Bandit Profit-maximization for Targeted Marketing

arXiv:2403.01361 · cs.LG, cs.GT, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, q-fin.GN · Submitted 2024-03-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: AI Radio. Generated commentary on the latest Artificial Intelligence papers.

Tom: I'm Tom.

Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Bandit Profit-maximization for Targeted Marketing".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. We study a sequential profit-maximization problem optimizing for both price and ancillary variables like marketing expenditures <ref:2403.01361#pg2>.

Tom: The firm’s objective is to maximize its gross profit, the total revenue minus marketing costs <ref:2403.01361#pg6>.

Jane: Our results are near-optimal algorithms for this class of problems in an adversarial bandit setting, where demand curves are arbitrary non-adaptive sequences, and the firm observes only noisy evaluations of chosen points on the demand curves <ref:2403.01361#pg6>.

Tom: Problem Formulation and Setting The problem is formalized as a bandit-learning model where the firm interacts with buyers from n local markets over a series of T timesteps <ref:2403.01361#pg6>.

Title and authors: Tom: We've seen the setup and the initial results, so now let's look closer at what this paper is actually proposing. The title "Bandit Profit-maximization for Targeted Marketing" tells us exactly what we are dealing with >

Jane: It’s essentially about sequential decision making under uncertainty where you have a fixed price but variable marketing costs across multiple markets, and the goal is to maximize total profit over time >

Lu: The paper formalizes this by defining the environment as a sequence of mappings that take your chosen price and costs and produce a distribution over what will actually sell >

Meng: It boils down to choosing those advertising expenditures c i for each market i, while keeping the price p common across all markets, to maximize total revenue minus those marketing costs >

Lalam: The main contribution here is formalizing profit maximization in this adversarial bandit setting, where the firm only gets to observe the actual sales figures after making a choice >

Tom: They are focusing on two specific assumptions about these demand curves: monotonic and cost-concave demands, which dictate how we should approach the problem mathematically >

Jane: Let's unpack those assumptions because that's where the algorithm design really splits, right? Monotonic means demand for a market goes up as you spend more marketing money but down as you raise the price >

Lu: And cost-concave means that diminishing returns kick in; your marketing dollars become less effective at driving more sales once you spend too much on that particular market >

Tom: So the algorithms they give us are tailored to exploit these structures, which is crucial because it lets them avoid a huge computational headache >

Jane: The key is that instead of treating every possible market combination as equally hard, they leverage the structure of how those demand curves behave across markets >

Lu: This decomposition into local cost optimizations and one global price optimization problem is a major insight, because it helps keep the complexity manageable >

The paper's summary: Tom: So to summarize what they did, they created two profit-maximizing algorithms, Algorithm one for monotonic demands and Algorithm two for cost-concave demands > <ref:2403.01361#pg1>

Jane: And the results they present are quite strong because their regret bounds are linear in the number of local markets, which is a big deal when you're dealing with many markets >

Lu: They show that for monotonic demands, the regret bound is O of n times T times three-quarters log T >

Meng: That linear dependence on n means it doesn't blow up exponentially when we have a lot of markets to monitor in production environments >

Lalam: For the cost-concave case, they get a regret bound of O of n times T times two-thirds log T >

Tom: And for that one, they even found that their regret bound matches what we already knew from other pricing problems without changing demand curves at all >

Jane: That's a surprising result because it means their method is very close to the theoretical limit for this specific kind of pricing challenge >

Lu: The underlying technique for the cost-concave case uses bandit convex optimization methods, specifically kernelized exponential weights updates when the demands are cost-concave >

The paper's improvements: Tom: So what are the actual suggested improvements beyond just getting these bounds? They hint at how they can make these algorithms even better in practice >

Jane: They show that while the core approach works for monotonic and cost-concave demands, the framework is quite flexible and can be adapted to a lot of other real-world scenarios >

Lu: They mention extending this framework to subscription services with memory effects, promotional credit problems, and even profit-maximizing A/B tests >

Meng: It sounds like they’re saying these algorithms aren't just for static marketing; they can be adapted to dynamic things like how users stay subscribed or how a credit offer performs over time >

Lalam: They also show that if you look closely at the analysis, you can actually improve the dependence on T for cost-concave demands from T three-quarters to T two-thirds >

Tom: That’s a small but concrete improvement, showing they’ve done a deeper dive into how time scales with the problem size >

Jane: And they also show that the approach can be extended even if you don't assume perfect continuity of demands, just Lipschitz continuity for non-monotonic demands >

Lu: So the idea is that the core mechanism isn't tied to one specific demand curve shape; it’s robust enough to handle a wider variety of real-world market responses >

Conclusion: Tom: To wrap up, we've seen that this paper on Bandit Profit-maximization for Targeted Marketing gives us near-optimal algorithms for sequential profit maximization in this kind of setting >

Jane: The main implication is that by exploiting the decomposable structure, we can keep the dependence on the number of markets linear instead of exponential >

Lu: That linear dependence means we aren't fighting a massive curse of dimensionality when scaling up our marketing strategies across many different customer segments >

Meng: From an engineering standpoint, if you were deploying this, you’d be looking at how much computational overhead the kernelized updates for cost-concave demands add to your daily operations >

Lalam: The final message is that this approach offers a concrete path forward for tackling complex pricing and marketing problems with strong, provable performance guarantees >

Tom: We're done with this one. If you want to hear more on how these ideas apply to other AI papers, we'll get right into the next one >

Joon Suk Huh, Ellen Vitercik, Kirthevasan Kandasamy

Computer Science Department, University of Wisconsin–Madison · Management Science and Engineering Department, Stanford University

cs.LG, cs.GT, econ.GN, q-fin.EC, q-fin.GN

Submitted: 2024-03-03

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: The Twenty-Fifth ACM Conference on Economics and Computation (EC'24). v3 corrects minor errors in the published version

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: We study a sequential profit-maximization problem optimizing for both price and ancillary variables like marketing expenditures <ref:2403.01361#pg2>.

Key concepts

Bandit-Learning Model
This frames the problem as a sequential decision process where a firm makes choices (price and marketing costs) over time to maximize profit while learning about unknown demand patterns. It involves interacting with buyers in multiple local markets, observing noisy feedback on chosen points.
Decomposable Structure
The core idea is breaking down the complex optimization into simpler parts: optimizing costs for each individual market given a fixed price, and then optimizing the price. This decomposition prevents the regret from growing exponentially with the number of markets involved.
Regret Bound
Regret measures how much worse a firm's cumulative profit is compared to what it would have earned if it had known the optimal price and costs in advance. The paper establishes tight bounds (like O(nT 3/4) or O(nT 2/3)) showing the algorithm performs very well against this benchmark.

Terminology

Summary

We study a sequential profit-maximization problem optimizing for both price and ancillary variables like marketing expenditures <ref:2403. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Bandit Profit-Maximization for Targeted Marketing Joon Suk Huh1 , Ellen Vitercik2,3, and Kirthevasan Kandasamy1 1Computer Science Department, UW–Madison 2Management Science and Engineering Department, Stanford University 3Computer Science Department, Stanford University Abstract We study a sequential profit-maximization problem, optimizing for both price and ancillary variables like marketing expenditures. Specifically, we aim to maximize profit over an arbitrary sequence of multiple demand curves, each dependent on a distinct ancillary variable, but sharing the same price.

01361#pg2>. The firm’s objective is to maximize its gross profit, the total revenue minus marketing costs <ref:2403. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Moreover, markets may have heterogeneous demand curves, each responding to prices and marketing expenditures differently. The firm’s objective is to maximize its gross profit, the total revenue minus marketing costs.

01361#pg6>. Our results are near-optimal algorithms for this class of problems in an adversarial bandit setting, where demand curves are arbitrary non-adaptive sequences, and the firm observes only noisy evaluations of chosen points on the demand curves <ref:2403. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The firm’s objective is to maximize its gross profit, the total revenue minus marketing costs. Our results are near-optimal algorithms for this class of problems in an adversarial bandit setting, where demand curves are arbitrary non-adaptive sequences, and the firm observes only noisy evaluations of chosen points on the demand curves.

01361#pg6>.

Problem Formulation and Setting

The problem is formalized as a bandit-learning model where the firm interacts with buyers from n local markets over a series of T timesteps <ref:2403.01361#pg6>. On each round t ∈ [T], the firm chooses a common, anonymous price pt, and for each market i ∈ [n], it chooses an ancillary cost ct,i representing marketing expenditure <ref:2403. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In this work, we formalize this problem with a bandit-learning model where the firm interacts with buyers from n local markets over a series of T timesteps. On each round t ∈ [T], the firm chooses a common, anonymous price pt , and for each market i ∈ [n], it chooses an ancillary cost ct,i, representing, for example, advertising spend in the market.

01361#pg6>. The goal is to minimize regret, which is the difference between the firm’s cumulative revenue and that of the optimal price and costs in hindsight <ref:2403. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Thus, the firm’s revenue on round t is Pn i=1 ptdt,i(ct,i, pt) − ct,i. The goal is to minimize regret, which is the difference between the firm’s cumulative revenue and that of the optimal price and ancillary costs in hindsight.

01361#pg6>. The environment is a sequence of mappings Dt: [0, 1]n+1 → ∆([0, 1]n) maps the chosen costs and price to a distribution over demands <ref:2403. p. 4
Where the paper says it

An environment is a sequence of mappings {Dt}t∈N, chosen possibly by an oblivious adversary. Here Dt : [0, 1]n+1 → ∆([0, 1]n ) maps the chosen costs and price to a distribution over demands.

01361#pg6>.

Algorithm Design and Structure

The authors provide two profit-maximizing algorithms, one for monotonic demands (Algorithm 1) and one for cost-concave demands (Algorithm 2) <ref:2403.01361#pg4>. Algorithm 1 exploits the decomposable structure by fixing a candidate price p and optimizing costs for each market, leading to a regret bound linear in the number of local markets n <ref:2403. p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 1995), fails to exploit the problem structure, and leads to a regret bound that is exponential in the number of local markets n. In this work, we show that one can carefully decompose the targeted marketing problem into n local cost optimizations, and one price optimization problem, leading to a regret bound that is linear in the number of markets.

01361#pg9>. Algorithm 2 leverages bandit convex optimization techniques, using kernelized exponential weights updates for cost distributions when demands are cost-concave <ref:2403. p. 3
Where the paper says it

To address this issue, we carefully design (biased) objectives that have lower variance and encourage exploration. For cost-concave demands, we use the same decomposition, but leverage ideas from bandit convex optimization Flaxman et al.

01361#pg8>.

Regret Bounds and Optimality

For monotonic demands (Assumption 1), the algorithm achieves a regret upper bound of O(nT 3/4) log T, which matches the known lower bound of Omega(nT 3/4) <ref:2403.01361#pg5>. For cost-concave demands (Assumption 2), Algorithm 2 yields a regret upper bound of O(nT 2/3) log T, which is nearly matching the known lower bound of Omega(nT 2/3) <ref:2403. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Specifically, we prove regret bounds of Oe nT 3/4 for monotonic demands and Oe nT 2/3 for cost-concave demands. Surprisingly, for cost-concave demands, our regret bound matches, up to logarithmic factors, well-known upper and lower bounds for pricing without shifting demand curves, i.

01361#pg5>.

Variations and Extensions

The framework extends to several variations, including subscription services with memory effects <ref:2403.01361#pg6>, promotional credit problems, and profit-maximizing A/B tests <ref:2403. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The firm wishes to maximize its revenue by maintaining a large active customer pool. The second variant is the promotional credit problem, where a service provider (e.

01361#pg6>. These extensions show that the algorithms can be adapted without significant modification, maintaining the established regret bounds for these problems <ref:2403. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For cost-concave demands, the lower bound is ΩnT 2/3 , which follows almost directly from the lower bound proved by Kleinberg and Leighton (2003). We show that our algorithms can be adapted to solve the aforementioned variants of the targeted marketing problem, without modifying their internal logic.

01361#pg6>. The analysis also shows that the dependence on T can be improved from T 3/4 to T 2/3 for cost-concave demands <ref:2403. p. 5
Where the paper says it

While it is natural to assume that the demand is also non-decreasing with these costs, it is not necessary for our analysis. Assumption 2 (Cost-concave demands).

01361#pg9>.

Lower Bound Construction

The lower bound proof relies on constructing a set of statistically indistinguishable environments, such as the baseline environment and alternative environments E(c⋆,p⋆), which have a positive optimal profit <ref:2403.01361#pg15>. This construction allows the authors to apply hypothesis testing arguments and use the Bregtagnolle-Huber inequality to establish a lower bound of Omega(nT 2/3) for cost-concave demands <ref:2403. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Following standard approaches (Bubeck et al. , 2012; Lattimore and Szepesv´ari, 2020), we reduce the adversarial bandit problem to the stochastic setting and apply hypothesis testing arguments to construct the lower bound.

01361#pg16>. The lower bound for monotonic demands is also established as Omega(nT 3/4) <ref:2403. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our results are near-optimal algorithms for this class of problems in an adversarial bandit setting, where demand curves are arbitrary non-adaptive sequences, and the firm observes only noisy evaluations of chosen points on the demand curves. For n demand curves (markets), we prove a regret upper bound of Oe nT 3/4 and a lower bound of Ω(nT) 3/4 for monotonic demand curves, and a regret bound of Θe nT 2/3 for demands curves that are monotonic in price and concave in the ancillary variables.

01361#pg9>.

Key Insights

A key insight is the decomposition of the problem into n local cost optimizations and one price optimization problem, which avoids the exponential regret associated with naive application of EXP3 to an (n+1)-dimensional bandit optimization <ref:2403.01361#pg10>. The design of loss functions fbt,i and bht is carefully managed to induce a favorable bias-variance trade-off in the decomposed problem <ref:2403. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The role of the second term in (6), and γ in the denominator of (5) and (6) is to induce a more favorable bias-variance trade-off in the decomposed problem. An alternative interpretation of this design choice is in terms of the exploration-exploitation tradeoff.

01361#pg10>. Furthermore, the analysis shows that exploiting the decomposable structure leads to a regret bound linear in n, avoiding exponential dependence on n <ref:2403. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 1995), fails to exploit the problem structure, and leads to a regret bound that is exponential in the number of local markets n. In this work, we show that one can carefully decompose the targeted marketing problem into n local cost optimizations, and one price optimization problem, leading to a regret bound that is linear in the number of markets.

01361#pg10>. The paper also highlights that while the proof does not assume continuity of demands, it can be extended to Lipschitz continuous non-monotonic demands <ref:2403. p. 5
Where the paper says it

While it is natural to assume that the demand is also non-decreasing with these costs, it is not necessary for our analysis. Assumption 2 (Cost-concave demands).

01361#pg9>. The regret bound for the A/B test variant is O(√MT 2/3) log(MT) <ref:2403. p. 1
Where the paper says it

, students, developers). The third variant is a profit-maximizing A/B test, where the firm conducts a series of experiments (e.

01361#pg6>. The final conclusion is that the approach only has linear dependence on n compared to an exponential dependence in naive settings <ref:2403. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In this approach, we need to track K parameters for qt,0, and K parameters for qt,i(· | p) for each i ∈ [n] and p ∈ IK, leading to a total of K + nK2 parameters. This is significantly fewer than the naive application of EXP3 explained above, where we would need to track Kn+1 parameters.

01361#pg10>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Exploiting decomposable structure for targeted marketing allows algorithms to avoid an exponential dependence on market count n, achieving a regret bound linear in n for monotonic demands or O(n(2/3) log T) for cost-concave demands.

  2. Utilizing kernelized exponential weights updates with modified loss functions allows the algorithm to explore regions more effectively by encouraging exploration in intervals where the demand function is convex with respect to marketing expenditure, leading to tighter regret bounds for cost-concave settings.

  3. The framework can be adapted to solve subscription service problems by defining a normalized loss based on the fraction of users who cancel, guaranteeing no-regret performance scaled by (1 - maxi i beta i) inverse.

  4. For promotional credit problems, the algorithms maintain no-regret performance without modification because the expected profit is a locally rescaled version of the targeted marketing problem's expected profit.

  5. The framework can be modified to solve A/B testing problems by renaming ancillary variables and setting cost distributions over discrete alternatives, achieving a regret guarantee of O(sqrt(M) log M).

Abstract

We study a sequential profit-maximization problem, optimizing for both price and ancillary variables like marketing expenditures. Specifically, we aim to maximize profit over an arbitrary sequence of multiple demand curves, each dependent on a distinct ancillary variable, but sharing the same price. A prototypical example is targeted marketing, where a firm (seller) wishes to sell a product over multiple markets. The firm may invest different marketing expenditures for different markets to optimize customer acquisition, but must maintain the same price across all markets. Moreover, markets may have heterogeneous demand curves, each responding to prices and marketing expenditures differently. The firm's objective is to maximize its gross profit, the total revenue minus marketing costs. Our results are near-optimal algorithms for this class of problems in an adversarial bandit setting, where demand curves are arbitrary non-adaptive sequences, and the firm observes only noisy evaluations of chosen points on the demand curves. For n demand curves (markets), we prove a regret upper bound of O tilde(nT 3/4) and a lower bound of Ω((nT) 3/4) for monotonic demand curves, and a regret bound of Θ(nT 2/3) for demand curves that are monotonic in price and concave in the ancillary variables.

Sources

Related papers