Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions

arXiv:2412.20007 · eess.IV, cs.CV · Submitted 2024-12-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Electrical Engineering. The day in electrical engineering: signals, systems and the hardware that carries them.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Deep learning models (DLMs) lacking feedback on their image segmentation mechanisms such as Dice coefficients and confidence in their performance face challenges processing previously unseen images in real-world clinical settings This study reports two DLMs, one trained from scratch and another based on transfer learning, with Monte Carlo dropout or Bayesby-backprop uncertainty estimations to segment lesions from the publicly available The International Skin Imaging Collaboration dermoscopy image database with lesions of cancer A novel approach to compute pixel-by-pixel uncertainty estimations of DLM segmentation performance in multiple clinical regions from a single dermatoscopy image with corresponding Dice scores is reported for the first time Image-level uncertainty maps demonstrated correspondence between imperfect DLM segmentation and high uncertainty levels in specific skin tissue regions with or without lesions Four new linear regression models that can predict the Dice performance of DLM segmentation using constants and uncertainty measures either individually or in combination from lesions, tissue structures, and non-tissue pixels regions critical for clinical diagnosis and prognostication in skin images are reported for the first time Model Training Strategies The study evaluates performance by training multiple DNNs using both Monte Carlo dropout (MCD) and Bayes-by-backprop (BBP) techniques with training from scratch (TFS) and transfer learning (TL) approaches for segmentation of melanoma, melanocytic nevus, and seborrheic keratosis skin conditions The Bayesian VGG-UNet CNN was trained on skin lesion images and their labels, integrating MCD and BBP techniques to mitigate noise during the downscaling phase All DLMs were trained for 50 epochs with a batch size of two using the Adam optimizer and a learning rate of (αlr = 0.001) Input images were resized to 608 × 416 (width × height), with outputs at 304 × 208, and training was done on an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 Ti with 32GB of GPU memory Uncertainty Quantification Methods To obtain pixel-level uncertainty, the study utilized Monte Carlo dropout (DLM MCD) and Bayes-by-backprop (DLM Bc) For each model prediction, 50 MC iterations were taken where the difference between 67th and 33rd percentiles of their sigmoid values from the DLMs predictions were set as uncertainty estimates and represented as heatmaps The final model output, OMi =

OMp1 s.t ∀ pixels, p in OMp1, (p > 0.95) =⇒ (p = 1) and (p ≤ 0.95) =⇒ (p = 0): The corresponding uncertainty map was obtained by Uncmapi = P67(

Uncj Mp: α j=1) − P33(

Uncj Mp: α j=1) Performance Analysis and Correlation The performance of the proposed Algorithm 1 is assessed by training four separate linear models to learn the correspondence between Dice scores and uncertainty measures from two clinical ROIs, either individually or in combination Statistical analysis revealed significant correlations (p < 0.

Title and authors: Rosa: So we're looking at this paper called "Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions". It’s about how deep learning models, which are really good at segmenting skin lesions from images, can be made more trustworthy by adding uncertainty estimates.

Dev: Right. Basically, the authors are tackling the problem that these deep learning models often just give you an answer without telling you how sure they are about it. They’re introducing ways to get pixel-by-pixel uncertainty and then linking that uncertainty to how well the model actually performs, using things like Dice scores.

Taro: So, it's not just about getting a segmentation mask; it’s about understanding the confidence level at every single point in that image. That means if a model is unsure about a spot, we know we need to pay extra attention there.

Rosa: Exactly. The paper reports two different deep learning models they trained: one trained completely from scratch and another using transfer learning, and they used two different ways to estimate uncertainty: Monte Carlo dropout and Bayes-by-backprop.

Dev: And then they didn't just stop there; they developed a new approach for computing these pixel-by-pixel uncertainty estimates across multiple clinical regions using just one dermatoscopy image, along with the corresponding Dice scores. That’s pretty specific, tying the uncertainty directly to where you look on the skin.

Taro: I’m curious about how this relates to real-world deployment. If we can see where a model is uncertain at a pixel level, that tells us exactly which areas need human review before making a diagnosis for a patient.

Rosa: That’s the core idea there. They show that these image-level uncertainty maps actually line up with areas where the deep learning segmentation was imperfect, whether there were lesions or not present in those specific skin tissue regions.

Dev: And they build on that by creating four new linear regression models to predict how well the deep learning model performs using constants and these uncertainty measures. These models look at things like lesion presence, tissue structures, and even non-tissue pixel regions, which is critical for making a diagnosis or prognostication in skin images.

Taro: So they’re not just measuring accuracy; they’re trying to predict the Dice performance itself based on where the model is uncertain across different parts of the image. That seems like it could guide how we trust these tools clinically.

Rosa: It’s about moving from a single overall score to a much more detailed picture of performance, which is what this paper, "Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions," aims to do.

Dev: And the methodology involves training these models using both transfer learning and training from scratch with Monte Carlo dropout or Bayes-by-backprop uncertainty estimations. They used a Bayesian VGG-UNet CNN trained on skin lesion images, integrating both MCD and BBP techniques to mitigate noise during the downscaling phase.

Taro: So they’re testing the robustness of these models by seeing how they perform when you use different training strategies and different uncertainty estimation techniques side by side.

Rosa: They trained these deep learning models for fifty epochs, using a batch size of two and the Adam optimizer with a learning rate set at zero point zero zero one. The input images were resized to six hundred eight times four hundred sixteen in width times height, with the outputs being three hundred four times two hundred eight.

Dev: And for quantifying that uncertainty, they used Monte Carlo dropout, which they called DLM MCD, and Bayes-by-backprop, or DLM Bc. For every model prediction they made, they ran fifty Monte Carlo iterations where the difference between the sixty-seventh and thirty-third percentiles of their sigmoid values from the predictions were set as uncertainty estimates.

Taro: So these uncertainty maps are basically heatmaps showing where the model is most uncertain, calculated by taking that sixth seventy percentiles minus that thirty-third percentiles from those Monte Carlo samples.

Rosa: That’s right. They then create a final model output, which they call OMi, and a corresponding uncertainty map called Uncmapi, using the calculation P67 of the unmapped predictions minus P33 of the unmapped predictions across all iterations alpha equals one.

Dev: The performance analysis part is where things get interesting because they train four separate linear models to learn how Dice scores correspond to these uncertainty measures from two clinical Regions of Interest, either looking at them individually or in combination.

Taro: That sounds like they are trying to build a predictive layer on top of the segmentation that uses the uncertainty map as an input feature alongside the lesion and tissue structure information.

The paper's summary: Rosa: So, we’re looking at this paper that builds a framework to quantify how much confidence a deep learning model has when it segments skin cancer lesions from images.

Dev: Right, so instead of just getting a picture of the lesion, they are getting a map showing where the model is unsure and why.

Rosa: They train two different types of deep learning models—one trained entirely from scratch and one using transfer learning—and they use Monte Carlo dropout or Bayes by backprop to get those uncertainty estimates.

Dev: That uncertainty estimate is pixel-by-pixel, so we can see exactly where the AI is struggling, whether it’s a lesion or just some normal skin tissue.

Rosa: And then they take this pixel-level uncertainty and use it to train four separate linear regression models to predict how good the overall segmentation score—the Dice score—will be.

Dev: That means they are linking where the model is uncertain across different areas, like lesions versus non-lesion tissue, directly to its performance prediction.

Rosa: So a person listening just needs to know that this new framework lets them see the confidence map alongside the segmentation mask and use those maps to predict performance based on image features.

Dev: It’s about moving beyond a single accuracy number and getting a detailed picture of model reliability across different clinical regions in one image.

Rosa: The implication here is that clinicians could use these uncertainty maps to guide their review, focusing their attention on the areas where the AI is least sure, which could be really helpful for safety cases.

Dev: It also lets us test those different training methods, like training from scratch versus transfer learning with dropout layers, and see which one gives a more reliable uncertainty map for specific tasks.

Rosa: So what we’re seeing here is a way to get an objective measure of the model's reliability without needing massive amounts of new validation data for every single prediction.

Dev: It’s about building a system that doesn't just segment, but also predicts its own performance based on where it has doubts across all the different parts of the image.

Rosa: This leads us to think about how this framework could be integrated into real-time clinical decision support systems, helping doctors make faster, more informed choices in dermatology.

The paper's improvements: Rosa: So we’re looking at how this paper suggests improving their framework by using those uncertainty maps to predict performance using linear regression models in a more complex way.

Dev: It's about taking that pixel uncertainty and combining it with other features like lesion presence and tissue structures to make a better prediction of the final Dice score.

Rosa: They’re suggesting these new linear models can be used individually or together to learn the relationship between those uncertainty measures and the actual segmentation accuracy.

Dev: That means if we know where a model is uncertain in relation to where a lesion is, we can get a more accurate forecast of how well it will segment that specific area.

Rosa: They are also proposing an approach where they generate ROI-based uncertainty maps by correlating that uncertainty with the Dice scores using equation three, which looks at all regions at once.

Dev: So instead of looking at one spot in isolation, you get a map showing the performance based on how uncertain the model is across different zones simultaneously.

Rosa: This whole thing allows for estimating model performance unsupervised by generating those uncertainty maps and mean uncertainty values through algorithm one, which lets you get those ROI-based estimates directly.

Dev: It’s about creating a system that gives you predicted Dice scores based on where the model is uncertain, which can then inform real-world clinical decisions in the skin imaging setting.

Rosa: The authors also tested different training strategies and found that training from scratch with dropout layers showed higher uncertainty in lesion regions compared to using Bayes by backprop.

Dev: That comparison is important because it tells us whether we should prioritize pure accuracy or a model that is more aware of its own doubts when we choose our training approach.

Rosa: So these improvements focus on making the uncertainty estimates actionable, turning them from just diagnostic tools into predictive metrics for performance across different image regions.

Dev: It’s about moving the analysis beyond just measuring what the model did wrong to predicting what it might do better in specific clinical contexts.

Rosa: This whole process is really about creating a more robust way to trust these deep learning models by giving us a quantified understanding of their performance limits in real skin images.

Conclusion: Dev: So we’re wrapping up on this paper, "Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions". We looked at how they quantified uncertainty using Monte Carlo dropout and Bayes by backprop across training strategies.

Rosa: Right, they showed how linking that pixel-level uncertainty to prediction performance using four linear regression models gives us a way to predict Dice scores based on lesion structure and tissue regions.

Dev: Essentially, this framework lets us see where the AI is shaky and use that information to predict its overall performance in a clinical setting without needing massive new datasets for every single test.

Taro: I’m interested in how training from scratch versus transfer learning showed different uncertainty patterns, especially with dropout layers influencing the results.

Rosa: That comparison is important because it gives us a hint on whether we should prioritize pure accuracy or a model that is more aware of its own doubts when we choose our training approach for skin lesions.

Dev: It’s about building something that doesn't just output an answer but outputs the reliability behind that answer across different clinical regions in one image.

Taro: If this framework works well outside the lab, it opens up possibilities for how we test autonomous systems in real-world, messy environments like a clinic.

Rosa: It certainly does; I’m curious to see how these uncertainty maps hold up when the world misbehaves, because that’s where field robotics usually gets tricky.

Dev: We need to keep watching those failure modes, especially since the system is designed for real-time loops, and this analysis helps define what a safe operational boundary looks like.

Taro: Exactly; understanding where the model fails gracefully is key when we are designing systems that have to recover in unexpected situations.

Rosa: So, to sum up, this paper gives us a solid way to quantify how much we can trust these deep learning models for skin cancer segmentation using uncertainty measures and performance regression.

Dev: It's about making the AI output more than just an image; it’s about giving us a performance prediction tied directly to the model’s confidence across different tissue types.

Taro: This gives researchers a tool to guide future training choices based on where uncertainty naturally arises in lesion versus background pixels.

Rosa: That’s the core idea behind this framework, "Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions".

Dev: We’ll be keeping an eye on how these predictions scale when we apply them to larger datasets in the next papers we review.

University of California Irvine · University of California Irvine

eess.IV, cs.CV

Submitted: 2024-12-28

Updated: 2024-12-28

Comments: Presented at the 2024 IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning and Applications (ICMLA), accepted for publication and in press by IEEE

Journal ref: 2024 23rd International Conference on Machine Learning and Applications (ICMLA), IEEE, pp. 546-553, 2024

DOI: 10.1109/ICMLA61862.2024.00080

Project page: https://www.isic-archive.com/#

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Deep learning models (DLMs) lacking feedback on their image segmentation mechanisms such as Dice coefficients and confidence in their performance face challenges processing previously unseen images…

Key concepts

Monte Carlo Dropout (MCD)
MCD is a technique where dropout layers are kept active during inference by running the model multiple times with different random dropout masks. By comparing the predictions from these runs, researchers can estimate uncertainty at each pixel, helping to quantify how confident the model is in its segmentation.
Bayes-by-backprop (BBP)
BBP is another method used to estimate uncertainty by treating the model's weights as random variables. It involves running a backward pass through the network multiple times with different weight samples. The resulting variance in predictions provides a measure of how uncertain the model is about its classification or segmentation at any given point.
Uncertainty Map (Uncmapi)
An uncertainty map is a visual representation generated by comparing the 67th and 33rd percentiles of the sigmoid output values from the DLM predictions. This map shows areas where the model's prediction is most uncertain, which often corresponds to regions with complex or ambiguous features in skin lesions.
Linear Regression Models
These are statistical models trained to predict a deep learning model's segmentation performance (like Dice scores). They use constants and uncertainty measures derived from different image regions—lesions, tissue structures, and non-tissue pixels—to help predict how well the DLM is expected to perform in a clinical context.

Terminology

Summary

Deep learning models (DLMs) lacking feedback on their image segmentation mechanisms such as Dice coefficients and confidence in their performance face challenges processing previously unseen images in real-world clinical settings This study reports two DLMs, one trained from scratch and another based on transfer learning, with Monte Carlo dropout or Bayesby-backprop uncertainty estimations to segment lesions from the publicly available The International Skin Imaging Collaboration dermoscopy image database with lesions of cancer A novel approach to compute pixel-by-pixel uncertainty estimations of DLM segmentation performance in multiple clinical regions from a single dermatoscopy image with corresponding Dice scores is reported for the first time Image-level uncertainty maps demonstrated correspondence between imperfect DLM segmentation and high uncertainty levels in specific skin tissue regions with or without lesions Four new linear regression models that can predict the Dice performance of DLM segmentation using constants and uncertainty measures either individually or in combination from lesions, tissue structures, and non-tissue pixels regions critical for clinical diagnosis and prognostication in skin images are reported for the first time

Model Training Strategies

The study evaluates performance by training multiple DNNs using both Monte Carlo dropout (MCD) and Bayes-by-backprop (BBP) techniques with training from scratch (TFS) and transfer learning (TL) approaches for segmentation of melanoma, melanocytic nevus, and seborrheic keratosis skin conditions The Bayesian VGG-UNet CNN was trained on skin lesion images and their labels, integrating MCD and BBP techniques to mitigate noise during the downscaling phase All DLMs were trained for 50 epochs with a batch size of two using the Adam optimizer and a learning rate of (αlr = 0.001) Input images were resized to 608 × 416 (width × height), with outputs at 304 × 208, and training was done on an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 Ti with 32GB of GPU memory

Uncertainty Quantification Methods

To obtain pixel-level uncertainty, the study utilized Monte Carlo dropout (DLM MCD) and Bayes-by-backprop (DLM Bc) For each model prediction, 50 MC iterations were taken where the difference between 67th and 33rd percentiles of their sigmoid values from the DLMs predictions were set as uncertainty estimates and represented as heatmaps The final model output, OMi = [OMp1 s.t ∀ pixels, p in OMp1, (p > 0. p. 295) =⇒ (p = 1) and (p ≤ 0.95) =⇒ (p = 0)] The corresponding uncertainty map was obtained by Uncmapi = P67([Uncj Mp] α j=1) − P33([Uncj Mp] α j=1)

Performance Analysis and Correlation

The performance of the proposed Algorithm 1 is assessed by training four separate linear models to learn the correspondence between Dice scores and uncertainty measures from two clinical ROIs, either individually or in combination Statistical analysis revealed significant correlations (p < 0.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Uncertainty Quantified Deep Learning and Regression Analysis Framework for Image Segmentation of Skin Cancer Lesions can enhance trust by providing pixel-by-pixel uncertainty estimates, allowing clinicians to review predictions at a cellular or single-pixel level.

  2. The system can predict Deep Learning Model (DLM) performance using linear regression models that incorporate constants and uncertainty measures from lesions, tissue structures, and non-tissue pixels critical for clinical diagnosis and prognostication in skin images.

  3. The improved AI system can generate ROI-based uncertainty maps by correlating uncertainty with Dice scores using Equation 3, which predicts performance based on all regions simultaneously, identifying regions contributing to greater uncertainty and poorer performance.

  4. The system can estimate model performance unsupervised by generating uncertainty maps and mean uncertainty values through Algorithm 1, allowing clinical ROI-based uncertainty estimates and predicted Dice scores to inform real-world clinical decisions.

  5. The AI can distinguish between the strengths of different DLM training approaches, such as TFS with dropout layers showing higher uncertainty in lesion regions compared to DLM Bc models, guiding the choice between accuracy and uncertainty awareness for specific tasks.

Sources

Related papers