First-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system

arXiv:2310.02472 · hep-th, hep-ph · Submitted 2023-10-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "First-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A model of N 4-component massless fermions in a quartic self-interaction based on ref.

19: is investigated in the presence of chemical potential and temperature via optimized perturbation theory that accesses finite-N contributions The model shows the finite-N corrections generate first-order phase transitions on the self-interacting fermions for the case N = 1 and the persistence of a second-order phase transition for N ≥ 2.

Mira: Model Setup and Methodology The investigation utilizes a model of N massless four-component fermions in the presence of a quartic self-interaction via ref.

19: The effective Lagrangian (2) introduces an auxiliary vector field Aµ where L = ψk i∂/ − Aγ/ 5ψk + N/2g AµAµ Corrections beyond the large-N limit are implemented via the optimized perturbation theory (OPT) deformation based on

30, 31, 36, 37: through the fictitious δ-parameter The effective potential expanded up to linear order on the δ-parameter is given by Vef f (Aµ, aµ, δ) = −δ/2g AµAµ + iZ d4p (2π)4 Tr ln p/− a/γ5 + iδ Z d4p (2π)4 Tr "(a/− A/)γ5 p/− a/γ5 > O(δ 2) The common fraction of the integrals in (7) can be written as 1 p/− a/γ5 = N0(p)/R(p).

Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper called "First-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system". It deals with a model of four component massless fermions with a quartic self interaction and how that behaves when you introduce temperature and chemical potential using optimized perturbation theory to get those finite N contributions.

Mira: Yeah, it's interesting because they are using this method to move past the large-N approximation and look at things like first-order transitions that might be missed by standard methods.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I'm thinking about how much overhead we'd need on real hardware to even attempt these kinds of calculations involving chemical potential and temperature.

Kai: Exactly. The paper says that for N equal to one, the finite N corrections generate a region in the phase space of temperature and density that is larger than what you'd expect from just looking at the large-N limit.

Mira: That's significant because for N equal to one, they find a very different behavior between what they call symmetric and asymmetric phases. They even identify a tricritical point with specific values like mu tric equals five point zero five times g to the negative one over two and temperature tric equals three times g to the negative one over two.

Lev: Those are concrete numbers that we could actually try to map out on some kind of lattice or simulation if we could handle those kinds of corrections.

Kai: The paper also shows that for N greater than or equal to two, there isn't a big qualitative difference in the phase transition itself; it still behaves like a second-order phase transition. That's a key distinction they highlight when comparing the different values of N.

Mira: But the real meat is what happens when you look at those specific critical values for temperature and chemical potential at zero chemical potential, which they state are Tc equal to the square root of three times g to the negative one over two times the square root of g to the negative one over two for N greater than or equal to one.

Lev: That's a formula we could plug into some numerical solvers, but we need to make sure our model setup actually matches what they used for their effective potential expansion up to linear order in the delta parameter.

Kai: And that leads us into how they improve their approach. The paper suggests using the principle of minimal sensitivity, which gives them a set of gap equations based on minimizing the effective potential with respect to both the auxiliary vector field and that delta parameter.

Mira: That minimization process leads to a specific solution for the gap equation, which is A bar mu plus g times Pi mu of bar a D equals zero, which essentially defines the vacuum state associated with that background field.

Title and authors: Lev: And we should also look at what happens when we take that solution and plug it back into the gap equation itself to see what kind of asymptotic behavior we get when N approaches infinity. They found that in the large N limit, the PMS solution reduces to a specific form where A bar zero equals A zero and A bar two zero equals negative three times pi over two g.

Kai: That means if you take this dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system and let N get really big, you're left with a very specific background configuration for the auxiliary field that dictates the vacuum structure.

Mira: And it connects back to their findings about the chiral chemical potential arising from the dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking character of the self interacting model, which is what gives rise to effects like Chiral Magnetic effect and Chiral vortical effect.

Lev: It also links directly to how gravity might behave in very early universes through Einstein-Cartan-Kibble-Sciama theory, where axial self interaction creates gravitational repulsion that prevents a cosmological singularity.

Kai: So, the main implication is that this axial self interaction could be a hint at new physics, maybe connecting to neutrino oscillation data or even dark matter Majorana candidates because of the way it couples to gravity and matter spin.

Mira: The paper suggests that studying these phase transitions on materials could be relevant because they are adapting these results to study those kinds of phase transitions in other physical systems.

Lev: It's a solid framework for exploring how non-perturbative effects, like those from optimized perturbation theory, can predict real physical phenomena in complex field theories.

Kai: So, to wrap up on the paper "First-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system", we see that the finite N corrections give us specific critical temperatures and chemical potentials for different N values.

Mira: The distinction between N equal to one and N greater than or equal to two is really important because it shows a qualitative difference in how the system transitions between its phases.

Lev: And remember, the paper flags that their method relies on the delta parameter expansion up to linear order, so we have to be careful about testing those specific findings without worrying about higher order corrections.

Kai: It’s a good piece of work because it takes a complex model and gives us specific phase transition points derived from non-perturbative techniques.

Mira: And for those who are interested in the connection between this model and experimental neutrino data or dark matter, the paper provides a pathway to explore those connections through these phase transitions.

Lev: We should keep an eye on how other researchers apply this method to see if they can reproduce these results using different types of systems.

Kai: That’s our time on this one paper about the first-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper is looking at how four component massless fermions interact when they have this quartic self interaction, and seeing what happens to their phase diagram when you introduce temperature and chemical potential using optimized perturbation theory to get those finite N numbers.

Mira: Yeah, the main thing they show is that these finite N corrections can actually generate a first-order phase transition specifically when N equals one.

Lev: That’s interesting because standard large N math usually smooths things out, so getting a first-order transition there suggests a real qualitative change in the system's behavior for that specific case.

Kai: Right, and for anything N greater than or equal to two, they found that the transition still looks continuous, so it's still second order. That distinction between N one and N greater than two is a key part of their finding.

Mira: Exactly. The paper then points out that for N one, they find a tricritical point with specific values for temperature and chemical potential, which tells us where the system changes its nature from continuous to something else entirely.

Lev: Those critical values they calculated, like the tricritical point at mu three times g to the negative one over two and temperature three times g to the negative one over two, that would be a concrete target for us if we were trying to run these kinds of simulations on real hardware.

Kai: So, they're not just talking about abstract math; they're giving us specific points in phase space where things get really weird in this fermion model.

Mira: And it has some big implications because the paper links this axial self interaction to neutrino oscillation data and even dark matter candidates like Majorana spinors, which is a pretty huge connection.

Lev: That connection through gravity theories, like Einstein-Cartan-Kibble-Sciama theory, where spacetime torsion creates gravitational repulsion in the early universe, is what makes me think about how this could link to cosmological observations.

Kai: It’s a hint at new physics because this model with axial self interaction can reconcile some of the data we see from neutrinos and dark matter candidates.

Mira: And they also suggest that studying these kinds of phase transitions on materials might be useful because you can adapt these results to study those kinds of phase changes in other physical systems too.

Lev: So, it’s a solid framework for taking a complex field theory model and finding specific physical consequences related to particle physics and even gravity.

Kai: Yeah, the paper shows how non-perturbative methods like optimized perturbation theory can give us these specific transition points that we wouldn't get from just looking at the large N limit.

Mira: So, we’re seeing a different picture for N one versus higher N, but the whole point is that these finite corrections matter for understanding the system's actual behavior.

Lev: And they did show what happens to the vacuum state when you look at those gap equations—the asymptotic behavior in the large N limit reduces to a specific configuration of the auxiliary field.

Kai: That means even in that big N limit, there’s still this fixed background structure for the auxiliary field that defines how everything settles down.

Mira: It shows how these non-perturbative results are deep, because they aren't just approximations; they lead to specific structural predictions for the vacuum itself.

Lev: So, we have these calculated transition points and a picture of the vacuum structure in the large N limit, which gives us a lot to chew on before we look at what this means for actual experimental setups.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we’re looking at how they suggest improving their approach to this model of four component massless fermions to get better results than just using standard large N approximations.

Kai: They introduce this idea of using optimized perturbation theory, or OPT, which lets them capture those finite N contributions that are usually missed in the standard math.

Mira: That’s important because it lets them go beyond the large N limit and actually see features like first-order transitions that might be hidden there.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, getting these finite N effects into something you can actually run on real hardware is tough, but if they can model the physics correctly, it sets a benchmark for what’s possible.

Kai: Right, and they show how this method lets them analyze the phase space of temperature and density more accurately.

Mira: They use that framework to define density as minus the derivative of the field with respect to chemical potential using those gap equations we talked about before.

Lev: And by applying that path integral approach, they can predict richer transition forms for N one systems, including those first-order transitions we saw earlier.

Kai: It’s like they’re giving us a better map of the phase diagram because they're not just relying on the smooth curve from the large N version.

Mira: So, if you take these improvements, you get a much clearer picture of where those first-order transitions actually happen and what conditions are needed for them to exist.

Lev: And they also show how this method helps determine the asymptotic behavior of that PMS solution when N gets really big.

Kai: It means even in the large N limit, there’s still a fixed structure to that auxiliary field background, which is useful for understanding the underlying physics.

Mira: So they’re using these mathematical tools to figure out not just where the transitions happen, but what kind of state you're looking at on both sides of that transition.

Lev: That level of detail, going from the microscopic action to the large N limit structure, is what makes this methodology so powerful for testing ideas in other areas.

Kai: And this detailed analysis gives us a better handle on where the approximations break down and where we need to focus our next efforts.

Conclusion: Tom: So, to wrap up this discussion on "First-order phase-transition on dynamical Lorentz symmetry breaking system", we’ve seen how optimized perturbation theory lets us find specific transition points for different N values in a four component fermion model with quartic self interaction.

Kai: It really shows how these non-perturbative techniques can reveal qualitative differences between N one and N greater than two systems.

Mira: And the main point is that the finite N corrections create a region on temperature and density space that's physically bigger than what we see in just the large N limit.

Lev: That means we have to be careful when we try to run these models on real hardware because those finite N effects could shift where things actually happen.

Kai: Exactly, and the authors show how this axial self interaction connects to neutrino data and dark matter candidates, which is a pretty big implication for particle physics.

Mira: Plus, they suggest that studying these phase changes in materials could be useful because you can adapt this model to other systems where these kinds of transitions occur.

Lev: So we have the specific critical numbers for temperature and chemical potential at zero chemical potential, which gives us targets for what kind of simulation overhead would actually be required.

Kai: That’s right, it’s a solid set of calculated points derived from this paper, but remember they rely on the delta parameter expansion up to linear order.

Mira: We also saw that the asymptotic behavior in the large N limit simplifies into a specific configuration for the auxiliary field background, which is an important piece of information about the vacuum.

Lev: From my side, it’s good to see how they connect that back to those gap equations we discussed earlier, and how it relates to things like torsion in gravity theories.

Kai: We’ve got a lot of work left on how these concepts tie into actual experimental constraints, so the next step is figuring out if these phase transition points are testable with current or future tools.

Mira: I think there’s a lot more to unpack regarding the connection between this model and those neutrino oscillation results, which is where the real excitement for me is.

Lev: I just want to say that while the math here is solid, translating these finite N corrections into a simulation that actually runs efficiently on a real quantum computer is going to be a significant hurdle we have to overcome.

Y. M. P. Gomes, *, M. J. Neves, *

Departamento de Física Teórica, Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro · Departamento de Física, Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro

hep-th, hep-ph

Submitted: 2023-10-03

Updated: 2024-07-08

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures, Accepted version in Nuclear Physics B

Journal ref: Nucl. Phys. B 1006 (2024) 116625

DOI: 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2024.116625

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 72/100

The gist: A model of N 4-component massless fermions in a quartic self-interaction based on ref.

Key concepts

Optimized Perturbation Theory (OPT)
A method used to calculate corrections beyond the large-N limit in this model. It uses a fictitious parameter called 'delta' to systematically include finite-N contributions, allowing the study of non-perturbative features like first-order transitions that standard methods miss.
Finite-N Corrections
These are small corrections arising from the fact that N is not infinitely large. For N=1, these corrections significantly alter the phase space compared to the large-N approximation, leading to qualitatively different system behaviors and richer transition forms.
Phase Transition (First/Second Order)
A change in the system's state as external parameters like temperature or chemical potential are varied. A first-order transition involves a sudden jump in the order parameter, while a second-order transition involves continuous changes. The paper finds different behaviors for N=1 versus N>=2.
Chemical Potential ($\mu$)
A thermodynamic quantity introduced to study systems at constant particle density. It modifies the energy levels of fermions and is crucial for exploring the phase space, especially when studying transitions at zero temperature.

Terminology

Summary

A model of N 4-component massless fermions in a quartic self-interaction based on ref. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gomes1, ∗ and M. Neves2, † 1Departamento de F´ısica Te´orica, Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, 20550-013, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil 2Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro, BR 465-07, 23890-971, Serop´edica, RJ, Brazil A model of N 4-component massless fermions in a quartic self-interaction based on ref.

[19] is investigated in the presence of chemical potential and temperature via optimized perturbation theory that accesses finite-N contributions The model shows the finite-N corrections generate first-order phase transitions on the self-interacting fermions for the case N = 1 and the persistence of a second-order phase transition for N ≥ 2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We discuss the solutions of the four cases in which (T = 0, µ = 0), (T ̸= 0, µ ̸= 0), (T ̸= 0, µ = 0) and (T = 0, µ ̸= 0), where the effective potential is so obtained as a function of the background vector field, the chemical potential, and the temperature. The model shows the finite-N corrections generate first-order phase transitions on the self-interacting fermions for the case N = 1 and the persistence of a second-order phase transition for N ≥ 2.

Model Setup and Methodology

The investigation utilizes a model of N massless four-component fermions in the presence of a quartic self-interaction via ref. [19] The effective Lagrangian (2) introduces an auxiliary vector field Aµ where L = ψk i∂/ − Aγ/ 5ψk + N/2g AµAµ Corrections beyond the large-N limit are implemented via the optimized perturbation theory (OPT) deformation based on [30, 31, 36, 37] through the fictitious δ-parameter The effective potential expanded up to linear order on the δ-parameter is given by Vef f (Aµ, aµ, δ) = −δ/2g AµAµ + iZ d4p (2π)4 Tr ln p/− a/γ5 + iδ Z d4p (2π)4 Tr "(a/− A/)γ5 p/− a/γ5 > O(δ 2) The common fraction of the integrals in (7) can be written as 1 p/− a/γ5 = N0(p)/R(p).

Symmetry Breaking and Gap Equations

The principle of minimal sensitivity (PMS) applied to the effective potential (10) is defined by the identity ∂Vef f/∂aµδ=1=0 This yields the PMS equation "∂omega/∂aµ + Πµ(a, D) + (a − A)ν ∂Πν/∂aµ−g2N∂Ξ/∂aµδ=1=0 The gap equation is defined by ∂Vef f/dAµAµ=Aµ=¯µ, aµ=¯aµ,δ=1=0 which yields the relation A¯µ + g Π µ(¯a, D) = 0 The solution for the gap equation is given by Ā0 + g Π µ(¯a, D) = 0.

Thermodynamic Quantities and Phase Transitions

The temperature (T) and chemical potential (µ) are introduced via Matsubara formalism modifying the p0-component by p0 → iωn − µ, and summing over all the Matsubara frequencies ωn This modification opens the three possible cases (T ̸= 0, µ ̸= 0), (T ̸= 0, µ = 0), and (T = 0, µ ≠ 0) that will be discussed in the next subsections The critical temperature at zero chemical potential is Tc(µ = 0) ∞ is given by a value dependent on N. For N > 1, the critical chemical potential at zero temperature is given by µc(T = 0) µc(T = 0) ≈ √πg1 − 5/6N−1/2. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Looking ahead to the results, the vacuum solution for the gap equation given by A¯ √ 0 = √ 3π |g| 1 (1−1/2N) 3/2 is representative in terms to show the non-perturbative properties of the OPT approach, since the non-polynomial character of the correction in comparison with the large-N results. The non-perturbative results also show up on the critical temperature at zero chemical potential Tc = √ √ 3 |g| 1 − 1/2N −1/2 for N ≥ 1 and the critical chemical potential at zero temperature given by µc = √π |g| 1 − 5/6N −1/2 for N > 1.

Finite-N Effects and Phase Portraits

The results show that for N ≥ 2, there is no qualitative difference, i.e., the phase transition still has a continuous behavior and thus is a second-order phase transition In contrast, the case N = 1 shows a qualitative difference. p. 6

Where the paper says it

, the phase transition still has a continuous behavior and thus is a secondorder phase transition. On the other hand, the case N = 1 shows a qualitative difference.

The finite-N corrections generate a region on the phase space T × density which is larger than the large-N counterpart. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Going further, the phase portraits are shown in Figs. 5 ,6, 7 and 6, and one can see that, for N > 1, the finite-N corrections generate a region on the phase space T × density which is larger than the large-N counterpart.

For N = 1, one finds a very different system behavior between the symmetric and asymmetric phases The tricritical point is represented by the red dot in Figs. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, one finds a very different system behavior in the case of N = 1. In this case, the system transits in much richer forms between the symmetric and asymmetric phases.

7 and 8, which gives us µtric ≈ 5. p. 9
Where the paper says it

We also obtain the tricritical point represented by the red dot in Figs. 7 and 8, which gives us µtric ≈ 5.

05g−1/2(ntric ≈ 35. p. 9
Where the paper says it

7 and 8, which gives us µtric ≈ 5. 05g −1/2 (ntric ≈ 35.

2g−3/2) and Ttric ≈ 3g−1/2. p. 9
Where the paper says it

05g −1/2 (ntric ≈ 35. 2g −3/2 ) and Ttric ≈ 3g −1/2 .

Physical Implications

The axial self-interaction has been shown to reconcile the LSND and super-Kamiokande neutrino oscillation data This phenomenon can be a first hint at new physics and has a strong connection with the results in this article. In the context of Einstein-CartanKibble-Sciama (ECKS) theory of gravity [43] which naturally extends general relativity to includes the spin of matter, the torsion of spacetime generates gravitational repulsion in the early Universe Furthermore, dark matter Majorana candidates could present first-order phase transitions at some densities. p. 8

Where the paper says it

High-precision measurements of the neutrino oscillations can be a way to find stronger bounds on G and a possible way to study flavor physics through the N dependence of the axial condensate. Going further, in the context of Einstein-CartanKibble-Sciama (ECKS) theory of gravity [43] which naturally extends general relativity to includes the spin of matter, the torsion of spacetime generates gravitational repulsion in the early Universe, preventing the cosmological singularity through a repulsive axial self-interactions between fermions.

The results shown in this work can be adapted to study phase transitions on such materials. p. 8
Where the paper says it

When this symmetry is explicitly or spontaneously broken, it leads to the manifestation of various electronic phases within the system [46]. The results shown in this work can be adapted to study phase transitions on such materials

Conclusions

The non-perturbative results also show up on the critical temperature at zero chemical potential Tc = √√3g1−1/2N−1/2 for N ≥ 1 and the critical chemical potential at zero temperature given by µc = √πg1−5/6N−1/2 for N > 1 The non-perturbative results are one of our main results. For N = 1, the system transits in much richer forms between the symmetric and asymmetric phases. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Furthermore, one finds a very different system behavior in the case of N = 1. In this case, the system transits in much richer forms between the symmetric and asymmetric phases.

The OPT predicts a first-order phase transition region below the tricritical temperature and above the tricritical density for N = 1 The robust nature of this feature in δ2-expansion can be tested. p. 9
Where the paper says it

2g −3/2 ) and Ttric ≈ 3g −1/2 . It is important to highlight that our result for N = 1 shows that below the tricritical temperature and above the tricritical density, the OPT predicts a first-order phase transition region.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform non-perturbative calculations by utilizing optimized perturbation theory (OPT) to access finite-N contributions, as described in Section II and III of the paper. This allows the system to move beyond large-N approximations and capture features like first-order transitions that are missed in standard methods.

  2. Improved AI can analyze phase diagrams for N=1 systems by consistently applying the path integral approach to define density as n = -∂Φ/∂µ using the PMS and gap equations (Equation 44). This enables the system to predict richer transition forms, including first-order transitions, unique to N=1.

  3. Improved AI can determine critical parameters with higher precision by solving the derived solutions for critical temperature Tc and chemical potential mu c. For example, it can calculate Tc = sqrt(sqrt(3)g / (1 - 1/2N)) for N >= 1, or mu c = sqrt(pi)g / (1 - 5/6N) for N > 1.

  4. Improved AI can model the effect of finite-N corrections on phase space by analyzing Figure 6. It can identify that "for N > 1, the finite-N corrections generate a region on the phase space T × density which is larger than the large-N counterpart."

  5. Improved AI can predict vacuum state behavior based on background fields by solving the gap equation (Equation 18) and PMS equation (Equation 16). It can determine that The asymptotic behavior of the PMS solution is the N-large limit (LN), when N → ∞, is reduced to: LN: a0 = A0, A¯2 0 − 3π/2 g = 0.

  6. Improved AI can explore the implications for high-energy physics by linking LSV models to neutrino oscillation data and dark matter candidates. It can assess that This phenomenon [axial self-interaction] can be a first hint at new physics and has a strong connection with the results in this article regarding Majorana spinors.

Abstract

A model of N 4-component massless fermions in a quartic self-interaction based on ref. is investigated in the presence of chemical potential and temperature via optimized perturbation theory that accesses finite-N contributions. We use the generating functional approach to calculate the corrections to the effective potential of the model. The model introduces an auxiliary pseudo-vector field with a nontrivial minimum and is influenced by temperature (T) and chemical potential (μ). These thermodynamic quantities are introduced through Matsubara formalism. Thereby, the integrals are modified, and via the principle of minimum sensitivity, we obtain the gap equations of the model. The correspondent finite-N solutions of these equations define the vacuum states of the model associated with the background pseudo-vector field. In particular, one focuses on its temporal component that acts as an effective chiral chemical potential. We discuss the solutions of the four cases in which (T = 0,μ= 0), (T not equal to 0,μ not equal to 0), (T not equal to 0,μ= 0) and (T = 0,μ not equal to 0), where the effective potential is so obtained as a function of the background vector field, the chemical potential, and the temperature. The model shows the finite-N corrections generate first-order phase transitions on the self-interacting fermions for the case N=1 and the persistence of a second-order phase transition for N at least 2.

Sources

Related papers