Providing Curative Distribution Grid Flexibility Using Online Feedback Optimization
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.
Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Providing Curative Distribution Grid Flexibility Using Online Feedback Optimization".
Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Distribution grid flexibility is regarded as a possible measure in curative system operation, yielding a need for an efficient and robust coordination mechanism for the joint flexibility provision by individual units to the transmission grid.
Rosa: This paper introduces a method to coordinate distribution grid level flexibility as a fast-responding curative measure based on Online Feedback Optimization.
Dev: Problem Context and Motivation Curative operation of energy transmission systems is a promising approach to allow for more efficient utilization of existing operating resources, therefore reducing the need for expensive preventive re-dispatch, while maintaining a high level of security in online system operation.
Rosa: This curative operation becomes possible through fast-responding measures, that are able to reduce line loading below the permanently admissible limits (PATL) in case of an overload within a short interval of time, ranging from several seconds to several minutes.
Paper summary: Rosa: So we're looking at this paper about providing distribution grid flexibility using Online Feedback Optimization, and it claims this is a way to handle system operation when things get overloaded quickly without needing those expensive preventive re-dispatches.
Dev: Yeah, it’s about using fast-responding measures to reduce line loading below the permanently admissible limits if there's an overload within a short time frame, ranging from several seconds to several minutes.
Taro: What matters here is that this approach lets you adjust power set points for flexibility providing units in real time to prevent those limit violations.
Rosa: The paper introduces a method based on Online Feedback Optimization to coordinate this distribution grid level flexibility as a fast-responding curative measure, which means it needs an efficient and robust coordination mechanism for all the individual units providing flexibility to the transmission grid.
Dev: It sets up an optimization problem where they formulate set points for active and reactive power to those units, with constraints in place to prevent violating operational limits.
Taro: What I find interesting is how they frame that optimization problem by minimizing a cost function that looks at the sum of active and reactive power that is fed into the grid by those flexible units.
Rosa: And they evaluate this method against three key requirements: first, set point disaggregation means the requested flexibility has to come from flexible units distributed within the flexibility providing grid.
Dev: Then there’s speed and reliability, demanding that this curative flexibility is provided within a preferably short time frame, less than two minutes for disaggregating new set points.
Taro: And third, they focus on safe flexibility potentials, making sure these set points don't cause violations in voltage limits at any bus or operating resource in the grid.
Rosa: So they tested this method on an exemplary low voltage grid with a single point connecting to the public medium voltage grid to see if it actually works in practice.
Dev: The results showed that the requested amount of active power at the point of connection is reached within three iterations of the Online Feedback Optimization algorithm after ten seconds for a sampling time, and then it stays without any tracking error afterward.
Taro: And they also found that if you feed in higher active power by a battery energy storage system, it results in a higher overall need for reactive power to keep the bus voltages within their permissible range.
Rosa: The controller they implemented is showing a high level of robustness against external disturbances that happen while providing this flexibility.
Dev: The main advantage they point out is that the Online Feedback Optimization algorithm requires very little explicit model information and it’s robust against model mismatch and time-varying disturbances.
Taro: It seems computationally efficient too, which is important when you need a fast response for something like curative operation.
Rosa: So to wrap up this paper, they introduced a method to coordinate distribution grid flexibility using Online Feedback Optimization as a viable option for curative system operation because of its speed and reliability under external disturbances.
Dev: It really stands out because of the low need for information about the grid and the robustness against model mismatch that sets this method further apart from conventional optimal power flow calculations.
Taro: They also mentioned that possible interference between multiple Online Feedback Optimization controllers during coordination will be investigated in future work, which is something to watch.
Rosa: So when you think about what this means for the world, it suggests a way to manage the immediate stresses on local distribution grids right now by coordinating decentralized flexibility units efficiently without needing perfect knowledge of every single component.
Conclusion: Rosa: So we're wrapping up this look at Online Feedback Optimization for distribution grid flexibility, focusing on their paper titled "Providing Curative Distribution Grid Flexibility Using Online Feedback Optimization."
Dev: Basically, they show how to coordinate those individual units providing flexibility—like batteries or storage—to handle sudden overloads in a grid.
Rosa: Right, they frame it as a fast response measure for when things get overloaded quickly, without needing those slow and expensive preventive re-dispatches.
Dev: The authors are pointing out that their method works because it doesn't need tons of specific model information about the whole grid to run the coordination loop.
Rosa: They tested it on a low voltage grid, and they found that after ten seconds, the requested active power at the connection point was met without any tracking error.
Dev: That speed is key for real-time control; it means they can react fast enough to keep things stable during those short intervals of overload.
Rosa: But there's a catch, they found that feeding in more active power through battery storage actually increased the need for reactive power just to keep the bus voltages okay.
Dev: That’s the trade-off; you get faster response but you might need more reactive support depending on what you're feeding in.
Rosa: The authors are saying this Online Feedback Optimization approach is robust against disturbances that happen while the flexibility is actually being provided to the grid.
Dev: It’s a solid way to coordinate distributed resources, but they did flag that figuring out how multiple of these feedback optimization controllers will interact when they're all trying to work together is still some future homework.
Rosa: That interaction between different controllers sounds like the next big thing we need to watch closely in this area.
RWTH Aachen University · Automatic Control Laboratory at ETH Zurich
eess.SY, cs.SY
Submitted: 2023-06-26
Updated: 2023-11-06
Journal ref: 2023 IEEE PES Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Europe (ISGT EUROPE)
DOI: 10.1109/ISGTEUROPE56780.2023.10407589
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: Distribution grid flexibility is regarded as a possible measure in curative system operation, yielding a need for an efficient and robust coordination mechanism for the joint flexibility provision by…
Key concepts
- Curative Operation
- This involves using fast-responding measures in energy transmission systems to reduce line loading below permanent limits when an overload occurs quickly. It allows for efficient use of existing resources without needing expensive preventive re-dispatch.
- Online Feedback Optimization (OFO)
- OFO is an optimization algorithm that acts as a controller in a closed loop with the power grid. It solves an optimization problem iteratively by using feedback from the grid to adjust set points, minimizing total active and reactive power feed-in.
- Set Point Disaggregation
- This requirement means that when flexibility is requested for curative measures, the system must be able to assign specific flexibility needs to individual Flexible Power Units (FPUs) located within the distribution grid. This ensures the coordination mechanism targets the correct sources.
- Robustness against Model Mismatch
- OFO is advantageous because it requires very little explicit model information about the grid. This makes it highly robust against errors in system models and external disturbances, unlike traditional optimization methods that rely heavily on accurate, detailed system models.
Terminology
Summary
Distribution grid flexibility is regarded as a possible measure in curative system operation, yielding a need for an efficient and robust coordination mechanism for the joint flexibility provision by individual units to the transmission grid. p. 0 This paper introduces a method to coordinate distribution grid level flexibility as a fast-responding curative measure based on Online Feedback Optimization. p. 0
Problem Context and Motivation
Curative operation of energy transmission systems is a promising approach to allow for more efficient utilization of existing operating resources, therefore reducing the need for expensive preventive re-dispatch, while maintaining a high level of security in online system operation. This curative operation becomes possible through fast-responding measures, that are able to reduce line loading below the permanently admissible limits (PATL) in case of an overload within a short interval of time, ranging from several seconds to several minutes. p. 0 The dispatch of set points for FPU can be formulated as an optimization problem preventing the violation of operational limits through constraints. p. 0
Methodology Overview
The core method involves implementing an optimization algorithm that acts as a controller in a closed loop with the power grid. The process begins by formulating an optimization problem to coordinate flexibility, which is then solved using Online Feedback Optimization (OFO). p. 1 The objective function is formulated as minimizing the sum of active and reactive power that is feed-in by the FPU in the grid. p. 2
Key Requirements for Coordination
The evaluation of OFO as an approach to flexibility coordination for curative measures is performed with respect to typical requirements derived from existing literature. These requirements include:
-
Set point disaggregation, which states that the requested flexibility for the curative measure needs to be provided by FPU that are distributed within the flexibility providing grid.
-
Speed and Reliability, demanding that curative flexibility must be provided within a preferably short time frame (∆t ≤ 2min), including the disaggregation of new set points to FPU.
-
Safe flexibility potentials, ensuring that the set points being disaggregated to the FPU in the grid must not lead to violations in voltage limits for each bus and operating resource in the respective grid.
Experimental Validation and Results
The method was implemented in an exemplary low voltage grid with a single PCC to the public medium voltage grid. The results showed that the requested amount of active power at the PCC is reached within three iterations of the OFO algorithm after ∆t = 10s for the chosen sampling time and remains without tracking error afterwards. p. 3 Furthermore, it was visible that higher active power feed-in by the BESS would result in an overall higher need for reactive power to keep bus voltages in the permissible range. p. 3 The implemented controller is exhibiting a high level of robustness against external disturbances that can occur during flexibility provision. p. 4
Advantages of the OFO Approach
The OFO algorithm holds several advantages over conventional coordination algorithms, i.e., [7]:
-
Very little explicit model information are needed.
-
Robustness against model mismatch and time-varying disturbances.
-
Computational efficiency.
Conclusion
In this paper we introduced a method to coordinate distribution grid flexibility for curative system operation by using OFO. It was shown that OFO is holding significant advantages over conventional approaches and is a viable option to coordinate flexibility for a curative measure, due to its speed and reliability under external disturbances. p. 4 This is underlined by the low need for information about the grid and the robustness against model mismatch that sets this method further apart from conventional OPF calculations. p. 4 Possible interference between multiple OFO controllers during coordination will be investigated in future work. p. 4
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This project received funding from the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action under the agreement no. 03EI4046E (PROGRESS). p. 4
REFERENCES
[1] InnoSys 2030, “InnoSys 2030 – Innovations in System Operation up to 2030 - Short Report on the Joint Project.” Jun. 01, 2022. Accessed: Apr. p. 4 17, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www. p. 4innosys230614597v1
[8] V. Haberle, A. p. 4 Hauswirth, L. p. 4 Ortmann, S. p. 0 Bolognani, and F. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 D ¨ orfler, “Non-convex Feedback Optimization with Input and Output Constraints,” IEEE Control Syst. p. 4 Lett., 2020
[9] M. Picallo, S. p. 4 Bolognani, and F. Dorfler, “Closing the loop: Dynamic ¨ state estimation and feedback optimization of power grids,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. p. 4 189, p. 106753, Dec. p. 4 2020
[10] L. Ortmann, A. p. 0 Hauswirth, I. p. 4 Caduff, F. Dorfler, and S. p. 0 Bolognani, “Ex- ¨perimental Validation of Feedback Optimization in Power Distribution Grids,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. p. 4 189, p. 106782, Dec. p. 4 2020
[11] L. Ortmann, C. p. 0 Rubin, A. Scozzafava, J. p. 4 Lehmann, S. p. 4 Bolognani, and F. Dorfler, “Deployment of an Online Feedback Optimization Controller ¨ for Reactive Power Flow Optimization in a Distribution Grid. p. 4” arXiv, May 11, 2023
[12] I. Hacker, F. Schmidtke, D. p. 0 van der Velde, and S. p. 4 Toni Czyrnik, “A framework to evaluate multi-use flexibility concepts simultaneously in a co-simulation environment and a cyber-physical laboratory. p. 4,” in CIRED 2021 - The 26th International Conference and Exhibition on Electricity Distribution, IET, 2021, pp. p. 4 1692–1696
[13] F. Schmidtke, I. p. 0 Hacker, C. Vertgewall, and A. p. 4 Ulbig, “Evaluation of multi-use charging strategies in a time-dependent co-simulation environment for behind-the-meter flexibility,” in CIRED Porto Workshop 2022: E-mobility and power distribution systems, Porto, Portugal: IET, 2022, pp. p. 4
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Fast response to overload by coordinating distribution grid flexibility using Online Feedback Optimization allows for
fast-responding curative measure
in system operation that reduces line loading below permanent limits in a short interval of time. -
The improved AI system can coordinate active and reactive power set points for flexibility providing units, such as BESS or PV inverters, by minimizing the sum of active and reactive power feed-in while satisfying voltage limits.
-
The system can handle external disturbances like varying voltage levels at the PCC or EV charging processes by maintaining bus voltages within permissible ranges through continuous closed-loop control.
-
The coordination mechanism is robust against model mismatch because it relies on
online measurements from the grid in each Controller Dynamic System
rather than requiringcomplete and accurate models of distribution grids.
Sources
- Optimization Algorithms as Robust Feedback Controllers
- Deployment of an Online Feedback Optimization Controller for Reactive Power Flow Optimization in a Distribution Grid
Related papers
- Industrial Load Modeling and Optimization for Market-Based Interaction with Power Systems
- Exact and Approximate Convex Reformulation of Linear Stochastic Optimal Control with Chance Constraints
- Certified Set Convergence for Piecewise Affine Systems
- Symbolic Control for Stochastic Systems via Finite Parity Games
- Multiobjective optimization-based design and dispatch of islanded, hybrid microgrids for remote, off-grid communities in sub-Saharan Africa
- Physiology-informed layered sensing for intelligent human-exoskeleton interaction