On the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model

arXiv:2501.19362 · math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2025-01-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We prove absence of ground states in the infrared-divergent spin boson model at large coupling Our key argument reduces the proof to verifying long range order in the dual one-dimensional continuum Ising model Combined with known results from percolation theory to establish long range order at large coupling Model Definition and Ground State Criterion The spin boson model describes the interaction of a two-state quantum system (called spin) with a bosonic quantum field The Hamiltonian is given by Hλ:= 2 0 0 ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ dΓ(ω) + λ 0 1, which is selfadjoint and bounded from below under Hypothesis A.

Kai: The existence of a ground state is signaled by the vacuum overlap ρ(λ) being strictly positive.

Mira: Phase Transition Mechanism The paper establishes that the spin boson model undergoes a phase transition with respect to the coupling strength.

Kai: This transition is unique, meaning there is a critical coupling constant below which a ground state exists and above which none can exist.

Title and authors: Kai: So Mira, this paper is called "On the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model," and it seems to be tackling a really tricky issue with these spin boson models. It’s looking at what happens when you have that infrared divergence, which is kind of like having problems at very low energies or long distances in quantum field theory.

Mira: Right, Kai. The authors are Volker Betz, Benjamin Hinrichs, Mino Nicola Kraft, and Steffen Polzer. They're focusing on proving that there's no ground state at large coupling in this spin boson model because they can connect it to the one-dimensional continuum Ising model.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we look at what this means for building hardware, it suggests that if you push the coupling strength too high, you won't find a stable ground state configuration in your system. It sets a hard limit on where we can expect to find these states.

Kai: Exactly. The core idea is reducing the problem to checking for long range order in that dual one-dimensional continuum Ising model, which they show is possible at large coupling using known results from percolation theory.

Mira: And what's really interesting, Kai, is how they connect the vacuum overlap of the spin boson ground state to those correlation functions of the continuum Ising model through Theorem three point four <ref:2501.19362#pg3>. That expansion gives us a concrete way to see if a positive vacuum overlap implies long range order in that dual system.

Lev: If that connection holds up mathematically, it means we can use percolation theory—which is pretty well understood for one dimension—to establish the absence of ground states at large coupling in the spin boson model. That’s a powerful shortcut.

Kai: It also shows something about the phase transition itself, Mira. They prove it's unique, meaning there's only one critical coupling constant where you switch from having a ground state to not having one at all.

Mira: That uniqueness comes from the expansion they present for the vacuum overlap in terms of Ising n-point functions, which leads to Corollary three point five, showing that long range order in the infrared divergent model directly implies no ground states > zero on page three of this work.

Lev: So, for someone building error correction codes or looking at quantum hardware fidelity, this means we have a clear boundary: below a certain coupling strength you might have a ground state, but above that boundary it's impossible to find one.

Kai: And they also give us an upper bound for the vacuum overlap of the ground state itself, which is useful for characterizing what those states look like when they *do* exist.

Title and authors: Mira: This paper is really solid because it ties together quantum field theory concepts with statistical mechanics—the Ising model—and percolation theory to make this claim about absence of states at large coupling in the spin boson model.

Lev: It's a neat way to approach something that's hard to tackle directly with standard perturbative methods, especially since earlier work was mostly restricted to small coupling.

Kai: So, moving on from this paper, what are some of the suggested improvements they make? They seem pretty focused on refining how we use these results.

Mira: They suggest an adaptive ground state prediction system that can tell you whether an infrared divergent spin boson model has a ground state just by looking at the coupling strength and checking for long range order in the dual one dimensional continuum Ising model.

Lev: That sounds like it would be a direct tool for simulation or even experimental design, telling you upfront if your parameters are in the regime where you need to worry about states existing or not.

Kai: And they also suggest tracking the critical coupling in discrete percolation models, which is how we can estimate an upper bound for that critical coupling above which ground states don't exist.

Mira: That part directly addresses the practical limitation, Kai, because it gives us a way to estimate that boundary using methods from discrete percolation theory as we track the critical coupling.

Lev: It moves away from just theoretical bounds and suggests a method for actually estimating that threshold in a more concrete setting.

Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model, it establishes that absence of ground states at large coupling is proven by verifying long range order in the dual one dimensional continuum Ising model and using known percolation theory results.

Mira: It also shows that there's a unique phase transition point defined by a critical coupling constant where the vacuum overlap expansion implies either existence or non-existence of a ground state.

Lev: For me, it’s important because it provides a rigorous way to understand the limits of these models when we move away from the small coupling regime where previous proofs were based on perturbation theory.

Kai: I think this is really useful for understanding the boundaries of what we can expect in these types of light-matter interactions when they get pushed into those infrared divergent regimes.

Mira: It’s a good piece for anyone interested in how statistical mechanics concepts, like long range order and percolation, can be applied to problems in quantum field theory that have been notoriously difficult.

Lev: We'll keep an eye on how this critical coupling estimation part translates into actual hardware constraints as we design the next generation of these models.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, we're looking at how this paper boils down: it proves that you can predict whether an infrared divergent spin boson model has a ground state just by checking for long range order in its dual one dimensional continuum Ising model.

Mira: Exactly. The authors connect the vacuum overlap of the spin boson ground state to correlation functions of that continuum Ising model through this theorem, which is really the main tool here.

Lev: From my side, it means we can use known results from percolation theory—which is pretty solid for one dimension—to establish the absence of ground states at large coupling in the spin boson model.

Kai: It’s about that unique phase transition point where you either get a ground state or you don't, depending on how strong the coupling is.

Mira: That uniqueness comes from analyzing that vacuum overlap expansion, which shows that if you have long range order in the dual system, then there must be no ground state for the spin boson model.

Lev: For real hardware, it’s a clean boundary to hit. You can see how this relates to tracking the critical coupling in discrete percolation models to get an upper bound on that threshold where states disappear.

Kai: It gives us a way to estimate that boundary using methods from discrete percolation theory, which is useful for setting practical limits on what we can expect.

Mira: And they also provide an upper bound for the vacuum overlap of the ground state itself, which helps us characterize what those states look like when they actually exist.

Lev: So, basically, it’s a rigorous way to understand the limits of these models when you move away from the small coupling regime where previous proofs were based on perturbation theory.

Kai: It’s really about understanding those boundaries in these light matter interactions when they get pushed into those infrared divergent regimes.

Mira: And that leads us to thinking, given this connection to percolation, how does this framework translate into more complex systems with higher dimensions?

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we're talking about how this paper suggests making things better: they propose an adaptive ground state prediction system that can tell you whether an infrared divergent spin boson model has a ground state just by checking for long range order in its dual one dimensional continuum Ising model.

Kai: That sounds like a direct tool for simulation or even experimental design, telling you upfront if your parameters are in the regime where you need to worry about states existing or not.

Mira: It’s about building a system that uses that correlation function connection we discussed earlier to predict the existence of those states based on the coupling strength.

Lev: That prediction would be very useful for running simulations because it cuts out a lot of unnecessary computation if we know upfront whether a solution is even possible in that regime.

Kai: And they also suggest tracking the critical coupling in discrete percolation models, which is how we can estimate an upper bound for that critical coupling above which ground states don't exist.

Mira: That part directly addresses the practical limitation because it gives us a way to estimate that boundary using methods from discrete percolation theory as we track the critical coupling.

Lev: So, it moves away from just theoretical bounds and suggests a method for actually estimating that threshold in a more concrete setting on real hardware.

Kai: It’s about getting a handle on where to stop pushing the coupling strength before we hit an unphysical regime.

Mira: And they also provide an upper bound for the vacuum overlap of the ground state, which helps us characterize what those states look like when they actually exist in that regime.

Lev: That characterization would be important for understanding the stability of any state we might find in a simulated environment.

Kai: It’s really about getting a handle on the limits of these models when you move away from the small coupling regime where previous proofs were based on perturbation theory.

Mira: And that leads us to thinking, given this connection to percolation, how does this framework translate into more complex systems with higher dimensions?

Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve been looking at "On the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model," and essentially, this paper proves that you can predict whether an infrared divergent spin boson model has a ground state just by checking for long range order in its dual one dimensional continuum Ising model.

Mira: Right. The main idea is using that vacuum overlap expansion to link the spin boson physics directly to the correlation functions of that continuum Ising model.

Lev: It’s about getting a handle on where to stop pushing the coupling strength before we hit an unphysical regime, and they give us a way to estimate that boundary using discrete percolation theory as we track the critical coupling.

Kai: It's about setting practical limits on what we can expect in these models when they get pushed into those infrared divergent regimes.

Mira: And the fact that it’s unique means there’s only one critical coupling constant where you switch from having a ground state to not having one at all.

Lev: That's good for error correction because it gives us a clear boundary to hit when designing protocols for those systems.

Kai: It really connects the math of field theory with statistical mechanics in a very concrete way, showing how long range order plays the role of a predictor for ground state existence.

Mira: And they provide an upper bound for that vacuum overlap itself, which is useful for characterizing what those states look like when they do exist.

Lev: For running these on real hardware, knowing that stability bound means we know the safe operating range without having to check every single parameter combination.

Kai: So, "On the Ising Phase Transition in the Infrared-Divergent Spin Boson Model" is this solid result linking long range order to state existence.

Mira: It’s a good piece for anyone interested in how statistical mechanics concepts like percolation can be applied to problems in quantum field theory that have been notoriously difficult.

Lev: We'll keep an eye on how this critical coupling estimation part translates into actual hardware constraints as we design the next generation of these models.

Technische Universität Darmstadt · Universität Paderborn · University of Geneva

math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2025-01-31

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 19 pages, version accepted for publication in Forum of Mathematics, Sigma

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: We prove absence of ground states in the infrared-divergent spin boson model at large coupling Our key argument reduces the proof to verifying long range order in the dual one-dimensional continuum…

Key concepts

Spin Boson Model
This is a quantum model describing how two-state spins interact with a bosonic field. The existence of a stable ground state in this system is what the researchers are trying to determine, particularly when the model has infrared divergences.
Vacuum Overlap $\rho(\lambda)$
This quantity measures whether a ground state exists in the spin boson model. If this overlap is strictly positive, it signals that a ground state can be found. The paper relates this overlap to correlation functions of a continuum Ising model.
Long Range Order
This refers to the behavior of correlations in the dual one-dimensional continuum Ising model at large coupling. Establishing long-range order in this simpler system is used as a key tool to prove that no ground state exists in the original spin boson model at strong coupling.

Terminology

Summary

We prove absence of ground states in the infrared-divergent spin boson model at large coupling Our key argument reduces the proof to verifying long range order in the dual one-dimensional continuum Ising model Combined with known results from percolation theory to establish long range order at large coupling

Model Definition and Ground State Criterion

The spin boson model describes the interaction of a two-state quantum system (called spin) with a bosonic quantum field The Hamiltonian is given by Hλ:= 2 0 0 ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ dΓ(ω) + λ 0 1, which is selfadjoint and bounded from below under Hypothesis A. The existence of a ground state is signaled by the vacuum overlap ρ(λ) being strictly positive. p. 0

Phase Transition Mechanism

The paper establishes that the spin boson model undergoes a phase transition with respect to the coupling strength. This transition is unique, meaning there is a critical coupling constant below which a ground state exists and above which none can exist. p. 0 The non-existence of the ground state is established by proving long range order in the one-sided Ising model. p. 1

Connection to Continuum Ising Model

The functional integral representation of the spin boson model is related to a continuum Ising model. The vacuum overlap expansion Theorem 3. p. 24 expresses ρ(λ) in terms of correlation functions of a one-dimensional, long range, continuum Ising model. p. 1 The proof relies on relating the vacuum overlap to spin correlations in this continuum Ising model. p. 4

Long Range Order and Absence of States

Theorem 4.1 states that if g(t) ≥ C(1 + t 2) −1 for some C > 0 and all t ∈ R, then for sufficiently large α > 0 inf t≥0 ta,1(t) > 0. p. 9 This long range order in the continuum Ising model implies the absence of ground states in the spin boson model. p. 2

Conclusion and Comparison

The results connect the long-range behavior of Ising correlation functions and the existence of ground states. The paper compares its findings with Spohn's approach, noting that a phase transition exists in the sense of KMS states. The connection between the critical parameter αc established in [Spo89] and the critical parameter from Theorem 2. p. 94 is conjectured but not yet proven. p. 1

Appendix A on Convergence

The convergence of the discrete to the continuum percolation is shown by demonstrating that (ξN,1, ξN,2) converges in distribution to (ξ1, ξ2) as N → ∞. This convergence allows for the identification of correlation functions with those from the continuum FK-percolation. p. 1 The proof relies on showing that the set of discontinuity points of 2C is a null set under Pe α,T,c. p. 4

References

[Abd11] A. Abdesselam. The Ground State Energy of the Massless Spin-Boson Model. p. 1 Ann. Henri Poincaré, 12(7):1321– 1347, 2011, arXiv:1005. p. 04366

[ABF87] M. Aizenman, D. J. Barsky, and R. Fernández. The Phase Transition in a General Class of Ising-Type Models is Sharp

[ACCN88] M. Aizenman, J. T. Chayes, L. Chayes, and C. M. Newman. Discontinuity of the magnetization in onedimensional 1/x − y 2 Ising and Potts models

[AH95] A. Arai and M. Hirokawa. On the Existence and Uniqueness of Ground States of the Spin-Boson Hamiltonian

[AKN87] M. Aizenman, H. Kesten, and C. M. Newman. Uniqueness of the Infinite Cluster and Continuity of Connectivity Functions for Short and Long Range Percolation

[Ara18] A. Arai. Analysis on Fock Spaces and Mathematical Theory of Quantum Fields

[BBKM17] V. Bach, M. Ballesteros, M. Könenberg, and L. Menrath. Existence of ground state eigenvalues for the spin–boson model with critical infrared divergence and multiscale analysis

[BDP12] S. Bachmann, D.-A. Deckert, and A. Pizzo. The mass shell of the Nelson model without cut-offs

[BFS98] V. Bach, J. Fröhlich, and I. p. 1 M. Sigal. Renormalization Group Analysis of Spectral Problems in Quantum Field Theory

[BN37] F. Bloch and A. Nordsieck. Note on the Radiation Field of the Electron

[BP22] V. Betz and S. p. 0 Polzer. A Functional Central Limit Theorem for Polaron Path Measures

[BU09] V. Betz and D. p. 0 Ueltschi. Spatial Random Permutations and Infinite Cycles

[Che08] T. Chen. Infrared renormalization in non-relativistic QED and scaling criticality

[Dam20] T. N. Dam. Absence of Ground States in the Translation Invariant Massless Nelson Model

[DM20a] T. N. Dam and J. S. Møller. Asymptotics in Spin-Boson type models

[DM20b] T. N. Dam and J. S. Møller. Spin-Boson type models analysed using symmetries

[EL74] V. J. Emery and A. Luther. Low-temperature properties of the Kondo Hamiltonian

[FN88] M. Fannes and B. Nachtergaele. Translating the spin-boson model into a classical system

[Frö54] H. Fröhlich. Electrons in Lattice Fields

[Frö73] J. Fröhlich. On the infrared problem in a model of scalar electrons and massless scalar bosons

[FS82] J. Fröhlich and T. p. 1 Spencer. The Phase Transition in the One-Dimensional Ising Model with 1/r2 Interaction Energy

[FV17] S. Friedli and Y. Velenik. Statistical mechanics of lattice systems: A Concrete Mathematical Introduction

[GD16] F. Grusdt and E. Demler. New theoretical approaches to Bose polarons

[Gér00] C. Gérard. On the Existence of Ground States for Massless Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonians

[GLL01] M. Griesemer, E. Lieb, and M. Loss. Ground states in non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics

[HH08] D. Hasler and I. p. 1 p. 1 Herbst. Absence of Ground States for a Class of Translation Invariant Models of Non-relativistic QED

[HH11] D. Hasler and I. Herbst. Ground States in the Spin Boson Model

[HHL14] M. Hirokawa, F. Hiroshima, and J. p. 1 Lőrinczi. Spin-boson model through a Poisson-driven stochastic process

[HHS21] D. Hasler, B. Hinrichs, and O. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Siebert. On Existence of Ground States in the Spin Boson Model

[HHS22a] D. Hasler, B. Hinrichs, and O. Siebert. Correlation bound for a one-dimensional continuous long-range Ising model

[HHS22b] D. Hasler, B. Hinrichs, and O. Siebert. FKN Formula and Ground State Energy for the Spin Boson Model with External Magnetic Field

[HHS24] D. Hasler, B. Hinrichs, and O. Siebert. Non-Fock ground states in the translation-invariant Nelson model revisited non-perturbatively

[Hin22a] B. Hinrichs. Existence of Ground States for Infrared-Critical Models of Quantum Field Theory

[Hin22b] B. Hinrichs. Existence of Ground States in the Infrared-Critial Spin Boson Model

[HL24] B. Hinrichs and J. p. 0 Lampart. A Lower Bound on the Critical Momentum of an Impurity in a Bose–Einstein Condensate

[HLVM] B. Hinrichs, J. p. 0 Lampart, and J. Valentín Martín. Ultraviolet Renormalization of Spin Boson Models I. p. 1 Normal and 2-Nilpotent Interactions

[HM22] F. Hiroshima and O. p. 1 Matte. Ground states and their associated path measures in the renormalized Nelson model

[HS23] D. Hasler and O. p. 1 Siebert. Ground States for translationally invariant Pauli-Fierz Models at zero Momentum

[IN88] J. Z. Imbrie and C. M. Newman. An intermediate phase with slow decay of correlations in one-dimensional 1/x− y 2 percolation, Ising and Potts models

[Kal73] O. Kallenberg. Characterization and convergence of random measures and point processes

[Kal17] O. Kallenberg. Random Measures, Theory and Applications, volume 77 of Probability Theory and Stochastic Modelling

[LHB20] J. Lőrinczi, F. Hiroshima, and V. p. 1 Betz. Feynman-Kac-Type Theorems and Gibbs Measures on Path Space

[LL23] S. Lill and D. Lonigro. Self-adjointness and domain of generalized spin-boson models with mild ultraviolet divergences

[LMS02] J. Lőrinczi, R. A. Minlos, and H. Spohn. The Infrared Behaviour in Nelson’s Model of a Quantum Particle Coupled to a Massless Scalar Field

[Lon22] D. Lonigro. Generalized spin-boson models with non-normalizable form factors

--- Page 1 ---

ON THE ISING PHASE TRANSITION IN THE INFRARED-DIVERGENT SPIN BOSON MODEL

arXiv:2501.19362v1 [math-ph] 31 Jan 2025

The spin boson model undergoes a phase transition with respect to the coupling strength This transition is unique, meaning there is a critical coupling constant below which a ground state exists and above which none can exist.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper proves absence of ground states in the infrared-divergent spin boson model at large coupling This result is established by proving long range order in the one-sided Ising model. The proof exploits a discretization scheme that is already present in [SD85] and results from discrete percolation theory. p. 1

How the training signal is built

The main technical result is Theorem 3.4, which expresses the vacuum overlap ρ(λ) in terms of correlation functions of a one-dimensional, long range, continuum Ising model. p. 1 This expression involves a convolution f ∗ h: [0, ∞) n → [0, ∞) of two measurable functions. p. 6 The proof shows that if ρ(λ) > 0, then the limit of Zα(λ),T / Zα(λ),2T is greater than zero. p. 9

Where the gains come from

The final proof of Theorem 2.9 combines Corollary 3. p. 25 and Theorem 4. p. 11 to prove that if R Rd e −tω(k) v(k) 2dk ≥ C(1 + t 2) −1 for some C > 0 and all t > 0, then λ0 < ∞. p. 3 This result is derived by combining the integrability criterion with the long range order results in the continuum Ising model. p. 1 The work also provides an upper bound for the vacuum overlap of the ground state. p. 4

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Adaptive Ground State Prediction: The improved system can predict whether an infrared-divergent spin boson model has a ground state based on coupling strength by evaluating if long range order exists in its dual one dimensional continuum Ising model.

  2. Phase Transition Characterization: The system can determine the uniqueness of the phase transition by analyzing the vacuum overlap expansion and its relation to Ising n-point functions, identifying a critical coupling constant below which a ground state exists and above which none can exist.

  3. Critical Coupling Estimation: The improved system can estimate an upper bound for the critical coupling above which ground states do not exist by tracking the critical coupling in discrete percolation models, as suggested by tracking the critical coupling in the discrete percolation models.

Sources

Related papers