Random Abstract Cell Complexes

arXiv:2406.01999 · cs.DS, cs.DM, cs.SI, math.AT · Submitted 2024-06-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: I'm Tom.

Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Random Abstract Cell Complexes".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. We define a random model for (abstract) cell complexes (CCs), similiar to the well-known Erdos–Rényi model for graphs and its extensions for simplicial complexes The cycle sampling, cycle count estimation, and combined cell sampling algorithms are available in the package py-raccoon on the Python Packaging Index Model Definition and General Framework The paper introduces a general model for random abstract cell complexes that generalizes the Linial-Meshulam model for SCs, but may also be used to lift a graph to a 2-dimensional cell complex This model is defined through iterative liftings from d to d + 1-dimensional cell complexes The model RCC(n, P(1), C(dmax)) is defined where the vector P(i) = (P(i)l) collects the inclusion probabilities of i-cells with boundary size l For dimension d = 2 and above, the cells that can be added depend on the sampled cells from dimension d − 1 The relationship to the Erdos–Rényi model is established by setting P(d)l = P(1)2 for 1-cells Cycle Exploration via Spanning Trees The authors introduce a spanning-tree-based method to explore the set of cycles on a graph, which provides a biased sample A spanning tree T induces a cycle basis CT

2406.01999: and uniform spanning trees can be efficiently obtained using Wilson’s algorithm The method allows for the approximation of the occurrence probability ρc = T: c ∈ CT / T of being induced by a uniformly sampled spanning tree This is achieved by calculating transition probabilities using the Laplacian Random Walk

2406.01999: Approximate Cycle Counting Algorithm The paper presents an algorithm to approximate the number of simple cycles in a graph based on the spanning-tree-based cycle sampling This approximation is derived through several intuitions, including importance sampling and subsampling of all spanning trees The final approximation for the number of cycles Nl is given by Equation (18) This allows for the calculation of a desired expected number of sampled 2-cells Empirical Validation and Analysis The utility of the random cell complex model is demonstrated by analyzing its properties, such as orientability and homologies The empirical evaluation shows that the approximation of the occurrence probability ρ˜c is very accurate for sufficiently large n and p on Erdos–Rényi graphs However, accuracy drops significantly for sparse configurations or graphs with a large diameter, such as Delaunay triangulations The performance of the algorithm is highly scalable, running in approximately O(n 2) time Applications and Null Model Properties Random CCs are showcased as null models for evaluating observed network statistics In the context of neural networks, random cell complexes can be used to investigate how far the choice of 2-cells is relevant The spectrum of the Hodge Laplacian reflects the connectivity and structure of a cell complex, with larger eigenvalues indicating more overlap between 2-cells and a closely-connected complex overall The analysis reveals that triangles capture the connectivity of the graph differently than any other polygons The main contributions include the introduction of a simple model for random abstract cell complexes, a general approach to working with the set of simple cycles on a graph, an efficient approximate sampling algorithm for the model, and a cycle count estimation algorithm Future research should focus on more theoretical analysis of the number of simple cycles and higher-dimensional cells The approach to explore the cycle space using spanning trees is applicable beyond higher-order networks The work provides groundwork for synthetic input data and null models for multiple purposes References

Paper summary: Tom: So wrapping up the Random Abstract Cell Complexes paper, the main points are that they introduced a simple model for these abstract cell complexes <ref:2406.01999#pg1>. They also gave us a general approach to working with simple cycles on a graph and an efficient approximate sampling algorithm <ref:2406.01999#pg3>.

Jane: I think the real implication is that we now have tools to generate these random cell complexes, and then we can use them as null models for evaluating observed network statistics, particularly in neural networks <ref:2406.01999#pg3>.

Lu: The work provides a foundation for synthetic input data and null models that can be used for multiple purposes <ref:2406.01999#pg1>.

Meng: For deployment, the efficiency of the sampling algorithm, running in O of n squared time, means we have something that’s scalable enough to run on some large systems <ref:2406.01999#pg3>.

Tom: It really is about providing a way to study how the choice of two-cells impacts network structure, which is a key question in neural network research <ref:2406.01999#pg3>.

Jane: The authors Hoppe and Schaub’s work sets up the groundwork for studying these richer models for relational data that go beyond just pairwise relationships <ref:2406.01999#pg2>.

Conclusion: Tom: So to recap, we’re talking about this paper titled "Random Abstract Cell Complexes," which basically sets up a mathematical way to build random structures for things like cell complexes and graphs.

Jane: It sounds a bit abstract, right? I wonder what that actually means for us when we look at complex systems.

Tom: Well, the core idea is defining this random model so we can use it as a tool—a null model—to test if something we observe in real networks is actually random or just happens by chance.

Lu: The authors build this model by doing these iterative liftings from one dimension to the next, making it a general framework that can handle different kinds of cell structures.

Meng: But what’s cool is that they link this complex model back to something we know, like the Erdos–Rényi graph model for simple graphs.

Jane: So, if you were driving home and you saw a network structure, how does this help you figure out if it’s just random noise or something meaningful?

Tom: It gives us an algorithm—a sampling method—that lets us estimate things like the number of cycles in that complex.

Lalam: My analysis confirms that this approximation for cycle counting is quite accurate when the network size gets large enough and the probability settings are right, especially on standard Erdos–Rényi graphs.

Jane: But they also admit it doesn't work as well if the network is very sparse or has a really long diameter, like in some kinds of physical structures.

Lu: They point out that while this method is scalable—it runs in big O of n squared time—it still has limitations when dealing with certain complex geometries.

Tom: The real implication here is that we now have a synthetic data source. We can build these random cell complexes and see what happens when we test our theories against them before looking at messy real-world data.

Jane: It really changes how we approach testing hypotheses in fields like neural networks, because you get to control the complexity of the structure you're analyzing directly.

Lu: The paper provides a strong foundation for generating this kind of synthetic input data for various purposes down the line.

Josef Hoppe, §Michael T. Schaub

RWTH Aachen University

cs.DS, cs.DM, cs.SI, math.AT

Submitted: 2024-06-04

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 9 pages, 7 figures (plus appendix). For evaluation code, see https://github.com/josefhoppe/random-abstract-cell-complexes

Code: https://github.com/josefhoppe/random-abstract-cell-complexes

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: We define a random model for (abstract) cell complexes (CCs), similiar to the well-known Erdos–Rényi model for graphs and its extensions for simplicial complexes The cycle sampling…

Key concepts

Random Abstract Cell Complexes (RCC)
This is a mathematical framework for creating random shapes made of cells (like points, lines, or triangles). The model builds these complexes iteratively, where the probability of adding a higher-dimensional cell depends on the cells already present in the previous dimension. It generalizes simpler models like those for graphs.
Cycle Exploration via Spanning Trees
This method uses a spanning tree—a minimal set of edges connecting all nodes in a graph—to sample cycles. A spanning tree induces a cycle basis, and by analyzing transition probabilities using the Laplacian Random Walk, researchers can estimate how often a specific cycle is included in a uniformly sampled spanning tree.
Approximate Cycle Counting Algorithm
This algorithm uses the results from spanning-tree sampling to estimate the total number of simple cycles in a graph. It employs techniques like importance sampling and subsampling to derive an approximation for the expected number of 2-cells, which helps count cycles efficiently.

Terminology

Summary

We define a random model for (abstract) cell complexes (CCs), similiar to the well-known Erdos–Rényi model for graphs and its extensions for simplicial complexes The cycle sampling, cycle count estimation, and combined cell sampling algorithms are available in the package py-raccoon on the Python Packaging Index

Model Definition and General Framework

The paper introduces a general model for random abstract cell complexes that generalizes the Linial-Meshulam model for SCs, but may also be used to lift a graph to a 2-dimensional cell complex This model is defined through iterative liftings from d to d + 1-dimensional cell complexes The model RCC(n, P(1), C(dmax)) is defined where the vector P(i) = (P(i)l) collects the inclusion probabilities of i-cells with boundary size l For dimension d = 2 and above, the cells that can be added depend on the sampled cells from dimension d − 1 The relationship to the Erdos–Rényi model is established by setting P(d)l = P(1)2 for 1-cells

Cycle Exploration via Spanning Trees

The authors introduce a spanning-tree-based method to explore the set of cycles on a graph, which provides a biased sample A spanning tree T induces a cycle basis CT [2406.01999] and uniform spanning trees can be efficiently obtained using Wilson’s algorithm The method allows for the approximation of the occurrence probability ρc = T: c ∈ CT / T of being induced by a uniformly sampled spanning tree This is achieved by calculating transition probabilities using the Laplacian Random Walk [2406. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Uniform spanning trees can be efficiently obtained by Wilson’s algorithm [19]. The probability of a certain path being included in a uniform spanning tree can be calculated via a particular absorbing random walk termed the Laplacian random walk [20].

01999]

Approximate Cycle Counting Algorithm

The paper presents an algorithm to approximate the number of simple cycles in a graph based on the spanning-tree-based cycle sampling This approximation is derived through several intuitions, including importance sampling and subsampling of all spanning trees The final approximation for the number of cycles Nl is given by Equation (18) This allows for the calculation of a desired expected number of sampled 2-cells

Empirical Validation and Analysis

The utility of the random cell complex model is demonstrated by analyzing its properties, such as orientability and homologies The empirical evaluation shows that the approximation of the occurrence probability ρ˜c is very accurate for sufficiently large n and p on Erdos–Rényi graphs However, accuracy drops significantly for sparse configurations or graphs with a large diameter, such as Delaunay triangulations The performance of the algorithm is highly scalable, running in approximately O(n 2) time

Applications and Null Model Properties

Random CCs are showcased as null models for evaluating observed network statistics In the context of neural networks, random cell complexes can be used to investigate how far the choice of 2-cells is relevant The spectrum of the Hodge Laplacian reflects the connectivity and structure of a cell complex, with larger eigenvalues indicating more overlap between 2-cells and a closely-connected complex overall The analysis reveals that triangles capture the connectivity of the graph differently than any other polygons

Conclusion and Future Directions

The main contributions include the introduction of a simple model for random abstract cell complexes, a general approach to working with the set of simple cycles on a graph, an efficient approximate sampling algorithm for the model, and a cycle count estimation algorithm Future research should focus on more theoretical analysis of the number of simple cycles and higher-dimensional cells The approach to explore the cycle space using spanning trees is applicable beyond higher-order networks The work provides groundwork for synthetic input data and null models for multiple purposes

References

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Sampling 2-cells from graphs can be achieved efficiently by using an approximate algorithm based on spanning trees, which involves a two-step process: first sampling s uniform spanning trees and then sampling cycles based on their occurrence probabilities.

  2. Cycle count estimation for random cell complexes can be made more amenable to application scenarios by providing an algorithm that allows one to fix the number of sampled cells in expectation, as described by Equation (13).

  3. The approximation of the occurrence probability rho c using the Laplacian random walk can be efficiently calculated on spanning trees, leading to an approximate probability rho˜c that is calculated using Equations (44) through (47).

  4. The cycle sampling algorithm allows for the retrieval of an estimation of Nl by using importance sampling, as shown in Equation (16), where the distribution q is sampled from a uniform spanning tree and then substituted into the expectation.

  5. Null models based on random cell complexes can be used to classify performance, as demonstrated in Figure 10, for evaluating novel methods that infer cells, marking randomness as a baseline comparison against triangle-based methods.

  6. Sensitivity analysis of neural networks defined on higher-order networks can be performed by using the random cell complex model to investigate how far the choice of 2-cells is relevant compared to other structural choices in neural network architectures.

Abstract

In machine learning and signal processing, methods based on (abstract) cell complexes (CCs) are being applied successfully in different applications. However, there is currently a lack of random models, which are necessary for a thorough evaluation of these methods, both by generating synthetic data and as null models to compare results to. We fill this gap by defining a random model for abstract cell complexes based on independent inclusion probabilities, similar to the Erdős-Rényi model for graphs. We also discuss how modifications to bias the model to incorporate more structure can be implemented. The model can also be used to lift a graph (or other cell complex) to a cell complex of arbitrary dimension. The main challenge in this is that the number of cycles (possible 2-cells) on graphs is exponential, and the same is true in higher dimensions. We overcome this complexity with an approximate sampling algorithm limited to 2-cells (polygons) that is based on a recent advance in sampling cycles on a graph. Using this algorithm, we analyze the properties of random 2-dimensional CCs and showcase its usage as a performance baseline for both topological signal processing and topological deep learning. The algorithm is available in the package py-raccoon on the Python Package Index.

Sources

Related papers