Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum

arXiv:2311.00806 · quant-ph · Submitted 2023-11-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum introduces entanglement witnesses that detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum.

Kai: The paper introduces entanglement witnesses for spin ensembles which detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum.

Mira: These witnesses are particularly effective at detecting states that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, including Greenberger-HorneZeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states.

Kai: The protocol involves estimating the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally-spaced directions on a plane.

Paper summary: Kai: To wrap up what we just talked about, this paper, "Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum," is proposing a way to certify whether you have genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements on the total angular momentum.

Mira: The core thesis is that they introduce entanglement witnesses specifically designed for spin ensembles where you only need to measure the sum of all those spins, and these witnesses are powerful because they can detect states like N-partite GHZ states which other tests often fail to find.

Lev: They show this works by setting up a precession protocol where you estimate the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally spaced directions on a plane, and genuine multipartite entanglement is certified when that score exceeds a specific separable bound.

Kai: So the key claim is that this method provides a way to detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only total angular momentum measurements, which fills a gap in current literature because it targets states like N-partite GHZ states.

Mira: And they back this up with some concrete results, showing conditions on the total spin and K for when the score PK being greater than P K minus sepK means the system is genuinely multipartite entangled.

Lev: The paper also lays out a comparison to other methods, noting that while their protocol needs K measurement settings, a fidelity-based witness might need one more setting, which has implications for how you'd actually run this on real hardware.

Kai: It seems like they’re giving us a new tool—a specific type of witness—that simplifies the experimental requirements by focusing on the collective spin rather than needing to address every single particle individually.

Mira: And it’s not just about GHZ states, because they showed this witness can also detect other multipartite entanglement states that share symmetries with them, like certain Dicke states.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at the title, "Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum," it sounds like they are trying to create a definitive test for whether you have genuine multipartite entanglement just by measuring the total spin vector.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are pointing out that this isn't just any measurement; it’s about using the specific structure of how those spins add up to detect entanglement that is hard to see otherwise, especially when dealing with states like N-partite GHZ states.

Lev: For someone building real hardware, the implication is that if you can design your measurement system around measuring total angular momentum efficiently, this witness could be a very practical way to check for entanglement without needing complex individual addressing.

Kai: It shifts the focus from tracking every single particle’s state to characterizing the collective state, which is often a more manageable challenge when dealing with large spin ensembles.

Mira: And for the broader field of quantum information, it provides a new recipe—a way to construct genuine multipartite entanglement witnesses from simpler bipartite ones, which opens up new avenues for creating tests that are even more general.

Lev: So ultimately, this work gives us a framework where we can use collective measurements to certify complex entanglement without needing the overhead of individual addressing for every spin.

Khoi-Nguyen Huynh-Vu, Lin Htoo Zaw, Valerio Scarani

College of Engineering and Computer Science, VinUniversity · Centre for Quantum Technologies, National University of Singapore · Department of Physics, National University of Singapore

quant-ph

Submitted: 2023-11-01

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 24 pages, 11 figures. Added previously-missing assumption (see erratum https://doi.org/10.1103/vqpq-8x8m)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 109, 042402 (2024)

DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.109.042402

Code: https://github.com/not-fred/arXiv-2311.00806

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum introduces entanglement witnesses that detect genuine multipartite entanglement using…

Terminology

Summary

Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum introduces entanglement witnesses that detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum Khoi-Nguyen Huynh-Vu,1 Lin Htoo Zaw,2 and Valerio Scarani2, 3 1College of Engineering and Computer Science, VinUniversity, Gia Lam district, Hanoi 14000, Vietnam 2Centre for Quantum Technologies, National University of Singapore, 3 Science Drive 2, Singapore 117543 3Department of Physics, National University of Singapore, 2 Science Drive 3, Singapore 117542 We introduce entanglement witnesses for spin ensembles which detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum. States that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, which include Greenberger-HorneZeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states, can be effectively detected by our witness.

Introduction to the Witness

The paper introduces entanglement witnesses for spin ensembles which detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum. These witnesses are particularly effective at detecting states that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, including Greenberger-HorneZeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Certification of genuine multipartite entanglement in spin ensembles with measurements of total angular momentum Khoi-Nguyen Huynh-Vu,1 Lin Htoo Zaw,2 and Valerio Scarani2, 3 1College of Engineering and Computer Science, VinUniversity, Gia Lam district, Hanoi 14000, Vietnam 2Centre for Quantum Technologies, National University of Singapore, 3 Science Drive 2, Singapore 117543 3Department of Physics, National University of Singapore, 2 Science Drive 3, Singapore 117542 We introduce entanglement witnesses for spin ensembles which detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum. States that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, which include Greenberger-HorneZeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states, can be effectively detected by our witness.

The protocol involves estimating the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally-spaced directions on a plane. p. 0
Where the paper says it

States that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, which include Greenberger-HorneZeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states, can be effectively detected by our witness. The protocol involves estimating the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally-spaced directions on a plane.

Genuine multipartite entanglement is detected when the observed score exceeds a separable bound. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Alternatively, one could measure along a single direction at different times, under the assumption that the total spins undergo a uniform precession. Genuine multipartite entanglement is detected when the observed score exceeds a separable bound.

The Precession Protocol as a Test

The protocol is presented first as a nonclassicality test consisting of many independent rounds where the total angular momentum is measured along directions defined by Jk:= e−i(2πk/K)Jz/ħJxei(2πk/K)Jz/ħ = cos(2πk/K)Jx + sin(2πk/K)Jy. The expected score for a quantum system in the state ρ is given by PK = tr(ρQK), where QK:= 1/K sum k=0 pos(Jk). p. 1

Where the paper says it

The upper bound PK ≤ Pc K predicted by classical theory is Pc K = 1/2 for K even and Pc K = (1+1/K)/2 for K odd [40, 41]. Meanwhile, the expected score for a quantum system in the state ρ is given by PK = tr(ρQK), with QK := 1 K K X−1 k=0 pos(Jk).

This protocol detects the nonclassicality of the measured system when the observed score PK > PcK, where PcK is the classical bound predicted by classical theory. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The upper bound PK ≤ Pc K predicted by classical theory is Pc K = 1/2 for K even and Pc K = (1+1/K)/2 for K odd [40, 41]. Meanwhile, the expected score for a quantum system in the state ρ is given by PK = tr(ρQK), with QK := 1 K K X−1 k=0 pos(Jk).

Application to Spin Ensembles

When applied to a composite system, this protocol becomes a precession-based entanglement witness (PEW) for the total angular momentum J⃗ of an ensemble of N particles. The primary contribution is introducing a witness of GME that requires only measurements of the total angular momentum and can detect N-partite GHZ states. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The primary contribution of this paper is to fill this gap. We introduce a witness of GME that requires only measurements of the total angular momentum of the spin ensemble, and can detect states that are missed by existing angular-momentum-based criteria, in particular, our witness can detect N-partite GHZ states.

The separable bound PsepK is defined as the maximum score achieved by a non-GME state. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Conversely, ρGME is GME if it is not a convex combination of states separable over any bipartition J: that is, ρGME ̸= P J pJρJ,J∁ . Finally, we define the separable bound P sep K ({jn} N n=1) as the maximum score achieved by a non-GME state of the spin ensemble {jn} N n=1, upon performing the precession protocol on the total angular momentum of the spin ensemble: P sep K {jn} N n=1 := max {pJ,ρJ,J∁ } tr" X J pJρJ,J∁ !

Separable Bounds and Results

The paper derives analytical expressions for the separable bound when the total spin is a half-integer, and numerical results are reported for other cases, with a conjecture provided for when the total spin is not known. Result 1 shows that if PNn=1 jn = K/2 for odd K ≥ 3, then PK > P K-sepK implies the spin ensemble is GME. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Indeed, we shall show that a sufficiently large violation of the classical bound by the spin ensemble implies GME. Our main results are as follows: an exact analytical bound when PN n=1 jn = K/2, for all odd K ≥ 3

Result 4 states that if PNn=1 jn ≤ 15 and odd 3 ≤ K ≤ 21, then PK > P conjK implies the spin ensemble is GME. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Indeed, we shall show that a sufficiently large violation of the classical bound by the spin ensemble implies GME. Our main results are as follows: an exact analytical bound when PN n=1 jn = K/2, for all odd K ≥ 3

Comparison to Other Criteria

The PEW requires K measurement settings while the fidelity-based witness requires K + 1 settings, suggesting that the latter might be a better choice if only individual addressing is available in quantum computation. The protocol can also be implemented as a quantum circuit. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Therefore, one might be better off using the fidelitybased witness in the context of quantum computation. As the precession protocol can be performed with local spin measurements and classical post-processing, our PEW can also be implemented as a quantum circuit

Detecting Specific States

The PEW can detect the entanglement of the K-partite GHZ state GHZK⟩. Furthermore, it detects other GME states that share similar symmetries to the GHZ state, which are missed by existing criteria. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The primary contribution of this paper is to fill this gap. We introduce a witness of GME that requires only measurements of the total angular momentum of the spin ensemble, and can detect states that are missed by existing angular-momentum-based criteria, in particular, our witness can detect N-partite GHZ states.

It is noted that the tripartite Dicke or W state W3⟩ achieves ⟨W3Q3W3⟩ = 11/16 > P conjK > P K-sepK when performing the precession protocol with measurements in the y–z plane. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Any of the referenced witnesses would be a better choice for detecting the entanglement of such states, as our witness is unable to detect the entanglement of Dicke states in general. We note an exception: the tripartite Dicke or W state |W3⟩ := D3 1 = 1 √ 3 (|↑↓↓⟩ + |↓↑↓⟩ + |↓↓↑⟩) (36) achieves ⟨W3|Q3|W3⟩ = 11/16 > P conj 3 > P 3-sep 3 when performing the precession protocol with measurements in the y–z plane.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The work concludes by providing a generic recipe for constructing witnesses of genuine multipartite entanglement out of witnesses of bipartite entanglement. A possible extension would be to consider the effects of anharmonicities when performing the precession protocol under the assumption of dynamics. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In some systems, having to measure only in one direction could be an advantage, coming at the cost of the assumption on the dynamics. Hence, this offers another way of performing the precession protocol, rather than measuring at a fixed time along one among several directions as we present in this paper.

The generality of the result in Sec. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This protocol is based on a test known as the “precession protocol” or “Tsirelson protocol” [40–42], which is a witness of nonclassicality for single systems. The first expression comes from a dynamical assumption in those works that we do not use here (see Sec.

III A allows for constructing other GME witnesses by choosing different functions of angular momentum to be used with Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In terms of the different types of multipartite entanglement, only some of the aforementioned angularmomentum-based witnesses can detect GME [25, 33–36], and those that do are mostly effective at detecting Dicke states [37], a generalization of W states. Notably missing are angular-momentum-based witnesses that can detect N-partite GHZ states |GHZN ⟩ ∝ |↑⟩⊗N + |↓⟩⊗N beyond the tripartite case.

(13). The study also shows that the observable J⃗2 can be used to construct other GME witnesses. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In this context, it is interesting to point out the similarities with the fidelity-based witness that is commonly used in the field of quantum computation [53], as is shown in Fig. (1) Both witnesses involve K equally distributed measurement settings: σθk for our PEW and σθk/2 for the fidelity-based witness, where σθ = cos θσx + sin θσy, σs = J (j=1/2) s /2ℏ are the usual Pauli operators, and θk = 2πk/K for k ∈ {1, 2, .

The analysis of the diagonal case suggests that for bipartite systems with equal spins, the classical bound is violated if the precession protocol is performed on the total angular momentum. p. 4
Where the paper says it

(8), the total angular momentum of the spin ensemble is J⃗ = X N n=1 J⃗(jn) = PN n=1 M jn j∈J ({jn}N n=1) J⃗(j) . (16) As before, the observable QK, which describes the precession protocol performed on the total angular momentum, will also inherit this block diagonal structure: QK = PN n=1 M jn j∈J ({jn}N n=1) 1 K K X−1 k=0 pos[J (j) k ] | {z } =:Q (j) K .

The general behavior of PsepK as min(˜ȷ, ȷ˜′) increases suggests that the maximum separable bound occurs at specific spin pairs. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Notice that the separable bound is large for min(˜ȷ,ȷ˜ ′ ) < 2, and takes on smaller values as min(˜ȷ,ȷ˜ ′ ) increases. This behavior [that the separable bound is large when min(˜ȷ, ˜ȷ ′ ) is small] can be found not just for K = 7 and K = 9, as plotted in Fig.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved entanglement certification for spin ensembles by introducing a witness that requires only measurements of total angular momentum, which can detect states missed by existing angular-momentum-based criteria, in particular N-partite GHZ states.

  2. A protocol that estimates the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally spaced directions on a plane, allowing for detection of genuine multipartite entanglement when the observed score exceeds a separable bound.

  3. Implementation of a precession based entanglement witness (PEW) where collective measurements are possible but not necessary, as any measurement of Jk can be done by first locally measuring J(jn)k for each spin and then manually adding up the measurement outcomes afterwards.

  4. A dynamical implementation of the precession protocol that involves measuring only one direction under the assumption that the total spins undergo a uniform precession, which is particularly useful in witnessing entanglement of postquench states.

  5. Construction of other genuine multipartite entanglement witnesses by choosing different functions of angular momentum to be used with Eq. (13), providing a generic recipe for constructing witnesses from bipartite entanglement witnesses.

  6. Ability to detect noisy GHZ states close to the theoretical limit when the total spin is known to be K/2, as the protocol detects GME when tr(rho(pG)GHZ,KQK) > P K-sep K for pG < 1/2.

  7. A method for constructing a witness using the observable J⃗2 that can detect genuine multipartite entanglement of unequal spins by finding a separable bound defined by g sep = Hbar squared min J⃗2 (˜ȷ - ȷ˜') squared + (˜ȷ + ˜ȷ').

  8. The ability to establish a reliable numerical upper bound for the multipartite separable bound using semidefinite programming, denoted as PSDP K, which is guaranteed to be greater than or equal to the true separable bound P sep K.

  9. An improved criterion for detecting genuine multipartite entanglement of N-partite spin ensembles where PN n=1 jn > 15 by performing the precession protocol with odd K between 3 and 21 and checking if PK > P conj K + epsilon.

Abstract

We introduce entanglement witnesses for spin ensembles which detect genuine multipartite entanglement using only measurements of the total angular momentum. States that are missed by most other angular-momentum-based witnesses for spin ensembles, which include Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states and certain superpositions of Dicke states, can be effectively detected by our witness. The protocol involves estimating the probability that the total angular momentum is positive along equally-spaced directions on a plane. Alternatively, one could measure along a single direction at different times, under the assumption that the total spins undergoes a uniform precession. Genuine multipartite entanglement is detected when the observed score exceeds a separable bound. Exact analytical expressions for the separable bound are obtained for spin ensembles j 1 times j 2 times times j N such that the total spin is a half-integer, and numerical results are reported for the other cases. Finally, we conjecture an expression for the separable bound when the total spin is not known, which is well supported by the numerical results.

Sources

Related papers