The principle of relativity in classical nonholonomic mechanics and G-Chaplygin systems with affine time-dependent constraints

arXiv:2407.06231 · math-ph, math.DG, math.MP · Submitted 2024-07-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The principle of relativity in classical nonholonomic mechanics and G-Chaplygin systems with affine time-dependent constraints".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We study the relativistic formulation of a classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics and introduce time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints, which are natural objects for the invariant formulation of nonholonomic systems with symmetries.

Kai: Relativistic Formulation and Setup The paper investigates the relativistic formulation of a classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics by following the perspective of moving frames.

Mira: It introduces time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints, which are natural objects for the invariant formulation of nonholonomic systems with symmetries.

Kai: The study begins by considering a rolling without sliding of a balanced disc of radius r over a vertical circle of variable radius R(t) as an initial step to address the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints.

Title and authors: Kai: So the title itself says "The principle of relativity in classical nonholonomic mechanics and G-Chaplygin systems with affine time-dependent constraints," which is pretty dense, but it points to the core idea of merging relativity with these specific types of mechanical problems.

Mira: It’s trying to show that you can apply the same kind of relativistic thinking—like how physics looks the same in different frames—to a system where you have those nonholonomic restrictions and time-dependent constraints.

Lev: What this means for us is that we might find a way to formulate these systems in a way that respects the principle of relativity, even though we aren't dealing with standard spacetime geometry right away.

Kai: It suggests there's an underlying geometric structure on space-time manifolds that can handle these time-dependent nonholonomic constraints smoothly.

Mira: I wonder if this framework is general enough to cover more complex interactions than just the simple rolling disc example they start with, which is a great starting point.

Lev: The paper sets up the foundation by looking at a rolling without sliding of a balanced disc over a vertical circle of variable radius R(t) as an initial step to tackle the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints.

Kai: That specific example helps ground it, but the real meat seems to be in how they connect those distributions in the moving frame, which is described by that relationship between the distributions A t and A tq.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper essentially argues that we can use moving frames to formulate relativistic nonholonomic mechanics, and they introduce G-Chaplygin systems as the key objects for this invariant formulation.

Mira: So the main takeaway is that these G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints are a natural way to describe nonholonomic systems when symmetries are involved, giving us an invariant formulation we can work with.

Lev: They specifically address the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints by modifying the Chaplygin multiplier method, and they prove that the reduced system becomes the usual Lagrangian system with respect to a new time.

Kai: That modification of the multiplier method is a key technical step because it allows them to solve for a specific transformation, which leads into this new Lagrangian problem with a transformed Lagrangian L star c.

Mira: And they show how this works in Example six point one, where the time reparametrization does exactly that transformation into a standard Lagrangian problem with that new form <ref:2407.06231#pg1>.

Lev: So the system projects nicely from the original complex dynamics down to this reduced system on some base space S, which is what they call a solution of the time-dependent G-Chaplygin system projecting to a solution of the reduced time-dependent G-Chaplygin system.

The paper's improvements: Kai: They propose several ways this framework improves things, starting with how you handle the constraints by using moving frames, which they state is equivalent to saying a curve in the original system is a motion of another system in the moving frame.

Mira: That equivalence, Theorem three point one, is pretty powerful because it means we can translate between two different descriptions of motion without losing information about the nonholonomic nature <ref:2407.06231#pg1>.

Lev: They also show that they can perform a G-Chaplygin reduction for the case of non-Abelian time-dependent symmetries using this invariant form derived from Voronec equations, which is important when things get more complex.

Kai: And on top of that, they tackle the Hamiltonization problem by modifying the Chaplygin multiplier method to incorporate a time reparametrization where N depends also on t.

Mira: That leads to this differential equation d ln of the velocity u t dt equals f(t), and solving that gives you a new time transformation z equal to z of tau defined by inverting that integral.

Lev: This transformation is what allows them to yield a Lagrangian problem with the transformed Lagrangian L star c, which is key for finding conserved quantities later on.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, the paper shows that this entire process of using moving frames and G-Chaplygin systems leads to a powerful method for solving these time-dependent nonholonomic problems.

Mira: The main implication is that you can use time reparametrization to transform the reduced system into a standard Lagrangian problem, which gives us a clear way to analyze the dynamics in terms of this new time.

Lev: And if you look at the results for the rolling disc example, they show that if the radius function R(t) is periodic in time, then this transformed system stays periodic with a period given by six point one four <ref:2407.06231#pg1>.

Kai: It’s a neat result because it shows that even in this constrained relativistic setting, periodicity can be maintained under these transformations when the external circle radius is time-periodic.

Mira: And for someone listening to the show, this means we have a systematic procedure—using this principle of relativity in classical nonholonomic mechanics and G-Chaplygin systems with affine time-dependent constraints—to find conserved quantities and solve the system using that new time.

Lev: One final thought is that they acknowledge their limitation: they haven't yet studied the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints in full generality, which means this framework is a starting point.

Kai: So we’ve got a solid framework now, but it opens up more questions about what happens when you push these systems further into more complex settings.

Mira: Definitely. We have to see how this connects with other areas of geometry and physics to see if we can extend these ideas beyond the specific examples they used.

Bošdar Jovanoviˑc

math-ph, math.DG, math.MP

Submitted: 2024-07-07

Updated: 2026-11-07

Comments: 29 pages, 4 figures, to appear in Journal of Geometry and Physics

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 66/100

The gist: We study the relativistic formulation of a classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics and introduce time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints…

Key concepts

Nonholonomic Constraints
These are constraints on motion that depend on velocity, not just position. In this context, they define an admissible distribution of velocities (At) within the tangent bundle of the configuration space Q. They characterize systems where movement is restricted to a specific subspace, such as rolling without sliding.
G-Chaplygin Systems
These are specific time-dependent systems that are natural for nonholonomic mechanics possessing symmetries. They incorporate affine constraints and serve as the fundamental objects for the invariant formulation of these types of nonholonomic systems, linking them to geometric structures in space-time.
Time Reparametrization
This mathematical technique involves changing the independent variable (time, t) to a new one ($ au$). By inverting a specific integral relationship derived from the system's dynamics, this transformation converts the complicated time-dependent G-Chaplygin system into a simpler Lagrangian problem defined with respect to the new time.
Moving Frames and Invariance
The paper uses analogies from rigid body dynamics by employing moving frames to formulate space-time mechanics. This approach establishes invariance by showing that the nonholonomic distribution transforms predictably between different reference frames, allowing for a consistent geometric description of the system's dynamics.

Terminology

Summary

We study the relativistic formulation of a classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics and introduce time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints, which are natural objects for the invariant formulation of nonholonomic systems with symmetries. p. 0

Relativistic Formulation and Setup

The paper investigates the relativistic formulation of a classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics by following the perspective of moving frames. It introduces time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints, which are natural objects for the invariant formulation of nonholonomic systems with symmetries. p. 0 The study begins by considering a rolling without sliding of a balanced disc of radius r over a vertical circle of variable radius R(t) as an initial step to address the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints. p. 0

Nonholonomic Constraints and Dynamics

The dynamics are derived from the d’Alambert principle or the d’Alambert-Lagrange principle, where a motion is obtained from the condition that the variational derivative of the Lagrangian vanishes along virtual displacements. Nonholonomic systems are characterized by a time-dependent affine distribution At of rank m of the tangent bundle T Q, where admissible curves have velocities belonging to At, t ∈ R. p. 2 The dynamics are governed by the equation δL(η)γ + F(η)γ = Xn i=1 ∂L/∂q˙i - d/dt ∂L/∂q˙i + Fiγ = 0, where F is a field of non-potential forces. p. 3

Moving Frames and Invariance

The paper employs analogies to fixed and moving reference frames in rigid body dynamics to present the space-time formulation of nonholonomic mechanics. The invariance of the d’Alambert principle is established by considering arbitrary time-dependent transformations between the configuration space Q and a manifold M diffeomorphic to Q. p. 1 The relationship between the distributions in the moving frame is given by Atq = dgt(Atx) + ωtq, where q = gt(x). p. 5

Chaplygin Systems and Hamiltonization

The system incorporates time-dependent G–Chaplygin systems, which are natural objects for the invariant formulation of nonholonomic systems with symmetries. The study addresses the Hamiltonization problem for time-dependent constraints by modifying the Chaplygin multiplier method and proving that the reduced system becomes the usual Lagrangian system with respect to a new time. p. 0 This is demonstrated in Example 6. p. 51, where a time-reparametrization transforms the reduced system into a Lagrangian problem with a transformed Lagrangian L∗c. p. 2

Natural Mechanical Systems and Reduction

The paper relates the construction to standard methods for time-independent natural mechanical systems by defining reduced metric, 1-form, and potential on S based on G–invariance. The reduced Lagrangian Lred(y, y, t˙) is defined using these reduced quantities. p. 0 The key result is that a solution of the time-dependent G–Chaplygin system projects to a solution of the reduced time-dependent G–Chaplygin system. p. 0

Rolling Disc Example

An illustrative example involves the rolling without sliding of a disc over a vertical circle of variable radius R(t), leading to a homogeneous constraint At = Dt: rψ˙ − (R + r) ˙φ = 0. This leads to the reduced Voronec equation (6. p. 07) which describes the dynamics of the system in terms of a time-reparametrization. p. 2 The transformed system is periodic if R(t) is T–periodic, with a period given by (6. p. 214).

Hamiltonization via Time Reparametrization

The Hamiltonization of time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems requires modifying the Chaplygin multiplier method to include a time-reparametrization where N depends also on t. The resulting differential equation (6. p. 710) d ln(˙u(t)) dt = f(t) can be solved, leading to the time-reparametrization z = z(τ) defined by inverting the integral (6. p. 613). This transformation yields a Lagrangian problem with the transformed Lagrangian L∗c. p. 4

Hamiltonian Formulation

The Hamiltonian function H∗(φ, p, τ) is derived from the reduced system and can be written in terms of the new time as H∗(φ, p, τ) = 1/2(mr squared + I)a(zτ)N2p2 + mrga(zτ)sin φ. The Hamiltonian equations yield the equations of motion in terms of the new time as φ′ = 1/((mr squared + I)a(zτ)N2p), p′ = -mrga(zτ)cos φ. p. 4

Summary

The paper establishes a framework for the invariant formulation of classical time-dependent nonholonomic Lagrangian mechanics using moving frames and introduces G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints as natural objects for this formulation. It proves that the reduced system from a rolling disc example becomes the usual Lagrangian system under a new time via a modified Chaplygin multiplier method. p. 0 The work culminates in showing how to perform Hamiltonization for these systems by employing time-reparametrization, leading to a transformed Lagrangian problem. p. 0 This approach provides a method for finding conserved quantities and solving the system in terms of the new time. p. 0

References

[1] V. I. Arnold, Mathematical methods of classical mechanics, Springer-Verlag, 1989. p. 0

[2] V. I. Arnold, V. V. Kozlov, A Neishtadt, Mathematical Aspects of Classical and Celestial Mechanics 3rd ed. p. 6, Springer, 2006.

[3] V. I. Arnold, B A Khesin, Topological Methods in Hydrodynamics 2nd ed. p. 0, Applied Mathematical Sciences, Springer, 2021. p. 6

[4] A Bakˇsa, Ehresmann connection in the geometry of nonholonomic systems, Publ. p. 1 Inst. Math., Nouv. S´er. 91(105) (2012), 19–24.

[5] Belyakov A O, Seyranian A P, Luongo A (2009) Dynamics of the Pendulum with Periodically Varying Length. p. 1 Physica D 238: 1589-1597.

[6] A Bilimovitch, Sur les syst´emes conservatifs non holonomes avec des liaisons dependentes du temps, C.R. 156 (1913), 1216–1218.

[7] A Bilimovic, A nonholonomic pendulum, Mat. p. 0 Sb. 29 (2) (1915), 234–240.

[8] A M Bloch, Nonholonomic Mechanics and Control, Interdisciplinary Applied Mathematics, Springer 2015. p. 0

[9] A M Bloch, P S Krishnaprasad, J E Marsden, R M Murray, Nonholonomic mechanical systems with symmetry, Arch. p. 2 Ration. Mech. Anal. 136 (1996), 21–99.

[10] A V Bolsinov, A V Borisov, I S Mamaev, Geometrisation of Chaplygins reducing multiplier theorem, Nonlinearity 28 (2015), 2307–2318. p. 2

[11] A V Borisov, I S Mamaev, I A Bizyaev, The Jacobi integral in nonholonomic mechanics, Regular and Chaotic Dynamics 20 (2015), 383–400. p. 8

[12] A V Borisov, A Tsiganov, On rheonomic nonholonomic deformations of the Euler equations proposed by Bilimovich, Theor. p. 4 Appl. Mech. 47(2) (2020), 155–168. p. 0

[13] F Cantrijn, J Cortes, M de Leon, D Martin de Diego, On the geometry of generalized Chaplygin systems, Math. p. 0 Proc. Camb. Philos. Soc. 132(2) (2002), 323–351.

[14] S A Chaplygin, On the theory of the motion of nonholonomic systems, Theorem on the reducing multiplier, Mat. p. 2 Sb. 28(2) (1912), 303–314.

[15] V Demchenko, Rolling without sliding of a gyroscopic ball over a sphere, doctoral dissertation, University of Belgrade, 1924, pp. p. 0 94.

[16] V Dragovi´c, B Gaji´c, B Jovanovi´c Demchenko’s nonholonomic case of a gyroscopic ball rolling without sliding over a sphere after his 1923 Belgrade doctoral thesis, Theor. p. 6 Appl. Mech. 47(2) (2020), 257–287. p. 0

[17] V Dragovi´c, B Gaji´c, B Jovanovi´c Gyroscopic Chaplygin Systems and Integrable Magnetic Flows on Spheres, J. p. 0 Nonlinear Sci., 33 (2023), 43 (51pp).

[18] K Ehlers, J Koiller, Cartan meets Chaplygin, Theor. p. 0 Appl. Mech. 46(1) (2019), 15–46.

[19] F Fasso, N Sansonetto, Conservation of ’moving’ energy in nonholonomic systems with affine constraints and integrability of spheres on rotating surfaces, J. p. 7 Nonlinear Sci., 26 (2016), 519–544.

[20] F Fasso, L C Garcia-Naranjo, N Sansonetto, Moving energies as first integrals of nonholonomic systems with affine constraints and integrability of spheres on rotating surfaces, Nonlinearity 31(2018) 755–782. p. 6

[21] B Gaji´c, B Jovanovi´c, Two integrable cases of a ball rolling over a sphere in Rn, Rus. J. Nonlin. Dyn., 15(4) (2019), 457–475.

[22] L C Garcia-Naranjo, Hamiltonisation, measure preservation and first integrals of the multidimensional rubber Routh sphere, Theor. Appl. Mech. 46(1) (1999), 65–88.

[23] L C Garcia-Naranjo, J C Marrero, The geometry of nonholonomic Chaplygin systems revisited, Nonlinearity 33(3) (2020), 1297–1341. p. 0

[24] B Jovanovi´c, Symmetries of line bundles and Noether theorem for time-dependent nonholonomic systems, Journal of Geometric Mechanics, 10 (2018) 173–187. p. 1

[25] B Jovanovi´c, Affine Geometry and Relativity, Foundations of Physics 53 (2023), 60 (29pp), arXiv:2305. p. 013496.

[26] B Jovanovi´c, D’Alamebrt and Hamiltonian principles and classical relativity in Lagrangian mechanics, Vestnik MGU. p. 0 Seriya 1 Matematika. Mekhanika (2024), arXiv:2403. p. 001114.

[35] P Voronec, On equations of motion of nonholonomic systems, Mat. p. 1 p. 1 Sb. 22(4) (1901), 659–686.

[31] E Massa, E Pagani, A new look at classical mechanics of constrained systems, Annales de l’I. p. 3 H. Poencar´e, section A, 66 (1997) no 1, 1–36. p. 1

[32] Dj Muˇsicki, Extended Lagrangian formalism and the corresponding energy relations, Eur. p. 6 J. Mech., A 23 (2004), 975–991.

[33] Dj Muˇsicki, Extended Lagrangian formalism for rheonomic systems with variable mass, Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, 44 (2017) no 1, 115–132. p. 0

[34] H Poincar´e, La Science et l’Hypothese, Paris, 1902 (French). p. 0 English translation: Science and Hypothesis, The Walter Scott Publishing co. p. 4, ltd. New York: 3 East 14th Street, 1905. p. 0

[35] P Voronec, On equations of motion of nonholonomic systems, Mat. Sb. 22(4) (1901), 659–686.

Conclusion

The study concludes by showing that the time-reparametrization transforms the reduced system into a Lagrangian problem with a specific Lagrangian L∗c. This transformation is valid when the radius function a(t) is bounded, and it demonstrates that if R(t) is T–periodic, the transformed system remains periodic with period (6. p. 414). The Hamiltonian formulation on the cotangent bundle provides a way to analyze the dynamics in terms of the new time. p. 8

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can handle time-dependent nonholonomic constraints by utilizing moving frames, as described in Theorem 3.1: A curve is a motion of the nonholonomic Lagrangian system (Q, L, F, A) if and only if Γ(t) = g−1t(γ(t)) is a motion of the nonholonomic Lagrangian system (M, l,f, A).

  2. Improved system can incorporate time-dependent G-Chaplygin systems with affine constraints by using the invariant formulation derived from Voronec equations: The invariant form of the equations allows us to perform a G–Chaplygin reduction for the case of non-Abelian time-dependent symmetries (Theorem 6.1).

  3. Improved system can solve Hamiltonization problems for time-dependent constraints by modifying the Chaplygin multiplier method, as shown in Theorem 6.2: We modify the Chaplygin multiplier method and prove that the reduced system becomes the usual Lagrangian system with respect to the new time.

  4. Improved system can model relativistic nonholonomic mechanics using a space-time formulation where distributions are defined geometrically: The distribution A can be regarded as the kernel of a vertical-valued one form Theta on Q × R that satisfies (i) Theta(q,t): T(q,t)(Q × R) → Wq is a linear mapping.

  5. Improved system can handle rolling motion over variable circles by transforming the reduced system into a Lagrangian problem with time reparametrization: "A time reparametrization t = z(τ), given by inverting the integral (6.13) transforms the reduced system (6.7) into the Lagrangian problem with the Lagrangian L∗c(φ, φ′, τ) = 1/2 (mr2 + I)a 2(z(τ))N (τ)φ′ squared − mrga(z(τ)) sin φ."

  6. Improved system can reduce complex nonholonomic systems with symmetries to a reduced system on the base space S: A solution γ(t) of the time-dependent G–Chaplygin system (Q, L, F, A, G) projects to a solution Γ(t) = πt(γ(t)) of the reduced time-dependent G–Chaplygin system (S, Lred, Fred, JK).

  7. Improved system can analyze natural mechanical systems with linear terms by defining the reduced Lagrangian based on G-invariant quantities: The reduced Lagrangian is then Lred(y, y, t ˙) = 1/2 Kred,t(˙y, y˙) + ∆red,t(˙y) − Vred(y, t).

Sources

Related papers