Convex Minimization with Integer Minima in O(n 4) Time

arXiv:2304.03426 · cs.DS, cs.DM, math.OC · Submitted 2023-04-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: I'm Tom.

Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Convex Minimization with Integer Minima in O(n 4) Time".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Given a convex function on R n with an integer minimizer, we show how to find an exact minimizer of f using O(n squared log n) calls to a separation oracle and O(n 4 log n) time The main result of this paper is a much more efficient algorithm for minimizing convex functions with integer minimizers Key Findings on Algorithm Efficiency The authors provide an algorithm that minimizes a convex function with an integer minimizer using only O(n squared log(nR)) separation oracle calls and an additional O(n 4 log(nR)) arithmetic operations For the special case of submodular function minimization (SFM), their result implies an algorithm that makes O(n cubed log n) evaluation oracle queries and uses an additional O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations This improves, for both the oracle complexity and the additional arithmetic operations, the state-of-the-art strongly-polynomial time SFM algorithms in

LSW15, DVZ21: Comparison to Previous State-of-the-Art The authors show that their algorithm improves both the oracle complexity and the number of arithmetic operations compared to Jiang’s algorithm Specifically, their additional number of arithmetic operations is significantly lower by a Θ(e n 4) factor than in Jiang's algorithm The paper demonstrates that their runtime matches what can be achieved using the current best known algorithmic techniques for cutting plane methods, which is O(n cubed log n · EO + n 4 log n) In contrast, Jiang’s algorithm does not have such a feature Techniques for Overcoming Bottlenecks The authors overcome computational bottlenecks in previous work by utilizing an intricate combination of a computationally more efficient cutting plane method based on the volumetric center due to Vaidya and a faster version of the LLL algorithm given in

NS16: They run Vaidya’s cutting plane method in blocks of O(n log n) consecutive steps, which allows them to compute only Oe(n) approximate shortest vectors in total, while still being able to avoid the appearance of extremely short vectors Harnessing the faster implementation of the LLL algorithm allows them to compute these approximate shortest vectors using a total of Oe(n 4) arithmetic operations Applications to Submodular Function Minimization For submodular function minimization (SFM), their result implies an algorithm that makes O(n cubed log n) queries to EO and uses an additional O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations This improves their oracle complexity from O(n cubed log2 n) to O(n cubed log n) while also improving the number of arithmetic operations from O(n 4 logO(1) n) to O(n 4 log n) Oracle Complexity and Runtime Analysis The oracle complexity analysis shows that after a sequence of k dimension reduction iterations, the potential increases additively by at most O(k log(γn) + nk log n), leading to a total amount of potential increase of at most O(n log(γn) + n squared log n) This implies that the total number of oracle calls is O(n squared log n + n log(γnR)) The runtime analysis confirms that the total number of arithmetic operations for CuttingPlaneMethod is at most O(n 4 log(nR)) This is achieved by combining the complexity of the dimension reduction step and the calls to FasterShortestVector Output Guarantee The algorithm guarantees finding an integral minimizer of f with high probability when all extreme points of K∗ are integral, as shown in Lemma 5.1 This is achieved by showing that the dimension reduction step preserves all integral points in K The paper concludes that the algorithm achieves O(n squared log n + n log(γnR)) calls to SO and O(n 4 log(nR)) arithmetic operations This result is derived by directly combining Lemma 5.1, Lemma 5.2 and Lemma 5.3 The authors provide a strongly-polynomial time SFM algorithm that improves both the oracle complexity and the number of arithmetic operations used by the algorithms in

LSW15, DVZ21: This is achieved via a much more general algorithm, whereas the algorithms in

LSW15, DVZ21: work specifically for SFM The paper shows that their algorithm matches what can be achieved using the current best known algorithmic techniques for cutting plane methods In contrast, Jiang’s algorithm does not have such a feature The overall efficiency gain is substantial, significantly improving the additional arithmetic operations in Jiang’s algorithm down to O(n 4 log n) and improving the oracle complexity from O(n squared log n) to O(n cubed log n) for SFM Final Result Summary Theorem 5.

Paper summary: Tom: To summarize what we just heard about "Convex Minimization with Integer Minima in O(n four) Time", the core thesis is that they found a way to solve this problem efficiently when you have an integer minimizer <ref:2304.03426#pg1,Convex Minimization with Integer Minima in>.

Jane: They claim they can find the exact minimizer using only O of n squared log n calls to a separation oracle and O of n four log n time overall <ref:2304.03426#pg1>.

Lu: This is significant because it beats Jiang's algorithm, which they say has at least Omega of e to the power of n eight arithmetic operations due to its reliance on certain expensive subroutines like the Lenstra-Lenstra-Lovász algorithm

Lenstra, Lenstra, Lov´asz, Math. Ann. one thousand nine hundred eighty-two: and a random walk based cutting plane method

Bertsimas, Vempala, JACM two thousand four: <ref:2304.03426#pg1,random walk based cutting plane method Bertsimas, Vempala, JACM 2004>.

Meng: So the main point is that they managed to reduce that exponential arithmetic cost down to a polynomial one for the general problem <ref:2304.03426#pg3>. That’s a huge leap for practical application.

Tom: And for submodular function minimization, they get even better, implying an algorithm with O of n three log n evaluation oracle queries and O of n four log n arithmetic operations <ref:2304.03426#pg3>.

Jane: They are showing that this new method is better than the existing state-of-the-art algorithms in submodular function minimization, improving both the query complexity and the extra arithmetic operations

LSW15, JLSW20: .

Lu: The methodology involves a combination of a faster LLL algorithm and a volumetric center cutting plane method by Vaidya, specifically using blocks of O of n log n steps to compute approximate shortest vectors

Vaidya, FOCS one thousand nine hundred eighty-nine: <ref:2304.03426#pg1,volumetric center cutting plane method>.

Meng: I wonder about the practical implementation here. How much overhead is there in combining these different components like LLL and the volumetric center method? That's where things often break at scale.

Tom: They tackle that by leveraging a faster version of the LLL algorithm given in

Neumaier, Stehl´e, ISSAC two thousand sixteen: , which lets them compute those approximate shortest vectors using O of n four arithmetic operations

Neumaier, Stehl´e, ISSAC two thousand sixteen: <ref:2304.03426#pg1,a faster version of the LLL algorithm>.

Jane: It sounds like they are not just tweaking an old method but building a more robust framework that handles the bottlenecks they identified in previous work.

Conclusion: Tom: So to wrap up on "Convex Minimization with Integer Minima in O of n four Time", this paper presents a concrete, efficient algorithm for finding exact minimizers when an integer solution exists.

Jane: The authors achieved this by combining a faster LLL implementation and the volumetric center cutting plane method by Vaidya to achieve O of n squared log n separation oracle calls and O of n four log n time <ref:2304.03426#pg1>.

Lu: This result is important because it moves the needle on how we approach general convex minimization with integer constraints, showing a way to get good oracle efficiency without sacrificing too much arithmetic efficiency

LSW15, JLSW20: .

Meng: For those of us shipping models, the implication is that if you're working on problems where an exact integer solution is required and you need polynomial time guarantees, this paper points toward a more viable path than the exponential methods we were using.

Tom: The authors explicitly say they match what can be achieved using current best known techniques for cutting plane methods, unlike Jiang's algorithm which has that high arithmetic cost <ref:2304.03426#pg3>.

Jane: In simpler terms, it means this paper provides a method that is both oracle-efficient and requires much fewer extra calculations than previous state-of-the-art options for the general problem.

Haotian Jiang, Yin Tat Lee, Zhao Song, Lichen Zhang

University of Washington · Adobe Research · Massachusetts Institute of Technology

cs.DS, cs.DM, math.OC

Submitted: 2023-04-07

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: SODA 2024. This version fixes errors in the cost of the shortest vector computations and in the leverage score maintenance. The oracle complexity bound still holds, and for submodular function minimization the arithmetic bound becomes $O(n^4 log^3 n)$ instead of $O(n^4 log n)$

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 98/100

The gist: Given a convex function on R n with an integer minimizer, we show how to find an exact minimizer of f using O(n squared log n) calls to a separation oracle and O(n 4 log n) time The main result of…

Key concepts

Separation Oracle
This is a subroutine that helps the algorithm determine if a given point is outside the feasible region defined by the convex function. It's crucial for guiding the search process toward the optimal solution without needing to evaluate every possible point.
Cutting Plane Method
This technique iteratively refines an approximate solution by adding linear constraints (cutting planes) derived from violated inequalities. The paper uses a specialized version of this method, optimized with dimension reduction and faster vector computations, to find the exact minimizer.
Submodular Function Minimization (SFM)
This is a specific problem where the function being minimized has submodular properties. The authors show their algorithm significantly improves existing SFM methods by achieving better oracle complexity and lower arithmetic operation counts compared to prior work.

Terminology

Summary

Given a convex function on R n with an integer minimizer, we show how to find an exact minimizer of f using O(n squared log n) calls to a separation oracle and O(n 4 log n) time

The main result of this paper is a much more efficient algorithm for minimizing convex functions with integer minimizers

Key Findings on Algorithm Efficiency

The authors provide an algorithm that minimizes a convex function with an integer minimizer using only O(n squared log(nR)) separation oracle calls and an additional O(n 4 log(nR)) arithmetic operations

For the special case of submodular function minimization (SFM), their result implies an algorithm that makes O(n cubed log n) evaluation oracle queries and uses an additional O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations This improves, for both the oracle complexity and the additional arithmetic operations, the state-of-the-art strongly-polynomial time SFM algorithms in [LSW15, DVZ21]

Comparison to Previous State-of-the-Art

The authors show that their algorithm improves both the oracle complexity and the number of arithmetic operations compared to Jiang’s algorithm Specifically, their additional number of arithmetic operations is significantly lower by a Θ(e n 4) factor than in Jiang's algorithm

The paper demonstrates that their runtime matches what can be achieved using the current best known algorithmic techniques for cutting plane methods, which is O(n cubed log n · EO + n 4 log n) In contrast, Jiang’s algorithm does not have such a feature

Techniques for Overcoming Bottlenecks

The authors overcome computational bottlenecks in previous work by utilizing an intricate combination of a computationally more efficient cutting plane method based on the volumetric center due to Vaidya and a faster version of the LLL algorithm given in [NS16]

They run Vaidya’s cutting plane method in blocks of O(n log n) consecutive steps, which allows them to compute only Oe(n) approximate shortest vectors in total, while still being able to avoid the appearance of extremely short vectors Harnessing the faster implementation of the LLL algorithm allows them to compute these approximate shortest vectors using a total of Oe(n 4) arithmetic operations

Applications to Submodular Function Minimization

For submodular function minimization (SFM), their result implies an algorithm that makes O(n cubed log n) queries to EO and uses an additional O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations This improves their oracle complexity from O(n cubed log2 n) to O(n cubed log n) while also improving the number of arithmetic operations from O(n 4 logO(1) n) to O(n 4 log n)

Oracle Complexity and Runtime Analysis

The oracle complexity analysis shows that after a sequence of k dimension reduction iterations, the potential increases additively by at most O(k log(γn) + nk log n), leading to a total amount of potential increase of at most O(n log(γn) + n squared log n) This implies that the total number of oracle calls is O(n squared log n + n log(γnR))

The runtime analysis confirms that the total number of arithmetic operations for CuttingPlaneMethod is at most O(n 4 log(nR)) This is achieved by combining the complexity of the dimension reduction step and the calls to FasterShortestVector

Output Guarantee

The algorithm guarantees finding an integral minimizer of f with high probability when all extreme points of K∗ are integral, as shown in Lemma 5.1 This is achieved by showing that the dimension reduction step preserves all integral points in K

The paper concludes that the algorithm achieves O(n squared log n + n log(γnR)) calls to SO and O(n 4 log(nR)) arithmetic operations This result is derived by directly combining Lemma 5.1, Lemma 5. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In Section 3. 5, we present the slicing lemma.

2 and Lemma 5. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In Section 3. 5, we present the slicing lemma.

3

Conclusion on General Convex Minimization

The authors provide a strongly-polynomial time SFM algorithm that improves both the oracle complexity and the number of arithmetic operations used by the algorithms in [LSW15, DVZ21] This is achieved via a much more general algorithm, whereas the algorithms in [LSW15, DVZ21] work specifically for SFM

The paper shows that their algorithm matches what can be achieved using the current best known algorithmic techniques for cutting plane methods In contrast, Jiang’s algorithm does not have such a feature The overall efficiency gain is substantial, significantly improving the additional arithmetic operations in Jiang’s algorithm down to O(n 4 log n) and improving the oracle complexity from O(n squared log n) to O(n cubed log n) for SFM

Final Result Summary

Theorem 5.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Fast exact minimization of convex functions with integer minimizers can be achieved using only O(n 2 log(nR)) separation oracle calls and an additional O(n 4 log(nR)) arithmetic operations, which is a significant improvement over previous state-of-the-art algorithms like Jiang's.

  2. For submodular function minimization (SFM), the algorithm achieves an improved runtime of O(n 3 log n) evaluation oracle queries and an additional O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations, surpassing existing methods in terms of both oracle complexity and arithmetic operations compared to [LSW15] and [DVZ21].

  3. The system can be adapted to solve submodular function minimization by leveraging the structure of the problem, leading to a randomized strongly-polynomial time algorithm with O(n 3 log n) queries to an evaluation oracle and O(n 4 log n) arithmetic operations.

Abstract

Given a convex function f on R n whose set of minimizers is nonempty and closed, lies in a box of radius R with R at most poly(n), and has integral extreme points, we give a randomized algorithm that finds an integral minimizer of f with high probability using O(n squared n+n R) calls to a separation oracle, O(n+ R/ n) calls to an approximate shortest vector routine such as the LLL algorithm, and O(n 4 (nR) n) other arithmetic operations. The previous best polynomial time algorithm [Jiang, SODA 2021, JACM 2022] achieves O(n(n n/ n+ R)) oracle complexity, but its overall runtime is at least Ω(n 8). We obtain our speedup by combining a variant of the volumetric center cutting plane method of [Vaidya, FOCS 1989], run on the hybrid barrier of [Lee, Sidford, Wong, FOCS 2015] with the fast implementation of [Jiang, Lee, Song, Wong, STOC 2020], and a variant of the LLL algorithm that reduces segments of consecutive basis vectors recursively. The method runs in blocks, so that shortest vectors are computed only O(n+ R/ n) times, and each computation takes O(n 3 cubed n) arithmetic operations in exact arithmetic. For submodular function minimization, our result implies an algorithm using O(n cubed n) calls to an evaluation oracle and O(n 4 cubed n) arithmetic operations in total. Its oracle complexity is better than that of the algorithms of [Lee, Sidford, Wong, FOCS 2015] and [Dadush, Végh, Zambelli, SODA 2018, MOR 2021], which had the best running time before this work.

Sources

Related papers