Electroweak baryogenesis from charged current anomalies in B meson decays

arXiv:2502.00445 · hep-ph · Submitted 2025-02-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Electroweak baryogenesis from charged current anomalies in B meson decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We demonstrate for the first time that new physics explaining the long standing charged B meson anomalies, R(D(∗)), can be the source of CP violation that explains the observed baryon asymmetry of the universe (BAU) <ref:2502.00445#pg2>.

Kai: The origin of the observed baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU) is one of the deepest puzzles in particle physics and cosmology <ref:2502.00445#pg2>.

Mira: To generate it, the Sakharov conditions

1: must be satisfied: (1) baryon number violation; (2) C and CP violation and (3) departure from thermal equilibrium <ref:2502.00445#pg2>.

Kai: The Standard Model (SM) in principle can fulfill all three conditions, but in practice fails to do so for the latter two <ref:2502.00445#pg2>.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at the paper now called "Electroweak baryogenesis from charged current anomalies in B meson decays". It’s by Athron and Ramsey-Musolf, with Sierra and Wu as collaborators.

Lev: I wonder how they manage to fit all these things together without it becoming too constrained by existing data.

Kai: That's the challenge. They compute the BAU in the semiclassical formalism using a novel approach, which is what makes this work a bit different from previous attempts <ref:2502.00445#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Mira: So we’re seeing that these new physics sources—specifically the CP violation arising from interactions in the charged current anomalies—can generate enough asymmetry to explain the observed BAU.

Kai: The paper focuses on how this new source of CP violation enters the electroweak baryogenesis mechanism, which requires a strong first order phase transition in a two Higgs doublet model.

Lev: That means we need extra bosonic degrees of freedom beyond the standard model to get that strong transition, right?

Mira: Exactly. The authors find that in this scenario, you can generate a left handed fermion number density, nL, at the bubble wall where the CP violation happens.

Kai: And then they use diffusion equations to track how that asymmetry diffuses into the space outside the bubble wall, which then gets converted into baryon asymmetry by sphaleron processes.

The paper's improvements: Lev: What are the main points they highlight as improvements over previous work in this area?

Mira: They show how these scenarios can be probed at future Higgs factories, specifically mentioning the CEPC and FCC-ee experiments. This gives us a way to test their predictions directly.

Kai: And they also address constraints, showing that lepton flavor universality, which is a standard feature of the SM, can still be respected at the one sigma level with complex lepton Yukawa couplings in this two Higgs doublet model.

Lev: That means they aren't just throwing couplings around; they’re trying to keep things consistent with what we see in other places.

Mira: Right. They show that by using the form factors provided by SuperIso four point one, you can compute the contributions to those R(D star) ratios and fit them while simultaneously satisfying all other flavor constraints at the one sigma level <ref:2502.00445#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Electroweak baryogenesis from charged current anomalies in B meson decays" shows a way for the new physics causing those R(D star) anomalies to also be the source of CP violation that generates the BAU.

Mira: It’s a proof of principle that new physics explaining flavor anomalies can provide enough CP violation for baryogenesis while respecting constraints from electron electric dipole moments and other flavor observables.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it’s promising because it ties a known anomaly to a cosmological problem and suggests testable signatures at future colliders.

Kai: Exactly. It's the first time they've demonstrated this connection between the charged current anomalies and successful electroweak baryogenesis in this way <ref:2502.00445#pg1>.

Mira: We’ll keep watching how these constraints from future Higgs factories test those predicted CP violating couplings.

Lev: And we’ll be looking for ways to build the hardware that can actually probe those high energy scales needed for this physics.

Peter Athron, *Michael J Ramsey-Musolf, *Cristian Sierra, &Yongcheng Wu

Department of Physics and Institute of Theoretical Physics, Nanjing Normal University · Tsung-Dao Lee Institute & School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University · Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE), Shanghai Jiao Tong University · Amherst Center for Fundamental Interactions, Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts

hep-ph

Submitted: 2025-02-01

Updated: 2026-11-01

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Physics Letters B 883 (2026) 141092

DOI: 10.1016/j.physletb.2026.141092

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: We demonstrate for the first time that new physics explaining the long standing charged B meson anomalies, R(D(∗))…

Key concepts

Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG)
This is a theory explaining how the matter in the universe became more abundant than antimatter during the early universe. It requires three conditions: baryon number violation, CP violation, and departure from thermal equilibrium. EWBG uses a phase transition involving new particles to create an asymmetry that survives until today.
Charged Current Anomalies
These are persistent deviations between Standard Model predictions and experimental measurements in B meson decays (like R(D(star)) ratios). These anomalies suggest the existence of new, undiscovered interactions or particles beyond the Standard Model. This paper investigates if these specific flavor puzzles can be the source of the CP violation needed for baryogenesis.
General Two Higgs Doublet Model (G2HDM)
The G2HDM is a theoretical framework extending the Standard Model by adding an extra Higgs doublet. This extension introduces new particles and couplings that can provide the necessary new CP-violating interactions required for EWBG. The paper uses this model to calculate how these new couplings affect the generation of baryon asymmetry.

Terminology

Summary

We demonstrate for the first time that new physics explaining the long standing charged B meson anomalies, R(D(∗)), can be the source of CP violation that explains the observed baryon asymmetry of the universe (BAU) <ref:2502. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Electroweak baryogenesis from charged current anomalies in B meson decays Peter Athron,1, ∗ Michael J. Ramsey-Musolf,2, 3, 4, 5, † Cristian Sierra,1, 2, ‡ and Yongcheng Wu1, § 1Department of Physics and Institute of Theoretical Physics, Nanjing Normal University, Wenyuan Road, Nanjing, Jiangsu, 210023, China 2Tsung-Dao Lee Institute & School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China 3Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE), Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China 4Amherst Center for Fundamental Interactions, Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003, USA 5Kellogg Radiation Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA (Dated: February 3, 2025) We demonstrate for the first time that new physics explaining the long standing charged B meson anomalies, R(D (∗) ), can be the source of CP violation that explains the observed baryon asymmetry of the universe (BAU).

00445#pg2>.

Introduction to Electroweak Baryogenesis

The origin of the observed baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU) is one of the deepest puzzles in particle physics and cosmology <ref:2502.00445#pg2>. To generate it, the Sakharov conditions [1] must be satisfied: (1) baryon number violation; (2) C and CP violation and (3) departure from thermal equilibrium <ref:2502. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The origin of the observed baryon asymmetry of the Universe (BAU) is one of the deepest puzzles in particle physics and cosmology. To generate it, the Sakharov conditions [1] must be satisfied: (1) baryon number violation; (2) C and CP violation and (3) departure from thermal equilibrium.

00445#pg2>. The Standard Model (SM) in principle can fulfill all three conditions, but in practice fails to do so for the latter two <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To generate it, the Sakharov conditions [1] must be satisfied: (1) baryon number violation; (2) C and CP violation and (3) departure from thermal equilibrium. The Standard Model (SM) in principle can fulfill all three conditions, but in practice fails to do so for the latter two.

00445#pg2>. Successful baryogenesis requires physics beyond the SM (BSM) <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The Standard Model (SM) in principle can fulfill all three conditions, but in practice fails to do so for the latter two. Thus, successful baryogenesis requires physics beyond the SM (BSM).

00445#pg2>. One of the most attractive mechanisms for this is Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG) [2–6] as it can be tested with electric dipole moments (EDMs) [7], collider physics [8, 9] and gravitational waves [10–12] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Thus, successful baryogenesis requires physics beyond the SM (BSM). One of the most attractive mechanisms for this is Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG) [2–6] as it can be tested with electric dipole moments (EDMs) [7], collider physics [8, 9] and gravitational waves [10–12].

00445#pg2>. EWBG requires new bosonic degrees of freedom in order to generate a strong first order phase transition (SFOPT) that breaks electroweak symmetry when the Higgs field develops a non-zero vacuum expectation value (VEV) <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

One of the most attractive mechanisms for this is Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG) [2–6] as it can be tested with electric dipole moments (EDMs) [7], collider physics [8, 9] and gravitational waves [10–12]. EWBG requires new bosonic degrees of freedom in order to generate a strong first order phase transition (SFOPT) that breaks electroweak symmetry when the Higgs field develops a non-zero vacuum expectation value (VEV).

00445#pg2>. Non-perturbative electroweak sphaleron processes that change total baryon plus lepton number [13, 14] (condition 1) are active outside the bubbles but heavily suppressed inside <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In the SFOPT bubbles of the broken phase nucleate and expand. Non-perturbative electroweak sphaleron processes that change total baryon plus lepton number [13, 14] (condition 1) are active outside the bubbles but heavily suppressed inside.

00445#pg2>. The presence of the phase transition and the associated phase boundary (bubble wall) reflect a departure from equilibrium (condition 3) <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Non-perturbative electroweak sphaleron processes that change total baryon plus lepton number [13, 14] (condition 1) are active outside the bubbles but heavily suppressed inside. The presence of the phase transition and the associated phase boundary (bubble wall) reflect a departure from equilibrium (condition 3).

00445#pg2>. CP violating interactions (condition 2) at the bubble wall generate a chiral asymmetry, i. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The presence of the phase transition and the associated phase boundary (bubble wall) reflect a departure from equilibrium (condition 3). CP violating interactions (condition 2) at the bubble wall generate a chiral asymmetry, i.

e., a non zero number density for left handed particles <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

CP violating interactions (condition 2) at the bubble wall generate a chiral asymmetry, i. , a non zero number density for left handed particles.

00445#pg2>. This asymmetry generated at the bubble wall subsequently diffuses into the space outside it <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

, a non zero number density for left handed particles. This asymmetry generated at the bubble wall subsequently diffuses into the space outside it.

00445#pg2>. The sphaleron process then converts that chiral asymmetry into a baryon asymmetry that is not washed out when the corresponding particles are swept inside the bubble wall as it expands <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This asymmetry generated at the bubble wall subsequently diffuses into the space outside it. The sphaleron process then converts that chiral asymmetry into a baryon asymmetry that is not washed out when the corresponding particles are swept inside the bubble wall as it expands.

00445#pg2>.

Linking Flavor Anomalies to BAU

In this work we show that this new CP violation may be sourced from interactions that have been proposed [15–17] to solve an entirely different problem: long standing and widely considered deviations between SM predictions and the data in flavor physics experiments <ref:2502.00445#pg2>. Specifically, the R(D(∗)) ratios in b → cτν decays [18] and the angular observables in b → sµ+µ− transitions [19, 20] in B meson decays, also known as the charged and neutral current anomalies respectively <ref:2502. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work we show that this new CP violation may be sourced from interactions that have been proposed [15–17] to solve an entirely different problem: long standing and widely considered deviations between SM predictions and the data in flavor physics experiments. Specifically, the R(D(∗) ) ratios in b → cτν decays [18] and the angular observables in b → sµ+µ − transitions [19, 20] in B meson decays, also known as the charged and neutral current anomalies respectively, have garnered considerable attention in flavor physics analyses [21–23].

00445#pg2>, have garnered considerable attention in flavor physics analyses [21–23] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work we show that this new CP violation may be sourced from interactions that have been proposed [15–17] to solve an entirely different problem: long standing and widely considered deviations between SM predictions and the data in flavor physics experiments. Specifically, the R(D(∗) ) ratios in b → cτν decays [18] and the angular observables in b → sµ+µ − transitions [19, 20] in B meson decays, also known as the charged and neutral current anomalies respectively, have garnered considerable attention in flavor physics analyses [21–23].

00445#pg2>. Experimental measurements of these observables deviate from SM predictions by roughly 3 σ and by more than 5σ when considering global fits to all b → sµ+µ− data [21, 22] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Specifically, the R(D(∗) ) ratios in b → cτν decays [18] and the angular observables in b → sµ+µ − transitions [19, 20] in B meson decays, also known as the charged and neutral current anomalies respectively, have garnered considerable attention in flavor physics analyses [21–23]. Experimental measurements of these observables deviate from SM predictions by roughly 3 σ and by more than 5σ when considering global fits to all b → sµ+µ − data [21, 22].

00445#pg2>. Here we investigate the link between the BAU and these persistent signals in the measurements from the LHCb and other particle detectors <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Experimental measurements of these observables deviate from SM predictions by roughly 3 σ and by more than 5σ when considering global fits to all b → sµ+µ − data [21, 22]. Here we investigate the link between the BAU and these persistent signals in the measurements from the LHCb and other particle detectors.

00445#pg2>. We show for the first time that the charged current anomalies could be revealing new physics that gives rise to a successful EWBG mechanism <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here we investigate the link between the BAU and these persistent signals in the measurements from the LHCb and other particle detectors. We show for the first time that the charged current anomalies could be revealing new physics that gives rise to a successful EWBG mechanism.

00445#pg2>. This mechanism generates the observed BAU while satisfying EDM [24], flavor and theoretical constraints [16, 17] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show for the first time that the charged current anomalies could be revealing new physics that gives rise to a successful EWBG mechanism. This mechanism generates the observed BAU while satisfying EDM [24], flavor and theoretical constraints [16, 17].

00445#pg2>. Several attempts at linking flavor anomalies to the BAU have been presented in the literature [25–29], but none of them have considered the effects in the BAU from new CP-violating couplings entering in the charged current anomalies [15–17] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This mechanism generates the observed BAU while satisfying EDM [24], flavor and theoretical constraints [16, 17]. Several attempts at linking flavor anomalies to the BAU have been presented in the literature [25–29], but none of them have considered the effects in the BAU from new CP-violating couplings entering in the charged current anomalies [15– 17].

00445#pg2>.

Modeling Electroweak Dynamics and Source Terms

The dynamics governing the generation of the left-handed fermion number density nL entails three elements: CP-violating scattering at the bubble wall; particle number density transfer reactions; and diffusion <ref:2502.00445#pg2>. The corresponding equations that encode these dynamics follow from the general set of KadanoffBaym (KB) equations <ref:2502. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The dynamics governing the generation of the left-handed fermion number density nL entails three elements: CP-violating scattering at the bubble wall; particle number density transfer reactions; and diffusion. The corresponding equations that encode these dynamics follow from the general set of KadanoffBaym (KB) equations.

00445#pg2>. Solving the full set of KB equations is practically challenging, and various approximations have been taken in the literature <ref:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The corresponding equations that encode these dynamics follow from the general set of KadanoffBaym (KB) equations. Solving the full set of KB equations is practically challenging, and various approximations have been taken in the literature.

00445#pg2>. Here, we follow the WKB treatment of Refs. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Solving the full set of KB equations is practically challenging, and various approximations have been taken in the literature. Here, we follow the WKB treatment of Refs.

[60–62] that yields a set of Boltzmann equations which one may further reduce to a tractable diffusion equation for nL <ref:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

[60–62] that yields a set of Boltzmann equations which one may further reduce to a tractable diffusion equation for nL. For the present purposes, a further simplification follows from the work of Ref. p. 1

Where the paper says it

[60–62] that yields a set of Boltzmann equations which one may further reduce to a tractable diffusion equation for nL. For the present purposes, a further simplification follows from the work of Ref.

00445#pg2>. For the present purposes, a further simplification follows from the work of Ref. [63] <ref:2502. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To establish the flavor anomaly-BAU connection, we employ the semi-classical formalism also called WentzelKramers-Brillouin (WKB) method for a leptonic CPviolating source, which provides a more conservative estimate than other approaches [30] as discussed below. For concreteness, we adopt the general two Higgs doublet model (G2HDM), which includes complex leptonic arXiv:2502.

00445#pg2>. The CP-violating source we consider resides in the lepton Yukawa sector of the G2HDM <ref:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

For the present purposes, a further simplification follows from the work of Ref. The CP-violating source we consider resides in the lepton Yukawa sector of the G2HDM.

00445#pg2>.

The Diffusion Equation and BAU Calculation

Following the prescription of Refs. [60–62] in the WKB formalism and using the diffusion approximation, one then obtains the single species diffusion equation Dl l′′(z) + υw l′(z) + Γl l(z) = Sl <ref:2502. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Following the prescription of Refs. [60–62] in the WKB formalism and using the diffusion approximation, one then obtains the single species diffusion equation Dl l ′′(z) + υw l ′ (z) + Γl l(z) = Sl , (1) where we have dropped the the subscript “L” for simplicity.

00445#pg2>. The net baryon number density nB is determined by solving the baryon number diffusion equation [70] <ref:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(1) is given by [53, 63, 66–69] l(z) = −A e z γs + , (2) with the amplitude A given in Eq. The net baryon number density nB is determined by solving the baryon number diffusion equation [70], n ′′ B(z) − υw Dq n ′ B(z) = Γws Dq R nB(z) + 3 2 nL(z) , (3) with Dq = 7.

00445#pg2>. The solution to Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We neglect the bubble wall curvature and work in the bubble wall rest frame, z = |x + υw t| and we take z < −Lw/2 as the symmetric phase, where Lw is the bubble wall thickness. In this way, the solution to Eq.

(3) is given in terms of the ratio YB ≡ nB/s YB = − 3 Γws / 2 s / Dqλ+ Z −Lw/2 −∞ l(z) e−λ−z dz <ref:2502. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2) and the solution of Eq. (3) is given in terms of the ratio YB ≡ nB/s [70], YB = − 3 Γws 2 s 1 Dqλ+ Z −Lw/2 −∞ l(z) e −λ−z dz, (4) where s = (2π 2/45)g∗T 3 is the entropy density at the temperature T, g∗ = 110.

00445#pg2>.

Constraints and Future Probes

The lepton flavor universality (LFU) is a fundamental feature of the SM and states that the W boson couples equally to the three lepton generations <ref:2502.00445#pg2>. These ratios can be explained at tree level using complex lepton Yukawa couplings in the G2HDM while simultaneously satisfying all other flavor constraints at the 1σ level [15–17] <ref:2502. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2 σ from the SM, thus motivating BSM physics in order to fit it. These ratios can be explained at tree level using complex lepton Yukawa couplings in the G2HDM while simultaneously satisfying all other flavor constraints at the 1σ level [15–17].

00445#pg2>. The CP-violating coupling κ˜τ is given in terms of Im(Nτ τ) = v Im(JA)/(√2 yτ τ mτ), and the electron EDM will provide the dominant constraint in our scenario <ref:2502. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Regarding the latter, the Higgs fermion effective Lagrangian can be written as [80, 81], −Lhτ τ = mτ v (κτ τ τ + iκ˜τ τ γ5τ ) h, (8) allowing a matching between this effective theory and the G2HDM (see End Matter, Eq. (B3) for the relevant part of the G2HDM Lagrangian), obtaining κτ = − sin α cos β + cβ−α cos β Re(Nτ τ ), κ˜τ = cβ−α cos β Im(Nτ τ ), (9) where the CP-violating coupling κ˜τ is given in terms of Im(Nτ τ ) = v Im(JA)/( √ 2 yτ τ mτ ), and JA is the Jarlskog invariant defined in Eq.

00445#pg2>. Sensitivity projections from the future Higgs factories, CEPC [58] and FCC-ee [59] (orange dashed curve), indicate that future experimental studies of Higgs di-tau decay properties sensitive to κ˜τ can test our predictions <ref:2502. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Thus care should be taken in inferring any specific bounds from our plots. Interestingly, sensitivity projections from the future Higgs factories, CEPC [58] and FCC-ee [59] (orange dashed curve), indicate that future experimental studies of Higgs di-tau decay properties sensitive to κ˜τ can test our predictions.

00445#pg2>.

Conclusion on the Connection

Our study of EWBG in the G2HDM provides a proof of principle that new physics explaining the R(D(∗)) anomalies can admit sufficient CP-violation as needed to explain the BAU while respecting eEDM and other phenomenological constraints <ref:2502.00445#pg2>. This work represents the first time such a connection between the charged current anomalies and successful EWBG has been demonstrated <ref:2502. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Our study of EWBG in the G2HDM provides a proof of principle that new physics explaining the R(D(∗) ) anomalies can admit sufficient CP-violation as needed to explain the BAU while respecting eEDM and other phenomenological constraints. To our knowledge, this work represents the first time such a connection between the charged current anomalies and successful EWBG has been demonstrated.

00445#pg2>. The finding relies on using the WKB method for a conservative estimate of the BAU, while employing a new approach that gives an analytical solution through simplifying approximations <ref:2502. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Our finding relies on using the WKB method for a conservative estimate of the BAU, while employing a new approach that gives an analytical solution through simplifying approximations. This work can be generalized for more complicated cases using different lepton diffusion constants DL ̸= DR, as well as including quarks in the full transport equations that were updated in Ref.

00445#pg2>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform predictive modeling for new physics scenarios by simulating Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG) within a General Two Higgs Doublet Model (G2HDM). This allows the system to predict baryon asymmetry generation based on flavor anomaly parameters like R(D(star)) and constraints from the electron electric dipole moment.

  2. Improved AI system can perform targeted searches for new physics by correlating flavor anomalies with cosmological observables. It can identify specific parameter regions in the G2HDM Yukawa sector that simultaneously explain long-standing B meson decay deviations and generate a viable baryon asymmetry compatible with current experimental limits on EDMs.

  3. Improved AI system can optimize future experimental strategies by projecting sensitivity gains for Higgs factories and electron EDM experiments. It can simulate how future measurements of Higgs di-tau decays or electron EDMs will constrain the CP-violating Yukawa couplings, helping to prioritize which BSM signatures offer the best path to discovery.

Abstract

We demonstrate for the first time that new physics explaining the long standing charged B meson anomalies, R(D(*)), can be the source of CP violation that explains the observed baryon asymmetry of the universe (BAU). We consider the general two Higgs doublet model with complex Yukawa couplings and compute the BAU in the semiclassical formalism, using a novel analytic approximation for the latter. After imposing constraints from both flavor observables and the electron electric dipole moment (eEDM), and assuming the occurrence of a sufficiently strong first order electroweak phase transition, we find that the observed BAU can be generated for benchmark points within the region favored by the global flavor fit. Reaching the observed BAU relies on optimized values of the phase transition parameters, which we treat as inputs. These scenarios, which explain both R(D(*)) and the BAU, can be probed with future eEDM experiments and Higgs factories measurements.

Sources

Related papers