Large N instantons, BPS states, and the replica limit
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Large N instantons, BPS states, and the replica limit".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Large N instantons provide a method to obtain conventional instanton amplitudes from large N theory, which is useful for studying resurgent properties at arbitrary complex values of N.
Kai: The paper studies the relationship between large N instantons and conventional instantons in matrix models and topological strings to show that the resurgent properties of the perturbative series at fixed but arbitrary N can be obtained from large N instantons.
Mira: Relation between Instantons and Perturbative Series The paper establishes a relationship between instantons associated with the 1/N expansion (large N instantons) and those associated with the perturbative series in the coupling constant (conventional instantons).
Kai: It shows that conventional instanton amplitudes can be obtained from large N instanton amplitudes by implementing the required analytic continuation to arbitrary complex N provided one regularizes the amplitudes appropriately.
Title and authors: Mira: So what exactly are they trying to show with this idea? They are looking at the relationship between instantons associated with the one over N expansion, which we call large N instantons, and the conventional instantons that come from expanding in the coupling constant.
Kai: Right. The core idea is that you can get those conventional amplitudes by applying a specific analytic continuation to make them work for any complex number of N, not just integers.
Lev: I'm wondering about the technical challenge there, though. When you talk about analytic continuation to arbitrary complex N, how do you actually handle the things like eigenvalue tunneling that are usually defined only when N is a positive integer?
Kai: That’s a big point. The paper addresses that difficulty by proposing ways to regularize these amplitudes appropriately so they make sense even when N isn't an integer. They show that large N instantons can actually calculate the instanton amplitudes in the replica limit, which is when you set N to zero.
Mira: And setting N to zero, what they call the replica limit, lets them study things like percolation or quenched disordered systems, which is a really interesting application for this setup.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we want to use this for actual simulations or hardware models—say for error correction—we have to know how this connection works when N is not an integer. The paper suggests they do some regularization through a procedure mentioned in the text, like the one proposed in <ref:2403.14462#pg3>.
Kai: It sounds like they are building a bridge between two worlds: the large N world and the standard perturbative world, using these instantons as the translators.
Mira: And they extend this idea to topological strings on local Calabi–Yau manifolds, where it's conjectured that this resurgent structure is tied to the spectrum of BPS states.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what they did, they established a link between the instantons from the one over N expansion and the conventional instantons from expanding in coupling constants. They show that if you use large N instanton amplitudes and apply analytic continuation correctly, you can get those conventional results for any fixed complex number of N.
Mira: But it goes deeper than just getting one set of numbers to match another; they investigate how the replica limit, which is when N equals zero, connects the "parametric" resurgent properties of the one over N expansion to the conventional resurgent properties of perturbative series.
Lev: That suggests that understanding how these expansions behave at N=zero gives us insight into how those standard series behave in their own right <ref:2403.14462#pg1>. It’s like using a special case to probe the general behavior, which is useful for checking stability on real hardware, I guess.
Kai: And they use examples like Chern–Simons theory on the three-sphere and Seiberg–Witten theory to show this connection works in practice. They also look at multi-cut matrix models and topological strings to see how these instanton effects behave when you have multiple cuts or complex geometry involved.
Mira: The paper suggests that for topological strings, the resurgent structure encoded by large N instantons is very closely related to the spectrum of BPS states, which is a really important connection for understanding these kinds of geometric theories.
Lev: If that conjecture holds—that the resurgent structure matches the BPS spectrum—then it gives us a way to understand those singularities in the free energy, which are often where you find information about physical states.
Kai: It’s interesting because they provide direct evidence for this connection using Seiberg–Witten theory and other topological string models. It moves the idea from just a conjecture to something that has some concrete support.
The paper's improvements: Mira: The authors suggest several ways to improve or extend the framework, particularly in how they connect these ideas. They point out that the instanton of the conventional perturbative series seems to actually select the strong coupling region of the large N theory.
Kai: That’s a key insight. It means that those conventional instantons aren't just random; they are tied to where the large N theory is behaving strongly, which helps narrow down where we need to focus our calculations.
Lev: From an error correction perspective, that sounds like it could help us understand which parts of the parameter space in a physical system correspond to those strong coupling regions we should be worried about when designing a circuit.
Mira: Then they talk about how Stokes constants associated with instanton corrections cannot be deduced unambiguously from the large N amplitudes alone because of wall-crossing phenomena when N is finite. They suggest that instead, we should look at the resurgent structure dictated by the strong coupling spectrum of the underlying large N theory, which they call omega strong N instead of omega weak N.
Kai: That sounds like a refinement to how we handle those subtleties at finite values of N, making our tools more reliable for real-world problems. It's moving from what's easy in the large N limit to what's possible when we have a finite number of constituents.
Lev: So they are essentially saying that when you try to calculate these things for actual physical parameters, you need to account for this wall-crossing structure dictated by the strong coupling spectrum, not just rely on the large N results directly. That’s a practical constraint we need to keep in mind when building anything.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up this paper "Large N instantons, BPS states, and the replica limit," they show that you can get conventional instanton amplitudes from large N ones through analytic continuation, and that the connection to BPS states is real in theories like Seiberg–Witten theory.
Mira: And they also pointed out that this structure helps us understand how the perturbative series behaves at fixed N, especially when you look at the replica limit as N goes to zero.
Lev: The main limitation they flag is that because of wall-crossing phenomena at finite N, you can't just pull Stokes constants from the large N results without more care. They suggest using omega strong N instead of omega weak N for that structure.
Kai: So the implication is that this tool can be used to calculate Stokes constants in topological string theory, even though there are still open questions about what exactly controls those Stokes constants near things like the conifold point.
Mira: Exactly. They leave an open problem about what the relevant spectrum controlling those Stokes constants near the conifold point, which is where they feel more work is needed for future research.
Lev: For me, it’s a good tool to get analytic results on those constants in topological string theory near the conifold point, so even if we can't solve everything right now, we have a better starting point.
Kai: It gives us a computational method that connects the two types of instantons and provides insight into BPS invariants through topological strings. That seems like a solid contribution to the field.
Marcos Marióno, Maximilian Schwick
Departement de Physique Thǩorique et Section de Mathǩmatiques Université de Gen࠺ve, Genⱥ, CH-1211 Switzerland
hep-th, math-ph, math.AG, math.MP
Submitted: 2024-03-21
Updated: 2026-11-01
Comments: 46 pages, 5 figures, clarifications and corrections added
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: Large N instantons provide a method to obtain conventional instanton amplitudes from large N theory, which is useful for studying resurgent properties at arbitrary complex values of N.
Key concepts
- Large N Instantons
- These are instanton solutions arising in matrix models that control the large order behavior of the 1/N expansion. They are used as a method to obtain conventional instanton amplitudes, enabling study of resurgent properties across complex values of N.
- Replica Limit ($N=0$)
- This limit connects the 'parametric' resurgent properties of the 1/N expansion to those of conventional perturbative series. Large N instantons allow for the calculation of instanton amplitudes in this limit, providing a bridge between different theoretical frameworks.
- BPS Spectrum and Topological Strings
- The paper conjectures that the resurgent structure in topological string theory is related to the spectrum of BPS states and invariants like Donaldson–Thomas invariants. Borel singularities are expected to be integer linear combinations of Calabi–Yau periods, with Stokes constants conjectured to be BPS invariants.
- Analytic Continuation for Complex N
- The authors establish a method using large N instantons to obtain conventional instanton amplitudes by implementing analytic continuation to arbitrary complex N. This requires appropriate regularization schemes, allowing calculations that are otherwise ill-defined for non-integer N.
Terminology
Summary
Large N instantons provide a method to obtain conventional instanton amplitudes from large N theory, which is useful for studying resurgent properties at arbitrary complex values of N. p. 2 The paper studies the relationship between large N instantons and conventional instantons in matrix models and topological strings to show that the resurgent properties of the perturbative series at fixed but arbitrary N can be obtained from large N instantons. p. 0
Relation between Instantons and Perturbative Series
The paper establishes a relationship between instantons associated with the 1/N expansion (large N instantons) and those associated with the perturbative series in the coupling constant (conventional instantons). It shows that conventional instanton amplitudes can be obtained from large N instanton amplitudes by implementing the required analytic continuation to arbitrary complex N provided one regularizes the amplitudes appropriately. p. 2 The authors demonstrate that large N instantons make it possible to calculate instanton amplitudes in the replica limit at N = 0. p. 2 This relates the parametric
resurgent properties of the 1/N expansion to conventional resurgent properties of perturbative series.
Formalism and Matrix Models
The general formalism for matrix models and topological strings is presented, focusing on one-cut matrix models as a simpler case. The free energy of the theory has an asymptotic expansion in 1/N, which can be computed from the perturbative series coefficients. p. 4 Large N instantons control the large order behavior of this 1/N expansion. p. 1 The one-cut matrix model example shows how multi-instantons can be obtained by eigenvalue tunneling. p. 2
Topological Strings and BPS Spectrum
The paper investigates topological strings on local Calabi–Yau manifolds, conjecturing that the resurgent structure is closely related to the spectrum of BPS states and BPS invariants like Donaldson–Thomas invariants. The Borel singularities of the total topological string free energy are conjectured to be integer linear combinations of the CY periods. p. 2 These singularities display a multi-covering structure, and the Stokes constant appearing in the Stokes automorphism is conjectured to be a BPS invariant associated with the charge A. p. 9
Results from Seiberg–Witten Theory
The study of Seiberg–Witten theory on the SW curve provides direct evidence that the resurgent structure contains information about the BPS spectrum. The Borel singularities reflect the spectrum of stable BPS states inside and outside the curve of marginal stability. p. 3 The Stokes constants calculated numerically match conjectures related to BPS invariants. p. 2
Conclusion and Open Problems
The paper concludes that the instanton of the conventional perturbative series selects
the strong coupling region of the large N theory. The authors note that Stokes constants associated with instanton corrections cannot be deduced unambiguously from large N amplitudes due to wall-crossing phenomena at finite N. p. 2 A main motivation is to provide a computational tool for calculating Stokes constants in topological string theory. p. 2
A Simple Derivation of the Multi-Instanton Formula
A simple derivation of the multi-instanton formula for the one-cut matrix model is provided by taking a limiting case of the general formulae. This derivation shows that the one-cut limit of the multi-instanton amplitude is precisely the expression derived from eigenvalue tunneling. p. 1
Asymptotics
The asymptotic behavior of the coefficients in the perturbative series can be determined by considering the instanton amplitude (3.20). For integer N, this asymptotic formula is verified numerically and confirms that only one term in the r. p. 6h.s of (4.22) contributes. The authors find good agreement between the predicted value of f(N) and numerical calculations for many values of N. p. 2
Open Problems
The paper highlights that understanding the relevant spectrum controlling Stokes constants in topological string theory near the conifold point is an open problem. Further work is needed to know what is the appropriate spectrum controlling the Stokes constants appearing in (6. p. 231). The paper also suggests that the approach of [6] can be used to obtain some analytic results on Stokes constants in topological string theory near the conifold point. p. 2
The derivation shows that the full trans-series for the partition function transforms as the perturbative one through a Fourier transform. This indicates that Borel singularities and Stokes constants do not depend on the frame. p. 2 p. 2 The derivation provides a simple way to obtain the results of [15, 16] for non-trivial multi-instanton amplitudes starting from Pasquetti–Schiappa instanton amplitudes. p. 8 p. 8 p. 8 The results confirm that the Stokes constants are induced by the Stokes constants of the large N theory. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2
The derivation shows that in a Fourier transform relation between frames, the full trans-series for the partition function transforms as the perturbative one. This indicates that the position of Borel singularities and Stokes constants do not depend on the frame. p. 2 The derivation provides a simple way to obtain the results of [15, 16] for non-trivial multi-instanton amplitudes starting from Pasquetti–Schiappa instanton amplitudes. The results confirm that the Stokes constants are induced by the Stokes constants of the large N theory.
The derivation shows that in a Fourier transform relation between frames, the full trans-series for the partition function transforms as the perturbative one. This indicates that Borel singularities and Stokes constants do not depend on the frame. The derivation provides a simple way to obtain the results of [15, 16] for non-trivial multi-instanton amplitudes starting from Pasquetti–Schiappa instanton amplitudes. The results confirm that the Stokes constants are induced by the Stokes constants of the large N theory.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve ability to derive conventional instanton amplitudes from large N instanton amplitudes by formalizing analytic continuation methods for arbitrary complex N values. The AI can now systematically handle
tunneling
procedures that are not well-defined for non-integer N, using regularization schemes like the one proposed in (3.16). -
Enhance understanding of the replica limit and its connection to conventional perturbative series by providing a direct link between large N instantons and the resurgent properties at N equals zero. The AI can now deduce the asymptotic behavior of coefficients a(c)k(N) as N approaches zero, yielding results like (2.27).
-
Develop specialized knowledge in relating topological string free energies to BPS invariants by explicitly linking Borel singularities of the series Fg(t) to the spectrum of stable BPS states. The AI can now interpret the Stokes constants Omega appearing in these singularities as conjectures for BPS invariants, as suggested by (5.31).
-
Enable rigorous comparison between perturbative series and large N instanton results at fixed but arbitrary N values by performing numerical checks against predicted asymptotic formulas derived from trans-series solutions, such as verifying (6.30) for N=2 in the Seiberg-Witten theory example.
-
Improve the ability to analyze wall-crossing phenomena in perturbative theories at finite N by identifying the relevant resurgent structure as dictated by the strong coupling spectrum of the underlying large N theory, specifically using Omega strong(N) instead of Omega weak(N).
Sources
- Peacock patterns and new integer invariants in topological string theory
- A Primer on Resurgent Transseries and Their Asymptotics
- Multi-Instantons and Multi-Cuts
- Exact multi-instantons in topological string theory
- Stability structures, motivic Donaldson-Thomas invariants and cluster transformations
- Resurgent Structure of the Topological String and the First Painlev'e Equation
- TASI Lectures on Large $N$ Tensor Models
- Borel and Stokes Nonperturbative Phenomena in Topological String Theory and c=1 Matrix Models
- Nonperturbative Effects and the Large-Order Behavior of Matrix Models and Topological Strings
- Asymptotics of the instantons of Painleve I
- The Resurgence of Instantons in String Theory
- Resurgent Transseries and the Holomorphic Anomaly
- Resurgent Transseries and the Holomorphic Anomaly: Nonperturbative Closed Strings in Local CP2
- Nonperturbative aspects of ABJM theory
- Non-perturbative topological string theory on compact Calabi-Yau 3-folds
- Mathematical structures of non-perturbative topological string theory: from GW to DT invariants
- Exponential Networks, WKB and Topological String
- Quantum Curves, Resurgence and Exact WKB
- Resurgence of Refined Topological Strings and Dual Partition Functions
- Large N instantons from topological strings
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions