Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation

arXiv:2502.07539 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2025-02-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation explores the potential of neutralino dark matter within gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking, offering an advantage over gravity mediation by avoiding SUSY CP/flavor problems and leading to milder fine-tuning In our models, the lightest neutralino, as the lightest SUSY particle (LSP), is a viable dark matter candidate, assuming a gravitino mass of O(100) TeV The paper studies four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios: bino-wino coannihilation, higgsino dark matter, wino dark matter, and entropy-diluted bino dark matter Model Framework and Setup The models are formulated in five-dimensional space-time where the SUSY breaking field and the matter fields are placed on separate branes to avoid issues related to flavor and CP violation The setup considers a five-dimensional (5D) N = 1 supersymmetric model compactified on an S1/Z2 orbifold, described by a specific action SUSY breaking is considered gravitational SUSY breaking, where the cosmological constant vanishes The superpotential in Eq.

Kai: (2) contains only a constant term due to the shift symmetry imposed, leading to real parameters after a U(1)R rotation Neutralino Dark Matter Scenarios Four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios are studied: 1.

Mira: bino-like dark matter with a nearly degenerate mass with the wino 2.

Kai: higgsino-like dark matter 3.

Title and authors: Kai: Now that we know what the paper is about, let's look at the actual title and who wrote it. It's "Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation".

Mira: And it seems like the authors, Michihisa Takeuchi, Norimi Yokozaki, and Junhao Zhu, are focusing this work on finding a consistent parameter space within their specific framework >

Lev: I'm interested in the fact that they include a fully explicit messenger sector and embed a supersymmetric radion stabilization mechanism compatible with the SUSY breaking sector in section five >

Kai: That sounds like they are trying to build something very complete, not just throwing parameters at a problem; they’re making sure the whole structure is consistent across different parts of the model >

Mira: And that consistency check seems important because it ties into how they manage anomaly mediation suppression by including the radion in their setup >

The paper's summary: Kai: So, when we look at the summary of "Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation", it boils down to them systematically comparing four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios against current and projected experimental sensitivities >

Mira: They’re looking at bino-like dark matter with a nearly degenerate mass with the wino, higgsino dark matter, wino-like dark matter, and finally, bino-like dark matter with an entropy production mechanism >

Lev: That systematic comparison is key because it shows where the best experimental prospects lie for each scenario >

Kai: And they determine specific values for things like the spin independent cross section for these scenarios, which gives us a direct way to see how testable they are >

Mira: They found that in the bino-wino coannihilation scenario, there's a small mass splitting between the lightest neutralino and the chargino around twenty to thirty GeV >

Lev: That small splitting is what allows for that efficient annihilation you talked about, which is a big deal for their viability in that case >

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out several improvements they made to the initial attempts at this research. They put a lot of effort into providing a quantitative comparison of four complementary neutralino dark matter scenarios against current and projected experimental sensitivities >

Mira: Specifically, they calculated some numerical results that show the HL-LHC reach for the bino-wino coannihilation scenario is up to three hundred thirty GeV at five sigma and four hundred thirty GeV at two sigma >

Lev: From an engineering view, those projections give us a concrete target for what kind of collider signatures we might be able to look for in this specific setup >

Kai: And they also show that the entropy-diluted bino dark matter scenario has a spin independent cross section around ten to twelve picobarns >

Mira: That cross section is only about a few percent of the current limit from the LZ experiment, which makes it much more promising for near-future direct detection experiments than the bino-wino coannihilation scenario >

Lev: So, while the coannihilation scenario has a better collider reach projection, they suggest that if we want to look at direct detection with current technology, the entropy-diluted bino dark matter is a more realistic target >

Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up this discussion on "Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation", it seems like the paper lays out a few very clear experimental pathways for testing these neutralino candidates.

Mira: The main implication is that depending on which scenario we are talking about, the direct detection cross section can range from ten to twelve picobarns, which puts it in a sweet spot for next generation experiments >

Lev: I'd add that they also show how the model handles the theoretical consistency by requiring specific conditions on the potential terms, like requiring that V equals zero with C not equal to zero gives Omega double prime gravitino Omega double prime Z equals zero, which forces g double prime rho to be zero at the minimum >

Kai: It’s good to see them address those consistency checks, because without that theoretical foundation holding up, all those cross sections are just numbers on a page >

Mira: So for someone listening who isn't deep in SUSY theory, the takeaway is that this paper gives us concrete benchmarks for what direct detection experiments should be aiming at based on this specific gauge mediation model >

Lev: And the big picture is that by using gauge mediation, we avoid some of the flavor issues associated with gravity mediation while still keeping a viable dark matter candidate like the neutralino >

Michihisa Takeuchi, Norimi Yokozaki, Junhao Zhu

School of Physics and Astronomy, Sun Yat-sen University · Zhejiang Institute of Modern Physics and Department of Physics, Zhejiang University

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2025-02-11

Updated: 2026-10-29

Comments: 23 pages, 4 figures; PRD accepted version

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 69/100

The gist: Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation explores the potential of neutralino dark matter within gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking…

Key concepts

Neutralino Dark Matter
The lightest neutralino particle in this model is proposed as a viable candidate for dark matter. This particle arises from supersymmetry breaking and its properties are determined by the specific mediation mechanism, such as gauge mediation, which helps avoid certain theoretical issues related to flavor and CP violation.
Gauge Mediation of SUSY Breaking
This is a method used to break supersymmetry in a way that is compatible with experimental observations. It involves introducing new fields on separate dimensions (5D space-time) to naturally suppress unwanted problems like flavor and CP violation, leading to milder fine-tuning compared to gravity mediation.
Bino-Wino Coannihilation
In this scenario, the lightest neutralino is nearly degenerate in mass with the wino particle. This near degeneracy allows for efficient annihilation of the overproduced bino dark matter through collisions with the wino-like next-to-lightest supersymmetric particle (NLSP).
Entropy Dilution
This mechanism addresses the overproduction problem of bino dark matter by introducing a late-decaying messenger field. This process dilutes the initial abundance of binos, requiring a dilution factor of about 100 to match the observed dark matter density.

Terminology

Summary

Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation explores the potential of neutralino dark matter within gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking, offering an advantage over gravity mediation by avoiding SUSY CP/flavor problems and leading to milder fine-tuning In our models, the lightest neutralino, as the lightest SUSY particle (LSP), is a viable dark matter candidate, assuming a gravitino mass of O(100) TeV The paper studies four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios: bino-wino coannihilation, higgsino dark matter, wino dark matter, and entropy-diluted bino dark matter

Model Framework and Setup

The models are formulated in five-dimensional space-time where the SUSY breaking field and the matter fields are placed on separate branes to avoid issues related to flavor and CP violation The setup considers a five-dimensional (5D) N = 1 supersymmetric model compactified on an S1/Z2 orbifold, described by a specific action SUSY breaking is considered gravitational SUSY breaking, where the cosmological constant vanishes The superpotential in Eq. (2) contains only a constant term due to the shift symmetry imposed, leading to real parameters after a U(1)R rotation

Neutralino Dark Matter Scenarios

Four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios are studied:

  1. bino-like dark matter with a nearly degenerate mass with the wino

  2. higgsino-like dark matter

  3. wino-like dark matter

  4. bino-like dark matter with an entropy production mechanism

Bino-Wino Coannihilation

In the bino-wino coannihilation scenario, the bino, which tends to be overproduced, is efficiently annihilated through the annihilation of the wino-like NLSP For numerical calculation, a consistent parameter region is presented in Fig. 1 where the mass splitting between the lightest neutralino (χ01) and the chargino (χ+1) is small, with mχ±1 - mχ01 ≈ 20 – 30 GeV The HL-LHC reach for this scenario is projected to be up to 330 GeV at 5σ and 430 GeV at 2σ

Higgsino and Wino Scenarios

Higgsino dark matter with a mass of approximately 1.1 TeV and wino dark matter with a mass of approximately 2. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Higgsino dark matter with a mass of approximately 1. 1 TeV and wino dark matter with a mass of approximately 2.

8 TeV can account for the observed dark matter density purely through thermal production For wino-like dark matter, there might be tensions with indirect detection experiments, depending on the dark matter density profile and the cosmic propagation model

Entropy-Diluted Bino Dark Matter

The overproduction of bino-like dark matter can be addressed by an entropy production mechanism involving late-decaying messenger fields The resulting dilution factor is required to be O(100) to satisfy the observed dark matter abundance The SI cross section for this scenario is O(10−12) pb, a few percent of the current LZ bound, making it more promising for near-future direct detection than the bino-wino coannihilation scenario

Conclusion

The spin-independent cross section for the bino dark matter scenario is σSI ∼ 10−17–10−14 pb, three to six orders of magnitude below the current LZ bound and also well below typical projections for the neutrino fog The spin-independent cross section for the entropy-diluted bino dark matter scenario is O(10−12) pb, a few percent of the current LZ bound, making this scenario more promising for near-future direct detection than the bino-wino coannihilation scenario Future experiments will be crucial in testing these scenarios and advancing our understanding of neutralino dark matter

Soft SUSY Breaking Masses

Messenger loops induce the gaugino masses, sfermion masses and Higgs masses The generated gaugino masses are M˜b ≃ g squared / 16π squared (B5 + B1), Mw˜ ≃ g squared / 16π squared (B5), Mg˜ ≃ g squared / 16π squared (B5 + B3) The sfermion masses are derived from the messenger sector couplings, with m2L˜ ≃ 1 / (256π4) g 4 / 3 (B25 + B1) + 3/10 g 4 / 1 (B25 + B21)

Radion Stabilization

The radion stabilization is governed by a supersymmetric version of Goldberger–Wise radion stabilization The resulting radion mass is positive for all c ≠ 1/2, and the radion stabilization can be embedded into our model almost independently

Anomaly Mediation Suppression

Anomaly mediation remains absent once the radion is included, as in Sec. 2 The radion potential itself is then governed by the h-direction alone, with Z fixed at its own vacuum, where DhW/h=0 = ∆(T) Anomaly mediation therefore remains absent once the radion is included, as in Sec. 2

Acknowledgments

N.Y. is supported by a start-up grant from Zhejiang University M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation Michihisa Takeuchi(a)∗ , Norimi Yokozaki(b)† , and Junhao Zhu(b)‡ (a) School of Physics and Astronomy, Sun Yat-sen University, 519082 Zhuhai, China (b) Zhejiang Institute of Modern Physics and Department of Physics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang 310027, China Abstract We explore the potential of neutralino dark matter within the framework of gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking. Gauge mediation offers an advantage over gravity mediation, as SUSY CP/flavor problems are avoided more easily, leading to significantly milder fine-tuning for electroweak symmetry-breaking compared to gravity mediation.

T. is supported by the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities, the One Hundred Talent Program of Sun Yat-sen University, China, and the Guangdong Natural Science Foundation (Project No. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Neutralino dark matter in gauge mediation Michihisa Takeuchi(a)∗ , Norimi Yokozaki(b)† , and Junhao Zhu(b)‡ (a) School of Physics and Astronomy, Sun Yat-sen University, 519082 Zhuhai, China (b) Zhejiang Institute of Modern Physics and Department of Physics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang 310027, China Abstract We explore the potential of neutralino dark matter within the framework of gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking. Gauge mediation offers an advantage over gravity mediation, as SUSY CP/flavor problems are avoided more easily, leading to significantly milder fine-tuning for electroweak symmetry-breaking compared to gravity mediation.

2026A1515012641) J.Z.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced dark matter scenario evaluation: The AI system can perform a systematic quantitative comparison of four complementary neutralino dark matter scenarios against current and projected experimental sensitivities, as stated in Section 1.

  2. Collider search simulation refinement: The AI system can simulate signal events for bino-wino coannihilation using a full background estimation strategy, including trigger acceptance and pile-up effects, to generate more realistic significance estimates than the naive leading-order simulations.

  3. Direct detection constraint mapping: The system can compute spin independent bino proton cross sections for various benchmark points and compare them directly against current limits from experiments like LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) to identify regions that are comfortably avoid[ed] by three to six orders of magnitude.

  4. Scenario comparison and prioritization: The AI can rank the four dark matter scenarios based on their projected experimental accessibility, noting that the entropy-diluted bino dark matter scenario has a SI cross section O(10−12) pb, a few percent of the current LZ bound, making this scenario more promising for near-future direct detection than the bino-wino coannihilation scenario of (a).

  5. Parameter space identification: The system can identify allowed parameter spaces for each scenario by determining the allowed parameter spaces and evaluate their consistency with existing experimental limits based on the 5D model constraints.

  6. Theoretical framework verification: The AI can verify the consistency of the model by checking conditions derived from supersymmetry breaking, such as requiring that V = 0 with C != 0, gives Omega''grav Omega''Z = 0, which forces g'' (rho) to be zero at the minimum.

Abstract

We explore the potential of neutralino dark matter within the framework of gauge-mediated supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking. Gauge mediation offers an advantage over gravity mediation, as SUSY CP/flavor problems are avoided more easily, leading to significantly milder fine-tuning for electroweak symmetry-breaking compared to gravity mediation. In our models, the lightest neutralino, as the lightest SUSY particle (LSP), is a viable dark matter candidate, assuming a gravitino mass of O(100) TeV. The models are formulated in five-dimensional space-time, where the SUSY breaking field and the matter fields are placed on separate branes to avoid issues related to flavor and CP violation, and the radion is stabilized by a supersymmetric Goldberger--Wise mechanism. Four distinct neutralino dark matter scenarios are studied: bino-wino coannihilation, higgsino dark matter, wino dark matter, and entropy-diluted bino dark matter. For each case, we determine the allowed parameter spaces and evaluate their consistency with existing experimental limits. Additionally, we examine the potential for testing these models through future investigations at the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) and through dark matter direct detection experiments.

Sources

Related papers