Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons

arXiv:2306.15757 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2023-06-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons are formed in electron-doped Mott insulators like Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6, which block the onset of a metallic phase even at ultrahigh doping and enable the coexistence of different spin-orbital Jeff states in the same compound.

Kai: Formation of Spin-Orbital Bipolarons Polarons and spin-orbit (SO) coupling are distinct quantum effects that play a critical role in charge transport and spin-orbitronics.

Mira: The study combines ab initio calculations and magnetic measurements to show that these two seemingly mutually exclusive interactions are entangled in the electron-doped SO-coupled Mott insulator Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6 (0 < x < 1), unveiling the formation of spin-orbital bipolarons.

Kai: Polaron charge trapping, favored by Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d1 spin-orbital Jeff = 3/2 levels into a bipolaron 5d2 Jeff = 2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a single-phase material.

Title and authors: Mira: Let's start by looking at the title and authors for this paper, "Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons." It immediately tells us what we’re dealing with: a complex interaction between spin, orbit, Jahn-Teller distortions, and bipolarons.

Kai: Yeah, it’s a mouthful. The authors are Celiberti and Mosca from the University of Vienna and Paris Centre de Physique Théorique. They bring expertise in both the theoretical modeling of these coupled effects and experimental measurements on these materials.

Lev: As an error correction researcher, I’m interested in how they manage to model this entanglement between the polaron physics and the spin-orbit coupling so precisely.

Kai: That’s exactly what I mean. They are showing that these two phenomena, polaron formation and spin-orbit coupling, which we usually think of as separate quantum effects, are actually entangled in this electron-doped Mott insulator.

Mira: It’s not just a simple superposition; they show how the polaron charge trapping converts the Os five d one spin-orbital Jeff three over two levels into a bipolaron five d two Jeff two manifold.

Lev: That conversion is what makes it harder to run on real hardware, because you have to account for this local modification of the electronic configuration at every single site.

Kai: Right, and they visualize this entanglement using DFT charge density isosurfaces, which shows the formation of entangled bipolaronic PB one and PB two bands displayed in panel b.

Mira: That visualization is key because it lets them conceptualize what a spin-orbit polaron actually looks like within this single phase material.

Lev: So, for us on the hardware side, if we can map these local states to something we can measure or correct, that’s where the real challenge lies.

Kai: And they also predict how electron doping affects Mott insulators by identifying how excess charge carriers get trapped at specific sites, like being trapped at a d one Os site.

Mira: This trapping leads to a local modification of the electronic configuration from d one to d two, which is what helps explain why the insulating gap remains open even at any concentration in Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6.

Lev: If we can reliably predict where these traps will form based on doping, that would dramatically improve our error correction schemes for these systems.

Kai: That capability of predicting localized trapping is crucial because it helps us understand the robustness of the Mott gap across that entire doping range.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize this paper, they are describing how adding excess electrons at a local Jeff three over two site causes the formation of those spin-orbit entangled Jeff two bipolarons.

Mira: These bipolarons block the onset of a metallic phase, and this happens because they are less stable than the delocalized alternative metal phase by one hundred thirty four meV.

Lev: A hundred thirty four meV difference is significant when you’re trying to maintain a gap in a Mott insulator, so that’s a big factor for practical applications.

Kai: They do this by showing that the excess charge is trapped at a d one Os site, which causes an isotropic expansion of the surrounding Os six oxygen octahedron by about four times ten to the minus two angstrom.

Mira: This expansion leads to new nearly flat bands developing in the mid gap region, and these are hallmarks of small polaron formation, which they confirm with local polaronic charge displayed in panel one a.

Lev: So they’re saying this local lattice change is the mechanism that stabilizes the small polaron phase against delocalization.

Kai: And they confirm that electron trapping in transition metal oxides generally occurs in an empty d zero manifold at the bottom of the conduction band, leading to a d zero to d one transition at the trapping site associated with one mid gap flat band.

Mira: This is all happening in BNOO, where the five d orbital is singlet, which sets up this specific environment for this behavior.

Lev: So they’re describing a very specific microscopic pathway for charge localization that we can use to calculate things like hopping dynamics using density functional theory and dynamical mean field theory.

Kai: And they found that the energy barrier for charge transfer is calculated at zero point six six meV, which is in excellent agreement with the experimentally derived activation energy.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Now let's look at what improvements this paper suggests for future research and how those ideas can be translated into better models.

Kai: They propose using improved AI systems to perform ab initio calculations of spin-orbital bipolarons by combining DFT charge density isosurfaces with magnetic measurements, as shown in figure one in this paper.

Lev: I like that idea because visualizing the entangled bands and conceptualizing a spin-orbit polaron within a single phase material is a huge step for understanding these complex materials.

Mira: That visualization is important because it lets us see the physics beyond what’s just just a static DFT calculation can show.

Kai: Another improvement they suggest is using AI to predict the effect of electron doping on Mott insulators by identifying how excess charge carriers are trapped at specific sites, like being trapped at a d one Os site.

Lev: That capability to pinpoint the trapping site based on doping is critical because it helps us understand why the insulating gap remains open at any concentration in Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6.

Mira: And they also suggest modeling polaron hopping dynamics using Density Functional Theory and Dynamical Mean Field Theory to determine the energy barrier for charge transfer, which they say is zero point six six meV.

Lev: That calculated barrier of zero point six six meV is in excellent agreement with the experimentally derived activation energy, so it’s a solid benchmark for testing our computational models.

Kai: Finally, they propose interpreting experimental NMR relaxation rate anomalies by fitting them to a Bloembergen-Purcell-Pound like model derived from phonon fluctuations.

Mira: Relating the polaron induced spin-lattice relaxation rate one over T one to the modulation of distortion modes q one and q three is a very specific way to interpret those anomalous peaks.

Lev: If we can successfully map those experimental signatures to these calculated phonon modes, that gives us a concrete target for what our models need to reproduce.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping this up on "Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons," the main implication is that this new polaron quasiparticle blocks the insulating metal transition even at ultrahigh doping.

Mira: This means we can see a coexistence of different spin-orbital Jeff states in the same compound, and this mixed state is a precursor to the homogeneous Jeff two state at full sodium to calcium substitution.

Lev: For our error correction research, this localized trapping mechanism gives us a concrete physical picture of how charge carriers are immobilized in these systems.

Kai: So, we have a very specific picture now for the spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons and why they matter for understanding these materials.

Mira: And we’re ready to look at what this means next in terms of exploring polaron physics in quantum materials with strong spin-orbit coupling, topological systems and two dimensional materials.

Lev: We just need to keep pushing the computational tools to handle these complex many-body problems with better fidelity on real hardware.

Kai: That’s the direction we’re heading for the next paper, looking at how this new physics translates into tangible experimental observables for our systems.

Lorenzo Celiberti, Dario Fiore Mosca, Giuseppe Allodi, Leonid V. Pourovskii, Anna Tassetti, Paola Caterina Forino, Rong Cong, Erick Garcia, Phuong M. Tran, Roberto De Renzi, Patrick M. Woodward, § Vesna F. Mitrović, § Samuele Sanna, and Cesare Franchini

University of Vienna, Faculty of Physics and Center for Computational Materials Science, Vienna, Austria · Department of Physics and Astronomy ’Augusto Righi’ Alma Mater Studiorum - Universita di Bologna · Centre de Physique Théorique, Ecole Polytechnique, CNRS, Institut Polytechnique de Paris · Coll຃ge de France, Universite PSL · Department of Mathematical, Physical and Computer Sciences University of Parma · Department of Physics Brown University · Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry The Ohio State University

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2023-06-27

Updated: 2023-06-27

Journal ref: Nature Communications (2024) 15:2429

DOI: 10.1038/s41467-024-46621-0

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons are formed in electron-doped Mott insulators like Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6…

Key concepts

Spin-Orbital Bipolarons
These are quasiparticles formed when charge trapping (polaron formation) interacts with strong spin-orbit coupling in Osmium ions. The trapping process changes the electronic state from a single electron configuration to a paired, two-electron configuration that carries both spin and orbital angular momentum.
Jahn-Teller Effect (JT)
The Jahn-Teller effect describes how molecules or materials distort their geometry to lower their energy when they have degenerate electronic states. In this study, the lattice distortion helps stabilize the polaron by converting the initial single electron state into a more stable bipolaron configuration.
Mott Insulator
A Mott insulator is a material that is insulating not because of band structure, but because of strong electron-electron interactions. These interactions prevent charge movement even when there are available energy levels, maintaining an insulating gap in the material.
Spin-Orbit (SO) Coupling
Spin-orbit coupling is an interaction between an electron's spin and its orbital motion. In this material, SO coupling influences the lattice distortion (Jahn-Teller distortion), affecting how stable the resulting charge carriers (bipolarons) are.

Terminology

Summary

Spin-orbital Jahn-Teller bipolarons are formed in electron-doped Mott insulators like Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6, which block the onset of a metallic phase even at ultrahigh doping and enable the coexistence of different spin-orbital Jeff states in the same compound. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Polaron charge trapping, favoured by the Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d1 spin-orbital Jeff = 3/2 levels, characteristic of the parent compound Ba2NaOsO6 (BNOO), into a bipolaron 5d2 Jeff = 2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a singlephase material. The gradual increase of bipolarons with increasing doping creates robust in-gap states that prevents the transition to a metal phase even at ultrahigh doping, thus preserving the Mott gap across the entire doping range from d 1 BNOO to d 2 Ba2CaOsO6 (BCOO).

Formation of Spin-Orbital Bipolarons

Polarons and spin-orbit (SO) coupling are distinct quantum effects that play a critical role in charge transport and spin-orbitronics. The study combines ab initio calculations and magnetic measurements to show that these two seemingly mutually exclusive interactions are entangled in the electron-doped SO-coupled Mott insulator Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6 (0 < x < 1), unveiling the formation of spin-orbital bipolarons. p. 0

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, the relativistic coupling between the spin and orbital angular momentum is notable in lattices with heavy atoms and develops in 5d TMOs, where electrons are spatially delocalized. Here we combine ab initio calculations and magnetic measurements to show that these two seemingly mutually exclusive interactions are entangled in the electron-doped SO-coupled Mott insulator Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6 (0 < x < 1), unveiling the formation of spin-orbital bipolarons.

Polaron charge trapping, favored by Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d1 spin-orbital Jeff = 3/2 levels into a bipolaron 5d2 Jeff = 2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a single-phase material. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Polaron charge trapping, favoured by the Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d1 spin-orbital Jeff = 3/2 levels, characteristic of the parent compound Ba2NaOsO6 (BNOO), into a bipolaron 5d2 Jeff = 2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a singlephase material. The gradual increase of bipolarons with increasing doping creates robust in-gap states that prevents the transition to a metal phase even at ultrahigh doping, thus preserving the Mott gap across the entire doping range from d 1 BNOO to d 2 Ba2CaOsO6 (BCOO).

The gradual increase of bipolarons with increasing doping creates robust in-gap states that prevents the transition to a metal phase even at ultrahigh doping, thus preserving the Mott gap across the entire doping range from d1 BNOO to d2 Ba2CaOsO6 (BCOO). p. 0
Where the paper says it

Polaron charge trapping, favoured by the Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d1 spin-orbital Jeff = 3/2 levels, characteristic of the parent compound Ba2NaOsO6 (BNOO), into a bipolaron 5d2 Jeff = 2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a singlephase material. The gradual increase of bipolarons with increasing doping creates robust in-gap states that prevents the transition to a metal phase even at ultrahigh doping, thus preserving the Mott gap across the entire doping range from d 1 BNOO to d 2 Ba2CaOsO6 (BCOO).

Experimental Evidence and Dynamics

Polaron formation is confirmed by 23Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and muon spin rotation (µSR) measurements on a BNOO sample having 12.5% Ca concentration. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Polaron formation is confirmed by 23Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and muon spin rotation (µSR) measurements on a BNOO sample having 12. 5% Ca concentration shown in Fig.

NMR shows an anomalous peak at T P,1 ≈ 130 K in the spin-lattice relaxation rate 1/T1, well above the temperature associated to the magnetic transition (6. p. 2
Where the paper says it

2(a) and (b), respectively. NMR shows an anomalous peak at TP,1 ≈ 130 K in the spin-lattice relaxation rate 1/T1 (squares), well above the temperature associated to the magnetic transition (6.

8 K); correspondingly, a peak is observed in the spin-spin relaxation rate 1/T2 at T P,2 ≈ 50 K. p. 2
Where the paper says it

NMR shows an anomalous peak at TP,1 ≈ 130 K in the spin-lattice relaxation rate 1/T1 (squares), well above the temperature associated to the magnetic transition (6. 8 K); correspondingly, a peak is observed in the spin-spin relaxation rate 1/T2 at TP,2 ≈ 50 K (triangles).

The anomalous peak in NMR 1/T1 temperature dependence is fitted using a Bloembergen-Purcell-Pound-like (BPP) model for quadrupolar spin-lattice relaxation. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The µSR results exhibit strong critical relaxation rates at the magnetic transition temperature, 7 K, but no further relaxation peak above, in agreement with the quadrupolar polaronic mechanism [16], since the spin 1/2 muon is not coupled to EFGs. The anomalous peak in NMR 1/T1 temperature dependence is fitted using a Bloembergen-Purcell-Pound-like (BPP) model for quadrupolar spin-lattice relaxation [37, 38] 1 T1 = ∆2 τc 1 + (ω0τc) 2 + 4τc 1 + (2ω0τc) 2 , (1) where ∆2 is the second moment of the perturbing quadrupole-phonon coupling and the correlation time τc = τ0 exp(Ea/kT) is expressed in terms of the activation energy Ea and the characteristic correlation time τ0 of the dynamical process.

The resulting fitting curve predicts a dynamical process with an activation energy of Ea = 74(2) meV, τ0 = 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The resulting fitting curve is represented by the solid line in Fig. 2(a) and predicts a dynamical process with activation energy of Ea = 74(2) meV, τ0 = 0.

7(0.2) ps and ∆2 = 2.75(6) × 109 s−2.

Role of Jahn-Teller and SO Coupling

The analysis shows that the isotropic expansion Q1 contributes 67% of the total Epol, making it the major lattice contribution to polaron stability. The tetragonal elongation along the [001] axis Q3 decreases with increasing cλ, and this SO-induced suppression of JT distortions is reflected on the JT energy (EJT), which correlates the SO-induced decrease of Epol with the progressive quenching of Q3. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Moreover, this SOinduced suppression of JT distortions is reflected on the JT energy (EJT ), estimated from the potential energy surface at different values of cλ and displayed in Fig. Therefore, Q3 appears to be the key JT mode explaining the coupling between SO and polaron stability, correlating the SO-induced decrease of Epol with the progressive quenching of Q3 and associated reduction of EJT .

The breathing-out mode Q1 stays constant throughout the range of SO intensity. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Upon charge trapping, the electrostatic potential of the OsO6 octahedron increases due to the additional excess charge. To counterbalance this energy cost, the oxygen cage expands according to the isotropic (A1g) breathing-out mode Q1.

Doping Dependence and Phase Stability

The second moment of the fluctuating field ∆2 (see Eq. (1)) exhibits a dome shape, characterized by a progressive increase until ≈ 75% Ca concentration, followed by a rapid decrease towards the full doping limit (x = 1, BCOO). p. 6

Where the paper says it

(1)) as a function of doping (Fig. 4(c)) exhibits a dome shape, characterized by a progressive increase until ≈ 75% Ca concentration, followed by a rapid decrease towards the full doping limit (x = 1, BCOO) with all Os sites converted into a non-polaron d 2 configuration in a undistorted and JT-quenched cubic lattice.

The main phonon contributions to polaron dynamics are encoded in the modulation of the breathing-out mode Q1 and the tetragonal distortion Q3 as a function of doping. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The obtained numerical data summarized in Fig. 4(c) reproduce the experimental trend and indicate that, upon doping in Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6, the main phonon contributions to polaron dynamics are encoded in the modulation of the breathing-out mode Q1 and the tetragonal distortion Q3 as a function of doping.

Conclusion and Outlook

The study discloses a new type of polaron quasiparticle which is responsible for blocking the IMT even at ultrahigh doping and enables the coexistence of different spin-orbital Jeff states in the same compound. This mixed-state can be interpreted as a precursor state towards the formation of the homogeneous Jeff = 2 state at full Na → Ca substitution (BCOO [50]), and the polaron is the main driving force of this transition. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Summarizing, our study discloses a new type of polaron quasiparticle which is responsible for blocking the IMT even at ultrahigh doping and enables the coexistence of different spin-orbital Jeff states in the same compound. This mixed-state can be interpreted as a precursor state towards the formation of the homogeneous Jeff = 2 state at full Na → Ca substitution (BCOO [50]), and the polaron is the main driving force of this transition.

In perspective, this work provides the conceptual means to explore polaron physics in quantum materials with strong spin–orbit coupling including topological [51], Rashba [52] and 2D materials [53], and pave the way for polaron spintronics [54], polaron heavy-elements catalysis [55] and polaron multipolar magnetism. p. 6
Where the paper says it

This mixed-state can be interpreted as a precursor state towards the formation of the homogeneous Jeff = 2 state at full Na → Ca substitution (BCOO [50]), and the polaron is the main driving force of this transition. In perspective, this work provides the conceptual means to explore polaron physics in quantum materials with strong spin–orbit coupling including topological [51], Rashba [52] and 2D materials [53], and pave the way for polaron spintronics [54], polaron heavy-elements catalysis [55] and polaron multipolar magnetism [31, 56–58].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform ab initio calculations of spin-orbital bipolarons by combining DFT charge density isosurfaces with magnetic measurements, as shown in Fig 1 in this paper. This allows for the visualization of entangled bipolaronic PB1 and PB2 bands displayed in panel b and the analysis of a conceptualizing a SO polaron within a single phase material.

  2. Improved AI system can predict the effect of electron doping on Mott insulators by identifying how excess charge carriers are trapped at specific sites, such as trapped at a d 1 Os site, leading to a local modification of the electronic configuration from d 1 → d 2. This capability is crucial for understanding why the insulating gap remains open at any concentration in Ba2Na1−xCaxOsO6.

  3. Improved AI system can model polaron hopping dynamics using Density Functional Theory and Dynamical Mean Field Theory to determine the energy barrier for charge transfer, as evidenced by the calculated barrier of 0.66 meV which is in excellent agreement with the experimentally-derived activation energy.

  4. Improved AI system can interpret experimental NMR relaxation rate anomalies by fitting them to a Bloembergen-Purcell-Pound-like (BPP) model derived from phonon fluctuations, specifically relating the polaroninduced spin-lattice relaxation rate 1/T1 to the modulation of distortion modes Q1 and Q3.

  5. Improved AI system can determine the key physical drivers for polaron stability by analyzing how SO dampens the JT distortion Q3 leading to a reduction of EJT and consequentially a progressive increase of Epol (less stable polaron) with increasing SO coupling strength.

Abstract

Polarons and spin-orbit (SO) coupling are distinct quantum effects that play a critical role in charge transport and spin-orbitronics. Polarons originate from strong electron-phonon interaction and are ubiquitous in polarizable materials featuring electron localization, in particular 3d transition metal oxides (TMOs). On the other hand, the relativistic coupling between the spin and orbital angular momentum is notable in lattices with heavy atoms and develops in 5d TMOs, where electrons are spatially delocalized. Here we combine ab initio calculations and magnetic measurements to show that these two seemingly mutually exclusive interactions are entangled in the electron-doped SO-coupled Mott insulator Ba 2Na 1-xCa xOsO 6 (0< x < 1), unveiling the formation of spin-orbital bipolarons. Polaron charge trapping, favoured by the Jahn-Teller lattice activity, converts the Os 5d 1 spin-orbital J eff=3/2 levels, characteristic of the parent compound Ba 2NaOsO 6 (BNOO), into a bipolaron 5d squared J eff=2 manifold, leading to the coexistence of different J-effective states in a single-phase material. The gradual increase of bipolarons with increasing doping creates robust in-gap states that prevents the transition to a metal phase even at ultrahigh doping, thus preserving the Mott gap across the entire doping range from d 1 BNOO to d squared Ba 2CaOsO 6 (BCOO).

Sources

Related papers