Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the mass aspect of the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem

arXiv:2411.18725 · hep-ph · Submitted 2024-11-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem is presented by introducing a strongly coupled chiral dark sector where a light composite fermion as dark matter acquires its mass through misalignment triggered by the QCD vacuum, ensuring it is at the GeV scale The Coincidence Problem and Mass Generation The paper addresses the problem of comparable masses between dark matter and baryons by proposing a solution where the dark matter mass is generated from the QCD vacuum, naturally satisfying the condition mD ≈ ΛQCD This approach requires a strongly coupled chiral dark sector featuring a light composite fermion as dark matter whose mass is set by misalignment triggered by the QCD vacuum The model features O(1) GeV dark baryon dark matter together with dark pions (axion-like particles) and a composite QCD axion naturally arising in the UV model Mechanism for Mass Acquisition The mass generation mechanism is illustrated by extending the Standard Model gauge group to the Pati-Salam subgroup SU(4)P S × U(1)R, where neutrino masses are dynamically generated by a quark condensate in QCD A new colored fermion condensate ⟨ψψ¯⟩ ≈ 4π f 2 E vQCD is introduced to avoid suppression and naturally leads to considering Vacuum Misalignment The desired dark lepton mass is given by mχ ≈ g squared E M2 E ψ′Lψ¯R = 4π fD fE squared fD sin θ A successful model requires the conditions fD sin θ ≈ vQCD and fE ≈ fD Toy Model and Vacuum Misalignment A toy model analogous to composite Higgs models (CHM) is constructed where a dark-fermion condensate forms at a high scale with a nearly flat direction, which is then broken by QCD once it becomes strongly coupled at low energies The resulting potential for the dark pion field is given by V(Π′) ∼ λf 4 D sin4 Π′ fD The final vacuum shift symmetry breaking leads to a misalignment fD sin θ ≈ ΛQCD √3 λ ≈ 4π √3 λ vQCD UV Completion and Dark Matter Identity The UV complete model is the "double 54321" model, which incorporates the required features through gauge symmetry breaking driven by dark color dynamics The true dark matter is a composite fermion composed of AF¯SFS, denoted as dark baryon X, whose mass is given by mX ≈ 2 mFS ≈ 8π √3 λ ΛQCD This demonstrates that comparable dark matter and baryon masses can be explained by the fact that dark matter also derives its mass from the QCD vacuum Cosmological Constraints and Phenomenology The model requires incorporating an Asymmetric Dark Matter (ADM) framework to ensure similar number densities, with constraints arising from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) on the dark pion lifetime Astrophysical observations impose a constraint on the axion decay constant, restricting the scale fD ≳ 5 × 107 GeV Direct detection cross sections for dark matter are estimated to be around ∼ 10−45 cm2 for a scale fD = 108 GeV The framework establishes a deep connection between the dark sector and the QCD sector through strong dynamics, resulting in O(1) GeV asymmetric dark baryon dark matter accompanied by dark pions and a composite QCD axion The study suggests that a finite parameter space exists under current experimental constraints, opening a new direction in BSM model-building Acknowledgments I thank Alvaro Pastor-Guti´errez, Hitoshi Murayama, ´Hsin-Chia Cheng, and Giacomo Cacciapaglia for useful discussions on the different issues of strong dynamics The paper includes references

1: through

73: in the acknowledgments section Supplemental Material This Supplementary Material provides additional details on the double 54321 model and includes calculations of the pNGB potential to support the results presented in the main text The detailed analysis of contributions to the pNGB potential is provided here Table I and Table II Content Table I shows the particle content of the SU(5) chiral gauge theory with three extra Dirac pairs Table II details the particle content of the double 54321 model Table III summarizes the fermion content after symmetry breaking in the double 54321 model The table lists quantum numbers for ψ and ψ′ Anomalous Current and Axion Potential The composite QCD axion a is associated with the current anomalous under QCD, leading to the interaction La = g squared s 3 2π 2 a fa with fa = √21/5 fD A non-perturbative QCD effect (instantons) will generate the well-known axion potential and mass after integrating out the QCD pion The leading-order potential from the spurion VQCD is given by V(Π′) ∼ −ΛD tr(VQCD U) ∼ Λ cubed QCDπ′2 Final Mass Term Derivation The final mass term for the dark pion is derived from the potential, resulting in a linear term proportional to VQCD The true vacuum is stuck somewhere between the two vacua and the dark pions also acquire a mass proportional to λΠ′ as shown in the main text Final Summary of Key Findings The work successfully demonstrates how a colorless dark matter can acquire an O(ΛQCD) mass from the QCD vacuum through a strongly coupled chiral theory with small vacuum misalignment The direct consequences are O(1) GeV asymmetric dark baryon dark matter accompanied by dark pions and a composite QCD axion The unique scale fD of dark color governs all relevant couplings This framework opens a new direction in BSM model-building exploring the role of strongly coupled theories in the dark sector References

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at the paper called "Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the mass aspect of the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem," and it tackles that nasty coincidence problem where dark matter and regular matter have similar masses.

Mira: Yeah, it proposes a way to solve that by making the dark matter mass come from something in our strong nuclear force—the QCD vacuum.

Kai: Basically, instead of some arbitrary mass term, this model suggests a light composite fermion that gets its mass through how the QCD vacuum misaligns things.

Lev: From an engineering side, if we are looking for GeV scale dark matter, the mechanism has to be very specific about how that misalignment happens at the low energy scale.

Mira: It introduces a strongly coupled chiral dark sector, which means there's a light composite fermion as the dark matter and some axion-like particles called dark pions.

Kai: And they bring in this composite QCD axion naturally arising from the UV model, which is pretty interesting because it connects the dark sector to our known strong force dynamics.

Lev: So we're talking about setting up a system where the mass scale itself is dictated by vacuum misalignment, which sounds like a very subtle mechanism to get that GeV scale right.

The paper's summary: Kai: To put it simply, the paper outlines how you can ensure comparable number densities between dark matter and baryons by having their masses derived from the QCD vacuum structure.

Mira: It suggests a specific setup: a strongly coupled chiral dark sector where the light composite fermion gets its mass from this vacuum misalignment.

Kai: They extend the Standard Model gauge group to include the Pati-Salam subgroup, SU(four)P S times U(one)R, and they dynamically generate neutrino masses using a quark condensate in QCD.

Lev: That quark condensate term you mentioned, ⟨psi psi bar⟩ equals four pi f squared E vQCD, is what avoids the suppression we usually see when trying to get those mass terms right.

Mira: And this structure naturally points us toward considering Vacuum Misalignment as the key driver for generating that desired dark lepton mass.

Kai: The toy model they build is like a composite Higgs model, where a dark fermion condensate forms at a high scale with a flat direction, and QCD then breaks it down once it gets strongly coupled at low energies.

Lev: So the paper is arguing that the potential for the dark pion field has to be very flat for QCD to influence the vacuum at this low scale, which imposes constraints on its coefficients.

The paper's improvements: Kai: They propose a few specific improvements over previous ideas, like using two Dirac dark quarks and a dark lepton condensate to generate that mass through misalignment.

Mira: They show that the desired dark lepton mass is given by m chi equals g squared E M2E psi prime L psi bar R times four pi f D times f E squared sin theta.

Lev: The key condition they need for this to work well is setting the scale f D sin theta equal to vQCD, and also having the dark lepton scale f E be equal to that same scale, so their parameters are linked.

Kai: This linkage between the scales and the vacuum expectation value of QCD is what makes this model work in terms of achieving that GeV mass for the dark matter particle.

Mira: They then construct a UV complete model they call the "double fifty-four thousand three hundred twenty-one" model, which uses gauge symmetry breaking driven by dark color dynamics to incorporate all these features.

Lev: The actual dark matter candidate is a composite fermion made of two FS fermions, denoted as dark baryon X, and its mass scales like mX equals two mFS times eight pi root three lambda QCD.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the mass aspect of the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem," they show a way for dark matter and baryons to have similar masses.

Mira: The result is O(one) GeV asymmetric dark baryon dark matter, along with those light dark pions and a composite QCD axion that shows up in the UV model <ref:2411.18725#pg1>.

Kai: It’s a deep connection between the strong dynamics of the QCD sector and what we think is happening in the dark sector.

Lev: From my view, it suggests that if we can find a strongly coupled chiral theory like this, we might be able to get our hands on concrete predictions for these dark particles.

Mira: The model has constraints from cosmological observations too; they need an Asymmetric Dark Matter framework and limits from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis on the dark pion lifetime.

Kai: And astrophysical constraints also restrict the axion decay constant f D, putting a lower bound around five times ten to seven gigaelectron volts.

Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik

hep-ph

Submitted: 2024-11-27

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: 10 pages, 1 figures, 4 tables, v2: matches version accepted for publication in EPJC

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 1303 (2026)

DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-026-16591-2

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 66/100

The gist: Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem is presented by introducing a strongly coupled chiral dark sector where a light…

Key concepts

Dark Matter-Baryon Coincidence Problem
This is the issue where dark matter and ordinary baryons seem to have comparable masses, which is hard to explain naturally in particle physics models. The paper attempts to solve this by making the dark matter mass dependent on a fundamental scale from Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), specifically $\Lambda_{QCD}$, ensuring they are of similar magnitude.
Chiral Dark Sector
This refers to a theoretical framework where the dark sector possesses chiral symmetry, meaning it has specific internal symmetries. The model uses this structure to describe the dark matter particle as a light composite fermion that gains mass through interactions with the QCD vacuum.
Vacuum Misalignment
This mechanism describes how the mass of dark particles is set by how the underlying field configuration (the vacuum) is slightly misaligned from its natural symmetry. In this model, QCD triggers this misalignment, which dictates the final mass scale of the dark matter particle.
Composite QCD Axion
This is a light particle arising from non-perturbative effects within QCD. It interacts with dark matter and mediates forces between dark particles. The paper shows how its potential and mass are generated by integrating out the QCD pion field, linking it to the overall dark sector dynamics.

Terminology

Summary

Generating the Dark Matter mass from the QCD vacuum: A new approach to the Dark Matter-Baryon coincidence problem is presented by introducing a strongly coupled chiral dark sector where a light composite fermion as dark matter acquires its mass through misalignment triggered by the QCD vacuum, ensuring it is at the GeV scale

The Coincidence Problem and Mass Generation

The paper addresses the problem of comparable masses between dark matter and baryons by proposing a solution where the dark matter mass is generated from the QCD vacuum, naturally satisfying the condition mD ≈ ΛQCD This approach requires a strongly coupled chiral dark sector featuring a light composite fermion as dark matter whose mass is set by misalignment triggered by the QCD vacuum The model features O(1) GeV dark baryon dark matter together with dark pions (axion-like particles) and a composite QCD axion naturally arising in the UV model

Mechanism for Mass Acquisition

The mass generation mechanism is illustrated by extending the Standard Model gauge group to the Pati-Salam subgroup SU(4)P S × U(1)R, where neutrino masses are dynamically generated by a quark condensate in QCD A new colored fermion condensate ⟨ψψ¯⟩ ≈ 4π f 2 E vQCD is introduced to avoid suppression and naturally leads to considering Vacuum Misalignment The desired dark lepton mass is given by mχ ≈ g squared E M2 E ψ′Lψ¯R = 4π fD fE squared fD sin θ A successful model requires the conditions fD sin θ ≈ vQCD and fE ≈ fD

Toy Model and Vacuum Misalignment

A toy model analogous to composite Higgs models (CHM) is constructed where a dark-fermion condensate forms at a high scale with a nearly flat direction, which is then broken by QCD once it becomes strongly coupled at low energies The resulting potential for the dark pion field is given by V(Π′) ∼ λf 4 D sin4 Π′ fD The final vacuum shift symmetry breaking leads to a misalignment fD sin θ ≈ ΛQCD √3 λ ≈ 4π √3 λ vQCD

UV Completion and Dark Matter Identity

The UV complete model is the double 54321 model, which incorporates the required features through gauge symmetry breaking driven by dark color dynamics The true dark matter is a composite fermion composed of AF¯SFS, denoted as dark baryon X, whose mass is given by mX ≈ 2 mFS ≈ 8π √3 λ ΛQCD This demonstrates that comparable dark matter and baryon masses can be explained by the fact that dark matter also derives its mass from the QCD vacuum

Cosmological Constraints and Phenomenology

The model requires incorporating an Asymmetric Dark Matter (ADM) framework to ensure similar number densities, with constraints arising from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) on the dark pion lifetime Astrophysical observations impose a constraint on the axion decay constant, restricting the scale fD ≳ 5 × 107 GeV Direct detection cross sections for dark matter are estimated to be around ∼ 10−45 cm2 for a scale fD = 108 GeV

Conclusion and Outlook

The framework establishes a deep connection between the dark sector and the QCD sector through strong dynamics, resulting in O(1) GeV asymmetric dark baryon dark matter accompanied by dark pions and a composite QCD axion The study suggests that a finite parameter space exists under current experimental constraints, opening a new direction in BSM model-building

Acknowledgments

I thank Alvaro Pastor-Guti´errez, Hitoshi Murayama, ´Hsin-Chia Cheng, and Giacomo Cacciapaglia for useful discussions on the different issues of strong dynamics The paper includes references [1] through [73] in the acknowledgments section

Supplemental Material

This Supplementary Material provides additional details on the double 54321 model and includes calculations of the pNGB potential to support the results presented in the main text The detailed analysis of contributions to the pNGB potential is provided here

Table I and Table II Content

Table I shows the particle content of the SU(5) chiral gauge theory with three extra Dirac pairs Table II details the particle content of the double 54321 model Table III summarizes the fermion content after symmetry breaking in the double 54321 model The table lists quantum numbers for ψ and ψ′

Anomalous Current and Axion Potential

The composite QCD axion a is associated with the current anomalous under QCD, leading to the interaction La = g squared s 3 2π 2 a fa with fa = √21/5 fD A non-perturbative QCD effect (instantons) will generate the well-known axion potential and mass after integrating out the QCD pion The leading-order potential from the spurion VQCD is given by V(Π′) ∼ −ΛD tr(VQCD U) ∼ Λ cubed QCDπ′2

Final Mass Term Derivation

The final mass term for the dark pion is derived from the potential, resulting in a linear term proportional to VQCD The true vacuum is stuck somewhere between the two vacua and the dark pions also acquire a mass proportional to λΠ′ as shown in the main text

Final Summary of Key Findings

The work successfully demonstrates how a colorless dark matter can acquire an O(ΛQCD) mass from the QCD vacuum through a strongly coupled chiral theory with small vacuum misalignment The direct consequences are O(1) GeV asymmetric dark baryon dark matter accompanied by dark pions and a composite QCD axion The unique scale fD of dark color governs all relevant couplings This framework opens a new direction in BSM model-building exploring the role of strongly coupled theories in the dark sector

References

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can model dark sector physics by incorporating a strongly coupled chiral dark sector featuring a light composite fermion as dark matter whose mass is generated through misalignment triggered by the QCD vacuum.

  2. The improved system can simulate the generation of neutrino masses from the QCD vacuum using an extension of the Pati-Salam model, specifically showing how the mass then takes the form mν ≈ g2E M2E 4π v3QCD f2/E (Equation 3).

  3. The system can implement a toy model analogous to composite Higgs models by constructing a dark sector with two Dirac dark quarks and a dark lepton whose mass is generated by vacuum misalignment, specifically showing mχ ≈ g2E M2E ψ′Lψ¯R = 4π fD fE2fD sin θ (Equation 8).

  4. The AI can perform cosmological simulations incorporating the constraints from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis by calculating the dark pion lifetime using τπ′ ∼ α2/s8π3m3π'f2D−1 = 2 s fD / (1011 GeV2) 2 GeV mπ'3 (Equation 18) to set an upper bound on the dark confinement scale fD.

  5. The system can analyze phenomenological constraints by calculating lower bounds on the dark confinement scale fD from astrophysical observations, noting the constraint from BBN, requiring τπ′ ≲ 1 s, thus sets an upper bound on the scale fD ≲ 7 × 1010 GeV (Page 5).

  6. The improved system can determine the mass of dark matter X as a composite fermion composed of two FS fermions by calculating mX ≈ 2 mFS ≈ 2 g2E M2E F′T F¯T ≈ 8π√3 λΛQCD (Equation 17).

  7. The system can map the relationship between gauge coupling scales and vacuum misalignment by deriving the condition for a successful model, which requires fD sin θ ≈ vQCD and fE ≈ fD (Equation 9).

  8. The AI can predict the mass of dark pions, which are the lightest particle in the dark sector, as mπ′ ≈ √6 λΛQCD ≳ 2 GeV (Page 4), which play an important role in cosmology and phenomenology.

Abstract

The comparable abundances of dark matter and baryons imply a deep connection between the dark sector and the QCD sector. In asymmetric dark matter models, the number densities of both sectors are ensured to be similar. However, a complete solution should also include a mechanism relating their masses. In this study, we explore a new mechanism where an O(Λ QCD) dark matter mass arises from the QCD vacuum. The idea is realized by a strongly coupled chiral dark sector, featuring a light composite fermion as the dark matter. Its mass is generated through the vacuum misalignment induced by QCD, ensuring the mass to be comparable with baryons. The model also features additional light bosons, including GeV-scale dark pions and a composite QCD axion.

Sources

Related papers