Production of eta b in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Production of eta b in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a calculation of the production cross section for the ηb meson through photon-photon interactions in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions at LHC energies, utilizing previously computed lattice QCD results for its decay width to provide a prediction that can be tested experimentally Formalism and Cross Section Calculation The total cross section for the production of ηb in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions is factorized in terms of the equivalent photon flux of each nucleus and the photoproduction cross section, as shown in equation (1) The total cross section can be rewritten as a function of the invariant mass W and rapidity Y through equations (3).
Kai: The photoproduction cross section for the ηb due to the fusion of two photons is expressed using the two-photon decay width as shown in equation (4).
Mira: The decay rate for ηb → γγ was calculated in Ref.
7: using lattice QCD and was found to be Γ(ηb → γγ) = 0.557(32)(1) keV.
Paper summary: Kai: So to summarize "Production of eta b in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions," the paper's main goal is to calculate how often you can produce an eta b meson when lead nuclei collide in an ultra-peripheral way at LHC energies. They use a calculation based on photon-photon interactions and they are using a previously computed lattice QCD result for the decay width of the eta b meson.
Mira: The thesis here is that by plugging this new lattice QCD decay width into their cross section formula, they can provide a prediction for the production cross section in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions that can be tested experimentally. It’s essentially applying a theoretical result from quantum chromodynamics to an experimental setup at the LHC.
Lev: I'd add that the paper is also focused on being comprehensive about how you model those photon fluxes, looking at three distinct ways to define ultra-peripheral collisions and different ways to treat the equivalent photon flux. This shows they aren't just sticking to one simple model for everything.
Kai: Right, so they are mapping out the theoretical landscape for this calculation by testing those different definitions of an ultra-peripheral collision and how you handle the photon flux modeling. They are showing that even with these different ways to define things, the results stay very close together.
Mira: This matters because it shows robustness in their prediction. When you have a prediction, you want to know if it holds up regardless of whether you use one particular theoretical framework for setting up the initial state of the collision.
Lev: From an engineering viewpoint, that means if we build detectors based on one definition of UPCs, we should be okay even if there's some uncertainty in the modeling, as long as those uncertainties don't blow up the final number too much.
Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about "Production of eta b in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions" and the authors, the main implication is that we now have a refined theoretical prediction for this specific meson production rate based on lattice QCD input. This gives experimentalists a concrete number to look for at the LHC.
Mira: It moves us closer to testing these predictions because they've done the heavy lifting of combining a new fundamental calculation with the experimental environment setup, specifically by systematically comparing those different collision definitions. It’s about making sure our theoretical input is as sound as possible before we rely on it for interpretation.
Lev: For me, what this means practically is that if we can get experimental data that matches this predicted cross section of zero point five two to zero point five four microbarns, it gives us a strong validation of the underlying lattice QCD input and our understanding of how these particles behave in high-energy heavy ion environments <ref:2412.18567#pg3>.
Kai: So, to wrap up, the key thing here is that they've updated this estimate for the eta b production cross section in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions at five point zero two teraelectronvolts per nucleon pair. It’s a more refined number than before.
Mira: And they highlighted how much it depended on that lattice QCD decay width, which was about zero point five five keV, which is significantly different from the older assumed value of about zero point four one keV <ref:2412.18567#pg3>. That difference shows how sensitive the prediction is to those fundamental inputs.
C.N. Azevedo, F.C. Sobrinho, F.S. Navarra
Instituto de Fdzsica, Universidade de S£ao Paulo
hep-ph
Submitted: 2024-12-24
Updated: 2024-12-24
Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 112, 064908 (2025)
DOI: 10.1103/196s-xxkw
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 78/100
The gist: The paper presents a calculation of the production cross section for the ηb meson through photon-photon interactions in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions at LHC energies…
Key concepts
- Photon-Photon Interaction
- This process describes how two photons from the colliding lead nuclei interact to create a particle, in this case, an ηb meson. The probability of this interaction depends on the energy of the photons and how they are distributed within the nucleus.
- Ultra-Peripheral Collision (UPC)
- An UPC is a specific type of heavy-ion collision where two nuclei pass close enough to each other that they interact primarily through their electromagnetic fields, without significant overlap or hadronic interactions. The paper explores three different ways to define this condition: by geometry, by including survival probability, and by kinematic constraints.
- Lattice QCD Decay Width
- This is a value for how quickly the ηb meson decays into two photons (ηb -> γγ), calculated using mathematical simulations based on Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) on a lattice. The paper used this new value to improve the prediction of the total production cross section.
- Equivalent Photon Flux
- This concept models the number and energy of photons that each nucleus effectively acts like during a collision. The calculation uses form factors, which describe how the charge distribution of the lead nucleus affects how these equivalent photons are distributed in space and energy.
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents a calculation of the production cross section for the ηb meson through photon-photon interactions in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions at LHC energies, utilizing previously computed lattice QCD results for its decay width to provide a prediction that can be tested experimentally
Formalism and Cross Section Calculation
The total cross section for the production of ηb in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions is factorized in terms of the equivalent photon flux of each nucleus and the photoproduction cross section, as shown in equation (1) The total cross section can be rewritten as a function of the invariant mass W and rapidity Y through equations (3). The photoproduction cross section for the ηb due to the fusion of two photons is expressed using the two-photon decay width as shown in equation (4). p. 1 cross section, as follows:
σ(P bP b → P b ⊗ ηb ⊗ P b; s) = Z
σˆ(γγ → ηb; W) N(ω1, b1) N(ω2, b2) S
2
abs(b) d2b1 d
2b2 dω1 dω2 , (1)
where √
s is the center-of-mass energy for the collision P bP b, ⊗ characterizes a rapidity gap in the final state,
W =
√
4ω1ω2 is the invariant mass of the γγ system, and ˆσ(γγ → ηb) is the photoproduction cross section of the
ηb due to the fusion of two photons. Moreover, ωi
is the energy of the photon emitted by nucleus Ai at an impact
parameter, or distance, bi from Ai
. (3)
Using the Low formula [9], we can express the cross section for the photon-photon interaction producing the pseudoscalar meson in terms of the two-photon decay width as follows:
σˆγγ→ηb
(ω1, ω2) = 8π
2
(2J + 1) Γηb→γγ
Mηb
δ(4ω1ω2 − M2
ηb
), (4)
where Mηb
and J are the mass and spin of the produced ηb respectively. The decay rate for ηb → γγ was calculated
in Ref. The decay rate for ηb → γγ was calculated
in Ref. [7] using lattice QCD and was found to be Γ(ηb → γγ) = 0. [7] using lattice QCD and was found to be Γ(ηb → γγ) = 0. 557(32)(1) keV.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Equivalent Photon Flux Modeling
The equivalent photon flux N(ω, b) of photons with energy ω at a transverse distance b from the center of the nucleus is expressed in terms of the charge form factor F(q), as given in equation (5). For a nucleus-nucleus collision, the realistic form factor is obtained as a Fourier transform of the nuclear charge density and is analytically expressed by equation (6). p. 1 1
u
2 + (b ω/γ)
2
du#2
(5)
where α = e
2/(4 π), J1 is the Bessel function of the first kind and γ is the Lorentz factor of the photon source
(γ =
√
s/2mp and mp is the proton mass). In the case of a nucleus-nucleus collision, the realistic form factor is
obtained as a Fourier transform of the nuclear charge density, and is analytically expressed by:
F(q
2
) = 4 π
A q3
ρ0[sin(q R) − q R cos(q R)]
1
1 + q
2 a
2
, (6) 1604/A fm−3
obtained for the lead nucleus [10, 11]. A simpler form
factor, often used in the literature, is of the monopole type, given by
F(q
2
) = Λ
2
Λ2 + q
2
, with ΛP b = 0. Introducing the
monopole form factor into (5), we obtain the following expression for the photon flux
N(ω, b) = Z
2α
π
2ω
"
ω
γ
K1
bω
γ
−
s
ω2
γ
2
+ Λ2
K1
b
s
ω2
γ
2
+ Λ2
! (8)
On the other hand, assuming a point-like form factor (F = 1), the photon flux takes the following form
N(ω, b) = Z
2α
π
2ωb2
ωb
γ
2
K2
1
ωb
γ
+
1
γ
2 K2
0
ωb
γ
, (9)
where K0 and K1 are the modified Bessel functions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Defining Ultra-Peripheral Collisions
The practical definition of an ultra-peripheral collision involves considering three different ways to define the collision, which are related through a Fourier transform. These definitions include:
-
Pure geometry, where the absorptive factor is defined as S 2abs(b) = Θ(b − R1 − R2). p. 2
Where the paper says it
On the practical definition of an ultra-peripheral collision 1. Pure geometry The factor S 2 abs(b) in (1) depends on the impact parameter of the collision and is denoted the absorptive factor, which excludes the overlap between the colliding nuclei and selects only ultra-peripheral collisions.
-
Geometry + dynamics, which uses the survival factor PNH(b) to account for the probability of no additional hadronic interaction, expressed as S 2abs(b) = 1 - PH(b). p. 3
Where the paper says it
Geometry + dynamics A more realistic treatment can be obtained using the survival factor PNH(b) that describes the probability of no additional hadronic interaction between the nuclei, which is usually estimated using the Glauber formalism. In this way we take into account the fact that, even when b & 2R, the probability of having strong interactions is finite.
-
Kinematics, which defines an UPC in terms of a kinematical constraint using the distribution of equivalent photons N(q), leading to the equivalent photon energy spectrum N(ω) (equation 14). p. 3
Where the paper says it
The distribution of equivalent photons generated by a moving particle with the charge Ze is [1, 2, 4]: N(q) = Z 2α π 2 (q⊥) 2 ω q4 = Z 2α π 2ω (q⊥) 2 ((q⊥) 2 + (ω/γ) 2) 2 , (13) where q is the photon 4-momentum, q⊥ is its transverse component, ω is the photon energy. To obtain the equivalent photon spectrum, one has to integrate this expression over the transverse momentum up to some value ˆq.
Results and Comparison
The predictions for the energy dependence of the total cross section for ηb production in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions are presented in Fig. 3a. The rapidity distribution of ηb produced at √s = 5. p. 4 For comparison, we also include the predictions for the production of ηc. 3b we show the rapidity distribution of ηb produced in P bP b collisions at √
s = 5. Having shown the energy dependence, let us focus on √
s = 5. 02 TeV, which is the most interesting case and
where we may have data. For all absorption factors, the pointlike and monopole form factors set, respectively, the lower
and upper limit of the cross section. The results obtained with the realistic form factor (6) lie in between. The results obtained with the realistic form factor (6) lie in between. Since the
predictions obtained with the geometric and geometric+dynamic absorption factor nearly coincide, we can say that
the most likely value of the cross section is 0. Since the
predictions obtained with the geometric and geometric+dynamic absorption factor nearly coincide, we can say that
the most likely value of the cross section is 0. 54 microbarns. The least known ingredient
was Γ(ηb → γγ) and in the quoted previous works it was assumed to be ≃ 0. The lattice QCD value is ≃ 0. p. 4 The least known ingredient
was Γ(ηb → γγ) and in the quoted previous works it was assumed to be ≃ 0. The lattice QCD value is ≃ 0. Finally, it is reassuring to observe the three central lines in Fig. 4 and realize that the three ways to
define an UPC lead to very similar results.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Improvements
The two main improvements in this work were the introduction of a very recently calculated value of Γ(ηb → γγ) and also the systematic comparison of different prescriptions to treat the absorptive effects. The obtained values of the ηb production cross section are larger than previous ones but within the same order of magnitude. p. 4 The two main improvements were the introduction of a very recently calculated
value of Γ(ηb → γγ) and also the systematic comparison of different prescriptions to treat the absorptive effects. The
obtained values of the ηb production cross section are larger than the previous ones but within the same order of
magnitude. The latter present a larger uncertainty. Taken together, these numbers
show a nice convergence to the value of the cross section mentioned above, which is in principle large enough to be
observed. Comparing the results shown in Table I and Table II we see that they are consistent. The least known ingredient
was Γ(ηb → γγ) and in the quoted previous works it was assumed to be ≃ 0. The lattice QCD value is ≃ 0. 34 % larger and approximately so are the corresponding cross sections. 34 % larger and approximately so are the corresponding cross sections. To summarize, we have updated the estimate of the ηb production cross section in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions
at √
s = 5. To summarize, we have updated the estimate of the ηb production cross section in ultra-peripheral Pb Pb collisions
at √
s = 5. 02 TeV per nucleon pair.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced Cross Section Prediction for Ultra-Peripheral Collisions: The improved system can calculate ηb production cross sections in PbPb collisions at 5.02 TeV using multiple formalisms, including pure geometry (S2abs(b) = Θ(b - R1 - R2)), geometry plus dynamics (S2abs(b) = PNH(b)), and kinematic constraints (using the photon flux N(ω)). This allows for a systematic comparison of different definitions of ultra-peripheral collisions.
-
Incorporation of Lattice QCD Decay Width: The system can utilize the recently calculated lattice QCD decay width, Γ(ηb → γγ) = 0.557(32) keV, to update cross section estimates compared to previous literature values (e.g., assuming 0.41 keV). This leads to an updated estimate of the ηb production cross section that is approximately 34% larger than previous results, showing improved precision in theoretical predictions.
-
Sensitivity Analysis on Photon Flux Modeling: The system can perform a sensitivity analysis by varying the parameter q hat in the photon flux expression N(ω) across different values (0.014 GeV, 0.020 GeV, 0.028 GeV). This demonstrates that while the three definitions of an UPC lead to very similar results, the choice of q hat affects uncertainty and provides a more robust prediction framework for unobserved processes.
Abstract
Very recently, the two-photon decay width of the η b meson was computed with lattice QCD methods. This decay has not yet been measured. The knowledge of this width allows for the calculation of the η b production cross section through photon-photon interactions in ultra-peripheral PbPb collisions. In this work we present this calculation, which is the first application of the lattice result. Since UPCs are gaining an increasing attention of the heavy ion community, we take the opportunity to perform a comprehensive study of the different ways of defining ultra-peripheral collisions and of the different ways to treat the equivalent photon flux.
Sources
- Precise prediction of the decay rate for $\eta_b\to \gamma \gamma$ from lattice QCD
- Equivalent photons in proton-proton and ion-ion collisions at the LHC
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses