Universal relations in Bose gases with power-law interactions in two and three dimensions

arXiv:2407.06419 · cond-mat.quant-gas · Submitted 2024-07-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Universal relations in Bose gases with power-law interactions in two and three dimensions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions are derived.

Kai: The obtained results are relevant for dipoles, quadrupoles, Rydberg atoms, excitons, van der Waals atoms, and other systems in the dilute limit.

Mira: Derivation of Universal Relations The authors derive universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions.

Kai: They find beyond mean-field expressions for Tan’s contact and establish new connections between the chemical potential and potential energy per particle, characteristic of systems with finite-range interactions.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap, this paper by Voronova et al., titled "Universal relations in Bose gases with power-law interactions in two and three dimensions," focuses on deriving universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions. The main thesis is finding beyond mean-field expressions for Tan’s contact, establishing new connections between the chemical potential and the potential energy per particle, which are characteristic of systems with finite-range interactions.

Mira: And they show this holds even when you consider that zero temperature Bose gases with finite-range power-law interactions can be treated outside of the universal regime. That means they aren't just relying on replacing the real interaction potential with a contact pseudopotential, which is a key point for the applicability of their results.

Lev: The implication for us is that we don't need to assume short-range behavior when we are dealing with power-law interactions. If the interaction decays slowly, say like one over distance to the power of alpha minus two in two dimensions or alpha minus three in three dimensions, this framework helps us connect the dots thermodynamically.

Kai: Right. And they tackle this by looking at 2D and three dee separately <ref:2407.06419#pg1>. In two dimensions, they define the pair correlation function g2(r) universally via a two-body wave function, and then show that the potential energy density is expressed in terms of Tan's contact C, yielding a universal relation between that density and C for power-law interactions with alpha greater than two in two dimensions at any temperature.

Mira: Then for three dimensions at zero temperature interacting via the potential V(r) equals one, they develop the theory of Tan's contact to get universal relations similar to the 2D case <ref:2407.06419#pg1>. They find that the two-body scattering problem leads to a pair distribution function g2(r) that matches with the Bogoliubov expression in a range from zero up to ξ where xi equals E times h squared over two m g n.

Lev: Matching it with the Bogoliubov expression in that specific range, from zero up to the healing length, tells us something concrete about how short-range physics connects to long-range behavior in these systems. It's not just a theoretical match; it defines a region where our approximations are valid.

Kai: And they provide an explicit expression for Tan's contact C, which is C equals four pi na squared over one plus sixty four over three pi p cubed na cubed plus other terms, based on those matching conditions. This gives us a way to calculate that contact parameter directly from the interaction parameters like the scattering length a.

Mira: So what this means for us is that even though they are dealing with finite-range potentials, they can still define a zero temperature Tan’s contact parameter for any interaction exponent alpha greater than two in two dimensions and alpha greater than three in three dimensions without using the contact pseudopotential approximation.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper, "Universal relations in Bose gases with power-law interactions in two and three dimensions," the authors are essentially building a rigorous framework for analyzing Bose gases when they interact using power-law potentials that aren't just simple short-range ones. The core contribution is establishing those universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function across different dimensions.

Mira: What this means for us, in plain terms, is that we have a way to connect the chemical potential and the potential energy per particle in these systems using these new relations. This connection is super important because it allows us to go beyond mean-field theory when dealing with finite-range interactions.

Lev: So if you're designing an experiment, this framework gives you a reliable way to connect what you measure—like the chemical potential—to the energy stored in the system, which is crucial for understanding how these complex gases behave under realistic interaction conditions.

Kai: And they validated their approach by showing that even for a specific case like a one over distance to the power of six interaction potential, variational Monte Carlo simulations showed that matching distances scaled linearly with the healing length over an extensive range of densities, and the difference between their optimal variational energy and diffusion Monte Carlo energy was only about ten to the fourth for a coupling constant g equal to zero point one times h squared divided by m.

Mira: That tiny difference in simulation results confirms that even though they are using these finite-range power-law interactions, the wave function they find is very close to the true ground state, especially when it focuses on describing those short-range parts of the potential.

Lev: It sounds like this paper gives us a solid way to proceed with modeling these systems in a real hardware context because it provides that rigorous connection between microscopic physics and macroscopic thermodynamics.

Kai: Exactly. The final universal connection they establish between chemical potential and potential energy per particle is what makes this work powerful for understanding these various ultracold atoms we study in the lab.

Nina S. Voronova, Elena V. Skirdova, I. L. Kurbakov, Grigory E. Astrakharchik

National Research Nuclear University MEPhI Moscow Engineering Physics Institute · Russian Quantum Center Skolkovo Innovation Center Moscow Russian Academy of Sciences Department de Física Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya Barcelona Spain

cond-mat.quant-gas

Submitted: 2024-07-08

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 18 pages, 2 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions are derived.

Key concepts

Power-law Interactions
This describes how bosons interact based on a specific mathematical relationship between the distance of two particles and their interaction strength. The interaction potential follows a form like V(r) = Q r^alpha, where 'r' is the separation distance and 'alpha' is an exponent greater than 2 in 2D or 3 in 3D.
Pair Distribution Function (g2(r))
This function describes the probability of finding two particles at a specific distance 'r' from each other in a Bose gas. The authors use this function to define universal relations, linking it to thermodynamic properties like energy density, which helps characterize the system's structure.
Tan’s Contact (C)
This parameter represents a characteristic measure of the interaction strength derived from the pair distribution function. The paper shows how this contact value relates to other system properties, establishing universal connections that are independent of specific short-range approximations.

Terminology

Summary

Universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions are derived. p. 0 The obtained results are relevant for dipoles, quadrupoles, Rydberg atoms, excitons, van der Waals atoms, and other systems in the dilute limit. p. 0

Derivation of Universal Relations

The authors derive universal relations between thermodynamic quantities and the pair distribution function for bosons interacting via power-law interactions in three and two dimensions. They find beyond mean-field expressions for Tan’s contact and establish new connections between the chemical potential and potential energy per particle, characteristic of systems with finite-range interactions. p. 0 The work demonstrates that zero-temperature Bose gases with finite-range power-law interactions can be treated outside of the universal regime, i. p. 1e. not by replacing the real interaction potential with the contact pseudopotential. p. 1

Two Dimensions Analysis

In two dimensions, the two-body s-wave scattering problem is solved using a power-law potential V(r) = Q r α. The pair correlation function g2(r) can be universally defined via the two-body wave function as g2(r) = C / 4π squared ψ squared (r). p. 4 The potential energy density u2D is expressed in terms of the contact C and yields a universal relation between the potential energy density and Tan’s contact C valid for power-law interactions with α > 2 in two dimensions and at any temperature. p. 5

Three Dimensions Analysis

For three-dimensional Bose gas at T = 0 interacting via the potential (1), the theory of Tan’s contact is developed to obtain universal relations in analogy with the 2D case. The two-body scattering problem leads to a pair distribution function g2(r) that can be matched with the Bogoliubov expression in the range a << r << ξ. p. 8 This matching yields an explicit expression for the Tan’s contact C = (4πna) squared / [1 + 64/3 π p cubed na cubed + ···]. p. 9

Key Findings and Applicability

The results show that the obtained expressions are applicable to potentials that cannot be substituted by zero-range ones. The authors explicitly define the zero-temperature Tan’s contact parameter for any interaction exponent (α > 2 in 2D and α > 3 in 3D) without introducing the contact pseudopotential approximation. p. 9 They show that the contact coincides with that for gases with zero-range interactions, however, in our case the dependence on α is explicitly included via the scattering length. p. 1 The final universal relation connects the chemical potential and potential energy per particle. p. 2

Summary of Results

Table 1 summarizes the scattering length a, the Tan’s contact C, and the relations for potential energy and chemical potential of the zero-temperature Bose gas with power-law interactions, for two and three dimensions. The results include expressions such as U N = mµ squared / [4πħh 2n(α − 2)] for the two-dimensional case. p. 7 The work validates thermodynamic relations by defining the potential energy density in terms of the contact. p. 1 The study confirms that including beyond-mean-field corrections allows one to accurately connect the chemical potential with the potential energy per particle. p. 0 p. 0 In the two-dimensional case, a more accurate value for the contact C is found compared to that obtained from the adiabatic sweep theorem. p. 9 The study demonstrates that the two-body scattering problem remains relevant up to distances on the order of the healing length in variational calculations. p. 9 The work provides a rigorous framework for analyzing Bose gases with finite-range power-law interactions. p. 1 The final universal connection between chemical potential and potential energy per particle is established. p. 9 p. 9 p. 9 In three dimensions, the contact coincides with that for gases with zero-range interactions, however, in our case the dependence on α is explicitly included via the scattering length. p. 1 The study confirms that including beyond-mean-field corrections allows one to accurately connect the chemical potential with the potential energy per particle. The final universal connection between chemical potential and potential energy per particle is established.

Details of Integration

The calculation of the integral in Eq. (14) in the limit r << ξ is performed by rewriting it using ξ = Æ ħh squared / 2mg n as g2(r) / n squared = 1 + I / (πnξ squared c 2), where I is defined by integrals involving modified Bessel functions. p. 7 The first integral in the square brackets, I3(η), is found to be π/2 [I0(η) - L0(η)]. p. 5 The second integral, I4(η), satisfies I'4(η) = ηI3(η) with the boundary condition I4(0) = 0, yielding I4(η) = η/π [I1(η) + L1(η)]. The final expression for g2(r)/n squared is given by Eq. p. 3 (41).

Validation via Simulations

Variational Monte Carlo simulations are performed for the V(r) proportional to 1/r 6 interaction potential to determine the maximal distances at which the two-body problem remains relevant within a many-body context. These simulations show that the matching distance scales linearly with the healing length over an extensive range of densities. p. 8 The relative difference between the optimal variational energy and the diffusion Monte Carlo energy is only 10-4 for the coupling constant g ≈ 0. p. 21ħh 2/m. This tiny difference confirms that the variational wave function is very close to the true ground state. p. 5 The variational procedure is primarily sensitive to the correct description of the short-range part, which is the focus of validation in this study. p. 8

Conclusion on Applicability

The paper concludes that their results do not rely on the adiabatic sweep theorem, differently from the original approach used by Shina Tan. The obtained expressions are applicable to potentials that cannot be substituted by zero-range ones. p. 9 They explicitly define the zero-temperature Tan’s contact parameter for any interaction exponent (α > 2 in 2D and α > 3 in 3D) without introducing the contact pseudopotential approximation. p. 9 The study provides a rigorous framework for analyzing Bose gases with finite-range power-law interactions. p. 1 p. 1 Results obtained in this work including the new universal relations are summarized in Table 1. p. 0 The final universal connection between chemical potential and potential energy per particle is established. The study provides a rigorous framework for analyzing Bose gases with finite-range power-law interactions.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Universal relation derivation for finite-range interactions allows AI systems to predict chemical potential from potential energy per particle using a formula like U N = m mu squared / 4 pi h squared n (alpha - 2) at zero temperature. This enables predictive modeling of thermodynamic properties in systems with realistic, finite interaction potentials.

  2. The framework provides a method to calculate the Tan's contact C for arbitrary power-law exponents alpha without assuming zero-range approximations, improving the accuracy of many-body simulations for systems like Rydberg atoms or dipolar gases. This allows AI to model complex interactions beyond simple contact interactions.

  3. The paper shows how to match the two body scattering problem solution with the many body Bogoliubov approximation in an intermediate distance regime (a << r << xi). This capability allows AI models to connect short-distance correlation functions derived from quantum scattering problems with long-range collective behavior in dilute Bose gases.

Sources

Related papers