Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations

arXiv:2405.09687 · hep-th, gr-qc · Submitted 2024-05-15 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations derives new methods to compute scattering and bound observables for geodesics of spinning particles in Kerr spacetime at linear in spin order.

Kai: Derivation of the Radial Action The paper develops a method to derive the radial action from the first-order worldline formalism, showing how this action effectively provides a Hamiltonian for the evolution of observables which can be analytically integrated.

Mira: The derivation starts with a spinless probe particle in Kerr spacetime using the first-order worldline action (1).

Kai: This leads to the well-known radial action I G r(r) = ˆCG r dr ∆q

EG(r 2+a 2)-aLG: 2 − ∆(KG + m2r2).

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations." Basically, it looks at how to calculate the scattering and bound behaviors of particles that have spin when they move in a Kerr spacetime.

Mira: Right, so the big claim here is that they've developed new ways to compute these observables—the impulse and the spin kick for scattering, and things like periastron advance for bound orbits—by looking at it linearly in terms of the spin.

Lev: So if we're talking about what this means for real hardware, does this linear approximation hold up when we try to run things on actual systems? Kai That's a good question. The paper claims they derived these methods using the first-order worldline formalism and then used a new covariant Dirac bracket formalism to get the impulse and spin kick expressions.

Mira: And they claim these expressions are valid up to order six times the gravitational coupling constant multiplied by one times four times s1 times four squared, which is an O G6 s1s42 error term for scattering observables.

Lev: An O G6 term is pretty high order for anything we try to implement on a real quantum system without massive overhead. The paper mentions that they use conserved quantities defined in terms of incoming kinematics like E bar equals sigma, and l equals epsilon dot s squared.

Kai: It's interesting because they're connecting the worldline action, which is usually just for spinless particles, to these spinning results using a covariant Dirac bracket formalism.

Mira: And they claim this allows them to compute the impulse and spin kick directly from that radial action, generalizing some earlier ideas in the literature.

Lev: But what about the assumptions underpinning that formalism? Since they're working with a probe particle in Kerr spacetime, are we assuming certain approximations about how much spin matters compared to the curvature?

Kai: Well, it seems they focus on generic spin orientations, which means their method should apply regardless of how the spin is aligned. They also use an action-angle representation to figure out the fundamental frequencies for bound orbits.

Mira: The paper computes things like the intrinsic spin precession, which they call K phi S r, and the periastron advance, called K phi r and K theta r. These are related to actions like J t equals minus E and J phi equals L.

Lev: So if we want to run this on a real computer or simulator, what's the practical overhead for calculating all these fundamental frequencies? Kai The paper says they analytically evaluate these frequency ratios using those defined actions, which suggests it's an exact calculation in terms of the action variables.

Mira: The conclusion is that they successfully developed new techniques for both scattering and bound observables using the worldline formalism. They also provide a PM expanded expression for the aligned spin periastron advance in the probe limit up to O G6 N s1s42.

Lev: That PM expansion part is what I'm watching closely. It means we get an error term that depends on how many powers of some parameter we keep, and they are claiming this specific structure for the aligned spin periastron advance.

Kai: So, to put it simply, they've given us new tools to find the impulse and spin kick when particles have generic spins in Kerr spacetime. And for bound orbits, they've given us the fundamental frequencies of precession and advance.

Mira: The real implication is establishing a parallel between how you calculate observables for scattering versus bound cases when dealing with these spinning particles in Kerr spacetime.

Lev: For hardware implementation, the main thing I see is that we are looking at linear spin order effects. If we need higher precision, say to one-loop order, this method might require a significant update to the action or the constraint handling.

Kai: So it's a solid starting point for understanding these observables in this spacetime geometry with spin involved. We'll see if these results can be fed into more complex calculations later on.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is about figuring out how to calculate scattering and bound movements for particles that have spin in Kerr spacetime using a new set of mathematical tools.

Mira: Right, they're looking at how you get things like the impulse and spin kick for when particles are scattering off these spinning black holes or stars.

Lev: And they also tackle the bound orbits, which are those paths that stay around the object, calculating things like how fast the orbit precesses or advances.

Kai: The authors developed a way to do this by building on a worldline action and then using something called a Dirac bracket formalism to get these observables directly from it.

Mira: It’s interesting because they tackle both scattering and bound cases with the same kind of method, which is usually not easy when you introduce spin into the picture.

Lev: The results they get are up to a sixth power of the gravitational coupling constant times one times four times s1 times four squared for the scattering bits, which tells us how precise this linear spin order calculation is.

Kai: And for bound orbits, they give you fundamental frequency ratios like those describing spin precession and periastron advance by defining some specific actions.

Mira: The big idea here is showing a parallel between the scattering results and the bound orbit results for particles with any generic spin orientation, which is a neat connection.

Lev: It sets up a framework for how we might approach these calculations in a way that connects different types of motion, but we have to be careful about what order of spin you are actually looking at here.

Kai: We're going to look at how this specific method handles the complexity when the spin isn't aligned in a simple way, which is where things get really interesting.

Riccardo Gonzo, Canxin Shi

Higgs Centre for Theoretical Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh · CAS Key Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences

hep-th, gr-qc

Submitted: 2024-05-15

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 6 pages + appendices, 1 ancillary file; v2: typos corrected, references added; v3: final version

Journal ref: PhysRevLett.133.221401 (2024)

DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.221401

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations derives new methods to compute scattering and bound observables for geodesics of spinning…

Key concepts

Radial Action
This is a mathematical quantity derived from the first-order worldline action of a particle in Kerr spacetime. It acts as a Hamiltonian that governs how observables evolve over time, allowing for analytical integration to find physical solutions for motion.
Covariant Dirac Bracket Formalism
This novel method uses Dirac's approach to handle constraints in the system by promoting standard Poisson brackets to Dirac brackets. This allows the authors to directly compute physical quantities like impulse and spin kick from the radial action.
Fundamental Frequencies
These are key rates describing the behavior of bound orbits in Kerr spacetime, such as periastron advance and precession of the orbital plane. The paper defines specific actions (like $J_t$ and $J_ heta$) to analytically evaluate these frequencies for generic spin orientations.
Spin Kick
The spin kick is a physical observable representing the change in the particle's intrinsic spin when it undergoes a scattering event. It is computed using the derived Dirac brackets applied to the radial action, providing an expression up to $O(G^6s_1s_4^2)$.

Terminology

Summary

Scattering and bound observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime with generic spin orientations derives new methods to compute scattering and bound observables for geodesics of spinning particles in Kerr spacetime at linear in spin order. p. 0

Derivation of the Radial Action

The paper develops a method to derive the radial action from the first-order worldline formalism, showing how this action effectively provides a Hamiltonian for the evolution of observables which can be analytically integrated. The derivation starts with a spinless probe particle in Kerr spacetime using the first-order worldline action (1). p. 1 This leads to the well-known radial action I G r(r) = ˆCG r dr ∆q[EG(r 2+a 2)-aLG]2 − ∆(KG + m2r2). p. 1

Covariant Formalism for Observables

The authors propose a novel covariant Dirac bracket formalism to compute the impulse and the spin kick directly from the radial action, generalizing some conjectural results in the literature. They use Dirac's approach by promoting Poisson brackets to Dirac brackets to take care of all second class constraints. Classical observables, such as the change of velocity ∆v µ i or spin ∆s µ i, can be extracted by recursively applying Dirac brackets to the radial action. p. 3

Impulse and Spin Kick Results

The impulse and spin kick are computed using the derived Dirac brackets applied to the radial action, yielding expressions up to O(G 6s 1s 4 2). The relevant conserved quantities in terms of incoming kinematics are defined as E¯ = σ, a = √s2·s2, l = ε · s2, and s∥ = ε · s1 − σ s1 · s2 − s1·v2 s2·v1. p. 4

Fundamental Frequencies for Bound Orbits

The paper uses an action-angle representation to compute the fundamental frequencies for generic bound orbits, including the intrinsic spin precession KϕS r, the periastron advance Kϕr and the precession of the orbital plane Kθr. The actions J t = −E, J ϕ = L, J ϕS = S∥, Jr = 1/2π˛ prdr, and Jθ = 1/2π˛ pθdθ are defined for the bound motion. p. 4 The fundamental frequency ratios Kϕr, Kθr, and KϕS r are then analytically evaluated using these actions. p. 5

Conclusion and Future Directions

The work successfully develops new techniques to compute scattering observables (impulse, spin kick) and bound observables (periastron advance, precession of the orbital plane and a newly defined internal spin precession) using the worldline formalism. The results are valid for generic spin orientations and provide a PM-expanded expression of the aligned-spin periastron advance in the probe limit up to O(G 6N s 1s 4 2). p. 5 Future work is suggested on extracting observables from recent higher spin amplitude calculations and extending results to 1SF order. p. 5 The paper establishes a parallel between observables for the scattering and bound case for generic spin orientations. p. 5

TABLE I

Type of observable Position space Spin space

Scattering ∆v µ 1(∆ϕ, ∆θ) ∆s µ 1Bound Kϕr, Kθr KϕS r.

Appendix A

In this appendix, we prove the formula for extracting momentum deflection from the scattering radial action in the case of a spinless probe in Kerr background. The proof involves deriving relations for the scattering angles ∆θ, ∆ϕ in the unconstrained system and promoting them to a covariant form with Dirac brackets. p. 6

Appendix B

In this appendix, we explain how different choices in the partial wave decomposition of a 4-point conservative amplitude for spinning particles leads to different amplitude-action relations. It discusses the conventional partial wave decomposition and an alternative representation in spheroidal harmonics. p. 8

Appendix C

We report here the explicit results for the PostMinkowskian expansion of the (scattering) radial action I>r in terms of the unit-mass variables E, ¯E, l, lQ, a, s∥. The results show patterns implying a hypergeometric representation of the radial action that manifest PM expansion and the factorization between E and l, lQ dependence. p. 8

TABLE II

I G r /m up to O(G 6s 0∥a 4).

TABLE III

I S r /m up to O(G 6s 1∥a 4).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of scattering observables for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime up to O(G6 s1s 4 2). This allows for ready-to-use expressions for amplitude calculations with generic spin orientations.

  2. New covariant Dirac bracket formalism is developed to compute the impulse and spin kick directly from the radial action, generalizing some conjectural results in the literature.

  3. Fundamental frequencies for generic bound orbits are computed using an action-angle representation, including intrinsic spin precession, periastron advance, and orbital plane precession.

  4. The system can be treated by defining a separable Hamilton-Jacobi action using adapted tetrads parallelly transported along the geodesic trajectory to simplify dynamics at linear in spin order.

  5. The extraction of scattering observables is achieved by recursively applying Dirac brackets to the radial action, which has been shown to recover covariant impulse and spin kick for the probe limit up to O(G6 s1s 4 2).

Sources

Related papers