2 Qq(¯qβ qβ)V −A, (17) O10 = ( ¯dα bβ)V −A X q 3 2 Qq(¯qβ qα)V −A, (18) where (¯q1 q2)V ±A ≡ q¯1 γµ (1±γ5) q2; α and β are the color indices; Qq is the electric charge of quark q in the unit of |e|; and q ∈ {u, d, c, s, b}. The amplitudes of the B → ππ decays with the QCDF approach The amplitudes of the B → ππ decays can be written as, A = h π π | Heff | B i = GF √ 2 n Vub V ∗ ud X 2 i=1 Ci h π π | Qi | B i − Vtb V ∗ td X 10 j=3 Cj h π π | Qj | B i o , (19) where h π π | Qi | B i is hadronic matrix element (HME).

The QCDF factorization formula Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The scattering kernel functions T I,II arising from hard gluon exchange are in principle perturbatively calculable order by order due to the QCD property of asymptotic freedom. The QCDF factorization formula Eq.

(20) makes the HME calculation become simpler and practicable in phenomenological analysis. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The QCDF factorization formula Eq. (20) makes the HME calculation become simpler and practicable in phenomenological analysis.

Incorporation of Color-Octet Matrix Elements

The paper introduces a phenomenological parameter X to parameterize the COCME contributions. The COCME contributions are nonperturbative, and should be smaller than those of the color-singlet current-current matrix elements. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We can imagine that before the formation of the color-neutral point-like configuration, the meson composed of the colored quark and colored antiquark might be regarded as a small color-dipole at the interaction point. In this paper, we will assume that (1) the COCME contributions are nonzero in B nonleptonic decays; (2) the chromatic interactions sourcing from the soft gluon exchange between the color-octet currents alter only the color charge, but are independent of the spin and flavor of the quarks; (3) the COCME contributions are nonperturbative, and should be smaller than those of the color-singlet current-current matrix elements.

The decay amplitudes for the B → ππ decays can be written as Mππ = Aππ + Cππ, where Cππ denotes the amplitudes from the COCME contributions. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The quantity of δ should be a strong phase, and the same for the B and B decays. With the above convention, the decay amplitudes for the the B → ππ decays can be written as, Mππ = Aππ + Cππ, (38) where Aππ have been given in Eq.

Numerical Results and Interpretation

The fit results with different experimental group data at three renormalization scales are respectively displayed in TABLE V, VI, VII and VIII. The optimal values of parameters from the PDG, Belle and BaBar data at the scale µ = mb/2 are X ∼ 0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

question, and called as ππ puzzle in B decays. TABLE I: Experimental data on the CP-averaged branching ratios and CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays from PDG, Belle, BaBar, and Belle II groups.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

question, and called as ππ puzzle in B decays. TABLE I: Experimental data on the CP-averaged branching ratios and CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays from PDG, Belle, BaBar, and Belle II groups.

3 and F Bπ 0 ∼ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An additional contributions from the color-octet current matrix elements (COCME) which are unnoticed in almost all the previous calculation, are taken into consideration and parameterized by X. It is found that (1) form factor F Bπ 0 ≈ 0.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An additional contributions from the color-octet current matrix elements (COCME) which are unnoticed in almost all the previous calculation, are taken into consideration and parameterized by X. It is found that (1) form factor F Bπ 0 ≈ 0.

22. With the optimal parameters, the fit branching ratios are in good agreement with the latest experimental data within an error range. p. 0
Where the paper says it

22 is favored by the available latest measurements. (2) The COCME contributions are helpful to interpret the experimental data on branching ratios rather than CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The COCME contributions can accommodate all the B → ππ decays on the whole, provide a possible fresh scheme or/and solution for the ππ puzzle in B decays. The fit CP asymmetries are more or less inconsistent with the current measurements, which need much more theoretical and experimental endeavors to try the best together to ease the tension. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Clearly, except for the data-driven fitting results [27], the theoretical expectation on branching ratio for the B 0 → π 0π 0 decay with either the QCDF or PQCD approaches, including higher order QCD contributions, is much smaller than the measurements. This disagreement is still an open a The definition of CP asymmetries is, for the charged B± meson decay, ACP = Γ(B− → π − π 0 ) − Γ(B+ → π + π 0 ) Γ(B− → π− π 0) + Γ(B+ → π+ π 0) , (1) and for the neutral B meson decays, ACP = Γ(B 0 → π π) − Γ(B0 → π π) Γ(B 0 → π π) + Γ(B0 → π π) = SCP sin(∆md t) − CCP cos(∆md t), (2) where ∆md denotes the mass difference between the two physical Bd meson eigenstates, and corresponds to the B0 -B 0 oscillation frequency, and the parameter λCP = Vtd V ∗ tb V ∗ td Vtb A(B 0 → π π) A(B0 → π π) , (3) SCP = 2 Im(λCP ) 1 + |λCP | 2 , (4) CCP = 1 − |λCP | 2 1 + |λCP | 2 .

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The form factor F Bπ 0 ≈ 0.22 is favored by both the fit and the recent lattice simulation [37] and LCSR calculation [38]. p. 0

Where the paper says it

It is found that (1) form factor F Bπ 0 ≈ 0. 22 is favored by the available latest measurements.

The COCME contributions can effectively enhance branching ratio for the B 0→ π 0π 0 decay. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Some theoretical results are shown in TABLE II. Clearly, except for the data-driven fitting results [27], the theoretical expectation on branching ratio for the B 0 → π 0π 0 decay with either the QCDF or PQCD approaches, including higher order QCD contributions, is much smaller than the measurements.

Where the gains come from

The optimal value X implies that the COCME contributions are small but not negligible, compared to the original contributions from color-singlet currents. The value of X is relatively larger than X ∼ 0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

(2) at the αs order, the vertex correction contributions V2 are suppressed by both αs and the color factor 1/N. So considering comprehensively above-mentioned factors, the expected value of branching ratio for the B 0 → π 0π 0 decay seems unlikely to be large.

25g given by the PQCD approach with a large form factor F Bπ 0 = 0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The chi-square function is defined as, χ 2 (θ) = X i (yi − µ(xi ; θ))2 σ 2 i , (40) where the measurement yi represents the branching ratio and CP asymmetries, µ(xi ; θ) corresponds to the theoretical value with the inputs xi in TABLE III and unknown parameters θ (such as X), and σi is known error. It is widely known that form factor F Bπ 0 is one nonperturbative input with the QCDF approach, and has a close relationship with branching ratio, which is easily seen from Eq.

27 in Ref. [35]. The fit branching ratios are in good agreement with the experimental data within an error range. p. 0
Where the paper says it

22 is favored by the available latest measurements. (2) The COCME contributions are helpful to interpret the experimental data on branching ratios rather than CP asymmetries for the B → ππ decays.

How the training signal is built

The correlation relations of parameters F Bπ 0 and X are illustrated in FIG. 1. The optimal values of parameters from the PDG, Belle and BaBar data at the scale µ = mb/2 are X ∼ 0.3 and F Bπ 0 ∼ 0.22. The correlation between X and δ is-0.44.

The small theoretical expectation of ACP (π−π 0) brings a big challenge to the experimental measurements. The observation of a large ACP (π−π 0) is likely to imply the hint of new physics beyond SM or a fresh physics breakthrough to be explored. p. 0

Where the paper says it

arXiv:2502. 12461v1 [hep-ph] 18 Feb 2025 Contributions from the color-octet matrix elements to the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach Yueling Yang,1 Bingbing Yang,1 and Junfeng Sun1 1 Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang 453007, China Abstract Motivated by the ππ puzzle in nonleptonic B decays in the time of high-precision and huge-data for particle physics, we restudy the B → ππ decays with QCD factorization approach.

The sharp difference on CCP (π−π +) between the theoretical expectation and experimental data can not be settled by the nonfactorizable contributions with the QCDF approach [25] and the COCME contributions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Clearly, except for the data-driven fitting results [27], the theoretical expectation on branching ratio for the B 0 → π 0π 0 decay with either the QCDF or PQCD approaches, including higher order QCD contributions, is much smaller than the measurements. This disagreement is still an open a The definition of CP asymmetries is, for the charged B± meson decay, ACP = Γ(B− → π − π 0 ) − Γ(B+ → π + π 0 ) Γ(B− → π− π 0) + Γ(B+ → π+ π 0) , (1) and for the neutral B meson decays, ACP = Γ(B 0 → π π) − Γ(B0 → π π) Γ(B 0 → π π) + Γ(B0 → π π) = SCP sin(∆md t) − CCP cos(∆md t), (2) where ∆md denotes the mass difference between the two physical Bd meson eigenstates, and corresponds to the B0 -B 0 oscillation frequency, and the parameter λCP = Vtd V ∗ tb V ∗ td Vtb A(B 0 → π π) A(B0 → π π) , (3) SCP = 2 Im(λCP ) 1 + |λCP | 2 , (4) CCP = 1 − |λCP | 2 1 + |λCP | 2 .

The fit CP asymmetries are more or less inconsistent with the current measurements, which need much more theoretical and experimental endeavors to try the best together to ease the tension. The optimal value of F Bπ 0 is inversely proportional to that of X. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The chi-square function is defined as, χ 2 (θ) = X i (yi − µ(xi ; θ))2 σ 2 i , (40) where the measurement yi represents the branching ratio and CP asymmetries, µ(xi ; θ) corresponds to the theoretical value with the inputs xi in TABLE III and unknown parameters θ (such as X), and σi is known error. It is widely known that form factor F Bπ 0 is one nonperturbative input with the QCDF approach, and has a close relationship with branching ratio, which is easily seen from Eq.

The correlation between F Bπ 0 and X is-0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An additional contributions from the color-octet current matrix elements (COCME) which are unnoticed in almost all the previous calculation, are taken into consideration and parameterized by X. It is found that (1) form factor F Bπ 0 ≈ 0.

58.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced model flexibility through parameterization of color-octet current matrix elements (COCME). The improved AI system can perform a data-driven fitting method to introduce a phenomenological parameter X to account for COCME contributions, allowing it to analyze the effect on branching ratios rather than just CP asymmetries.

  2. Improved prediction accuracy for B pi pi decays by incorporating form factor dependence. The system can now determine optimal values for both the form factor F B pi 0 and the parameter X through a least squares method using experimental data, leading to better agreement with measurements across different decay modes and experiments like PDG, Belle, BaBar, and Belle II.

  3. Better discrimination between theoretical approaches based on fitting results. The AI can compare the optimal values of form factor F B pi 0 and parameter X obtained at different renormalization scales (mu) to identify the scale where the minimal chi square is achieved, thus providing a more robust assessment of the theoretical framework's validity.

  4. More nuanced interpretation of experimental data tension. The system can quantify how COCME contributions enhance branching ratios for B 0 -> pi 0 pi 0 while being suppressed for B 0 -> pi + pi -, offering a deeper understanding of why theoretical expectations often disagree with measurements in this decay channel.

Abstract

Motivated by the long-standing `` ππ puzzle'' in nonleptonic B decays, we revisit the B to ππ decays within the QCD factorization (QCDF) framework, now incorporating the soft color-octet matrix element (COME) contributions, an ingredient that has been largely overlooked in earlier QCDF studies. A comprehensive phenomenological analysis is performed under three distinct scenarios, with the free parameters determined via fits to the available experimental data using the χ squared method. The goodness-of-fit is very poor for Scenario S1, which corresponds to the traditional QCDF case without the soft COME contributions, and for Scenario S2, which includes the soft COME contributions but omits the weak annihilation (WA) contributions. Scenario S3, in which both the COME and WA contributions are included simultaneously, achieves an excellent overall fit. In Scenario S3, the QCDF approach can accommodate almost all B to ππ observables in a consistent and satisfactory manner, and the fitted parameters ρ A < 1 (WA) and ρ c about 0.3 (soft COME) are in good agreement with the QCDF power counting scheme and the factorization hypothesis.

Related papers