Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters

arXiv:2401.10123 · physics.app-ph · Submitted 2024-01-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters".

Title and authors: Kai: Moving on to the title and authors of this paper, "Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters." It sounds very specific to what's being measured.

Mira: Yeah, it’s about connecting the material structure—this specific alpha-W and Co60Fe40 combination—to the actual terahertz radiation they generate.

Lev: When you see a title like that, you know immediately they are looking at an active device concept, something that actually generates a signal rather than just studying static properties.

Kai: It's not just theoretical modeling; it’s measuring the actual THz emission from these epitaxial spintronic emitters.

Mira: Exactly. They are bridging the gap between fundamental material science and practical spintronic device functionality using this terahertz measurement technique.

Lev: The authors listed are a solid group with expertise spanning materials science, physics, and experimental techniques like time-domain spectroscopy.

Kai: It’s a good mix because you need people who understand the quantum mechanics of those surface states as well as the people who can actually build and measure these complex heterostructures.

Mira: And that's exactly why having this kind of multidisciplinary team working on a problem like this is so valuable; you get both deep theoretical insight and experimental validation.

Lev: It shows they understand that getting from a material property to a measurable signal requires expertise at every step, from the first principle calculations all the way to the time-domain measurement.

Kai: So, looking at it as a whole, this paper isn't just reporting data; it’s mapping out how to engineer these emitters for better terahertz performance.

Mira: It sets a benchmark for how interface engineering affects spin current conversion in magnetic heterostructures.

Lev: And that's the kind of work that informs what we need to build next in terms of spin injection efficiency.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now, let’s look at the actual summary they provide for "Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters." It boils down to two main things.

Mira: They focus on comparing two different emitter types: the alpha-W(one hundred ten)/Co60Fe40(one hundred ten) and the alpha-W(one)/Co60Fe40(three), deposited on different substrates <ref:2401.10123#pg1,W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) and>.

Lev: So they are setting up a controlled experiment where they can isolate variables like the substrate and the specific W surface orientation.

Kai: They found that the alpha-W(one hundred ten)/Co60Fe40(one hundred ten) emitter generates about ten percent more THz radiation than its counterpart grown on aluminum oxide <ref:2401.10123#pg1>.

Mira: That enhancement is attributed to those Dirac surface states on the alpha-W(one hundred ten) interface, and they are also looking at how that affects the spin Hall angle and the spin-to-charge conversion efficiency <ref:2401.10123#pg1>.

Lev: So, if you want high THz output, you need to engineer that specific W(one hundred ten) surface structure because of those electronic effects <ref:2401.10123#pg1>.

Kai: They also investigated how pumping the laser light from either side—substrate or film—affects the total THz generation magnitude.

Mira: They found that pumping from the substrate side leads to a significantly larger generated THz electric field, which they attribute to interference effects in the film stack being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co60Fe40 layer.

Lev: That’s a practical detail; it tells us how we can optimize our optical setup for maximum signal collection when dealing with these emitters.

Kai: Overall, this summary is telling us that there are specific material choices and experimental pumping conditions that drive the THz emission efficiency up significantly in these systems.

Mira: It points toward interface engineering being a crucial knob for tuning performance here, not just bulk material composition.

Lev: So we’re seeing a clear path: engineer the interface structure to leverage those electronic states, and then optimize your optical pumping strategy based on where you are doing the experiment.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper also outlines several ways they suggest future improvements to their research. One major suggestion is clarifying the difference between the surface states.

Mira: They suggest using first principle calculations to distinguish between Dirac-type surface states in different crystallographic planes, specifically noting that the alpha-W(one) states are only linear very close to the Gamma point, compared to W(one hundred ten) <ref:2401.10123#pg1>.

Lev: That’s important because if those surface state properties are different, it means you can predict which orientation will give you better spin Hall angle performance.

Kai: They also emphasize assessing the importance of interface quality by quantifying its effect on spin transfer efficiency by looking at the spinmixing conductance.

Mira: This is a critical parameter because they show that the spinmixing conductance is enhanced in the presence of interface intermixing, which confirms that intermixing is beneficial for our goal.

Lev: That gives us a concrete metric to use when designing our next layers; we need to ensure we aren't just aiming for perfect atomic flatness if intermixing helps us.

Kai: And they also touch on how substrate choice matters by comparing Al2O3 and MgO, noting that the emitted W/CoFe THz electric field amplitude is of similar magnitude even when switching substrates.

Mira: So, despite the substrate choice, the core physics seems robust enough to yield a comparable result for these specific emitter types.

Lev: That suggests that while substrate effects exist, controlling the interface directly is still the most important factor for maximizing performance in this context.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up our discussion on "Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters," these findings give us a clear picture of what drives the THz output.

Mira: We learned that the alpha-W(one hundred ten)/Co60Fe40(one hundred ten) emitter is about ten percent better, and that this is tied to those Dirac surface states on the W(one hundred ten) interface <ref:2401.10123#pg1>.

Lev: And we know that the key mechanism for enhancement involves atomic intermixing at the W/CoFe interface making it more transparent to spin current.

Kai: Plus, they confirmed that pumping from the substrate side gives a larger signal, which is due to laser light interference in the stack absorbing in the Co60Fe40 layer.

Mira: This work solidifies that precise control over atomic-scale interface quality and knowing your optical pumping direction are both necessary for optimizing spin-to-charge conversion.

Lev: For us working on error correction, it means we need to focus on building interfaces where the spin mixing conductance is maximized, and that’s a very tangible goal.

Kai: It's a lot of tuning involved in getting these emitters to perform well across different material choices.

Mira: Exactly. The full picture from "Terahertz emission from alpha-W/CoFe epitaxial spintronic emitters" shows us exactly what we need to engineer for better performance in spintronic THz applications.

Venkatesh Mottamchetty, Rimantas Brucas, Anna L. Ravensburg, Renan Maciel, Danny Thonig, Jürgen Henk, Rahul Gupta, Arne Roos, К Cheuk Wai Tai, У Vassilios Kapaklis and Peter Svedlindh

Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Uppsala University · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University · School of Science and Technology, Orebro University · Institut für Physik, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg · Department of Physics, University of Gothenburg · Department of Materials and Environmental Chemistry, Stockholm University

physics.app-ph

Submitted: 2024-01-18

Updated: 2026-11-17

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Terahertz emission from epitaxial α-W/CoFe spintronic emitters is reported, showing efficient THz generation in epitaxial α-W/Co60Fe40 spintronic emitters The generated THz radiation is about 10%…

Key concepts

Spintronic THz Emitter (STE)
An STE is a magnetic heterostructure combining a heavy metal (like tungsten) and a ferromagnetic material. When pulsed with laser light, it generates an ultrafast spin current that converts into detectable THz radiation through effects like the inverse spin Hall effect.
Spin Hall Angle ($ heta_{SHE}$)
This parameter measures the efficiency of converting a generated spin current ($j_s$) into a charge current ($j_c$) via the inverse spin Hall effect. A larger $ heta_{SHE}$ means more efficient conversion of spin information into measurable electrical signals, directly impacting THz emission.
Interface Intermixing
This refers to the presence of a few atomic layers where the W and CoFe materials are mixed at their boundary. Calculations show that this intermixing enhances the spin-mixing conductance, making the interface more transparent to spin currents and boosting THz emission.
Dirac Surface States
These are specific electronic states predicted for certain crystal planes of tungsten (like W(110)). These surface states are crucial because they are believed to directly influence the spin Hall angle and thus affect how efficiently the STE converts spin into charge current.

Terminology

Summary

Terahertz emission from epitaxial α-W/CoFe spintronic emitters is reported, showing efficient THz generation in epitaxial α-W/Co60Fe40 spintronic emitters The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) emitter, which might be linked to a difference in Dirac surface states appearing in α-W(110) and α-W(001) Our results also reveal that the generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side

Emitter Investigation

Two types of emitters were investigated, namely epitaxial α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) and αW(001)/Co60Fe40(001) deposited on single crystalline Al2O3(11¯20) and MgO(001) substrates A strong motivation for choosing these substrates is that they provide two different interfaces for tungsten, namely α-W (110) in case of Al2O3 (11¯20) and α-W (001) in case of MgO (001) It has been shown that the α-W(110) interface exhibits Dirac-type surface states This is believed to have a direct impact on the spin Hall angle and therefore also on the spin-to-charge conversion of the STE

Interface Effects and Spin Current

The enhanced THz emission for the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) emitter is likely a result of an ˚Angstr¨om-scale scattering region at the interface consisting of a few atomic composite layers as described in the first-principles calculations This enhancement is attributed to the presence of ˚Angstr¨om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface, which makes it more transparent to the spin current First-principle calculations show that the spinmixing conductance is enhanced in the presence of interface intermixing

Measurement Conditions and Optical Effects

The generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side, which is explained by a larger part of the laser light due to interference effects in the film stack being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co60Fe40 layer in this measurement configuration The difference between measurement orientations arises because light beams reflected from two surfaces of the substrate are non-coherent and are not subject to interference effects, whereas on the film side, interference occurs between multiply reflected beams due to the thin aluminium-oxide cap

Comparison with Reference Systems

A comparison with a reference Fe/Pt STE shows that the emitted W/CoFe THz electric field amplitude is of similar magnitude It is also noted that light scattering at the substrate back surface may suppress the amplitude of the emitted THz electric field by increased absorption of the laser light in the substrate

X-ray Reflectivity Analysis

X-ray reflectivity (XRR) measurements were utilized to quantify various parameters, including layer thickness and interface roughness for all emitters The estimated values of layer thicknesses and both interface roughnesses for all emitters are presented in Tables ST1-ST4

Conclusion on Absorption Mechanism

Both the calculated results and the experimental results indicate that the absorptance is higher when light is incident from the substrate side The trend of increased absorptance with film thickness of the CoFe layer is also consistent with expectations The absorption mechanism within the two metallic layers is likely similar due to the similarity of optical constants for W, Co, and Fe Both calculated and experimental results indicate that absorptance is higher when light is incident from the substrate side The trend with varied input parameters is consistent with experimental results, even though calculations do not take light scattering into account

Final Summary of Findings

To summarize, this work provides direct evidence of THz emission in epitaxial α-W/Co60Fe40 spintronic emitters The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) emitter, which might be linked to a difference in Dirac surface states appearing in α-W(110) and α-W(001) Even if an explanation based on a difference in surface electronic structure cannot be ruled out, the more likely explanation is that the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) interface is more transparent to the spin current due to the presence of ˚Angstr¨om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface Our results also reveal that the generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side Measurements of reflectance and transmittance spectra as well as Fresnel calculations for the studied film stacks show that this can be explained by a larger part of the laser light being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co60Fe40 layer in this measurement configuration due to interference effects The emitted W/CoFe THz electric field amplitude is of similar magnitude when compared to a reference Fe/Pt STE It is also worth noting that light scattering at the substrate back surface may suppress the amplitude of the emitted THz electric field by increased absorption of the laser light in the substrate The paper is supported by Swedish Research Council, Olle Engkvists Stiftelse, and Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft

--- Page 1 ---

Venkatesh Mottamchetty,1, 2 Rimantas Brucas,1 Anna L. Ravensburg,2 Renan Maciel,2 Danny Thonig,3, 2 J¨urgen Henk,4 Rahul Gupta,5 Arne Roos,1 Cheuk Wai Tai,6 Vassilios Kapaklis,2 and Peter Svedlindh1 Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Uppsala University Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University School of Science and Technology, Orebro University Institut f¨ur Physik, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg Department of Physics, University of Gothenburg Department of Materials and Environmental Chemistry, Stockholm University (Dated: October 11, 2024) We report efficient terahertz (THz) generation in epitaxial α-W/Co60Fe40 spintronic emitters Two types of emitters have been investigated; epitaxial α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) and αW(001)/Co60Fe40(3) deposited on single crystalline Al2O3(1¯2) and MgO(573) substrates, respectively First principle calculations of the electronic band structure at the W(001) surface reveal Dirac-type surface states, similar to that reported previously for the W(110) surface The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(3) grown on single crystalline Al2O3(1¯2), which is explained by the fact that the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(3) interface for this emitter is more transparent to the spin current due to the presence of ˚Angstr¨om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface Our results also reveal that the generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side, which is explained by a larger part of the laser light due to interference effects in the film stack being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co60Fe40 layer in this measurement configuration

--- Page 2 ---

I. INTRODUCTION

Terahertz (THz) radiation is typically defined from 0.3 to 30 THz of the electromagnetic spectrum corresponding to a wavelength range of 1 mm to 10 µm This has limited its use despite of a large number of possible applications [1–3] A more recent technique builds on the spin degree of freedom in magnetic heterostructures [14–16] A magnetic heterostructure generating THz radiation, referred to as a spintronic THz emitter (STE), typically consists of a heavy metal (HM) with strong spin-orbit interaction and a ferromagnetic (FM) material It is well established that a femto-second laser pulse leads to a demagnetization process of the FM layer and the generation of an ultrafast superdiffusive spin current (js) [17, 18] The transfer of spin current across the FM/HM interface will via the inverse spin Hall effect (ISHE) [19] or the inverse Rashba-Edelstein effect (IREE) [20] generate a transient charge current (jc) in the HM layer that emits THz radiation Critical parameters for the emission of THz radiation are the spin-to-charge conversion efficiency characterized by the spin Hall angle (θSHE) of the HM, θSHE = js/jc, and the transparency of the FM/HM interface characterized by the effective spin-mixing conductance (g↑↓ef f) of the interface [21–23]

Spin Current Generation Mechanism

A femto-second laser pulse leads to a demagnetization process of the FM layer and the generation of an ultrafast superdiffusive spin current (js) The transfer of spin current across the FM/HM interface will via the inverse spin Hall effect (ISHE) [19] or the inverse Rashba-Edelstein effect (IREE) [20] generate a transient charge current (jc) in the HM layer that emits THz radiation

Critical Emission Parameters

Critical parameters for the emission of THz radiation are characterized by two main factors 1. The spin Hall angle (θSHE) of the HM, defined as θSHE = js/jc 2. p. 0

Where the paper says it

se THz radiation. Critical parameters for the emission of THz radiation are the spin-to-charge conversion efficiency characterized by the spin Hall angle (θSHE) of the HM, θSHE = js/jc, and the transparency of the FM/HM interface characterized by the effective spin-mixing conductance (g ↑↓ ef f ) of the interface [21–23].

The transparency of the FM/HM interface characterized by the effective spin-mixing conductance (g↑↓ef f) of the interface

Tungsten Phase Properties

Tungsten may crystallize in the ground-state α-W A2 phase or in the metastable β-W A15 phase The high-resistivity β-W phase has been reported to exhibit a giant SHE with a spin Hall angle θSHE ∼ −0.3 to −0.4 In contrast, the low-resistivity α-W phase exhibits a more modest value of the spin Hall angle (θSHE ∼ −0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Interestingly, the high-resistivity β-W phase (ρ ∼ 150 − 300 µΩcm) has been reported to exhibit a giant SHE with a spin Hall angle θSHE ∼ −0. 4 [25–27], while the lowresistivity α-W phase (ρ ∼ 20 µΩcm) exhibits a more modest value of the spin Hall angle (θSHE ∼ −0.

07) The difference in spin Hall angle is a combined effect of the spin Hall conductivity and the much larger resistivity of the β-W phase

Surface States and Electronic Structure

Ab initio calculations have revealed that Dirac fermions appearing in the β-W phase are important to understand its giant spin Hall effect The presence of topological surface states in tungsten was first predicted by Thonig et al. [30] for the α-W phase These surface states predominately appear in certain crystallographic planes

Interface Sensitivity

The α-W(110) interface exhibits Dirac-type surface states, which is believed to have a direct impact on the spin Hall angle and therefore also on the spin-to-charge conversion of the STE It is motivated to investigate if the two interfaces are different in this respect and if there are other interface related properties that may affect emission

Growth Methods

Magnetic heterostructures were deposited on single crystalline Al2O3 (11¯20) and MgO (001) substrates using direct current (dc) magnetron sputtering The W growth temperature was optimized with respect to W layering and crystal quality, yielding 843(2) K for single W layers

Characterization Techniques

A THz time-domain spectrometer was employed to measure the THz emission from the W/CoFe heterostructures Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning TEM (STEM) were performed to obtain information on atomic species and thickness X-ray reflectometry (XRR) and diffraction (XRD) were carried out to quantify layer thicknesses and interface roughness

Optical Property Measurement

To determine the optical absorptance of the investigated film stacks, reflectance (R) and transmittance (T) spectra were measured using an integrated sphere The absorptance was then calculated as A = 1 − R − T

Surface Band Structure Simulation

The spectral function of the surface band structure was simulated by density functional relativistic multiple scattering theory This simulation accounts for relativistic effects by solving the Dirac equation and models the surface using a semi-infinite geometry within the layer-KKR scheme

Spin Texture Description

The spin texture exhibits characteristics of Rashba type, governed by both point group symmetry and timereversal symmetry Specifically, the spin lies in-plane and is perpendicular to the wave vector k, which is often referred to as the ’Rashba component’ Near the Dirac point, the spin polarization reaches 30% (in absolute terms), which is below that of topological insulator Bi2Te3 about 60% The Chern number, determined by the number of topological surface states, is the same for both W(001) and W(110) surfaces

Conclusion on Interface Quality

Based on high-resolution HAADF-STEM images, the enhanced THz electric field amplitude for the STE grown on the Al2O3 (11¯20) substrate is likely a result of an ˚Angstr¨om-scale scattering region at the interface consisting of a few atomic composite layers This suggests that interface intermixing enhances THz emission and is important for spin-to-charge conversion

--- Page 3 ---

FIG. 1. HRTEM and high-resolution HAADF-STEM images of W/CoFe layers in (a,c) Al2O3 and (b,d) MgO substrate, respectively The estimated thicknesses of the W and CoFe layers are 3. p. 3

Where the paper says it

HRTEM and high-resolution HAADF-STEM images of W/CoFe layers in (a,c) Al2O3 and (b,d) MgO substrate, respectively. Inset: overall FFT of the HRTEM image.

2 nm and 3.4 nm on the Al2O3 substrate and 3. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) grown on single crystalline Al2O3(11¯20), which is explained by the fact that the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) interface for this emitter is more transparent to the spin current due to the presence of ˚Angstr¨om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface. Our results also reveal that the generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side, which is explained by a larger part of the laser light due to interference effects in the film stack being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co60Fe40 layer in this measurement configuration.

2 nm and 3.2 nm on the MgO substrate, respectively The EDS maps confirm that the element distributions are confined in each layer High-resolution HAADF-STEM images illustrate the epitaxial relationship between substrate and layers by the alignment of lattice planes In the case of the MgO substrate, the interface between W and CoFe layers is atomically flat, while a few atomic layers intermixing at the interface is observed for the Al2O3 substrate The asymmetric contrasts of different lattice fringes indicate a slight but detectable crystallographic misorientation from the zone axis By contrast, the interface in the film deposited on MgO exhibits more localized bright/dark contrasts indicating local strain, where distortion of lattice fringes and edge dislocations are expected

--- Page 4 ---

Figure 2(a) shows the generated THz electric field in time domain for W/CoFe STEs deposited on Al2O3 (11¯20) and MgO (001) substrates when pumping from the substrate side Note that the polarity of the THz waveform is reversed when reversing the magnetization direction while keeping the pumping side the same Thus, the THz emission is clearly of magnetic origin Figure 2(b) shows the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude for MgO/W(3)/CoFe(2.5)/Al2O3(6) versus laser fluence As expected, the peak-to-peak amplitude increases linearly at low laser fluence, but the increase slows down above 0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

field peak-to-peak amplitude versus laser fluence for the same STEs. As expected, the peak-to-peak amplitude increases linearly at low laser fluence, but the increase slows down above 0.

2 mJ/cm2 laser fluence and reaches a maximum at about 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

As expected, the peak-to-peak amplitude increases linearly at low laser fluence, but the increase slows down above 0. 2 mJ/cm2 laser fluence and the amplitude reaches a maximum at about 0.

6 mJ/cm2 laser fluence followed by a weak decrease of the amplitude on further increase of the laser fluence Similar behaviour has previously been observed and can be attributed to the spin accumulation and laser-induced heating effects The variation of the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude with thickness of the W and CoFe layers is reported in SM, Fig. p. 3
Where the paper says it

6 mJ/cm2 laser fluence followed by a weak decrease of the amplitude on further increase of the laser fluence. Similar behaviour has previously been observed and can be attributed to the spin accumulation and laser-induced heating effects [48–50].

S9 The largest amplitude is obtained for a W thickness of 2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The variation of the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude with thickness of the W and CoFe layers is reported in SM, Fig. The largest amplitude is obtained for a W thickness of 2.

5nm and a CoFe thickness of 3nm

--- Page 5 ---

FIG. 2(c,d) show, respectively the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude for MgO/W(3)/CoFe(2. p. 3

Where the paper says it

5nm and a CoFe thickness of 3nm. Figures 2(c,d) show, respectively the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude for MgO/W(3)/CoFe(2.

5)/Al2O3(6) and sapphire/W(3)/CoFe(2. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Figures 2(c,d) show, respectively the THz electric field peak-to-peak amplitude for MgO/W(3)/CoFe(2. 5)/Al2O3(6) and sapphire/W(3)/CoFe(2.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can predict which epitaxial interface, W(110)/CoFe(110) or W(001)/CoFe(001), will yield a larger terahertz emission based on material growth conditions, using the finding that The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for alpha-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) grown on single crystalline Al2O3(1¯20).

  2. Improved AI can determine the dominant mechanism enhancing spin current generation by correlating interface characteristics with output, specifically identifying that the α-W(110)/Co60Fe40(110) interface for this emitter is more transparent to the spin current due to the presence of ˚Angstr¨om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface.

  3. Improved AI can predict the influence of substrate and film side pumping on THz emission magnitude, as experimental results show the generated THz electric field is significantly larger when pumping from the substrate side for STEs grown on Al2O3(1¯20) or MgO(001).

  4. Improved AI can model and predict the relationship between laser fluence and THz peak-to-peak amplitude, learning that the peak-to-peak amplitude increases linearly at low laser fluence, but the increase slows down above 0.2 mJ/cm2 laser fluence and the amplitude reaches a maximum at about 0.6 mJ/cm2.

  5. Improved AI can distinguish between Dirac-type surface states in different crystallographic planes by analyzing first principle calculations, noting that the Dirac-type surface states appearing in α-W(001) are linear only very close to the Γ-point compared to W(110).

  6. Improved AI can assess the importance of interface quality by quantifying its effect on spin transfer efficiency, leveraging the finding that the spinmixing conductance is enhanced in the presence of interface intermixing.

  7. Improved AI can predict whether a change in substrate (e.g., from Al2O3 to MgO) will significantly alter THz emission, as shown by the observation that The emitted W/CoFe THz electric field amplitude is of similar magnitude for different STEs, despite differences in substrate choice.

Abstract

We report efficient terahertz (THz) generation in epitaxial α-W/Co 60 Fe 40 spintronic emitters. Two types of emitters have been investigated; epitaxial α-W (110) /Co 60 Fe 40(110) and α-W (001) /Co 60 Fe 40(001) deposited on single crystalline Al 2 O 3 (11 2 bar0) and MgO(001) substrates, respectively. First principle calculations of the electronic band structure at the W (001) surface reveal Dirac-type surface states, similar to that reported previously for the W (110) surface. The generated THz radiation is about 10% larger for α-W (110) /Co 60 Fe 40(110) grown on single crystalline Al 2 O 3 (11 2 bar0), which is explained by the fact that the α-W (110) /Co 60 Fe 40(110) interface for this emitter is more transparent to the spin current due to the presence of Ångstr" om-scale interface intermixing at the W/CoFe interface. Our results also reveal that the generation of THz radiation is larger when pumping with the laser light from the substrate side, which is explained by a larger part of the laser light due to interference effects in the film stack being absorbed in the ferromagnetic Co 60 Fe 40 layer in this measurement configuration.

Sources

Related papers