Credible Sets of Overall Ranking of Entities

arXiv:2401.01833 · stat.ME · Submitted 2024-01-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Statistics. The day in statistics: methods, theory and the inference under them.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Credible Sets of Overall Ranking of Entities".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Ranking, and inferences based on ranking of a set of entities are important problems in numerous contexts This is especially true in small area statistics where there may be only a limited amount of directly observed data from each entity or small area, while precise and accurate estimates of best or worst performing entities are needed for fund allocation, planning and policymaking, stakeholder advocacy, evaluation of welfare programs, and so on.

Tom: We propose novel Bayesian approaches to address this problem.

Jane: Our proposals result in partitions of the parameter space with posterior distribution driven partial ordering of the sets in a partition.

Tom: This in turn translates to a coherent probability mass function over ranks for every entity, and a coherent probability mass function over entities for every rank.

Title and authors: Tom: So, this paper, "Credible Sets of Overall Ranking of Entities," comes from the University of Maryland Baltimore County and the Department of Statistics at the University of Georgia. It’s written by Chatterjeea, Dattab, Houd, and Mandalb >

Jane: It tells us that ranking entities isn't just some academic exercise; it’s crucial for things like welfare programs or policy making where you need to know who is winning or losing in a specific area >

Lu: The authors are addressing the gap where existing methods only produce a single rank vector, which doesn't give policymakers enough information about the uncertainty of those ranks >

Meng: What they are proposing seems to be a way to get multiple probability distributions for the ranks, which is much more useful than just one guess at who is number one >

Lalam: They introduce these novel Bayesian approaches that result in partitions of the parameter space and then a posterior distribution driven partial ordering of those sets, which translates into coherent probability mass functions over ranks for every entity >

The paper's summary: Tom: So, the paper says they use two main Bayesian models based on prior distributions for the unknown parameters, one being noninformative and flat, and the other leading to hierarchical Bayes or empirical Bayes models >

Jane: They then build an empirical credible set for those parameters, which helps them generate a candidate set of rank vectors to form what they call an empirical credible set of the rank parameter >

Lu: This process leads to this set RBayes,alpha which is a partially ordered set of rank vectors, and each column in it is a probability mass function on the ranks for that specific small area >

Meng: They also mention that this empirical distribution is an approximation of the posterior distribution based on a truncated version of the posterior, which they call the EMCD >

Lalam: The paper also develops a new theoretical framework called the triangular Fay-Herriot framework to give these Bayesian approaches strong theoretical properties, including showing Cauchy convergence type results almost surely >

The paper's improvements: Tom: The real strength here, according to their simulations comparing different methods like KWW and MRSW, is that the hierarchical Bayes elliptical method tends to be the best performer when there are covariates in the model >

Jane: And they claim these elliptical Bayesian credible sets are often much smaller than those from Cartesian models or even frequentist confidence sets that have the same level of coverage >

Lu: That means we get a tighter, more focused set of plausible rank vectors, and the probability mass functions associated with them are similar or better in terms of what they tell us about the ranks >

Meng: They also quantified uncertainty using metrics like effective cardinality and mean absolute deviation to measure how concentrated these distributions are and assess the reliability of those rank estimates >

Lalam: The paper suggests that using a hierarchical Bayesian framework combined with an elliptical credible set is generally the best strategy for this kind of ranking problem, especially when covariates are involved >

Conclusion: Tom: So to wrap up, the authors demonstrate that these Bayesian approaches comprehensively outperform the non-Bayesian methods like KWW and MRSW we looked at >

Jane: The main recommendation is to use a hierarchical Bayesian approach with an elliptical credible set because it seems to provide better results for the rank vectors and their associated probability mass functions >

Lu: They also pointed out that while this framework works well, there's still the challenge of computational viability when dealing with very large problems >

Meng: From an engineering standpoint, if you’re running this on real traffic data at scale, you have to keep those computational costs in mind because the methods can get heavy >

Lalam: So to end it all up, "Credible Sets of Overall Ranking of Entities" offers a way to get coherent probability mass functions over ranks for every entity and over entities for every rank >

Snigdhansu Chatterjeea, Gauri Sankar Dattab, Yiren Houd, Abhyuday Mandalb

University of Maryland Baltimore County · Department of Statistics, University of Georgia Center for Statistical Research and Methodology, U.S. Census Bureau Department of Biostatistics, Yale School of Public Health

stat.ME

Submitted: 2024-01-03

Updated: 2026-11-15

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Ranking, and inferences based on ranking of a set of entities are important problems in numerous contexts This is especially true in small area statistics where there may be only a limited amount of…

Key concepts

Rank Vector ($\check{r}$)
This vector defines the true rank of an entity based on its characteristic $\theta$. It is calculated by counting how many other entities have a smaller or equal characteristic than the entity in question. This allows researchers to define the precise ordering of all entities.
Triangular Fay-Herriot ($\Delta$-FH) Framework
This is a new theoretical framework developed for analyzing inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data. It provides strong theoretical properties, showing that Cauchy convergence type results hold almost surely, which validates the proposed Bayesian approach.
Elliptical Credible Sets
These are specific types of credible sets used in the Bayesian analysis. They are shown to be significantly smaller than standard Cartesian or frequentist confidence sets while maintaining similar or better properties for rank vectors and their associated probability mass functions, making them a preferred tool.
Empirical Marginal Credible Distribution (EMCD)
This is a distribution constructed for each small area, representing the probability mass function over the ranks for that specific entity. It helps users understand the bounds of support and moments of the posterior rank estimates for that area.

Terminology

Summary

Ranking, and inferences based on ranking of a set of entities are important problems in numerous contexts This is especially true in small area statistics where there may be only a limited amount of directly observed data from each entity or small area, while precise and accurate estimates of best or worst performing entities are needed for fund allocation, planning and policymaking, stakeholder advocacy, evaluation of welfare programs, and so on. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Census Bureau, Suitland, MD dBiostatistics, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT Abstract Ranking, and inferences based on ranking of a set of entities, are important problems in numerous contexts. This is especially true in small area statistics where there may be only a limited amount of directly observed data from each entity or small area, while precise and accurate estimates of best or worst performing entities are needed for fund allocation, planning and policymaking, stakeholder advocacy, evaluation of welfare programs, and so on.

We propose novel Bayesian approaches to address this problem. p. 0
Where the paper says it

However, ranks estimates constructed exclusively on point estimates of parameters lack uncertainty quantification, and may lead to imbalances and inequities when these are based on small sample sizes. We propose novel Bayesian approaches to address this problem.

Our proposals result in partitions of the parameter space with posterior distribution driven partial ordering of the sets in a partition. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We propose novel Bayesian approaches to address this problem. Our proposals result in partitions of the parameter space with posterior distribution driven partial ordering of the sets in a partition.

This in turn translates to a coherent probability mass function over ranks for every entity, and a coherent probability mass function over entities for every rank. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Our proposals result in partitions of the parameter space with posterior distribution driven partial ordering of the sets in a partition. This in turn translates to a coherent probability mass function over ranks for every entity, and a coherent probability mass function over entities for every rank.

Our Bayesian algorithms significantly outperform the state-of-the-art non-Bayesian alternatives, and are amenable to inclusion of covariates in the model as well as borrowing strengths across small areas. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This in turn translates to a coherent probability mass function over ranks for every entity, and a coherent probability mass function over entities for every rank. Our Bayesian algorithms significantly outperform the state-of-the-art non-Bayesian alternatives, and are amenable to inclusion of covariates in the model as well as borrowing strengths across small areas.

We develop a novel theoretical framework for inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data, and provide probabilistic guarantees of performances of the proposed Bayesian ranking algorithms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We evaluate our proposed Bayesian algorithms in terms of accuracy and stability using a number of applications and a simulation study. Additionally, we develop a novel theoretical framework for inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data, and provide probabilistic guarantees of performances of the proposed Bayesian ranking algorithms.

Problem Formulation in Small Area Statistics

In small area contexts, estimation of subpopulation means is often the primary goal for National Statistics Offices. However, inference on the overall ranking of entities is equally critical in planning and policy making. p. 1

Where the paper says it

For example, information on the poverty rates, access to clean water or primary healthcare and so on at disaggregated levels are required for various welfare programs. However, inference on the overall ranking of entities, such as hospitals, animal herds, crop varietals, is equally critical in planning, policy making and advocacy related to such programs.

The problem addressed involves ranking m such entities, indexed by i = 1,. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Hereafter, we use the generic term “small area” or “entity” to imply such subdomains where there is paucity of directly observed data. In this paper, we address the problem of ranking m such entities, indexed by i = 1, .

.., m, based on a common characteristic θ = (θ1,. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In this paper, we address the problem of ranking m such entities, indexed by i = 1, . , m, based on a common characteristic θ = (θ1, .

.., θm), which is reflected in a measurable quantity Y = (Y1, · · ·, Ym). p. 1
Where the paper says it

, m, based on a common characteristic θ = (θ1, . , θm), which is reflected in a measurable quantity Y = (Y1, · · · , Ym).

The true rank vector ˇr is defined as rˇi ≡ rˇi(θ) = Xm j=1 I(θj ≤ θi) = 1 + Xj:j̸=i I(θj ≤ θi), for i = 1, · · ·, m. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Define the true rank vector ˇr = (ˇr1, . , rˇm), where rˇi ≡ rˇi(θ) = Xm j=1 I(θj ≤ θi) = 1 + X j:j̸=i I(θj ≤ θi), for i = 1, · · · , m.

Bayesian Methodology and Credible Sets

The paper introduces two Bayesian models by specifying suitable prior distributions for the unknown θ on Θm. The first prior is noninformative and flat over Θm, while the second leads to hierarchical Bayes (HB) and empirical Bayes (EB) models studied by Fay and Herriot (1979). p. 3

Where the paper says it

The second prior, stated in Section 3. 2, leads to the widely used hierarchical Bayes (HB) and empirical Bayes (EB) models studied by Fay and Herriot (1979), Berger (1985), Aitkin and Longford (1986), Berger and Deely (1988), Laird and Louis (1989), Morris and Christiansen (1996) and many others.

The process involves obtaining a credible set for θ, then generating candidate values to form an empirical credible set of the rank parameter ˇr. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Since we use Monte Carlo (MC) or Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) computational techniques in this paper, we obtain several candidate θ ∈ S to form an empirical credible set. We obtain rank vectors from each of these candidate values, and thus obtain the corresponding empirical credible set of the rank parameter ˇr, generically denoted by R ⊂ σ({1, 2, .

This leads to a frequency distribution over the ranks in R, which is described as a probability mass function over R. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Many of these candidates will produce the same rank vector, since (2) is a many-to-one function. Consequently, we can obtain a frequency distribution over the ranks in R, which is conveniently described as a probability mass function over R.

Empirical Credible Distributions and Interpretation

The paper constructs four empirical credible sets: SUB,C,α, SHB,C,α, SUB,E,α (UB model), and SHB,E,α (HB model). These sets are used to obtain candidate rank vectors R(sj) for each element θ(sj) in SBayes. p. 8

Where the paper says it

5 Bayesian rank posets Below, we use the notation SBayes,α to denote any one of the four empirical credible sets SUB,C,α, SHB,C,α, SUB,E,α, or SHB,E,α constructed above. For each element θ (sj ) in SBayes,α, we use equation (2) to obtain a candidate rank vector R(sj ) , which are collected in the set RBayes,α.

The resulting set RBayes,α is a partially ordered set (poset) of rank vectors. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In addition, we also have the relative frequencies of the distinct elements of the set RBayes,α. Using these relative frequencies in a non-decreasing order to arrange the rank vectors in RBayes,α, we henceforth consider RBayes,α as a partially ordered set (poset) of rank vectors.

The j-th column of RBayes, denoted by RBayes,j below, corresponds to a probability mass function on the ranks for the j-th small area. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The j-th column of RBayes, denoted by RBayes,j below, corresponds to a probability mass function on the ranks {1, 2, . , m} that the j-th small area may take.

An interpretation is that the EMCD is an approximation of the posterior distribution of the ranks based on a truncated version of the posterior. p. 8
Where the paper says it

This can be intuitively understood by noting that the conditional posterior distribution of θ given A is multivariate normal and applying the Laplace approximation and consistency of the posterior mode of A; we omit the details. Thus, an HPD credible set for θ will be approximately elliptic, defined by the Mahalanobis distance function based on the posterior mean and variancecovariance of θ.

Theoretical Framework and Performance Comparison

The authors develop a new approach for theoretical analysis called the triangular Fay-Herriot (∆-FH) framework. The results show that the proposed Bayesian approaches have strong theoretical properties using this framework. p. 4

Where the paper says it

For this novel theoretical development, we introduce and develop the triangular Fay-Herriot (∆-FH) framework, and show that for posterior distributions of θ or ˇr, Cauchy convergence type results hold almost surely. Our theoretical results have wider implications for small area studies beyond establishing properties of EB or HB small area ranking problem, and such subsequent developments will be reported in depth in a future study.

A simulation study comparing KWW and MRSW with the four Bayesian proposals shows that the HB elliptical method is typically the best performer in the presence of covariates. p. 4
Where the paper says it

While our studies encompass four possible Bayesian approaches, the basic principles we lay down are applicable for any other reasonable choice of prior or technique for constructing credible sets. Section 4 contains a simulation experiment to illustrate the advantages and limitations of our proposed Bayesian approaches and their performance relative to KWW and MRSW.

Elliptical Bayesian credible sets are often orders of magnitude smaller than Cartesian ones or frequentist confidence sets that have the same level of coverage, while having similar or better properties in terms of the rank vectors and their associated probability mass functions. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(2020) showed that the set of rank vectors RKWW,α = {(r1, · · · , rm) : ri ∈ {|ΛLi| + 1, · · · , |ΛLi| + 1 + |ΛOi|} for i = 1, · · · , m}, (5) is a joint confidence set for ˇr having a joint coverage probability at least (1−α). KWW have briefly remarked that a Bayesian version of their frequentist solution is possible.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

(2020) showed that the set of rank vectors RKWW,α = {(r1, · · · , rm) : ri ∈ {|ΛLi| + 1, · · · , |ΛLi| + 1 + |ΛOi|} for i = 1, · · · , m}, (5) is a joint confidence set for ˇr having a joint coverage probability at least (1−α). KWW have briefly remarked that a Bayesian version of their frequentist solution is possible.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The authors strongly recommend using a hierarchical Bayesian approach and an elliptical credible set. Elliptical Bayesian credible sets are often orders of magnitude smaller than Cartesian ones or frequentist confidence sets that have the same level of coverage, while having similar or better properties in terms of the rank vectors and their associated probability mass functions. The authors also discuss the challenge of computational viability for large problems.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The volume of these sets is well-known and also given in supplementary Section S.3. The other metric is a measure of average length, which for orthotopes is m−1 Pj(Uj − Lj). p. 3

Where the paper says it

The difference in the sizes of a Bayesian credible set and a KWW-based confidence set with identical coverage rapidly increases with an increasing m. Similar comments can be made for EB-based approaches resulting from our computations, but since such details bring no additional insight, we omit EB-related results to contain the length of this paper.

How the training signal is built

The posterior distribution of θ from either Section 3.1 or Section 3. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To quantify and account for uncertainty in ˆr, we need to study the joint distribution of θˆ. While there is considerable literature on many other aspects of small area statistics, the problem of ranking of small areas has received relatively less attention; we discuss the relevant literature in Section 2.

2 does not concentrate anywhere. p. 8
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, from any of the the four choices for RBayes,α we can easily obtain the marginal empirical frequency of any subvector of ranks, or the frequency distribution of the ranks for any subset of small areas. For clarity in presentation to stakeholders, we concentrate on the one-dimensional marginal distribution of ranks (and their relative frequencies in the proposed Bayesian paradigm) for any particular small area.

The authors propose a triangular Fay-Herriot (∆-FH) model to establish interesting properties of this model. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Additionally, we develop a novel theoretical framework for inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data, and provide probabilistic guarantees of performances of the proposed Bayesian ranking algorithms. Keywords: Credible sets; Fay-Herriot model; hierarchical Bayes; highest posterior density; small area estimation; triangular Fay-Herriot framework; unstructured Bayes 1Address for correspondence: Abhyuday Mandal, Department of Statistics, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, 30606 (amandal@stat.

Where the gains come from

The AMD and EC for KWW and MRSW are about 3 times that of the Bayesian counterparts, with elliptical credible sets being distinctly better. The HB method performs substantially better for the smaller values of A (0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

This partial ordering induces a corresponding partial ordering in S, and in the rest of the paper we will also consider S to be a partially ordered set. In the various applications and simulation studies that we conducted, the partially ordered set R produced by either of the two priors, and two different techniques for obtaining credible sets S, resulted in better quality and more easily interpretable results compared to KWW, based on several metrics for comparing sets; details are provided below.

001, 0.005, 0.01) relative to the Di’s, as in these cases there is a substantial structure in the θi’s. p. 4
Where the paper says it

While our studies encompass four possible Bayesian approaches, the basic principles we lay down are applicable for any other reasonable choice of prior or technique for constructing credible sets. Section 4 contains a simulation experiment to illustrate the advantages and limitations of our proposed Bayesian approaches and their performance relative to KWW and MRSW.

The HB elliptical method is typically the best performer in the presence of covariates. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We use the additional subscripts of C and α to emphasize that the set is a Cartesian product and depends on α. 4 Construction of elliptical empirical credible sets An optimal method to create a credible set S from a posterior is to use the highest posterior density (HPD) method.

Summary and conclusions

The authors demonstrate that the Bayesian approaches comprehensively outperform the non-Bayesian approaches of KWW and MRSW. Using a hierarchical Bayesian framework and an elliptical credible set seems to be the best strategy. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Hence similar to above, define the empirical credible set SHB,E,α = {θ (s) ∈ Θ(S) : M(θ (s) , θˆHB, VHB) ≤ c}, where θˆHB = 1 S PS s=1 θ (s) , VHB = 1 S PS s=1{θ (s) − θˆHB}{θ (s) − θˆHB} T , and suitably chosen c > 0. Note that in a likelihood-based framework it is possible to get an elliptical confidence set by inverting an appropriate likelihood-based acceptance region.

The interpretation of the Bayesian results on ranking, which obtain a probability mass function for each small area, is interesting but challenging at first glance. A technically correct way of interpreting the empirical marginal credible distribution RBayes,j for the j-th entity or small area is in terms of bounds of support, moments and other properties of the rank that this entity may take. p. 9

Where the paper says it

This is also relevant for the numerous applications of small area rankings at NSOs and elsewhere. A simple way of interpreting RBayes,j is in terms of bounds for probabilities, moments and support of the posterior ranks of the j-th small area.

The set SBayes,α helps in eliciting the most plausible rank vectors with their associated probabilities in RBayes,α. The EMCD is an approximation of the posterior distribution of the ranks based on a truncated version of the posterior. p. 8

Where the paper says it

This can be intuitively understood by noting that the conditional posterior distribution of θ given A is multivariate normal and applying the Laplace approximation and consistency of the posterior mode of A; we omit the details. Thus, an HPD credible set for θ will be approximately elliptic, defined by the Mahalanobis distance function based on the posterior mean and variancecovariance of θ.

The authors also discuss the challenge of computational viability for large problems.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Bayesian ranking systems can provide coherent probability mass functions over ranks for every entity and over entities for every rank, which is a major innovation over preceding approaches like Klein et al (2020). This allows planners to obtain a probability associated with each rank vector.

  2. The system can utilize the triangular Fay-Herriot framework to establish theoretical properties of predictors like theta hat or rank-predictors like r hat, showing that Cauchy convergence type results hold almost surely. This provides a novel theoretical development for inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data.

  3. The system can be optimized by using a hierarchical Bayesian framework combined with an elliptical credible set, as this approach is shown to be typically the best performer in the presence of covariates across simulation studies. Elliptical Bayesian credible sets are orders of magnitude smaller than Cartesian ones or frequentist confidence sets that have the same level of coverage.

  4. The system can generate an empirical marginal credible distribution (EMCD) for each small area, which is a probability mass function on the ranks for the j-th small area. This EMCD allows users to understand the bounds of support, moments and other properties of the posterior ranks of the j-th small area.

  5. The system can quantify uncertainty using metrics like effective cardinality (EC) and mean absolute deviation (AMD), which are used to measure how well a distribution is concentrated and to assess the reliability of rank estimates.

Abstract

Ranking, and inferences based on ranking of a set of entities, are important problems in numerous contexts. This is especially true in small area statistics where there may be only a limited amount of directly observed data from each entity or small area, while precise and accurate estimates of best or worst performing entities are needed for fund allocation, planning and policymaking, stakeholder advocacy, evaluation of welfare programs, and so on. However, ranks estimates constructed exclusively on point estimates of parameters lack uncertainty quantification, and may lead to imbalances and inequities when these are based on small sample sizes. We propose novel Bayesian approaches to address this problem. Our proposals result in partitions of the parameter space with posterior distribution driven partial ordering of the sets in a partition. This in turn translates to a coherent probability mass function over ranks for every entity, and a coherent probability mass function over entities for every rank. Our Bayesian algorithms significantly outperform the state-of-the-art non-Bayesian alternatives, and are amenable to inclusion of covariates in the model as well as borrowing strengths across small areas. We evaluate our proposed Bayesian algorithms in terms of accuracy and stability using a number of applications and a simulation study. Additionally, we develop a novel theoretical framework for inference and ranking problems involving a triangular array of Fay-Herriot models and data, and provide probabilistic guarantees of performances of the proposed Bayesian ranking algorithms.

Related papers