Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation

arXiv:2407.17254 · astro-ph.HE, hep-ph · Submitted 2024-07-24 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The acceleration of particles in astrophysical sources by the Fermi mechanism is revisited under the assumption of Lorentz invariance violation (LIV) to calculate energy spectra and acceleration times as a function of energy beyond which LIV becomes relevant.

Vera: Lorentz Invariance Framework The paper introduces the phenomenological expression of LIV by modifying Einstein’s dispersion relation with a function f(p, m) as E squared = m squared + p squared + f(p, m).

Jocelyn: This modification is expanded in terms of momentum p as E squared = m squared + p squared + X n/δnp(n+2).

Vera: In the theoretical view, LIV is expected to be relevant at the Planck scale, Epl ≈ 10 28 eV.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: So we started by looking at what’s actually in this paper, "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation." It sets up the whole idea that we modify Einstein’s dispersion relation with a function f of momentum and mass, which they expand into terms like X over delta n times p to the power of n plus two two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Vera: That modification essentially introduces a new term into the energy equation, E squared equals mass squared plus momentum squared plus that LIV function, and they focus on how this affects particle acceleration beyond a certain energy scale.

Subrahmanyan: The key point here is that the authors are testing this hypothesis against UHECRs, ultra-high energy cosmic rays, because those particles are the ones expected to probe these very high energy scales where LIV might become relevant two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Jocelyn: They’re using two branches of acceleration: first-order and second-order Fermi acceleration, which they then analyze under this new LIV assumption to see how the spectra change.

Vera: It’s about seeing if this modification causes significant changes in the energy spectrum produced by these sources, especially at very high energies.

Subrahmanyan: That’s what matters because it links the fundamental symmetry of spacetime directly to observable particle behavior two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Vera: So looking at what they actually found in "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation," the core finding is that LIV causes significant changes to both first-order and second-order Fermi acceleration mechanisms. They calculate the energy spectrum and the acceleration time for particles using this LIV hypothesis.

Jocelyn: Specifically, for the first-order mechanism, they found that the energy spectrum shows a strong suppression for energies above a certain break point. That means there’s less of those high-energy particles than we would expect without LIV effects two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That suppression is important because it directly relates to how these sources are expected to produce particles at those extreme energies, which is crucial for structure formation models two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Vera: And they also looked at the second-order mechanism, where the energy gain changes based on collisions with moving magnetized clouds under LIV. They found that the average energy gain becomes two plus two to the three divided by square root of one plus delta n times E n V squared two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Jocelyn: So, for that second-order process, they show it has an important modification to the particle spectrum emitted by the source. Plus, their calculation shows that the acceleration time under this LIV framework actually decreases as energy goes up.

Subrahmanyan: That decreasing acceleration time is interesting because it suggests a different timescale for how fast these particles can reach high energies in these environments two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: When we look at how the authors improved this work in "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation," they focused on developing two distinct branches of Fermi acceleration, first-order and second-order, which are both analyzed under the LIV hypothesis.

Vera: They didn't just stick to one mechanism; they built a scenario that considers both, which gives a more complete picture for how these cosmic rays are produced two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: The improvement lies in using this framework to deduce the maximum energy achievable by a particle in each source, as well as the resulting energy spectrum and luminosity under LIV assumptions two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Jocelyn: They deduced that for UHECRs accelerated by the first-order mechanism, they see a strong suppression of flux above the break. This is a major result because it tells us something concrete about the particle distribution at high energies two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Vera: And they also showed how this calculation can be used to set limits on those LIV breaking factors by comparing it to measured UHECR energy spectra. That’s a direct way to constrain the physical scale of Lorentz invariance violation two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: The potential here is that if we can identify a specific source, like an AGN or a radio galaxy, we could use this method to constrain the LIV coefficients more tightly two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap up this discussion on "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation," the paper shows that LIV significantly alters both first-order and second-order Fermi mechanisms. The main result is that for the first-order mechanism, we get a strong suppression of particle flux above a certain break energy two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And they show how this modification can be used to derive limits on the LIV breaking coefficients by fitting it to measured UHECR energy spectra, which is really important for our searches two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological view, these results help us understand the maximum energies particles can reach in these astrophysical sources and where we might look for evidence of physics beyond standard relativity two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Vera: So, to summarize this paper on "Fermi acceleration under Lorentz invariance violation," it gives us concrete calculations showing how LIV modifies the spectra from both first-order and second-order Fermi processes.

Jocelyn: And the real implication is that by using these models, we can start constraining the physical scale of Lorentz invariance violation using actual cosmic ray data.

Subrahmanyan: That potential for UHECR data to find or impose limits on LIV improves significantly if we can identify a source and select a subset of particles two <ref:2407.17254#pg1>.

Vera: It’s a solid piece of work that connects particle acceleration directly to fundamental physics, and it opens up new ways to test these ideas.

Instituto de Física de São Carlos, Universidade de São Paulo

astro-ph.HE, hep-ph

Submitted: 2024-07-24

Updated: 2024-09-02

DOI: 10.1088/1475-7516/2024/10/029

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 65/100

The gist: The acceleration of particles in astrophysical sources by the Fermi mechanism is revisited under the assumption of Lorentz invariance violation (LIV) to calculate energy spectra and acceleration…

Key concepts

Lorentz Invariance Violation (LIV)
This is a theoretical modification to the standard laws of physics where the speed of light and fundamental constants are not perfectly constant for all particles. The paper models this by adding a term, f(p, m), to the standard energy equation, suggesting that at very high energies, these violations become noticeable.
Second-Order Fermi Acceleration
This mechanism involves particles gaining energy through repeated collisions with moving gas clouds carrying magnetized plasma. When LIV is included, the average energy gain formula changes significantly ($\Delta E/E = 2 + 2^{3/\sqrt{1 + \delta n E n V^2}}$), leading to a modified particle energy spectrum emitted by the source.
First-Order Fermi Acceleration
This process relies on particles gaining energy by repeatedly crossing a supersonic shock wave in the interstellar medium. The LIV modification alters the average energy gain ($\Delta E/E = 4/3\sqrt{1 + \delta n E n V}$), resulting in a specific spectral shape that shows a suppression of particle flux at energies above a certain threshold.
Energy Spectrum Suppression
When LIV is introduced into the first-order Fermi mechanism, the resulting energy spectrum exhibits a distinct suppression. This means that for particles with energies exceeding a critical 'break' energy defined by the LIV parameters, their observed flux drops more sharply than predicted by standard acceleration models.

Terminology

Summary

The acceleration of particles in astrophysical sources by the Fermi mechanism is revisited under the assumption of Lorentz invariance violation (LIV) to calculate energy spectra and acceleration times as a function of energy beyond which LIV becomes relevant. p. 0

Lorentz Invariance Framework

The paper introduces the phenomenological expression of LIV by modifying Einstein’s dispersion relation with a function f(p, m) as E squared = m squared + p squared + f(p, m). This modification is expanded in terms of momentum p as E squared = m squared + p squared + X n/δnp(n+2). p. 2 In the theoretical view, LIV is expected to be relevant at the Planck scale, Epl ≈ 10 28 eV. p. 2

Second-Order Fermi Acceleration

The second-order Fermi acceleration mechanism involves collisions of particles with moving gas clouds carrying magnetized plasma. The average energy gain for particles colliding with moving magnetized clouds under Lorentz invariance violation results in ∆E/E = 2 + 2(3/√1 + δnEnV 2). p. 3 The introduction of LIV into the second-order Fermi mechanism results into an important modification of the energy spectrum of particles emitted by the source. p. 6 Furthermore, the acceleration time tLIV will decrease in the Lorentz Violation framework as we increase in energy. p. 6

First-Order Fermi Acceleration

The first-order Fermi mechanism relies on the propagation of a supersonic shock wave through the interstellar medium where particles gain energy. The average energy gain is calculated as ∆E/E = 4/3√1 + δnEnV. p. 3 The resulting energy spectrum can be written as dN/dE = −(1 + 2(1 + δnEn)) − nδnEn 2(1 + δnEn)(3/2)√1 + δnEnN/E. p. 7 The introduction of LIV in the first-order Fermi mechanism causes a suppression of the flux of particles for energies above the break. p. 7

Conclusion and Implications

The paper concludes that while LIV changes are important for both mechanisms, the first-order mechanism results in a significant flux suppression of particles for energies above the LI break. The calculation presented here can be used to derive limits on the LIV coefficients by using the measured UHECR energy spectrum. p. 8 The potential of UHECR data to find or impose limits on LIV will improved significantly if a source is identified and if a subset of particles is selected. p. 8

Appendix Details

The appendix presents the solution to the differential equation A(E, δn, n)d 2N/dE squared + B(E, δn, n)dN/dE + C(E, δn, n)N = 0 with coefficients given in section 3.1. The solutions for low and high-energy regimes for all orders of n are power laws. p. 5 The transition between the low and high-energy regimes can be modeled by assuming that the power-law index depends on the parameters of our problem N(E, δn, n) = N0E λ(E,δn,n). p. 5 The error function and tanh (E) can be shown to solve this equation. p. 5

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Better UHECR Source Identification Simulation: The system can simulate how different astrophysical sources (AGN, radio galaxies, starburst regions) would modify their particle acceleration spectra under Lorentz Invariance Violation (LIV). This allows AI to predict the expected energy spectrum from a specific source type before observational data is even available.

  2. LIV Parameter Estimation for Cosmic Ray Origins: The system can use the measured UHECR energy spectrum to fit the LIV breaking parameters (delta1 and delta2) derived from first-order and second-order Fermi mechanisms. This allows AI to constrain the physical scale of Lorentz invariance violation relevant to cosmic ray acceleration.

  3. Distinguishing Acceleration Mechanisms: The AI can differentiate between first-order and second-order Fermi acceleration in astrophysical sources by analyzing the resulting spectral index changes. Specifically, it can determine if a source's observed spectrum is better explained by the modified power laws derived for each mechanism under LIV assumptions.

  4. Maximum Energy Prediction Under LIV: The system can calculate the maximum energy a particle can achieve at its source (Emax) using the modified acceleration time formulas (equations 4.6 and 4.7). This helps AI determine if realistic astrophysical sources can produce particles reaching the highest energies observed by observatories like Pierre Auger, even when accounting for LIV effects.

Sources

Related papers