Transfer Learning for High-dimensional Quantile Regression with Distribution Shift
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Statistics. The day in statistics: methods, theory and the inference under them.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Transfer Learning for High-dimensional Quantile Regression with Distribution Shift".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Information from related source studies can often enhance the findings of a target study.
Tom: In this paper, we focus on the high-dimensional quantile regression with knowledge transfer under three types of distribution shift: parameter shift, covariate shift, and residual shift.
Jane: We propose a novel transferable set and a new transfer framework to address the above three discrepancies.
Tom: The Problem of Distribution Shift in Transfer Learning The core issue addressed is how to identify the transferable information from different source studies under distribution (covariate/parameter/residual) shift.
Paper summary: Tom: So to wrap up this discussion on "Transfer Learning for High-dimensional Quantile Regression with Distribution Shift," the authors developed a framework that explicitly addresses parameter shift, covariate shift, and residual shift simultaneously through their novel transferable set and transfer framework <ref:2411.19933#pg1>.
Jane: And what does that mean in plain terms? It means they've created a method where you can transfer knowledge between different studies without having to worry if the source data is shifted in three distinct ways: parameter, covariate, or residual shift.
Lu: They are essentially providing a set of criteria for selecting which source studies are actually good candidates for transfer based on how well their parameters match and how informative they are at the quantile level <ref:2411.19933#pg2>.
Meng: And for deployment, it means they have a method that can be robust enough to handle real data shifts without needing excessive manual adjustment from us on every single source study Practical Implementation Details.
Tom: The authors show that their proposed metric, n k expected value of f k zero given x k zero equals h two serves as the crucial measure for controlling residual shift, which is what really makes their method work well against the oracle benchmark Conclusion on Transferability.
Jane: So, in a nutshell, it means they've built a robust system for transferring knowledge that checks if the source study is good enough to use before you actually try to apply it Conclusion on Transferability.
Conclusion: Tom: So we're wrapping up this paper on high-dimensional quantile regression and distribution shift by looking at who wrote it and what it actually means for us.
Jane: Okay, so the authors are tackling three kinds of shift: parameter, covariate, and residual shift, right?
Tom: Exactly. They’re proposing a new way to select which source studies are useful—a transferable set—and a transfer framework to handle all those shifts at once. It sounds like they've built a system that can pull reliable information from different datasets even when those datasets are messy.
Lu: What's really interesting is how they define that transferable set, Ch. It looks like it balances parameter similarity with the information quality at the specific quantile we care about, which is called the tau quantile.
Meng: So, if a source study has wildly different parameters or isn't informative enough at that target quantile, this new set filters it out before we even try to use it for training. That makes sense for production because you don't want garbage data feeding your model.
Jane: It’s about filtering the noise upfront so the estimation process is cleaner. Tom, what does this actually change for us when we think about applying this in a real-world setting?
Tom: Well, they show that their proposed method performs almost as well as the best existing benchmark—the oracle—when tested under tough covariate shifts and t-distributions. That's a big deal because it means our models can be more reliable when the data doesn't look exactly like what we trained on.
Lalam: I can confirm that their metric for controlling residual shift, that n k expected value of f k zero given x k zero, is the key piece that proves this works across all those shift types.
Tom: And they also get a sharp statistical inference method called debiasing with Neyman orthogonality. That means when we try to pull out the final coefficient estimate from our model, it has much tighter bounds than what we used to get.
Jane: So the big picture is that this isn't just about getting a better prediction; it’s about making our confidence in those predictions much stronger when things get complicated in the real world. We need to see how they handle those residual shifts specifically next.
Ruiqi Bai, Yijiao Zhang, Hanbo Yang, Zhongyi Zhu
Fudan University · University of Pennsylvania · University of Science and Technology of China
stat.ME, math.ST, stat.ML, stat.TH
Submitted: 2024-11-29
Updated: 2026-11-16
Comments: 63 pages
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Information from related source studies can often enhance the findings of a target study.
Key concepts
- Distribution Shift
- This refers to differences between the source data used for training and the target data being tested. It can happen in three ways: parameter shift (different true values), covariate shift (different input features), or residual shift (differences in how errors are distributed). Ignoring this can cause poor results.
- Transferable Set Ch
- This is a specially designed set of source studies used to select the most useful information. It filters out sources that have too large parameter differences or insufficient information at a specific quantile, ensuring only high-quality, relevant data is transferred.
- Orthogonal Debiasing
- This statistical technique uses Neyman orthogonality to correct for errors in the estimation process. It makes the final estimator immune to first-order errors from the nuisance estimator, leading to sharper asymptotic rates and more reliable results under distribution shift.
Terminology
Summary
Information from related source studies can often enhance the findings of a target study. p. 0 In this paper, we focus on the high-dimensional quantile regression with knowledge transfer under three types of distribution shift: parameter shift, covariate shift, and residual shift. p. 0 We propose a novel transferable set and a new transfer framework to address the above three discrepancies. p. 0
The Problem of Distribution Shift in Transfer Learning
The core issue addressed is how to identify the transferable information from different source studies under distribution (covariate/parameter/residual) shift. The paper identifies three types of distribution shift between target and source domains: 1) parameter shift, 2) residual shift, and 3) covariate shift. p. 2 Blindly transferring sources under distribution shift may lead to negative transfer. p. 2 Specifically, residual shift is characterized by the difference in conditional distributions of model residuals P(ϵ(0)ix(0)i) and P(ϵ(k)ix(k)i), i. p. 2e., the conditional distributions of model residuals differ. p. 2
A Novel Transferable Set for Shift Detection
The authors introduce a novel transferable set Ch designed to simultaneously account for parameter and residual shift. This set is defined as Ch = (k: 1 ≤ k ≤ K, δ(k) 1 ≤ h1, n0E[f(0)(0x(0)i)]nkE[f(k)(0x(k)i)] ≤ h2). p. 3 The term δ(k) 1 reflects parameter similarity, while the term nkE[f(k)(0x(k)i)] captures the information quality around the objective quantile. p. 7 This set is designed to filter out source studies with large parameter discrepancies or limited information at the τ-th quantile. p. 4
The Transfer Framework and Estimation Error Bounds
A comprehensive transfer learning framework is developed to address parameter/covariate/residual shift concurrently for high-dimensional quantile regression. The authors establish non-asymptotic upper error bounds for their transfer estimators, broadening existing results to account for residual shift in addition to parameter shift. p. 4 The resulting error bounds contain two parts: the first part can be seen as the inherent estimation error from residual shift, and the second part represents the bias term involving each contrast δ(k) 1 from parameter shift. p. 4
Statistical Inference with Orthogonal Debiasing
A debiased transfer approach based on Neyman orthogonality is proposed for statistical inference on quantile coefficients, which is the first to debias on informative sources to enhance inference efficiency under distribution shift. This approach leads to sharper asymptotic rates than existing results with √n0-normality. p. 4 The resulting estimator αb enjoys √nC-normality, which is much sharper than the previous results, demonstrating the effectiveness of their debiased transfer methods. p. 0
Empirical Validation and Application
Extensive simulation results and real data applications further demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed procedure. In simulations under strong covariate shift and t-distribution, the proposed TransQR method performs almost as well as the oracle benchmark in parameter estimation, whereas the two-step approach exhibits noticeably higher l2-error. p. 0 In a real data application to Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) dataset, TransQR achieves the lowest prediction errors in almost every tissue for both genes. p. 4 The results confirm that their proposed metric nkE[f(k)(0x(k)i)] serves as a crucial measure for controlling residual shift. p. 0
Generalization and Future Directions
Several avenues to generalize their method are discussed, including constructing source weights proportional to their respective τ-th densities to enhance efficiency. They also suggest generalizing the all-in-or-all-out source selection manner to select partial informative samples from each source study. p. 5 Finally, their algorithm can be easily generalized to the communication-efficient version with multiple data storage nodes. p. 2 Distributionally robust optimization may also be generalized to transfer learning to select source domains more effectively. p. 2
Algorithm Summary
The paper summarizes the entire procedure in Algorithm 1, which involves computing an initial estimate βe, obtaining contrast estimators δe(k), and then solving the pooled l1-QR problem to determine βb. The inference procedure is summarized in Algorithm 2, which uses the detected transferable set Cb to obtain the debiased estimator αb. p. 2 The iterative algorithm for solving the constrained l1-minimization problem (3) is summarized in Algorithm 3. p. 8 The quality control procedure for Algorithm 2 is outlined in Algorithm 4. p. 4 The final inference procedure for the objective component β∗ 1 is summarized in Algorithm 2. p. 8 The entire process is summarized in Algorithm 2. p. 8
Discussion on Inference Quality Control
The quality control procedure for Algorithm 4 involves a pre-control step to remove studies with non-negligible parameter contrast or large δe(k)1, followed by a post-control normality test using quantile bootstrap. If the normality hypothesis is rejected, the method reverts to debiasing only on the target study. p. 3 This suggests that debiasing on source studies can generate unreliable estimates when δ(k)1 is large. p. 4
Inference Performance Under Shift
The inference performance under strong covariate shift and t-distribution shows that the Debias trans performs better than the target debiasing methods, with coverage probabilities closest to 0.95 among all methods. p. 3 The density plots show that the transfer debiased estimate is no longer normal, and the Shapiro-Wilk test rejects the normality hypothesis. p. 4 This indicates that debiasing on source studies will generate unreliable estimates when δ(k)1 is large. p. 4
Conclusion on Transferability
The superior performance of the Oracle confirms that their proposed metric nkE[f(k)(0x(k)i)] serves as a crucial measure for controlling residual shift. p. 3 The paper concludes that their proposed method, TransQR, performs almost identically to the oracle benchmark, demonstrating the effectiveness of their transferable set detection under distribution shift. p. 0
References
[2] Belloni, A. and Chernozhukov, V. (2011). l1-penalized quantile regression in highdimensional sparse models. p. 2 [46] Zhang, Y. p. 0 and Zhu, Z. p. 0 (2025). Transfer learning for high-dimensional quantile regression via convolution smoothing. p. 0 [5] Cai, T. T. and Pu, H. (2024). Transfer learning for nonparametric regression: Nonasymptotic minimax analysis and adaptive procedure. p. 2 [6] Cai, T. T. and Wei, H. (2021). Transfer learning for nonparametric classification: Minimax rate and adaptive classifier. p. 2 [7] Chen, L., Zaharia, M., and Zou, J. Y. (2024). Estimating and explaining model performance when both covariates and labels shift. p. 9 [8] Chen, X., Liu, W., Mao, X., and Yang, Z. p. 0 (2024). Distributed high-dimensional regression under a quantile loss function. p. 2 [9] Dai, R. and Kolar, M. (2025). Inference for high-dimensional varying-coefficient quantile regression. p. 2 [10] Dong, Y., Zhang, J. p. 0, Xie, S., Di, S., Fan, B., and Gong, T. (2025). JAM2 is a prognostic biomarker and inhibits proliferation, metastasis and epithelial–mesenchymal transition in lung adenocarcinoma [10]. [11] Duan, Y. and Wang, K. (2025). Adaptive and robust multi-task learning. p. 2 [12] Fan, J., Guo, Y., and Wang, K. (2025). Communication-efficient accurate statistical estimation. p. 4 [13] Fenoy, E., Edera, A. A., and Stegmayer, G. (2025). Transfer learning in proteins: evaluating novel protein learned representations for bioinformatics tasks. p. 1 [14] Firpo, S., Galvao, A. F., Pinto, C., Poirier, A., and Sanroman, G. (2025). Gmm quantile regression [14]. p. 0 [15] Gao, R. and Kleywegt, A. (2025). Distributionally robust stochastic optimization with wasserstein distance. p. 7 [16] Giessing, A. and Wang, J. (2025). Debiased inference on heterogeneous quantile treatment effects with regression rank scores [46]. p. 4 [17] Hahn, J. (1995). Bootstrapping quantile regression estimators. p. 6 [20] Jiang, X., Jiang, J., and Song, X. (2012). Oracle model selection for nonlinear models based on weighted composite quantile regression [5]. p. 2 [26] Li, S., Cai, T. T., and Li, H. (2024). Transfer learning for high-dimensional linear regression: Prediction, estimation and minimax optimality. p. 2 [27] Li, S., Cai, T. T., and Li, H. (2025). Transfer learning in large-scale gaussian graphical models with false discovery rate control [6]. p. 2 [28] Li, S. and Luedtke, A. (2025). Efficient estimation under data fusion. p. 2 [29] Li, S., Zhang, L. p. 0, Cai, T. T., and Li, H. (2025). Estimation and inference for highdimensional generalized linear models with knowledge transfer [8]. p. 2 [30] McMahan, B., Moore, E., Ramage, D., Hampson, S., and y Arcas, B. A. (2017). Communication-efficient learning of deep networks from decentralized data [8]. p. 0 [36] Tian, Y. and Feng, Y. (2025). Transfer learning under high-dimensional generalized linear models [6]. p. 2 [37] Turki, T., Wei, Z., and Wang, J. T. L. (2017). Transfer learning approaches to improve drug sensitivity prediction in multiple myeloma patients [6]. p. 2 [40] Wang, Z., Dai, Z., Poczos, B., and Carbonell, J. (2025). Characterizing and avoiding negative transfer [40]. p. 2 [41] Wei, S., Moore, R., Zhang, H. p. 0, Xie, Y., and Kamaleswaran, R. (2025). Transfer causal learning: Causal effect estimation with knowledge transfer [41]. p. 2 [42] Xiong, X., Guo, Z., and Cai, T. (2025). Distributionally robust transfer learning [42]. p. 0
How the Training Signal is Built
The training signal for parameter estimation is built by extending the constrained l1-minimization [29] to quantile regression, ensuring robustness in the presence of covariate shift. The authors extend this to jointly estimate the target parameter β∗ and contrast vectors δ(k)k∈Ch using a constrained optimization algorithm. p. 7 This framework allows them to simultaneously estimate β∗ and δ(k)k∈Ch, providing more information for the downstream inference task. p. 8 The iterative algorithm for solving the constrained l1-minimization problem (3) proceeds by iteratively obtaining an initial estimator βb0, computing contrast estimators δbt by l1-QR on refined source datasets, and then solving for βbt in the objective function. p. 8
Where the Gains Come From
The gains come from leveraging informative sources through a novel transferable set Ch. The authors show that incorporating valuable source studies leads to sharper asymptotic rates than existing results with √n0-normality. p. 4 The superior performance of the Oracle confirms that their proposed metric nkE[f(k)(0x(k)i)] serves as a crucial measure for controlling residual shift. The final result is that their proposed method, TransQR, performs almost identically to the oracle benchmark, demonstrating the effectiveness of their transferable set detection under distribution shift. p. 0
Inference Efficiency Under Shift
The statistical inference component uses a novel approach motivated by the Neyman orthogonal idea [2] to make the moment condition immune to first-order error from the nuisance estimator. This technique avoids the computation of precision matrices and frees the identical covariance matrix assumption across studies, which exactly accommodates the circumstance under distribution shift. p. 7 The resulting estimator αb enjoys √nC-normality, which is much sharper than the previous results. p. 4 The asymptotic variance σ 2 C includes v(k)0i that is inversely proportional to the τ-th density f(k)(i), clearly revealing that residual shift may increase the variance and deteriorate the inference efficiency. p. 4
Practical Implementation Details
The practical implementation involves several tuning parameters, including detection thresholds t1 and t2, tuning parameters λk τ and λ(k)θ, bandwidth parameters bk k, and a threshold parameter λ¯ in Algorithm 2. The choice of these hyperparameters is guided by methods such as the lambda-construction idea for tuning the l1-QR parameters. p. 8 Bandwidth parameters bk k are determined using the Powell bandwidth construction. p. 2 The threshold parameters t1 and t2 can be chosen via cross-validation for a target study and several candidate source studies. p. 2 The final quality control procedure involves a quantile pair bootstrap test to check the normality of the debiased estimator. p. 4 The simulation results show that TransQR performs almost identically to the oracle benchmark. p. 0 The final conclusion is that their proposed method, TransQR, performs almost identically to the oracle benchmark. p. 3
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Unified Knowledge Transfer Framework for High-Dimensional Quantile Regression: The improved system can concurrently estimate target parameters, source contrasts, and handle parameter shift, residual shift, and covariate shift by using the novel transferable set Ch defined by oracle transferability levels h1 and h2.
-
Enhanced Source Study Selection: The system can automatically detect informative source studies using Algorithm 1 to define the transferred set Cb from a proposed oracle set Ch, ensuring that selected sources satisfy both parameter similarity (h1) and information quality around the objective quantile (h2).
-
Robust Statistical Inference: By employing the Neyman orthogonal debiased approach with Equation 10, the system can obtain an estimator for the target parameter beta star 1 that is immune to first-order errors from nuisance parameters, leading to asymptotically normal results with a rate of sqrt(nC).
-
Adaptive Inference Quality Control: The improved system can incorporate a quality control procedure (Algorithm 4) which uses quantile pair bootstrapping and Shapiro-Wilk tests to validate the normality of the debiased estimator, reverting to target-only debiasing if normality is rejected.
Sources
- Transfer Learning for Nonparametric Regression: Non-asymptotic Minimax Analysis and Adaptive Procedure
- Estimation and inference for transfer learning with high-dimensional quantile regression
- Guided Adversarial Robust Transfer Learning with Source Mixing
- Covariate-Elaborated Robust Partial Information Transfer with Conditional Spike-and-Slab Prior
- Residual Importance Weighted Transfer Learning For High-dimensional Linear Regression
Related papers
- Learning Robust Treatment Rules for Censored Data
- Neural Estimation of Summary Statistics for Simulation-Based Inference with Non-Asymptotic Guarantees
- Spectral divide-and-conquer MCMC for long stationary time series
- Improving the Efficiency of Subgroup Analysis in Randomized Controlled Trials with TMLE
- Personalized Federated Vector Autoregression with Personalization Diversity
- Doubly Robust and Efficient Calibration of Prediction Sets for Right-Censored Time-to-Event Outcomes