Novel collider signatures in the type-I 2HDM+ a model

arXiv:2404.05704 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2024-04-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Novel collider signatures in the type-I 2HDM+ a model".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates Type-I Two-Higgs-Doublet Model plus a singlet extension (2HDM+a) as a framework for interpreting dark matter searches at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC).

Kai: The authors present the first detailed analysis of such models with a type-I Yukawa sector, demonstrating how constraints from flavor physics can be lifted for moderate values of beta, potentially allowing extra Higgs bosons (A, H, H plus or minus) to exist even lighter than the discovered 125 GeV Higgs boson.

Mira: The research explores several benchmarks where the BSM states are not necessarily mass-degenerate and details the dominant decay channels and expected sensitivity in Run 2 data utilizing truth-level analyses.

Kai: The analysis incorporates constraints from Higgs-boson physics, flavor physics, and electroweak precision observables.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up on this paper, "Novel collider signatures in the type-I 2HDM+a model", the authors are showing how this specific extension of the Higgs sector can be studied at a machine like the LHC <ref:2404.05704#pg1,Novel collider signatures in the type-I 2HDM+a model>.

Mira: They start by pointing out that previous searches were mostly limited to a type-II sector where all extra Higgs bosons had to be heavy and degenerate.

Lev: This work uses a type-I Yukawa sector, which they argue can allow those lighter extra Higgs bosons to exist even below the one hundred twenty-five GeV Higgs mass if tan beta is in a moderate range <ref:2404.05704#pg1,a type-I Yukawa sector, which>.

Kai: The key thing is that they are not just looking for one signal; they are looking at a combination of searches like h plus energy transverse missing momentum, b bar b plus Z, and ZZ plus energy transverse missing momentum to map out the possibilities.

Mira: They also discuss the relic density and direct detection predictions within this model, even noting that finding a benchmark where those energy transverse missing momentum signals are dominant while achieving the correct relic density is still a hurdle.

Lev: The main implication for us is that this type-I 2HDM+a framework provides a specific roadmap for interpreting any future dark matter searches at the LHC <ref:2404.05704#pg1,dark matter searches at the LHC>.

Kai: It gives us concrete benchmarks to test against, showing where we need to look next in terms of energy transverse missing momentum and other channels.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about taking a specific type of Higgs model called Type-I Two-Higgs-Doublet Model plus a singlet extension, and seeing what kind of actual signals we can expect from the LHC for dark matter searches.

Mira: Right. The authors are looking at how they can use these specific signatures—like those involving energy transverse missing momentum—to map out the different ways this model could actually look in data.

Lev: From my side, it's interesting because it’s not just theory; they are trying to connect these predictions to actual detector capabilities, which is where things get tricky with the real hardware.

Kai: Exactly. The main point is that by combining these different search channels—the h plus missing energy, the b bar bar plus a Z boson, and the two Z bosons with missing energy—they can explore whole regions of parameter space that we haven't looked at before in this model.

Mira: It suggests that even if we don't find a signal in one specific place, these complementary searches together give us a much bigger picture of what the dark matter particle might actually be doing.

Lev: But they also flag a problem with the relic density prediction when you let the singlet Higgs mass get too high, specifically when it decays into those dark matter particles and it's kinematically allowed.

Kai: That’s a real caveat. So, while these searches open up new avenues for discovery, we still have to wrestle with that relic density issue to make sure the model is actually consistent with what we observe in the cosmic background.

Mira: And they predict a very specific direct detection cross section for this dark matter particle, which is about two point eight times ten to the negative forty seventh square centimeters.

Lev: That cross section number sounds quite small, and it tells us how much of a signal you'd actually see in some of those direct detection experiments.

Kai: So, the authors are summarizing all these constraints by putting them into one big two dimensional scan, which shows exactly where the model is allowed to live based on everything we know right now.

Mira: It really boils down to showing that this Type-I 2HDM plus a singlet extension is a viable framework for dark matter interpretation, provided we use this comprehensive set of searches at the LHC <ref:2404.05704#pg1>.

Lev: And they're pointing toward future work where they look at things like t bar t or four t production as ways to probe those less explored parts of the mass planes.

Physikalisches Institut, University of Freiburg · Department of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki · Max Planck Institute for Physics

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2024-04-08

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 47 pages, 14 figures; v3: bounded-from-below conditions corrected ($P^4$ term added, misprints in (3.8) fixed), results unchanged. Thanks to Daniel Puigmartí Molano for pointing this out!

Code: https://github.com/LHC-DMWG/modelrepository

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 84/100

The gist: The study investigates Type-I Two-Higgs-Doublet Model plus a singlet extension (2HDM+a) as a framework for interpreting dark matter searches at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC).

Key concepts

Type-I 2HDM+a
This is a theoretical model combining the Type-I Two-Higgs-Doublet Model with an additional singlet field. It is used to describe how Higgs bosons and dark matter particles interact, providing a framework for searching for new physics at colliders like the LHC.
Flavor Physics Constraints
These are restrictions imposed by experiments studying the interactions of quarks and leptons. The study uses these constraints to show that in this model, extra Higgs bosons can exist even if they are lighter than previously thought, which opens up new possibilities for discovery.
Collider Signatures
These are the specific patterns of particles expected when searching for new physics at the LHC. The paper focuses on signatures like $h+E_T^{ ext{miss}}$ and $bar{b}+Z$, which are key to finding evidence for these extended Higgs sectors.
Relic Density
This refers to the predicted amount of dark matter that exists in the universe today. The study notes a challenge where this density is often too high when certain decay processes are allowed, complicating the search for ideal dark matter benchmarks.

Terminology

Summary

The study investigates Type-I Two-Higgs-Doublet Model plus a singlet extension (2HDM+a) as a framework for interpreting dark matter searches at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). p. 2

Where the paper says it

The latter can be remedied either by introducing an extra scalar singlet that mixes with the SM Higgs [35–41], a possibility which is however severely constrained by the recent measurements of the SM Higgs couplings [42–44], or by extending the SM Higgs sector with additional doublets [45–62]. The two-Higgs-doublet model with an additional pseudoscalar [63–66], hereafter referred to as the 2HDM+a model, constitutes the simplest gauge-invariant and renormalisable extension of the simplified pseudoscalar DM model benchmarked in [28, 29], admitting a host of signatures for DM direct and indirect detection experiments, as well as for collider phenomenology.

The authors present the first detailed analysis of such models with a type-I Yukawa sector, demonstrating how constraints from flavor physics can be lifted for moderate values of beta, potentially allowing extra Higgs bosons (A, H, H plus or minus) to exist even lighter than the discovered 125 GeV Higgs boson. p. 0
Where the paper says it

So far, all the 2HDM+a benchmarks considered by the ATLAS and CMS experiments are limited to a type-II Yukawa sector, in which the Higgs bosons A, H, and H± are all constrained to be mass-degenerate and heavier than around 600 GeV. In this work, we present the first detailed study of 2HDM+a models with a type-I Yukawa sector, which, for moderate values of tan β, lift the constraints from flavour physics, allowing the extra Higgs bosons to be even lighter than the 125 GeV Higgs boson discovered at the LHC.

The research explores several benchmarks where the BSM states are not necessarily mass-degenerate and details the dominant decay channels and expected sensitivity in Run 2 data utilizing truth-level analyses. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss several benchmarks where the A, H, and H± states are not necessarily mass-degenerate and the signatures that arise in these models, some of which have not yet been explored at the LHC. We present the dominant channels in the studied benchmarks and the expected sensitivity in Run 2 data using truth-level analyses and discuss potential improvements in the experimental searches for Run 3.

The analysis incorporates constraints from Higgs-boson physics, flavor physics, and electroweak precision observables. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Further details on the DM phenomenology in the type-I 2HDM+a model can be found in Section 7. 2 Flavour physics and BSM Higgs searches While flavour observables such as B → Xsγ and Bs → µ +µ − place tight constraints on the mass of the charged Higgs boson (i.

It specifically examines the decay patterns of spin-0 BSM states (A, H, H plus or minus, a) to determine their dominant collider signatures. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In Section 4, we study the partial decay widths and branching ratios of the BSM spin-0 states. This analysis enables us to determine the dominant collider signature expected in the type-I 2HDM+a model with a non-degenerate BSM Higgs sector.

The most frequent final state identified is the one exhibiting the highest inclusive signal strength under the assumption of resonant production of a BSM Higgs boson followed by its decay. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The latter effects have been explored in [132, 133], revealing that for a heavy Higgs boson, different treatments of its propagator can lead to notable changes in inclusive production cross sections compared to the case of a BreitWigner with a fixed width, as employed in our article. Consequently, for parameter choices resulting in Γi/mi > 30%, the respective signal strengths exhibit some (difficult to quantify) model dependence related to the precise treatment of the BSM propagators.

The paper assesses sensitivity for several novel collider signals: h + E T miss, b b bar + Z, b b bar + E T miss, and ZZ + E T miss. p. 1

Where the paper says it

5 Search for b ¯b + ET,miss final states 26 6. 6 Search for ZZ + ET,miss signals 26 6.

The results indicate that these searches enable the exploration of complementary regions in the mass planes (m A–m H). p. 2
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, we note that in the type-I 2HDM+a model, larger departures from the alignment limit are allowed [90], which can also lead to new experimental signatures (see e. The goal of this paper is thus twofold: (i) to establish a first set of concrete benchmark points that are theoretically consistent and fulfil the constraints imposed by flavour experiments as well as LEP and LHC measurements, and (ii) to provide a first exploration of the experimental signatures that can arise, highlighting the complementarity of different searches in distinct regions of the parameter space.

Specifically, future searches for Z + E T miss and processes like t t bar or 4t are suggested as avenues to probe unexplored parameter space. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Since the couplings of the charged Higgs boson to SM fermions are also tan β suppressed, the existing LHC limits on H± production from processes like pp → tbH± [99, 100] can also be avoided by making tan β sufficiently large. As a result, the constraints arising from direct searches for BSM Higgs bosons are generally weaker in type-I than in type-II 2HDM models, in particular for tan β values of a few.

Furthermore, in Type-I 2HDM+a models with a non-degenerate BSM Higgs sector, intriguing additional signatures such as b b bar+Z, b b bar+E T miss, ZZ + E T miss, and hh+E T miss emerge. p. 2
Where the paper says it

While these assumptions are well-motivated in view of electroweak (EW) precision observables [89] and measurements of the couplings of the 125 GeV Higgs boson [90], they limit the range of experimental signatures that could emerge from an extended Higgs sector. In this paper, we show that the 2HDM+a model with a moderately fermiophobic Yukawa sector of type I can accommodate a large region of parameter space featuring non-degenerate BSM Higgs bosons, giving rise to experimental signatures that remain completely unexplored.

The study also addresses relic density and direct detection predictions within the Type-I 2HDM+a model. p. 1

Where the paper says it

7 Summary of constraints 27 6. 8 Comments on other ET,miss channels 30 7 Comments on relic density and direct detection predictions 31 8 Conclusions 32 A Impact of gg → h4χ contribution to the h + ET ,miss signal 34 B Details on the signal generation 35 B.

A challenge noted is that the relic density remains consistently overabundant for m A > 2m chi when the decay A to chi chi is kinematically allowed, which complicates finding benchmarks where E T miss signals are dominant while simultaneously achieving the correct relic density. p. 5
Where the paper says it

for ma > 2mχ, the DM relic density is in general overabundant in the 2HDM+a model [27, 70, 81]. Since the ET,miss signatures studied below are generated by the a → χχ¯ decay, this implies that finding benchmarks where ET,miss signals are dominant while simultaneously producing the correct relic density is challenging.

The predicted SI DM-nucleon cross section can reach sigma SI = 2. p. 9
Where the paper says it

While our Monte Carlo (MC) studies consider effects from off-shell BSM Higgs production and decay, they do not account for potential modifications to the Higgs line shape [129–131]. The latter effects have been explored in [132, 133], revealing that for a heavy Higgs boson, different treatments of its propagator can lead to notable changes in inclusive production cross sections compared to the case of a BreitWigner with a fixed width, as employed in our article.

8 times 10-47 cm squared in the studied parameter space. p. 2
Where the paper says it

While these assumptions are well-motivated in view of electroweak (EW) precision observables [89] and measurements of the couplings of the 125 GeV Higgs boson [90], they limit the range of experimental signatures that could emerge from an extended Higgs sector. In this paper, we show that the 2HDM+a model with a moderately fermiophobic Yukawa sector of type I can accommodate a large region of parameter space featuring non-degenerate BSM Higgs bosons, giving rise to experimental signatures that remain completely unexplored.

The main conclusion is that the combined constraints from searches for h+E T miss, b b bar+Z, b b bar+E T miss, and ZZ+E T miss allow for the exploration of complementary regions in the parameter space of Type-I 2HDM+a realizations, which is summarized by a 2D scan combining all discussed constraints. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, we note that in the type-I 2HDM+a model, larger departures from the alignment limit are allowed [90], which can also lead to new experimental signatures (see e. The goal of this paper is thus twofold: (i) to establish a first set of concrete benchmark points that are theoretically consistent and fulfil the constraints imposed by flavour experiments as well as LEP and LHC measurements, and (ii) to provide a first exploration of the experimental signatures that can arise, highlighting the complementarity of different searches in distinct regions of the parameter space.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can perform detailed sensitivity studies for novel collider signals in type-I 2HDM+a models by utilizing truth-level analyses, such as those described in Section 6.3, which account for detector-level effects using the RIVET framework and specific kinematic cuts like ET,miss > 150 GeV.

  2. Improved AI systems can execute sophisticated searches for b bar plus Z signatures by implementing the search strategy detailed in Section 6.4, which involves selecting events based on lepton charges, transverse momenta, and invariant mass windows around the mH hypothesis to set constraints on the parameter space.

  3. Improved AI systems can conduct truth-level analyses for b bar plus ET miss final states by combining signal processes like gg → A → Ha → b bar plus χ chi bar and gg → A → ZH → nu nu b bar plus b bar production to derive sensitivity estimates, extending the mass reach down to mH = 50 GeV.

  4. Improved AI systems can evaluate the impact of various contributions on the h plus ET miss signal by calculating the ET miss spectrum for both gg → h chi chi and gg → h four chi production, determining that including the latter can enhance sensitivity by around 25% in certain fiducial regions.

  5. Improved AI systems can perform two dimensional scans in the mA–mH plane to explore parameter space constraints from experimental data, effectively mapping out regions where constraints from EW precision measurements, such as the bound (3.6) on the rho parameter, are violated or where vacuum stability conditions are met.

  6. Improved AI systems can predict and visualize dominant final-state configurations for resonant production of pseudoscalar A in the mA–mH plane, providing a comprehensive view of seven different signatures that can provide the dominant final state in A decays.

  7. Improved AI systems can calculate the projected values for the spin independent DM nucleon cross section from tree level exchange of a pseudoscalar a, extending up to sigma SI = 2.8 times 10 to the power negative 47 cm squared, which is relevant for current direct detection experiments and suggests they do not impose constraints on type-I 2HDM+a benchmarks.

Abstract

The 2HDM+ a model is one of the main models used in the interpretations of dark matter searches at the LHC. So far, all the 2HDM+ a benchmarks considered by the ATLAS and CMS experiments are limited to a type-II Yukawa sector, in which the Higgs bosons A, H, and H plus or minus are all constrained to be mass-degenerate and heavier than around 600, GeV. In this work, we present the first detailed study of 2HDM+ a models with a type-I Yukawa sector, which, for moderate values of β, lift the constraints from flavour physics, allowing the extra Higgs bosons to be even lighter than the 125, GeV Higgs boson discovered at the LHC. We discuss several benchmarks where the A, H, and H plus or minus states are not necessarily mass-degenerate and the signatures that arise in these models, some of which have not yet been explored at the LHC. We present the dominant channels in the studied benchmarks and the expected sensitivity in Run 2 data using truth-level analyses and discuss potential improvements in the experimental searches for Run 3.

Sources

Related papers