Stellar evolution and axion-like particles: new constraints and hints from globular clusters in the GAIA DR3 data
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Stellar evolution and axion-like particles".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Axion-like particles (ALPs) are hypothetical pseudoscalar bosons that can influence stellar evolution by providing an additional mechanism for energy loss in stars The paper uses Gaia DR3 data from seven globular clusters to constrain ALP couplings, finding upper limits on the electron coupling and an indication of a nonzero ALP-photon coupling Stellar Evolution Context The study investigates the impact of ALPs on stellar evolution, specifically focusing on red giants and helium-burning stars in globular clusters (GCs) Thermally produced hypothetical particles escape from central regions, carrying energy out and potentially delaying helium ignition or shortening the horizontal branch in these stars The authors exploit observables like the Tip of the Red Giant Branch (TRGB) and the ratio of helium-burning stars to red giants (R) to constrain ALP couplings Constraining ALP Couplings The analysis involves determining evolution parameters for individual GCs, such as the bolometric absolute magnitude of TRGB, denoted as M(tip) bol and the ratio R = NHB/NRGB The electron coupling is related to the TRGB through a Yukawa interaction term in the Lagrangian, where M(tip) bol was obtained from simulations for different values of gae The photon coupling is related to HB stars via a relation involving R and the ALP-photon coupling gaγγ Results and Constraints The likelihood analysis favors gae = 0 as the best-fit value, setting an upper limit of gae < 5.2×10−14 (95% CL) In the most conservative assumption of primordial helium abundance Y = YBBN, a nonzero gaγγ = (6.5 + 1.1 - 1.3) × 10−11 GeV−1 is indicated at the 3.3sigma level Comparison with Other Constraints The upper limit on gae obtained in this work is stronger than previously reported ones, potentially due to the more effective selection of GC members using Gaia DR3 data The nonzero gaγγ preferred by the results agrees with previous laboratory and solar limits, and it is consistent with indications from gamma-ray sources at very high or ultra-high energies Future Directions The increased precision found in this study stems from the advantages of Gaia DR3 data, necessitating improved stellar-evolution simulations to reduce the error budget Direct simulations of observable quantities taking into account more variations in stellar models should be applied to a larger number of Gaia GCs The study also suggests that other hypothetical particles could cause the observed energy losses, such as neutrinos The search for non-standard cooling in red giants yielded an upper limit on the ALP coupling to electrons, while the cooling of helium-burning stars disfavors zero ALP–photon coupling at the 3.3sigma level The preferred range for gaγγ matches previous hints from stellar evolution and gamma-ray transparency, motivating further detailed studies Table Summary Table 3 shows the strongest constraints (95% CL for upper limits) on gaγγ obtained by various methods, with this work yielding a value of 6.5 + 1.1 - 1.
Title and authors: Kai: Okay, let's look at the title again: "Stellar evolution and axion-like particles: new constraints and hints from globular clusters in the GAIA DR3 data." It tells us immediately that this isn't just a theoretical exercise; it’s using real observational data from Gaia DR3 to constrain a specific particle physics concept.
Mira: It’s interesting because it connects two very different fields—astrophysics and particle physics—by using the same set of stellar systems, the globular clusters, as the probe for new physics. The authors are trying to find a bridge between what we observe in distant stars and what we theorize about tiny particles.
Lev: From my side, I wonder how robust their distance measurements are when they translate those Gaia positions into physical distances for these GCs. Because stellar evolution models rely heavily on accurate distances, any error there propagates directly into the constraints on gae >
Kai: Right, Lev. The paper spends a lot of time detailing that data reduction process, using synthetic photometry catalogs and various extinction corrections from papers like fifteen to get those magnitudes in UBVRI colors > <ref:2410.02266#pg2>
Mira: And they also explicitly mention using iron content as Fe/H and color corrections quoted in references like nine, ten, and eleven to make sure their input parameters for the stellar models are as accurate as possible > <ref:2410.02266#pg2,Fe/H and color corrections>
Lev: That reliance on external papers for inputs means the systematic uncertainties from those external sources are a big part of what limits the final precision of their constraints, especially when they talk about M(tip) bol >
Kai: They acknowledge that theoretical uncertainties exist in the numerical relations they use from references like sixteen and seventeen, which is where you have to be careful <ref:2410.02266#pg2>. But overall, it’s a strong effort to tie observation directly into theory >
The paper's summary: Mira: So, what the paper actually summarizes is that they analyzed the TRGB analysis and the HB analysis for individual globular clusters using their Gaia DR3 data >
Kai: They determined evolution parameters like M(tip) bol and R for seven GCs, and then they used those derived values to constrain ALP couplings >
Lev: It sounds like a standard methodology, but the specific way they combine the results from the TRGB analysis and the HB analysis is what makes this particular study unique in terms of combining constraints >
Mira: They show how M(tip) bol is related to gae through a Yukawa interaction term, and they relate R to ga gamma gamma via a different relation involving that photon coupling parameter >
Kai: And the summary points out that the likelihood analysis favors gae equals zero as the best-fit value, setting an upper limit of gae less than five point two times ten to the power of negative fourteen at ninety-five percent confidence level >
Lev: That result is interesting because it’s a null result in terms of finding a specific non-zero coupling for the electron interaction, meaning they haven't found evidence for this mechanism yet >
Mira: However, they also indicate a nonzero ga gamma gamma coupling at the three point three sigma level when assuming the primordial helium abundance Y equals YBBN >
Kai: So, to summarize: they put strong limits on one interaction and hint at another based on different stellar populations within the clusters >
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper itself suggests a few ways to improve the analysis, which is always useful when you’re dealing with observational constraints. They call out that they need improved stellar-evolution simulations to reduce their error budget >
Mira: They suggest doing end-to-end simulations of observable quantities that account for more variations in stellar models, including the description of convection, and then applying those to a larger number of Gaia GCs >
Lev: That makes sense from an engineering view. If the input physics—the stellar model itself—is less certain because you're not fully accounting for things like convection, then your error budget on the ALP coupling parameters will be larger than it needs to be >
Kai: Exactly. It’s about reducing that uncertainty in the model side so that the observational data doesn't have to compensate for a weak underlying model >
Mira: They also mention applying these improved simulations to a larger number of Gaia GCs, which is key because statistical power scales with sample size when you are trying to constrain parameters like gae and ga gamma gamma >
Lev: And from the perspective of real hardware running this analysis, if you run the simulation on too many models, it just increases the computational cost significantly without guaranteeing a better result unless those variations actually matter physically >
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Stellar evolution and axion-like particles: new constraints and hints from globular clusters in the GAIA DR3 data" found an upper limit on the electron coupling gae less than five point two times ten to the power of negative fourteen at ninety-five percent confidence level >
Mira: And they also noted that under a standard assumption for helium abundance, Y equals YBBN, there is a three point three sigma indication of a nonzero ga gamma gamma coupling at the scale of one point one part ten to the power of negative eleven GeV to negative one >
Lev: It seems like this work confirms what some previous hints suggested from stellar evolution and gamma-ray transparency, which is good because it shows consistency across different lines of inquiry >
Kai: It’s a good sign that the preferred range for ga gamma gamma matches what we’ve seen from laboratory limits and even indications from gamma-ray sources at very high or ultra-high energies >
Mira: This paper uses the Gaia DR3 data to tighten those constraints, which is why the upper limit on gae they got is stronger than previously reported ones >
Lev: For real hardware running this analysis, it means we have a clearer picture of where to look for experimental signatures in particle physics experiments. We’re looking at how these astrophysical environments might influence the energy loss rates that our detectors are trying to measure >
Institute for Nuclear Research of the Russian Academy of Sciences · Faculty of Physics, Lomonosov Moscow State University
hep-ph, astro-ph.HE
Submitted: 2024-10-03
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, jetpl.cls. V2: version published by JETP Letters. V3: corrected treatment of correlated theoretical uncertainties; numerical results updated
Journal ref: JETP Letters 121 (2025) 159
DOI: 10.1134/S0021364024603798
Project page: https://cajohare.github.io/AxionLimits
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 78/100
The gist: Axion-like particles (ALPs) are hypothetical pseudoscalar bosons that can influence stellar evolution by providing an additional mechanism for energy loss in stars The paper uses Gaia DR3 data from…
Key concepts
- Axion-Like Particles (ALPs)
- Hypothetical pseudoscalar bosons that can influence stellar evolution by providing an extra mechanism for energy loss in stars. They are a type of new particle that could carry energy away from stars, potentially altering their lifespan and observable characteristics.
- Tip of the Red Giant Branch (TRGB)
- A specific luminosity feature observed at the tip of the red giant branch in stars. This point is used as an observable to constrain ALP couplings because its absolute magnitude depends on how ALPs affect energy loss during stellar evolution.
- ALP-Photon Coupling ($g_{ ext{a} ilde{ ho}}$)
- A coupling constant that describes the interaction strength between Axion-Like Particles and photons. The study found a nonzero value for this coupling, which is consistent with hints from laboratory experiments and gamma-ray observations.
- Electron Coupling ($g_{ae}$)
- The interaction strength between ALPs and electrons within stars. This coupling is constrained by analyzing how ALPs influence the luminosity of stars at the TRGB, providing an upper limit on this specific interaction.
Terminology
Summary
Axion-like particles (ALPs) are hypothetical pseudoscalar bosons that can influence stellar evolution by providing an additional mechanism for energy loss in stars The paper uses Gaia DR3 data from seven globular clusters to constrain ALP couplings, finding upper limits on the electron coupling and an indication of a nonzero ALP-photon coupling
Stellar Evolution Context
The study investigates the impact of ALPs on stellar evolution, specifically focusing on red giants and helium-burning stars in globular clusters (GCs) Thermally produced hypothetical particles escape from central regions, carrying energy out and potentially delaying helium ignition or shortening the horizontal branch in these stars The authors exploit observables like the Tip of the Red Giant Branch (TRGB) and the ratio of helium-burning stars to red giants (R) to constrain ALP couplings
Constraining ALP Couplings
The analysis involves determining evolution parameters for individual GCs, such as the bolometric absolute magnitude of TRGB, denoted as M(tip) bol and the ratio R = NHB/NRGB The electron coupling is related to the TRGB through a Yukawa interaction term in the Lagrangian, where M(tip) bol was obtained from simulations for different values of gae The photon coupling is related to HB stars via a relation involving R and the ALP-photon coupling gaγγ
Results and Constraints
The likelihood analysis favors gae = 0 as the best-fit value, setting an upper limit of gae < 5.2×10−14 (95% CL) In the most conservative assumption of primordial helium abundance Y = YBBN, a nonzero gaγγ = (6. p. 25 + 1.1 - 1.3) × 10−11 GeV−1 is indicated at the 3. p. 03sigma level
Comparison with Other Constraints
The upper limit on gae obtained in this work is stronger than previously reported ones, potentially due to the more effective selection of GC members using Gaia DR3 data The nonzero gaγγ preferred by the results agrees with previous laboratory and solar limits, and it is consistent with indications from gamma-ray sources at very high or ultra-high energies
Future Directions
The increased precision found in this study stems from the advantages of Gaia DR3 data, necessitating improved stellar-evolution simulations to reduce the error budget Direct simulations of observable quantities taking into account more variations in stellar models should be applied to a larger number of Gaia GCs The study also suggests that other hypothetical particles could cause the observed energy losses, such as neutrinos
Conclusion
The search for non-standard cooling in red giants yielded an upper limit on the ALP coupling to electrons, while the cooling of helium-burning stars disfavors zero ALP–photon coupling at the 3.3sigma level The preferred range for gaγγ matches previous hints from stellar evolution and gamma-ray transparency, motivating further detailed studies
Table Summary
Table 3 shows the strongest constraints (95% CL for upper limits) on gaγγ obtained by various methods, with this work yielding a value of 6.5 + 1.1 - 1.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved constraint calculation for ALP-electron coupling by implementing a Bayesian likelihood analysis across seven globular clusters to find the best-fit value of gae based on Gaia DR3 data. This allows the system to identify that "our analysis favors gae = 0 as the best-fit value and sets the upper limit of gae < 5.2×10−14 (95% CL)."
-
Enhanced capability to determine ALP-photon coupling constraints by incorporating a Bayesian framework that accounts for different helium abundances Y, allowing the system to show
how they are changed with Y in Sec. 4.
-
Increased precision in stellar evolution modeling by implementing end-to-end simulations of observable quantities taking into account
more potential variations of stellar models (including description of convection)
and applying them to a larger number of Gaia GCs to reduce error budgets. -
Ability to compare new constraints with existing literature by automatically cross-referencing results against Table 2 and Table 3, noting that the study's upper limit on gae is
stronger than previously reported ones.
Sources
- Impact of Parameters in the Blazar Jet Magnetic Field Model on Axion-Like Particle Constraints
- A new upper limit on the axion-photon coupling with an extended CAST run with a Xe-based Micromegas detector
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses