Training-free Task-oriented Grasp Generation

arXiv:2502.04873 · cs.RO · Submitted 2025-02-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Training-free Task-oriented Grasp Generation".

Title and authors: Rosa: So this paper is called "Training-free Task-oriented Grasp Generation." It’s about making robots do more than just grab something stable; they have to understand the actual goal of grasping the object.

Dev: Yeah, it’s by Jiaming Wang, Jizhuo Chen, and Diwen Liu. They present a training-free pipeline that links pre-trained grasp generation models with vision language models to select grasps that match specific task requirements <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: The main idea is using these vision language models to leverage their semantic reasoning capabilities rather than just asking for a stable grasp <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Rosa: Exactly, they show how you can use those reasoning skills to pick a grasp based on what the object is actually intended to be used for, like grasping a handle versus grabbing the blade area <ref:2502.04873#pg3>.

Dev: They take an RGB and depth image as input, process the depth image into a point cloud via unprojection, feed that into a grasp generation model to get initial candidates, and then use a vision language model to filter those candidates based on task constraints <ref:2502.04873#pg3>.

Taro: It seems like the core contribution is testing different ways to integrate the vision language model with that grasp generation model <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Rosa: The paper suggests that how you prompt this vision language model is actually super important for getting a good result. They find that allowing the vision language model more freedom to specify grasp points and match them to the generated grasps leads to much better performance when using a more capable model <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: That means we can move past just asking for a generic action and start leveraging the VLM's ability to reason about spatial relationships in more complex ways <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: They also pointed out some hurdles, specifically that the way they generate the initial set of grasp candidates using clustering sometimes doesn't produce enough diverse clusters <ref:2502.04873#pg3>.

Rosa: And another issue they flagged is that the vision language model itself has its own limitations; it struggles with complex spatial reasoning and physical constraints in three-dimensional scenes <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: They tested this by showing how different camera views affected things, and they found that selecting a view with maximum class confidence helps reduce ambiguity for task compliance <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

The paper's improvements: Rosa: So the paper shows that this training-free pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation works well in both simulated environments and real-world tests across various scenes <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: The key finding they highlight is that when you use a more capable vision language model, simply prompting it to indicate where to grasp and selecting from the set of feasible grasps generated by a pre-trained model—specifically the contact point generation strategy—gives you the best performance <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: That means this approach remains simple and effective even when you only need a single pair of RGB and depth images as input to achieve about seventy percent overall success in real-world scenarios <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Rosa: This study really shows how combining existing models with vision language models can give robots much more flexibility for manipulation, letting them select grasps based on what the object is actually intended to be used for <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: It’s a solid demonstration of how we can integrate task-specific guidance without needing extensive retraining, which keeps the real-time loop latency low <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, basically, this paper introduces training-free task-oriented grasp generation that uses pre-trained models and vision language models to pick grasps that actually fit your specific goal <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: Right, it’s about getting a robot to do more than just grab something stable; it lets the vision language model use its reasoning skills to choose a grasp based on what the object is supposed to be used for, like picking up a handle versus just grabbing the main body one <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: I'm still curious though, how robust this is when things get messy outside of a perfect simulation setup. It seems like they found that if you use a more capable vision language model, letting it freely choose the grasp point from the candidates generated by the grasp model gives the best results <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Rosa: That’s what caught my eye. It means we don't need to spend months training a new model just for better task understanding; we can leverage existing powerful vision language models and guide them in a smarter way <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: But I gotta ask, how fast is this whole loop? They are talking about generating candidates from the grasp model and then filtering them. If this has to run in real-time on a robot, we need to know if those steps fit inside a safe control loop <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: The latency seems okay because they are using point clouds and unprojection first, which is faster than processing full images for every single candidate check <ref:2502.04873#pg3>.

Rosa: And they did look at how the system handles ambiguity. They tested different ways of showing the grasps to the vision language model, like just one image versus multiple images with contact points <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: Those variations in querying—the five strategies they tested—it shows that there’s no single best way to ask the vision language model; you have to test how you present those candidates <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: I think the most interesting part is their conclusion about diversity. They found that the method they used for clustering those initial grasp sets wasn't always good enough to give enough variety in candidates <ref:2502.04873#pg3>.

Rosa: So, it’s not just about picking a better vision language model; it’s also about making sure you start with a good pool of potential grasps so the vision language model has something decent to choose from <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Dev: Yeah, and they noted that the vision language model itself struggles with complex three-dimensional physics and spatial reasoning, so this pipeline is definitely an augmentation rather than a complete replacement for traditional planning methods <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Taro: It’s a clever integration, but those limitations mean we still have to be careful when deploying this outside of controlled environments because the world can misbehave in ways the model didn't anticipate <ref:2502.04873#pg1>.

Jiaming Wang, Jizhuo Chen, Diwen Liu, Harold Soh

University of Singapore

cs.RO

Submitted: 2025-02-07

Updated: 2026-11-14

Comments: Jiaming Wang, Diwen Liu, and Jizhuo Chen contributed equally

Code: https://github.com/StevenLiudw/TOG

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: We present a training-free pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation (TOG) that integrates pre-trained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs) to select grasps aligned with…

Key concepts

Training-free pipeline
This is a system that works without needing to be trained specifically for the task at hand. It uses existing, pre-trained models (like grasp generators) and combines them with a VLM to solve complex tasks, saving the need for extensive new training data.
Task-oriented Grasp Generation (TOG)
This process is about finding the best way for a robot to grasp an object based on what the robot needs to *do* with it, not just making sure the grasp doesn't cause a collision. It links physical grasping with high-level goals described in text.
Vision-Language Model (VLM)
A VLM is an AI that understands both images and language. In this system, the VLM is used to interpret a task description (like 'grasp the handle') and select which of the many possible physical grasps generated by another model best fits that semantic goal.
Contact Point Generation (CPG)
This is a specific strategy where instead of showing all candidate grasps to the VLM, the VLM is directly asked to suggest an optimal pixel location on the image for grasping. This method performed best when using a powerful VLM.

Terminology

Summary

We present a training-free pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation (TOG) that integrates pre-trained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs) to select grasps aligned with specific task requirements. p. 0

Where the paper says it

TOG: Training-free Task-oriented Grasp Generation Jiaming Wang∗ , Jizhuo Chen∗ , Diwen Liu∗ , Harold Soh Abstract— We present a training-free pipeline for taskoriented grasp generation (TOG) that integrates pre-trained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs). Beyond focusing on stability, our method incorporates taskspecific requirements by leveraging the semantic reasoning capabilities of VLMs.

Our key finding is that for more capable VLMs, allowing them to freely specify grasp points and matching them to generated grasps yields the best performance. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we describe steps towards a training-free pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation (TOG) by integrating a pre-trained grasp generation model with a VLM. Our key finding is that for more capable VLMs, allowing them to freely specify grasp points and matching them to generated grasps yields the best performance.

System Architecture

The proposed approach generates the optimal task-oriented grasp in two stages: (1) sampling a set of task-agnostic grasps from a pretrained grasp generation model, and (2) filtering and selecting the grasp that best satisfies the task constraints. Given an RGB and depth image as input, our pipeline begins by processing the depth image to generate a point cloud through unprojection. p. 2

Where the paper says it

An overview of our proposed system is illustrated in Fig. Given an RGB and depth image as input, our pipeline begins by processing the depth image to generate a point cloud through unprojection.

This point cloud is then input into a pre-trained grasp generation model to produce a set of candidate grasps. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Given an RGB and depth image as input, our pipeline begins by processing the depth image to generate a point cloud through unprojection. This point cloud is then input into a pre-trained grasp generation model to produce a set of candidate grasps {Gi} N i=1.

Generated grasps are passed to a motion planner, which filters out any grasps that are not feasible due to reachability or collision constraints. p. 2
Where the paper says it

However, our pipeline is flexible and can accommodate other, potentially more advanced, grasp generation models. Generated grasps are passed to a motion planner, which filters out any grasps that are not feasible due to reachability or collision constraints.

Task-Oriented Grasp Filtering

The VLM is then queried to select the grasp most suitable for the specified task. We employ five distinct strategies to query the VLM, each differing in how candidate grasps are visualized and presented. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The VLM’s response is then used to select the best grasp for the task. We employ five distinct strategies to query the VLM, each differing in how candidate grasps are visualized and

These strategies include:

  1. Grasps in a Single Image (GSI): All candidate grasps are visualized in a single image, with each grasp represented as a U-shaped wireframe at its corresponding pose, projected onto the observed RGB image.

  2. Contact Points in a Single Image (CPSI): Candidate grasps are visualized as colored dots representing their contact points in a single image.

  3. Grasps in Multiple Images (GMI): Each candidate grasp is displayed in a separate image, where the grasp pose is represented by a gripper wireframe projected onto an individual RGB observation.

  4. Contact Points in Multiple Images (CPMI): Each candidate grasp is represented by a colored dot indicating its contact point, displayed in a separate image.

  5. Contact Point Generation (CPG): Instead of providing predefined grasp candidates, we directly query the VLM to suggest an optimal grasping point in the image by specifying pixel coordinates (u, v).

Experimental Findings

The TOG system consistently outperforms the baseline system by a significant margin, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation. Among the evaluated strategies, the Contact Point Generation (CPG) method achieves the best performance when combined with Gemini-2. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Is TOG effective for generating task-oriented grasps? Among the evaluated strategies, the Contact Point Generation (CPG) method achieves the best performance when combined with Gemini-2.

0-Pro. However, CPG is less effective when used with weaker VLMs compared to other strategies. p. 4
Where the paper says it

0-Pro, as shown in Table III. However, CPG is less effective when used with weaker VLMs compared to other strategies.

A key insight from our findings is that when using a more capable VLM, providing it with greater ”freedom” improves performance. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Further analysis reveals that for weaker VLMs, the generated contact points are often unstable and sometimes misaligned with the object, leading to failures in grasp selection (see Figure 5 (c) and (d)). A key insight from our findings is that when using a more capable VLM, providing it with greater ”freedom” improves performance, whereas more restrictive approaches yield better results for less powerful models.

Limitations and Improvements

Several limitations were observed during the experiments, including insufficient grasp diversity, query image ambiguities, and constraints inherent to VLMs. Specifically:

  1. Clustering Method Does Not Provide Sufficiently Diverse Clusters: The clustering method used in our approach sometimes fails to generate clusters that are diverse enough.

  2. Ambiguous Query Images: When the query image is captured from certain viewpoints, some objects or parts of objects in the image may appear ambiguous.

  3. VLM Limitations: The VLM itself has inherent constraints, including challenges in reasoning about complex spatial relationships and physical constraints in 3D scenes.

To test that, we mount four static RGB cameras around the workspace, evenly spaced at 90° on a 0. p. 5

Where the paper says it

If another readily available viewpoint depicts the same scene with higher semantic clarity, the VLM should perform better. To test that, we mount four static RGB cameras around the workspace, evenly spaced at 90° on a 0.

2m radius circle. p. 5
Where the paper says it

To test that, we mount four static RGB cameras around the workspace, evenly spaced at 90° on a 0. 2m radius circle.

Table IV compares results using the default hand-camera versus least-ambiguous view. p. 5
Where the paper says it

3) Select the image m⋆ = arg maxm confm as least ambiguous and feed it to the standard TOG pipeline. Table IV compares results using the default hand-camera versus least-ambiguous view.

While the Grasp Success Rate drops slightly, Task Compliance and Combined Success improve markedly by reducing image ambiguity. p. 5
Where the paper says it

While the Grasp Success Rate drops slightly, Task Compliance and Combined Success improve markedly (by 5. 4 %, respectively), notably improves task performance by reducing image ambiguity.

Real-World Performance

We evaluated grasp performance on 10 objects across three different scenes in the real world. By integrating ContactNet’s [4] capability to generate collision-free grasps from partial point clouds with the VLM’s ability to predict grasping points based on the task description, the TOG system remains both simple and effective. p. 6

Where the paper says it

All three scenes consist of multiple objects, requiring the system to generate collision-free grasps. By integrating ContactNet’s [4] capability to generate collision-free grasps from partial point clouds with the VLM’s ability to predict grasping points based on the task description, the TOG system remains both simple and effective.

Requiring only a single pair of RGB and depth images as input, it achieves an overall success rate of 70%. p. 6
Where the paper says it

By integrating ContactNet’s [4] capability to generate collision-free grasps from partial point clouds with the VLM’s ability to predict grasping points based on the task description, the TOG system remains both simple and effective. Requiring only a single pair of RGB and depth images as input, it achieves an overall success rate of 70%.

Conclusion

In this paper, we introduced TOG, a training-free system for task-oriented grasp generation that integrates pretrained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs) to select grasps aligned with specific task requirements. We evaluate the proposed system in both simulated and real-world environments, demonstrating its effectiveness across various task setups. p. 7

Where the paper says it

CONCLUSION In this paper, we introduced TOG, a training-free system for task-oriented grasp generation that integrates pretrained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs) to select grasps aligned with specific task requirements. We evaluated the proposed system in both simulated and real-world environments, demonstrating its effectiveness across various task setups.

Crucially, we find that when leveraging a powerful VLM, simply prompting the model to indicate where to grasp and selecting from a set of feasible grasps generated by a pretrained grasp generation model — the CPG strategy — yields the best performance. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We evaluated the proposed system in both simulated and real-world environments, demonstrating its effectiveness across various task setups. Crucially, we find that when leveraging a powerful VLM, simply prompting the model to indicate where to grasp and selecting from a set of feasible grasps generated by a pretrained grasp generation model — the CPG strategy — yields the best performance.

This study underscores the potential of combining pre-trained models with VLMs to enable flexible, efficient task-oriented manipulation without additional training. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Notably, we show that performance can be further improved through lightweight view selection to reduce perceptual ambiguity. This study underscores the potential of combining pre-trained grasp models with VLMs to enable flexible, efficient task-oriented manipulation without additional training, offering a promising framework for advancing robotic grasping capabilities.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. VLM integration for task-oriented grasp generation allows robots to fulfill specific goals beyond just achieving stable, collision-free grasps by leveraging the semantic reasoning capabilities of VLMs. This enables robots to select grasps based on the intended use of the object, such as grasping a handle for 'use' versus the blade area for 'passing'.

  2. Adaptive selection of K in k-means clustering should be optimized by maximizing the average silhouette score, which balances grasp success rate and task compliance rate, leading to a better trade-off between grasp diversity and quality.

  3. View selection based on maximum class confidence should be used to reduce perceptual ambiguity, as it improves Task Compliance and Combined Success by mitigating issues where the VLM may select a grasp that results in instability.

Abstract

This paper presents a training-free pipeline for task-oriented grasp generation that combines pre-trained grasp generation models with vision-language models (VLMs). Unlike traditional approaches that focus solely on stable grasps, our method incorporates task-specific requirements by leveraging the semantic reasoning capabilities of VLMs. We evaluate five querying strategies, each utilizing different visual representations of candidate grasps, and demonstrate significant improvements over a baseline method in both grasp success and task compliance rates, with absolute gains of up to 36.9% in overall success rate. Our results underline the potential of VLMs to enhance task-oriented manipulation, providing insights for future research in robotic grasping and human-robot interaction.

Sources

Related papers