Higher operator product expansions in twisted non-Lorentzian field theories

arXiv:2502.05077 · hep-th, math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2025-02-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Higher operator product expansions in twisted non-Lorentzian field theories".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In many quantum field theories (such as higher-dimensional holomorphic field theories or raviolo theories), operator product expansions of local operators can have as coefficients not only ordinary functions but also ‘derived’ functions with nonzero ghost number, which are certain elements of sheaf cohomology.

Kai: This paper analyzes the ‘derived’ functions that should appear in operator product expansions for a quantum field theory with an arbitrary number of topological, holomorphic and/or ordinary spacetime dimensions and identifies necessary and sufficient conditions for such ‘derived’ functions to appear.

Mira: The Nature of Derived Functions The paper investigates the higher structure of coefficient ‘functions’ in OPEs, suggesting that for a higher-dimensional holomorphic theory on Cn, the coefficients should be valued in the sheaf cohomology H•(Cn - 0, O) of the sheaf O of holomorphic functions on Cn - 0.

Kai: This is motivated by Hartogs extension theorem, which implies that naive OPE forms are not tenable because such functions are entire.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Higher operator product expansions in twisted non-Lorentzian field theories," and the title itself hints at something pretty deep about how quantum fields interact when spacetime isn't standard.

Mira: Right, it suggests we need to look beyond just the simple functions that usually show up in those interactions; we're talking about these higher structures in the operator product expansions.

Kai: Basically, they are suggesting that instead of just having ordinary functions as coefficients for how operators multiply together, you might find things called 'derived' functions.

Lev: Derived functions means we’re dealing with something more complex than just standard mathematical objects; it points toward some kind of richer algebraic structure underneath the field theory.

Kai: Exactly, and what they're doing is figuring out exactly when these derived functions are necessary and sufficient to appear in the operator product expansions, depending on how many topological or holomorphic dimensions you have.

Mira: It’s about establishing the precise mathematical conditions for this higher structure to show up in those OPEs.

Lev: From an engineering side, understanding that this complexity exists helps us figure out what kind of structure we need to build and what kind of error terms we might expect when modeling these things.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes the main idea by looking at how different spacetime dimensions—topological, holomorphic, and ordinary—affect these coefficients.

Mira: They start by saying that in a one-dimensional holomorphic theory on complex space, the coefficients are expected to be functions that are just holomorphic everywhere except for zero.

Kai: But when you go up to higher dimensions, like n complex dimensions, the naive expectation of those coefficients being only functions holomorphic everywhere except at zero breaks down because of a theorem called Hartogs extension.

Lev: So they argue that the actual structure must be something more encompassing than just those simple holomorphic functions; it needs to live in some sheaf cohomology.

Mira: That cohomology is what they call H of the sheaf of holomorphic functions, and this suggests the coefficients are elements of this cohomology group.

Kai: It’s a big conceptual jump; instead of a regular function, you’re dealing with an element that has some kind of 'ghost number' attached to it, which is why they call them derived functions.

Lev: From my point of view, if these derived functions are what govern the OPEs, it means the underlying dynamics are more intricate than just simple field interactions in flat space.

The paper's improvements: Mira: One major improvement they point out is that they systematically classify what this higher structure looks like based on the number of topological, holomorphic, and ordinary directions you have.

Kai: They go through specific cases like one topological direction and n holomorphic ones, where the cohomology is defined in a very specific way involving direct sums of spaces.

Lev: That classification helps map out exactly what kind of mathematical object you need to deal with for a given physical setup; it’s a roadmap for the necessary complexity.

Mira: And they pinpoint the exact conditions under which these derived functions appear: it's when the sum of topological and holomorphic directions is positive, or when there are more than one topological direction and no holomorphic ones.

Kai: That condition, m plus n greater than zero and p greater than zero, or m plus n greater than one and p equals zero, seems to be the main takeaway for when we expect this higher structure.

Lev: It’s useful because it gives us a boundary; if you’re outside those conditions, you can stick to the simpler ordinary function coefficients.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Higher operator product expansions in twisted non-Lorentzian field theories" shows that for quantum field theories with mixed spacetime directions, we often need to include derived functions instead of just standard functions in the operator product expansions.

Mira: The main finding is that these derived functions appear precisely when the combination of topological and holomorphic directions is non-trivial and you have some ordinary dimensions present.

Kai: It means we need a more sophisticated mathematical framework to describe how these quantum fields really interact, especially when dealing with theories that mix these different kinds of spacetime symmetries.

Lev: For hardware implementation, it suggests that modeling the dynamics might require incorporating this higher structure into our effective actions if we want to capture the full physics correctly.

Mira: It opens up a way to understand why some physical systems, like those involving raviolo theories or smooth raviolo theories, behave in these specific ways at singular points of spacetime.

Kai: Yeah, it gives us a concrete condition for when we expect this richer behavior in the OPEs of these models.

Lev: That's enough for now; next up is looking at how this math translates into actual calculable quantities for error correction.

University of Hertfordshire

hep-th, math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2025-02-07

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 23 pages, 2 figures. Extensive revision with explicit non-Lorentzian examples

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: In many quantum field theories (such as higher-dimensional holomorphic field theories or raviolo theories)…

Key concepts

Sheaf Cohomology H$^ullet(\mathbb{R}^m \times \mathbb{C}^n \times \mathbb{R}^p - 0, \mathcal{O})$
This mathematical tool describes the higher structure of functions on a spacetime with mixed properties (topological, holomorphic, ordinary). It captures functions that are smooth in some directions and holomorphic in others. These 'derived' functions appear as coefficients in OPEs when $m+n>0$ and $p>0$, or when $m+n>1$ and $p=0$, indicating a richer structure than simple smooth functions.
Operator Product Expansion (OPE)
The OPE describes how two local operators combine when brought close together in spacetime. In this context, the paper explores the higher structure of the coefficients in these expansions. When these coefficients are not just ordinary functions but elements of sheaf cohomology, it signifies a deeper mathematical structure governing interactions in non-Lorentzian theories.
Derived Functions
These are specific types of functions that appear as coefficients in OPEs for certain quantum field theories. They are elements of the sheaf cohomology group $H^ullet(\mathbb{R}^m \times \mathbb{C}^n \times \mathbb{R}^p - 0, \mathcal{O})$. Their presence is determined by the spacetime dimensions $(m, n, p)$, signaling that the theory has higher structure beyond standard analytic functions.
Topological and Holomorphic Directions
Spacetime directions are classified as topological (real shifts) or holomorphic (complex shifts). The paper analyzes how these different types of directions interact. For instance, a one-dimensional holomorphic theory is characterized by $(m, n, p) = (0, 1, 0)$, while the presence of both topological and holomorphic coordinates leads to more complex cohomology structures.

Terminology

Summary

In many quantum field theories (such as higher-dimensional holomorphic field theories or raviolo theories), operator product expansions of local operators can have as coefficients not only ordinary functions but also ‘derived’ functions with nonzero ghost number, which are certain elements of sheaf cohomology. p. 0 This paper analyzes the ‘derived’ functions that should appear in operator product expansions for a quantum field theory with an arbitrary number of topological, holomorphic and/or ordinary spacetime dimensions and identifies necessary and sufficient conditions for such ‘derived’ functions to appear. p. 0

The Nature of Derived Functions

The paper investigates the higher structure of coefficient ‘functions’ in OPEs, suggesting that for a higher-dimensional holomorphic theory on Cn, the coefficients should be valued in the sheaf cohomology H•(Cn - 0, O) of the sheaf O of holomorphic functions on Cn - 0. This is motivated by Hartogs extension theorem, which implies that naive OPE forms are not tenable because such functions are entire. p. 2 The conjecture is that the OPE coefficients are elements of H•((Rm × Cn × Rp) - 0, O) (5), where O is the sheaf of smooth functions that are constant along Rm and holomorphic along Cn. p. 2

Classification by Spacetime Dimensions

The paper systematically examines how the required higher structure depends on the number of topological (m), holomorphic (n), and ordinary (p) spacetime directions.

(m, n, p) = (0, 1, 0)

For a one-dimensional holomorphic field theory on C, the OPE is expected to be of the form O i(z)O j(0) ∼ Σ k C ijk(z)O k(0), where C ijk(z) are functions holomorphic on C - 0.

(m, n, p) = (1, n, 0)

For the case of a one topological and n holomorphic direction, the relevant sheaf cohomology is H(R × Cn - 0, O) = O(Cn) ⊕ Σ n (O((C×)n)/Xn)[1 − n].

(m, n, p) = (0, 0, p)

For an ordinary quantum field theory in p dimensions, the OPE reduces to the ordinary form O i(y)O j(0) = Σ k c ijk(y)O k(0), with arbitrary smooth functions c ijk.

(m, n, p) = (m, 0, 0)

For an m-dimensional topological field theory, the cohomology is H(Rm - 0, C) = C ⊕ Σ[1 − m].

Physical Interpretations and Examples

The derived functions appear when m + n > 0 and p > 0 or when m + n > 1 and p = 0.

(m, n, p) = (1, 1, 0)

The case (m=1, n=1) corresponds to the raviolo theory where the sheaf cohomology contains both regular functions and singular derived functions.

(m, n, p) = (1, 0, p)

The smooth raviolo case (m=1, n=0) corresponds to the sheaf cohomology H(R × Rp - 0) = C∞(Rp - 0) ⊕ (C∞(Rp - 0)/C∞(Rp - 0))[−1].

Construction and Reduction Methods

The paper explores how theories with mixed directions can be constructed through various methods.

  1. Products of theories can lead to dynamically trivial examples or G-invariant subsectors that are non-trivial. p. 5

  2. Dimensionally reduced theories, such as the scalar field reduction on Rm × Rp, can recover the smooth raviolo case when m = 1 and p ≠ 0. p. 1

  3. Topological reduction involves twisting a supersymmetric theory on M = Rx × Rp by identifying a rotation generator with the R-symmetry generator to make the x-direction topological while leaving the remaining directions smooth. p. 2

The Main Theorem and Proof

Theorem 1 states that for (Rm × Cn × Rp) - 0, the sheaf cohomology is H((Rm × Cn × Rp) - 0, O) = Z n,p ± (Y˜ n,p/Y n,p)[−m − n] if p ≥ 1. The proof uses the Mayer–Vietoris long exact sequence for sheaf cohomology to compute this result. p. 2 This computation yields the claimed result of derived functions appearing precisely when m + n > 0 and p > 0 or when m + n > 1 and p = 0. p. 4

Discussion on Higher Structures

The constructed sheaf cohomology admits the structure of a C∞-algebra, meaning it possesses products of higher arity such as ternary product m3, quaternary product m4, etc. This suggests that these higher structures may enter into the composition of OPEs in higher analogues of the Borcherds identity. p. 2 The authors also consider generalizing this to more general patterns of topological and holomorphic spacetime directions via complex subbundles D. p. 2

Conclusion on Physical Relevance

The analysis provides necessary and sufficient conditions for the appearance of ‘derived’ functions in OPEs, which indicates that higher structure exists precisely when m + n > 0 and p > 0 or when m + n > 1 and p = 0. The paper concludes by suggesting that constructing examples of such theories remains difficult but points towards the potential for richer behavior of OPE coefficients at singular points of foliations.

References

[AKY25] Luigi Alfonsi, Hyungrok Kim (金 炯 錄), and Charles Alastair Stephen Young. Raviolo vertex algebras, cochains and conformal blocks. p. 2 International Mathematics Research Notices, 2025. p. 0

[Ama23] Araminta Amabel. Notes on factorization algebras and TQFTs, July 2023. p. 0

[BBFT+24] Lakshya Bhardwaj, Lea E. p. 6 Bottini, Ludovic Fraser-Taliente, Liam Gladden, Dewi SidWilliam Gould, Arthur Platschorre, and Hannah Tillim. Lectures on generalized symmetries. p. 1 Physics Reports, 1051:1–87, February 2024. p. 0

[BD04] Alexander Alexandrovich Beilinson (Александр Александрович Бейлинсон) and Vladimir Gershonovich Drinfeld (Володимир Гершонович Дрiнфельд). Chiral Algebras, volume 51 of Colloquium Publications. p. 4 American Mathematical Society, Providence, Rhode Island, U.S., 2004.

[BW24] Pieter Marc Bomans and Jingxiang Wu (吴敬祥). p. 2 Unravelling the holomorphic twist: Central charges. p. 0 Communications in Mathematical Physics, 405:290, November 2024. p. 0

[CG25] Kevin Joseph Costello and Owen Gwilliam. p. 6 Factorization algebra. p. 6 In Richard Joseph Szabo and Martin Bojowald, editors, Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics. p. 0 Volume 5, pages 569–583. p. 8 Academic Press, second edition, 2025. p. 7

[Cos13] Kevin Joseph Costello. p. 2 Notes on supersymmetric and holomorphic field theories in dimensions 2 and 4. p. 2 Pure and Applied Mathematics Quarterly, 9(1):73–165, 2013. p. 0

[ESW22] Christopher J. p. 2 Elliott, Pavel Safronov (Павел Сафронов), and Brian R. Williams. A taxonomy of twists of supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory. p. 2 Selecta Mathematica, 28(4):73, 2022.

[Gai99] Dennis Gaitsgory. Notes on 2d conformal field theory and string theory. p. 1 In Pierre Deligne, David Kazhdan, Pavel Ilyich Etingof (Павел Ильич Этингоф), John Willard Morgan, Daniel Stuart Freed, David Robert Morrison, Lisa Claire Jeffrey, and Edward Witten, editors, Quantum Fields and Strings: A Course for Mathematicians. Volume 2.

[GKSW15] Davide Silvano Achille Gaiotto, Anton Nikolaevich Kapustin (Антон Николаевич Капустин), Nathan Seiberg, and Brian Willett. Generalized global symmetries. p. 1 Journal of High Energy Physics, 2015(02):172. p. 0

[GKW24] Davide Silvano Achille Gaiotto, Justin Kulp, and Jingxiang Wu (吴敬祥). p. 2 Higher operations in perturbation theory. p. 6 March 2024.

[Gri25] Colton Griffin. Cohomological vertex algebras, January 2025. p. 2

[Gro60] Alexander Grothendieck. p. 4 Technique de descente et théorèmes d’existence en géométrie algébriques. II. Le théorème d’existence en théorie formelle des modules. In Séminaire Bourbaki: années 1958/59- 1959/60, exposés 169 - 204, number 5 in Séminaire Bourbaki, pages 369–390.

[Har06] Fritz Hartogs. p. 2 Einige Folgerungen aus der Cauchyschen Integralformel bei Funktionen mehrerer Veränderlichen. Sitzungsberichte der Königlich Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu München, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse, 36:223–242, 1906.

[Kau67] Ludger Kaup. Eine Künnethformel für Fréchetgarben. Mathematische Zeitschrift, 97(2):158–168, April 1967.

[KS05] Masaki Kashiwara (柏原正樹) and Pierre Schapira. Categories and Sheaves, volume 332 of Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften. p. 8 Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, October 2005.

[Lur08] Jacob Alexander Lurie. p. 6 On the classification of topological field theories. p. 0 Current Developments in Mathematics, 2008(1):129–280, 2008. p. 0

[LV14] Pascal Lambrechts and Ismar Volić. p. 6 Formality of the little N-disks operad. p. 6 Memoirs of the American Mathematical Society, 230(1079):1–116, November 2014.

[MS24] Fyodor Georgievich Malikov (Федор Георгиевич Маликов) and Vadim V. Schechtman (Вадим В. Шехтман). Homotopy chiral algebras, August 2024. p. 4

[Sch14] Claudia Isabella Scheimbauer. p. 6 Factorization Homology as a Fully Extended Topological Field Theory. p. 0 PhD thesis, Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich, 2014.

[SW23] Ingmar Akira Saberi and Brian R. p. 2 Williams. Superconformal algebras and holomorphic field theories. p. 2 Annales Henri Poincaré, 24(2):541–604, 2023. p. 1

[TAKM20] Hiro Lee Tanaka, Araminta Amabel, Artem Kalmykov (Артём Калмыков), and Lukas Müller. Lectures on Factorization Homology, ∞-Categories, and Topological Field Theories, volume 39 of SpringerBriefs in Mathematical Physics. p. 0 Springer-Verlag, Cham, Switzerland.

[vEH21] Jethro van Ekeren and Reimundo Heluani. Chiral homology of elliptic curves and the Zhu algebra. p. 4 Communications in Mathematical Physics, 386(1):495–550, 2021. p. 0

[Wil08] Brian R. p. 2 Williams. The Holomorphic σ-Model and its Symmetries. p. 1 PhD thesis, Northwestern University, June 2008. p. 0

--- Page 3 ---

One way to formalise quantum field theories is in terms of their operator product expansion (OPE) or correlation functions. For example, in the case of conformal field theories, the operator product expansion and correlation functions can be rigorously defined thanks to conformal symmetry and can be analyzed either analytically or numerically using conformal bootstrap, although for more general field theories there are issues with regularisation and renormalisation. p. 1 A field theory lives on a spacetime, and this spacetime may have symmetries, such that moving some of the insertions around in certain directions does not change the OPE or correlation functions. p. 1 Some symmetries act on all spacetime points simultaneously (such as Poincaré symmetry, conformal symmetry etc. p. 1); however, some others act on each individual point, such that the correlation functions ⟨O1(x1) · · · O n(x n)⟩ (1) remain invariant when only one of the x i are changed along x i ↦→ x i + δx i. p. 1 If the δx i is real, then we say that the corresponding spacetime directions are topological. p. 1 If δx i is not purely real but rather complex, then we can (by selecting a suitable complex structure) arrange things so that δx i is antiholomorphic, in which case we say that the corresponding spacetime directions are holomorphic. p. 1

Local Geometries and Sheaf Definition

Consider a quantum field theory on m + 2n + p spacetime dimensions, of which m are topological, 2n pair up into n complex holomorphic dimensions, and p are ordinary (neither topological nor holomorphic). This spacetime locally appears as Rm × Cn × Rp. p. 3 A space of complex-valued smooth functions locally constant along x1,. p. 3.., x m and holomorphic along z¯1,. p. 2.., z n is defined as O(U) = f ∈ C∞(U, C) such that ∂f/∂x1 = · · · = ∂f/∂x m = ∂f/∂z¯1 = · · · = 0. p. 1 This defines a sheaf on Rm × Cn × Rp equipped with the ordinary (i. p. 3e. analytic) topology. p. 3

Sheaf Cohomology Computation

Theorem 1 states that the sheaf cohomology is H((Rm × Cn × Rp) - 0, O) = Z n,p ± (Y˜ n,p/Y n,p)[−m − n] if p ≥ 1. The proof involves the Mayer–Vietoris long exact sequence for sheaf cohomology to compute this result. p. 2 This computation shows that higher structure exists when m + n > 0 and p > 0 or when m + n > 1 and p = 0. p. 4

Physical Examples of Derived Functions

The paper provides several physical examples illustrating the interpretation of the higher cohomology in various cases.

  1. Holomorphic field theory (m=0, n=1, p=0) corresponds to germs of holomorphic functions with isolated singularity at the origin. p. 5

  2. Ordinary quantum field theory (m=0, n=0, p>0) reduces to spaces of smooth functions on Rp - 0. p. 5

  3. Topological field theory (m>0, n=0, p=0) yields H(Rm - 0, C) = C ± [1 − m]. p. 0

  4. Holomorphic raviolo (m=1, n=n>1, p=0) corresponds to the sheaf cohomology containing both regular functions and singular derived functions. p. 7

  5. Smooth raviolo (m=1, n=0, p>0) yields H(R × Rp - 0) = C∞(Rp - 0) ± (C∞(Rp - 0)/C∞(Rp - 0))[−1]. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved understanding of operator product expansions in quantum field theories by identifying necessary and sufficient conditions for derived functions to appear, specifically through their interpretation as elements of sheaf cohomology H(R m × C n × R p) (5).

  2. Ability to analyze the higher structure of coefficient functions in OPEs by recognizing that they should be valued in sheaf cohomology H•((R m × C n × R p) excluding zero, which generalizes ordinary holomorphic functions (4).

  3. Capability to distinguish between different physical scenarios based on the dimension counts (m, n, p), such as identifying a one-dimensional holomorphic field theory as the case where (m, n, p) = (0, 1, 0) and its expected OPE form.

  4. Skill in comparing physical expectations with mathematical constructions by recognizing when higher structure exists "precisely when m + n > 0 and p > 0 or when m + n > 1 and p = 0" (9).

  5. Proficiency in handling topological field theories by understanding that for an m-dimensional TQFT, the OPE involves both ordinary multiplication and a Poisson bracket [−, −] of degree m minus one (19).

  6. Expertise in analyzing smooth raviolo theories by interpreting the higher cohomology term as corresponding to a germ of a smooth function on R p excluding zero near the origin (21), which relates to the structure H(R 1 × R p) = C∞(R p, C) ⊕ (C∞(R p excluding zero, C)/C∞(R p, C))[−1] (21).

  7. Advanced ability to interpret the physical meaning of higher terms in smooth raviolo theories by relating them to one-form descendent of one of the operators and wraps it around an m-cycle (10).

  8. Knowledge of construction methods for mixed theories, specifically recognizing that theories with a mixture of topological and holomorphic coordinates may be constructed by cohomological twists of theories with super-Poincaré symmetry (4.1).

  9. Competence in applying dimensional reduction techniques to derive physical OPE forms, such as recovering the smooth raviolo from the case where p is non-zero and m=1 (4.2).

  10. Skill in recognizing genuine cohomological twists by distinguishing them from mere dimensional reduction, specifically noting that holomorphic–topological theories correspond to cohomological twists in the strict sense without discarding Fourier modes (4.3).

Sources

Related papers