Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = 5.02 TeV

arXiv:2410.15671 · hep-ph, nucl-th · Submitted 2024-10-21 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = 5.02 TeV".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. An attempt has been made to estimate the minimum size of the deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) matter in small systems, such as the p-Pb system, that could be satisfactorily modeled with low-order hydrodynamics The increase in elliptic flow fluctuations indicates a breakdown of fluid behavior at dN/dy ≈ 14 for p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV System Size and Deconfinement Onset The study aims to estimate the system size threshold, marked as the system size deconfinement onset in Fig.

Kai: 1, for peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV The authors investigate whether signatures observed in small systems are due to cold nuclear matter effects, genuine QGP-like hot nuclear matter effects, or something in-between They attempt to estimate this system size threshold for peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV Hydrodynamic Modeling Framework The soft sector of p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV was simulated using a comprehensive framework called JETSCAPE This modular framework utilizes individual stage modules including TRENTo, Freestreaming, MUSIC, iSS, and SMASH The initial condition is generated by the TRENTo model which treats constituents inside nucleons in a manner analogous to how nucleons are treated inside a nucleus The pre-equilibrium stage is simulated using the Freestreaming module based on the collisionless Boltzmann equation of massless particles Hydrodynamic Applicability and Breakdown The applicability of hydrodynamics is determined exclusively by the relative contribution of the non-hydrodynamic mode to the hydrodynamic mode The fluid behavior will break down if the contribution of the non-hydrodynamic mode exceeds that of the hydrodynamic mode The primary objective is to study the behavior of the elliptic flow coefficient for extreme values of the shear relaxation time in peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV Key Findings on Elliptic Flow The results show that the flow curves for two shear relaxation time factors coincide up to the centrality class of 40-60%, indicating that the dynamics is insensitive to changes in the shear relaxation time The point of mismatch moves towards lower pT from midcentral to peripheral collisions, which is in line with those in the analysis performed for Pb-Pb and Au-Au collisions The onset may lie somewhere between the 55-65% and 60-70% classes, corresponding to a rapidity density of dN/dy ≈ 14 The onset obtained in the present study is a conservative estimate, and the real onset may lie at lower values of dN/dy There is significant scope for improving this analysis by including a signature of the onset from the hard sector A natural extension of this study would be to include a signature of the onset from the hard sector The work can be performed with realistic 3+1D hydrodynamics such that the experimental flow at forward rapidity can be utilized for better tuning Acknowledgments N.H.

Mira: is grateful to Paul Romatschke, Chun Shen, Yasuki Tachibana, and Scott Moreland for clarifying various doubts from time to time N.H.

Kai: would also like to thank the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay for financial support S.D.

Paper summary: Lev: So summarizing the paper "Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = five point zero two TeV," they used a sophisticated JETSCAPE framework to estimate the minimum size of deconfined matter that low-order hydrodynamics can handle <ref:2410.15671#pg1,Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at>.

Kai: They found that for peripheral proton-lead collisions, the flow curves are relatively stable up to sixty percent centrality, suggesting dynamics aren't extremely sensitive to shear relaxation time in that region.

Mira: But they pinpoint a potential breakdown point around sixty to seventy percent centrality, which they link to a rapidity density of about fourteen. They suggest this estimate is conservative and the true onset might be smaller.

Lev: The authors also pointed out that the analysis would benefit greatly if they added information from the hard sector to better define where this hydrodynamization begins.

Kai: The paper shows that for small systems, like p-Pb collisions at five point zero two tera-electron volt per nucleon pair, we can use low-order hydrodynamics to get some useful hints about the size of the QGP region.

Mira: It really matters because it helps us distinguish between cold nuclear matter effects and genuine hot nuclear matter effects in these small systems.

Lev: From an engineering view, this means if we're building hardware to simulate these collisions, we need to keep that breakdown criterion in mind when setting our limits on what the simulation can reliably predict.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at the paper "Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN equals five point zero two tera electron volt per nucleon pair."

Mira: Basically, they're trying to figure out exactly how big a collision needs to be before we can trust simple fluid models like hydrodynamics to describe what's happening.

Lev: It’s about finding that threshold where the system gets messy and non-hydrodynamic stuff starts dominating the picture.

Kai: They set up this complex simulation using JETSCAPE, which combines different modules for everything from how protons inside nucleons behave to how they evolve after the initial collision.

Mira: The central question they tackle is whether what we see in these small proton lead collisions is just "cold nuclear matter" stuff, or if a real hot quark-gluon plasma is actually forming.

Lev: They focus on elliptic flow fluctuations because that's where the fluid behavior really shows up—or breaks down.

Kai: The main finding they get is that the point where the fluid model fails moves toward more peripheral collisions, meaning it happens when there are fewer particles involved in the interaction.

Mira: But they found this estimate for the onset to be quite conservative, suggesting that maybe we need to look at even smaller systems or different conditions to see what's really going on.

Lev: The authors themselves admit that including data from the hard scattering process would give them a much better idea of where that transition point actually lies.

Kai: So it’s a good map for where we should focus our next experiments—where to push the limits of what these small systems can tell us about the hot matter inside.

Nikhil Hatwar, Sadhana Dash, Basanta Kumar Nandi

Indian Institute of Technology Bombay · Department of Physics, COEP Technological University

hep-ph, nucl-th

Submitted: 2024-10-21

Updated: 2026-11-03

Journal ref: Nikhil Hatwar et al 2026 J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 53 105004

DOI: 10.1088/1361-6471/aeb319

Code: https://github.com/JETSCAPE/JETSCAPE

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: An attempt has been made to estimate the minimum size of the deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) matter in small systems, such as the p-Pb system…

Key concepts

Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP)
QGP is a state of matter where quarks and gluons are deconfined, meaning they are no longer bound within individual protons or neutrons. This state exists at extremely high temperatures and densities, similar to the conditions in the early universe.
Elliptic Flow Fluctuations
Elliptic flow describes how particles move anisotropically (non-uniformly) in the collision's transverse plane. Changes or fluctuations in this flow signal when the system transitions from behaving like a fluid (hydrodynamic) to something else, indicating a change in its internal dynamics.
Hydrodynamics Breakdown
Hydrodynamics is a mathematical tool used to describe the collective, fluid-like motion of matter. When the contribution of non-hydrodynamic modes becomes too large compared to the hydrodynamic mode, it means the system's behavior is no longer well-described by simple fluid equations.
System Size Threshold
This refers to a critical size or density threshold in a collision (like p-Pb) where the conditions are expected to trigger the transition into QGP. The study attempts to pinpoint this threshold using hydrodynamic modeling results.

Terminology

Summary

An attempt has been made to estimate the minimum size of the deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) matter in small systems, such as the p-Pb system, that could be satisfactorily modeled with low-order hydrodynamics The increase in elliptic flow fluctuations indicates a breakdown of fluid behavior at dN/dy ≈ 14 for p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at √ sNN = 5. 02 TeV Nikhil Hatwar∗ Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Powai, Mumbai, India and Department of Physics, COEP Technological University, Shivajinagar, Pune 411005, Maharashtra, India Sadhana Dash and Basanta Kumar Nandi Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Powai, Mumbai, India (Dated: June 25, 2026) An attempt has been made to estimate the minimum size of the deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) matter in small systems, such as the p-Pb system, that could be satisfactorily modeled with low-order hydrodynamics.

02 TeV

System Size and Deconfinement Onset

The study aims to estimate the system size threshold, marked as the system size deconfinement onset in Fig. 1, for peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Probing the onset of hydrodynamization in peripheral p-Pb collisions at √ sNN = 5. 02 TeV Nikhil Hatwar∗ Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Powai, Mumbai, India and Department of Physics, COEP Technological University, Shivajinagar, Pune 411005, Maharashtra, India Sadhana Dash and Basanta Kumar Nandi Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Powai, Mumbai, India (Dated: June 25, 2026) An attempt has been made to estimate the minimum size of the deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) matter in small systems, such as the p-Pb system, that could be satisfactorily modeled with low-order hydrodynamics.

02 TeV The authors investigate whether signatures observed in small systems are due to cold nuclear matter effects, genuine QGP-like hot nuclear matter effects, or something in-between They attempt to estimate this system size threshold for peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5. p. 0
Where the paper says it

However, the discovery of most of these Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) signatures in small systems like proton-nucleus and high-multiplicity proton-proton collisions has been puzzling [7–11]. Currently, we are confronted with the question of whether these signatures are a result of cold nuclear matter effects [12], genuine QGP-like hot nuclear matter effects [13], or something in-between [14].

02 TeV

Hydrodynamic Modeling Framework

The soft sector of p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV was simulated using a comprehensive framework called JETSCAPE This modular framework utilizes individual stage modules including TRENTo, Freestreaming, MUSIC, iSS, and SMASH The initial condition is generated by the TRENTo model which treats constituents inside nucleons in a manner analogous to how nucleons are treated inside a nucleus The pre-equilibrium stage is simulated using the Freestreaming module based on the collisionless Boltzmann equation of massless particles

Hydrodynamic Applicability and Breakdown

The applicability of hydrodynamics is determined exclusively by the relative contribution of the non-hydrodynamic mode to the hydrodynamic mode The fluid behavior will break down if the contribution of the non-hydrodynamic mode exceeds that of the hydrodynamic mode The primary objective is to study the behavior of the elliptic flow coefficient for extreme values of the shear relaxation time in peripheral p-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV

Key Findings on Elliptic Flow

The results show that the flow curves for two shear relaxation time factors coincide up to the centrality class of 40-60%, indicating that the dynamics is insensitive to changes in the shear relaxation time The point of mismatch moves towards lower pT from midcentral to peripheral collisions, which is in line with those in the analysis performed for Pb-Pb and Au-Au collisions The onset may lie somewhere between the 55-65% and 60-70% classes, corresponding to a rapidity density of dN/dy ≈ 14

Conclusion and Outlook

The onset obtained in the present study is a conservative estimate, and the real onset may lie at lower values of dN/dy There is significant scope for improving this analysis by including a signature of the onset from the hard sector A natural extension of this study would be to include a signature of the onset from the hard sector The work can be performed with realistic 3+1D hydrodynamics such that the experimental flow at forward rapidity can be utilized for better tuning

Acknowledgments

N.H. is grateful to Paul Romatschke, Chun Shen, Yasuki Tachibana, and Scott Moreland for clarifying various doubts from time to time N. p. 8

Where the paper says it

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS N. is grateful to Paul Romatschke, Chun Shen, Yasuki Tachibana, and Scott Moreland for clarifying various doubts from time to time.

H. would also like to thank the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay for financial support S. p. 8
Where the paper says it

is grateful to Paul Romatschke, Chun Shen, Yasuki Tachibana, and Scott Moreland for clarifying various doubts from time to time. would also like to thank the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay for financial support.

D. acknowledges the SERB Power Fellowship, SPF/2022/000014, for support in this work The input files for the framework and individual models have been made available at Ref. p. 8
Where the paper says it

would also like to thank the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay for financial support. acknowledges the SERB Power Fellowship, SPF/2022/000014, for support in this work.

[86, 87] The observables are produced for the kinematic cuts: 0 < pT < 3 GeV/c and −0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The input files for the framework and individual models have been made available at Ref. The observables are produced for the kinematic cuts: 0 < pT < 3 GeV/c and −0.

8 < y < 0.8 The nucleon-nucleon collision cross section has been set to σNN = 67 mb The shear relaxation time factor (bπ) of Eq. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The nucleon-nucleon collision cross section has been set to σNN = 67 mb [88]. The shear relaxation time factor (bπ) of Eq.

(21) is set to 2 and 6 for the elliptic flow results in Fig. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The shear relaxation time factor (bπ) of Eq. (21) is set to 2 and 6 for the elliptic flow results in Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Adaptive Hydrodynamic Applicability Assessment: The improved system can dynamically estimate whether hydrodynamic behavior is breaking down by monitoring the contribution of the non-hydrodynamic mode to the hydrodynamic mode as a function of collision centrality and rapidity density, directly addressing whether collective flow can persist down to systems of only a dozen final-state particles.

  2. Onset Prediction for Small Systems: The system can predict the minimum size threshold for QGP formation in small systems by using "the variation of the second-order transport coefficient of second-order relativistic viscous hydrodynamics, the shear relaxation time, has been utilized to study the sensitivity of experimental observables like the elliptic flow coefficient."

  3. Fluctuations Analysis for Initial State vs. System Dilution: The system can distinguish between initial state fluctuations and system dilution by plotting the elliptic flow for the 60-80% centrality class with a smooth initial state and observing that fluctuations in v2 increase in magnitude, especially at higher pT, signifying that these fluctuations are not caused by fluctuations in the initial state.

  4. Shear Relaxation Time Sensitivity Mapping: The system can map how observables change based on the shear relaxation time factor by generating elliptic flow results for two extreme values of the shear relaxation time factor and observing that the flow curves for the two shear relaxation time factors coincide up to the centrality class of 40-60%.

  5. Centrality-Dependent Onset Estimation: The system can pinpoint the approximate onset of hydrodynamic applicability by identifying the point of mismatch moves towards lower pT from midcentral to peripheral collisions, which signifies a signature of hydrodynamic onset marked by the approximate yellow patch in Fig. 8.

Abstract

We estimate the multiplicity scale below which the hydrodynamic description of small systems, such as p-Pb collisions, becomes increasingly sensitive to non-hydrodynamic effects. The sensitivity of experimental observables, namely the elliptic flow coefficient, is investigated by varying the shear relaxation time within second-order relativistic viscous hydrodynamics. To achieve this, a representative system of peripheral p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = 5.02 TeV is simulated utilizing the state-of-the-art JETSCAPE event generator. The soft-sector dynamics are modeled via a sequence of initial conditions, a pre-equilibrium stage, hydrodynamics, and a hadronic afterburner. Transverse momentum spectra and rapidity distributions for light-flavored hadrons are extracted and compared with experimental data. The resulting increase in elliptic flow fluctuations indicates a breakdown of fluid behavior at a rapidity density of dN/dy about 10--15 for p-Pb collisions at sqrt s NN = 5.02 TeV.

Sources

Related papers