Contravariant Koszul duality between non-positive and positive dg algebras

arXiv:2409.08842 · math.RT · Submitted 2024-09-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Contravariant Koszul duality between non-positive and positive dg algebras".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. The Koszul dual of locally finite non-positive dg algebras is locally finite positive dg algebra, while the Koszul dual of a locally finite positive dg algebra is not necessarily locally finite, and this paper characterizes those positive algebras whose Koszul dual is locally finite <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Ada: Duality between classes of algebras The paper establishes a bijection between quasi-isomorphism classes of locally finite non-positive dg algebras and quasi-isomorphism classes of pvd-finite locally finite positive dg algebras by taking Koszul duals <ref:2409.08842#pg4>.

Emmy: This correspondence is mediated by the Koszul dual functor, which takes a locally finite non-positive dg algebra A to S(A!)op <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Ada: Characterization of pvd-finite positive algebras The paper characterizes locally finite positive dg algebras whose Koszul dual is locally finite by providing equivalent conditions, such as the existence of an injective cogenerator in HA, or that EndD(A)(SA) is a finite-dimensional G-graded algebra <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Title and authors: Ada: We talked about the title and authors of this paper, "Contravariant Koszul duality between non-positive and positive dg algebras". It’s by Riku Fushimi, and it sets up this whole relationship between the two types of algebras we discussed.

Emmy: The core idea is that the Koszul dual functor, which they define as taking an algebra to its quadratic dual, acts like a translation mechanism between these two different mathematical structures. It's not just a simple mapping; it induces equivalences on entire categories of derived objects.

Kolya: So, if we think about this translation mechanism, what does that actually mean for the structure? Is it preserving some kind of information?

Ada: It preserves certain structural features, specifically between the perfect derived category and the perfectly valued derived category for both kinds of algebras. The paper shows this connection is a direct consequence of applying Koszul duality to these specific algebra types.

Emmy: And beyond that, this duality is used to establish what they call the ST-correspondence. This is a bijection between silting objects and algebraic t-structures for both the non-positive algebras and the pvd-finite positive ones they studied.

The paper's summary: Ada: To summarize what this paper is doing, it’s showing that we have a way to map locally finite non-positive dg algebras to locally finite positive dg algebras using the Koszul dual functor. This mapping gives us a strong structural correspondence between the two classes of algebras.

Emmy: The key finding here is Theorem D, which shows how this dual relationship leads to equivalences between the perfect derived category and the perfectly valued derived category for both types of algebras they study. It’s a powerful way to connect these different mathematical worlds.

Kolya: So, when you look at those equivalences, what kind of things are we actually seeing being preserved? Are we just seeing abstract shapes matching up, or is there some more concrete information about the underlying objects?

Ada: It's more than just abstract shapes. The paper connects these categories to concepts like silting objects and algebraic t-structures through the ST-correspondence. This means that when you study one type of object, you can look at its dual structure and see a corresponding algebraic t-structure on the other side.

Emmy: That correspondence is really neat because it allows us to use tools from one area—like silting theory—to understand structures in the other area, even though they look fundamentally different initially.

The paper's improvements: Ada: Now, Riku Fushimi suggests some important extensions and characterizations for these positive algebras. Specifically, they characterize those positive dg algebras whose Koszul dual is locally finite by giving several equivalent conditions to check.

Emmy: They mention things like checking for the existence of an injective cogenerator in a certain category, or that the endomorphism ring of the algebra with some specific grading has a finite dimension when graded. These are concrete ways to test if an algebra fits into this well-behaved class.

Kolya: So, what is the real implication here? Is this just about classifying algebras, or does it help us understand some broader properties of these categories?

Ada: It helps us understand the properties of the derived categories themselves. For instance, they show that under certain assumptions, every covariantly finite bounded heart of a category turns out to be a length heart. This is a big deal for understanding how these categories behave when you look at their bounded parts.

Conclusion: Ada: So, wrapping up this paper on the "Contravariant Koszul duality between non-positive and positive dg algebras". The main takeaway is that we have a way to systematically relate locally finite non-positive dg algebras to locally finite positive ones through Koszul duality.

Emmy: And they’ve given us tools—like the ST-correspondence—to connect silting objects and algebraic t-structures across these two settings, which is a very useful bridge in representation theory.

Kolya: I just wonder about the limitations mentioned in the paper. They mention that for a positive algebra whose dual isn't locally finite, we don't have this nice local finiteness guarantee. That’s a necessary caveat when applying these results to broader settings.

Ada: True, so the paper is very precise about what it covers and where its guarantees hold. It really lays down the groundwork for how we think about these dual relationships in this area of mathematics, especially as we look at things like Smalø's symmetry which they connect to triangulated categories.

Emmy: And that connection to Smalø's symmetry suggests that this duality isn't just a technical trick; it’s pointing toward a deeper structural symmetry within these categories themselves.

Kolya: So, in short, we have established the correspondence between these two classes of algebras and found ways to classify the positive ones properly. That seems like a solid piece of work for now.

Riku Fushimi

math.RT

Submitted: 2024-09-13

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 24 pages. v3: substantially revised and streamlined. To simplify the exposition, the G-graded setting and the appendix of v2 are omitted, and the main results have been reorganized

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: The Koszul dual of locally finite non-positive dg algebras is locally finite positive dg algebra, while the Koszul dual of a locally finite positive dg algebra is not necessarily locally finite…

Key concepts

Koszul Dual Functor
This functor maps a dg algebra A to S(A!)op, which relates non-positive algebras to positive ones. It is central to the duality, showing that quasi-isomorphism classes of these two types of algebras are in bijection.
ST-correspondence
This correspondence provides a bijection between silting objects and algebraic t-structures for both classes of dg algebras. It is established as a consequence of Koszul duality, linking different categorical structures together.
Locally Finite Algebra
An algebra is locally finite if its derived category has certain finiteness properties, specifically being Hom-finite. This property is crucial in characterizing the relationship between the dg algebra and its derived categories.
Perfect Derived Category (per(A))
The perfect derived category captures information about the homological properties of a dg algebra. The paper shows that Koszul duality induces equivalences between per(A) for non-positive algebras and pvd((A!))op for positive ones.

Terminology

Summary

The Koszul dual of locally finite non-positive dg algebras is locally finite positive dg algebra, while the Koszul dual of a locally finite positive dg algebra is not necessarily locally finite, and this paper characterizes those positive algebras whose Koszul dual is locally finite <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>.

Duality between classes of algebras

The paper establishes a bijection between quasi-isomorphism classes of locally finite non-positive dg algebras and quasi-isomorphism classes of pvd-finite locally finite positive dg algebras by taking Koszul duals <ref:2409.08842#pg4>. This correspondence is mediated by the Koszul dual functor, which takes a locally finite non-positive dg algebra A to S(A! p. 1)op <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>.

Characterization of pvd-finite positive algebras

The paper characterizes locally finite positive dg algebras whose Koszul dual is locally finite by providing equivalent conditions, such as the existence of an injective cogenerator in HA, or that EndD(A)(SA) is a finite-dimensional G-graded algebra <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. A key result is Theorem 3. p. 214, which states that for a locally finite positive G-dg algebra A, the conditions (1) through (5) are equivalent <ref:2409. p. 108842#pg18>.

Triangulated category equivalences

The Koszul dual functor induces contravariant equivalences between the perfect derived category and the perfectly valued derived category for both types of algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg4>. Specifically, Theorem D shows that for a locally finite non-positive dg algebra A, per(A) is equivalent to pvd((A! p. 2))op <ref:2409. p. 0 p. 008842#pg18>, and for a pvd-finite locally finite positive dg algebra A, per(A) is equivalent to pvd((A! p. 1))op <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Functorially finite hearts

The paper investigates the functorially finiteness of bounded hearts of perfectly valued derived categories, showing that for a locally finite non-positive G-dg algebra A, any functorially finite bounded heart of pvd(A) is length <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. Furthermore, Theorem 5. p. 11 provides a bijection between equivalence classes of silting objects in per(A), simple-minded objects in pvd(A), algebraic t-structures of pvd(A), and bounded co-t-structures of per(A) <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Koszul double duality

The Koszul double duality is established through Theorem 4.17, which shows that the canonical morphism A -> EndCdg(A) -> EndDdg(A)(A! p. 7!) is a quasi-isomorphism <ref:2409. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 108842#pg18>. This implies that the Koszul dual functors are self-adjoint, as the composition D((A! p. 6))op Φ F◦Φ is the right adjoint of Φ <ref:2409. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 008842#pg18>.

Density of Koszul dual functors

The Koszul dual functors are shown to be dense in their respective derived categories, meaning they induce equivalences between the relevant derived categories <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This density is proven using properties of homotopy limits and colimits applied to the truncation functors <ref:2409. p. 808842#pg18>.

ST-correspondence

The Koszul duality establishes the ST-correspondence, which provides a bijection between silting objects and algebraic t-structures for both classes of algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This correspondence is also shown to hold for pvd-finite locally finite positive G-dg algebras <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Length hearts characterization

Theorem 5.12 characterizes when a bounded t-structure on D whose heart is H has certain properties, stating that the conditions (1) through (6) are equivalent for a proper non-positive G-dg algebra A <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>.

Torsion classes in modΛ

Corollary 5.14 shows that for a finite dimensional algebra Λ, the torsion class T is functorially finite in modΛ if and only if the torsion class F is functorially finite in modΛ <ref:2409. p. 1 p. 1 p. 108842#pg18>. This result extends to t-discrete triangulated categories <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>.

Twisting the grading

Appendix A introduces a technique for twisting the grading of formal dg algebras via a group isomorphism and a group homomorphism, defining Vρψ and the map µV,W <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This allows for connections between dg (or A∞) Koszul duality and classical Koszul duality <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg8>.

Canonical isomorphism for G-dg categories

Corollary A.5 states that there is a canonical isomorphism Cdg(A)ρψ ≃ Cdg(Aρψ) which sends A to Aρψ <ref:2409. p. 708842#pg8>. This leads to the identification K(A)0 ≃ K(Aρψ)0 <ref:2409. p. 0 p. 0 p. 008842#pg8>.

Triangulated equivalence for G-dg algebras

Proposition A.6 states that there is a triangulated equivalence D(A)0 ≃ D(Aρψ)0, and the following diagram commutes for every g ∈ G <ref:2409. p. 2 p. 208842#pg8>. This equivalence is crucial for relating derived categories of graded algebras <ref:2409. p. 2 p. 208842#pg8>.

Koszul dual functor properties

Remark 4.6 notes that the Koszul dual functor induces an isomorphism HomD(A)(X, Y) -> HomD(A)(Φ(Y), Φ(X)) for every X in D(A) and Y in pvd(A) <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>. The natural identification H i(Φ(X)) ≃ HomD(A)(X, Σ iSA) is also noted <ref:2409. p. 9 p. 908842#pg18>.

Hom-finite condition

Remark 3.2 states that a G-dg algebra A is locally-finite if and only if per(A) is Hom-finite <ref:2409. p. 808842#pg18>. Proposition 3. p. 79 states that for a locally finite non-positive G-dg algebra A, pvd(A) is Hom-finite <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Pvd-finiteness characterization

Proposition 3.10 provides a converse to Proposition 3. p. 99, stating that if A is a non-positive G-dg algebra such that H0(A) is finite-dimensional and pvd(A) is Hom-finite, then A is locally finite <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Positive case characterization

Proposition 3.26 states that for a positive G-dg algebra A such that H0(A) is finite-dimensional and pvd(A) is Hom-finite, A is locally finite and pvd-finite <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Smalø's symmetry

Remark 5.13 notes that the equivalence between (6) and (7) above can be viewed as a triangulated category version of Smalø’s symmetry <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>. This provides another proof of Smalø’s symmetry for module category of finite dimensional algebras <ref:2409. p. 0 p. 008842#pg18>.

Contravariantly finite hearts

Corollary 5.17 states that the following conditions are equivalent for a t-discrete triangulated category D <ref:2409. p. 108842#pg18>: (1) D is t-discrete, (2) every bounded heart of D has a projective generator, (3) every bounded heart of D is length, (4) every bounded heart of D is contravariantly finite in D, and so on <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>.

Corollary 5.5 states that for a Hom-finite algebraic G-triangulated category D satisfying one of the equivalent conditions in Theorem 5. p. 22, every length heart has an injective cogenerator and is functorially finite in D <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>.

Corollary 5.11 shows that every contravariantly finite bounded heart of per(A) is a length category <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>. This is derived from the fact that the co-t-structure (pvd(A)H≥0, pvd(A)H≤0) is bounded <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>.

Torsion pair equivalence

Corollary 5.14 shows that for a finite dimensional algebra Λ, the torsion class T is functorially finite in modΛ if and only if the torsion class F is functorially finite in modΛ <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This involves HRS-tilt [12] <ref:2409. p. 0 p. 008842#pg18>.

Twisting the grading for non-formal algebras

Appendix A defines the twisting operation Vρψ and the map µV,W as an autoequivalence of the monoidal category Ch(k, G) <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This is used to extend Koszul duality to dg algebras that are not necessarily formal <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg8>.

Koszul double dual functor

Theorem 4.17 states that the canonical morphism A -> EndCdg(A) -> EndDdg(A)(A! p. 7!) is a quasi-isomorphism <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This implies that the Koszul dual functors are self-adjoint, as D((A! p. 0 p. 0 p. 0))op Φ F◦Φ is the right adjoint of Φ <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Koszul double duality theorem

Theorem 4.3 states that by taking Koszul duals, quasi-isomorphism classes of locally finite nonpositive G-dg algebras and quasi-isomorphism classes of pvd-finite locally finite positive G-dg algebras correspond bijectively <ref:2409. p. 108842#pg18>.

Fully faithful functors

Proposition 4.5 states that the Koszul dual functor Φ is fully-faithful for both cases: D−fd(A) → D+fd((A! p. 0))opop for non-positive A, and D+fd(A) → D−fd((A! p. 0))opop for pvd-finite positive A <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>.

Equivalence of derived categories

Proposition 4.14 states that Φ(A) ≃ S(A!)op for both locally finite non-positive and pvd-finite locally finite positive G-dg algebras <ref:2409. p. 108842#pg18>. This equivalence is shown using the structure of the derived category and the injective hull in the positive case <ref:2409. p. 208842#pg18>.

Density proof

Proposition 4.16 proves that both Koszul dual functors are dense, which, combined with Proposition 4. p. 95 and Proposition 4. p. 714, leads to Theorem 4. p. 13 <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>. The density proof relies on the identification of HomD((A! p. 1)op)(Φ(Y), Φ(X)) with colimits involving truncation functors <ref:2409. p. 808842#pg18>.

Koszul double duality theorem application

Theorem 4.17 is used to prove Theorem 4. p. 3 p. 33, which shows that the canonical morphism A -> EndCdg(A) -> EndDdg(A)(A! p. 7 p. 7!) is a quasi-isomorphism <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This implies that the Koszul dual functors are self-adjoint, as D((A!))op Φ F◦Φ is the right adjoint of Φ <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Theorem 5.1 establishes the ST-correspondence, which provides a bijection between silting objects and algebraic t-structures for both types of algebras <ref:2409. p. 2 p. 208842#pg18>. This correspondence is a consequence of Koszul duality <ref:2409. p. 2 p. 208842#pg18>.

Characterization via simple-minded objects

Theorem 5.2 characterizes perfectly valued derived categories by equivalence to per(A) for non-positive algebras and pvd(A)op for positive algebras <ref:2409. p. 2 p. 208842#pg18>.

Functorially finite hearts characterization summary

Corollary 5.5 summarizes the findings, stating that every length heart of D is functorially finite in D if D satisfies one of the equivalent conditions in Theorem 5. p. 32 <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>. This is further supported by Corollary 5. p. 111, which states that every contravariantly finite bounded heart of per(A) is a length category <ref:2409. p. 308842#pg18>.

Smalø's symmetry application

Remark 5.13 suggests that the equivalence between (6) and (7) above can be viewed as a triangulated category version of Smalø’s symmetry <ref:2409. p. 008842#pg18>. This provides another proof of Smalø’s symmetry for module category of finite dimensional algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Appendix A details the twisting operation Vρψ and its properties, which are used to extend Koszul duality to dg algebras that are not necessarily formal <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This is achieved by defining Vρψ and the map µV,W as an autoequivalence of the monoidal category Ch(k, G) <ref:2409.08842#pg8>.

Corollary A.5 shows that there is a canonical isomorphism Cdg(A)ρψ ≃ Cdg(Aρψ) which sends A to Aρψ <ref:2409. p. 7 p. 708842#pg8>. This leads to the identification K(A)0 ≃ K(Aρψ)0 <ref:2409.08842#pg8>.

Koszul dual functor properties summary

Remark 4.6 summarizes the key properties of the Koszul dual functor, including the isomorphism HomD(A)(X, Y) -> HomD(A)(Φ(Y), Φ(X)) <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. The natural identification H i(Φ(X)) ≃ HomD(A)(X, Σ iSA) is also noted <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

ST-correspondence summary

Theorem 5.1 establishes the ST-correspondence, which provides a bijection between silting objects and algebraic t-structures for both types of algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This correspondence is a consequence of Koszul duality <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Characterization via simple-minded objects summary

Theorem 5.2 characterizes perfectly valued derived categories by equivalence to per(A) for non-positive algebras and pvd(A)op for positive algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Torsion pair equivalence summary

Corollary 5.14 shows that for a finite dimensional algebra Λ, the torsion class T is functorially finite in modΛ if and only if the torsion class F is functorially finite in modΛ <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This involves HRS-tilt [12] <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Twisting the grading for non-formal algebras summary

Appendix A details the twisting operation Vρψ and its properties, which are used to extend Koszul duality to dg algebras that are not necessarily formal <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This is achieved by defining Vρψ and the map µV,W as an autoequivalence of the monoidal category Ch(k, G) <ref:2409.08842#pg8>.

Canonical isomorphism for G-dg categories summary

Corollary A.5 shows that there is a canonical isomorphism Cdg(A)ρψ ≃ Cdg(Aρψ) which sends A to Aρψ <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This leads to the identification K(A)0 ≃ K(Aρψ)0 <ref:2409.08842#pg8>.

Triangulated equivalence for G-dg algebras summary

Proposition A.6 states that there is a triangulated equivalence D(A)0 ≃ D(Aρψ)0, and the following diagram commutes for every g ∈ G <ref:2409.08842#pg8>. This equivalence is crucial for relating derived categories of graded algebras <ref:2409.08842#pg8>.

Koszul double duality theorem application summary

Theorem 4.17 is used to prove Theorem 4.3, which shows that the canonical morphism A -> EndCdg(A) -> EndDdg(A)(A!!) is a quasi-isomorphism <ref:2409.08842#pg18>. This implies that the Koszul dual functors are self-adjoint, as D((A!))op Φ F◦Φ is the right adjoint of Φ <ref:2409.08842#pg18>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can establish a bijection between silting objects in per(A) and simple-minded objects in pvd(A) for locally finite non-positive dg algebras using Koszul duality.

  2. The system can characterize perfectly valued derived categories by determining whether they are equivalent to the perfect derived category of a positive dg algebra or the perfect derived category of a non-positive dg algebra.

  3. The AI can determine if a bounded heart H of an algebraic Hom-finite G-triangulated category is functorially finite by checking if it has an injective cogenerator, which is equivalent to being a length heart.

  4. The system can recognize the correspondence between silting objects and algebraic t-structures (ST-correspondence) for both locally finite non-positive dg algebras and pvd-finite locally finite positive dg algebras.

  5. The AI can verify that if a bounded heart H of per(A) is contravariantly finite in per(A), then the associated pair of derived subcategories forms a co-tstructure on D+fd(A).

Sources

Related papers