Bandgap fluctuations and robustness in two-dimensional hyperuniform dielectric materials

arXiv:2302.02815 · physics.class-ph, physics.optics · Submitted 2023-02-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Bandgap fluctuations and robustness in two-dimensional hyperuniform dielectric materials".

Title and authors: Kai: So, focusing on the title and authors of "Bandgap fluctuations and robustness in two-dimensional hyperuniform dielectric materials," we see this work is really about the statistical behavior of bandgaps in these structured, disordered settings. It sets up a framework for testing if a material's photonic bandgap holds up statistically when you change the pattern realization.

Mira: And the authors, Luis S. Froufe-Pérez and Geoffroy Aubry, are bringing together physics with this numerical study of how stealthiness affects these gaps across different scales of disorder. It’s important because it moves beyond just looking at perfect crystals or completely random materials; it looks at something in between.

Lev: I’m interested in what they build computationally here. They generate five hundred different 2D point patterns for each stealthiness value from zero point one up to zero point five, with steps of zero point five as described in reference eight <ref:2302.02815#pg1>. That's a lot of simulation work to get those ensemble statistics.

Kai: That’s right, and what they are measuring involves computing the bands for TM modes by direct diagonalization using eight thousand planewaves. They are calculating the largest gap for each single sample realization first before averaging it across all five hundred patterns.

Mira: The key takeaway from that setup is that they are specifically testing how the gaps behave in different regimes of disorder, which is what this paper aims to do by characterizing these stealthy hyperuniform materials.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what the paper summarizes is their findings on how the bandgaps change as you vary that stealthiness parameter chi. They found that at low stealthiness, where correlations are weak, the bandgaps of different system realizations appear over a wide frequency range and they tend to be narrow and generally do not overlap at all.

Mira: That’s a key distinction. But above a critical value of stealthiness, which they pinpoint as chi equal to zero point three five, things change dramatically; the bandgaps start becoming large and they overlap significantly from one sample realization to another, and then a second gap actually appears in those systems.

Lev: That overlap is what I’m watching closely for hardware design. If the gaps are overlapping, it means you can't rely on a single frequency range being stable across different manufacturing batches.

Kai: Right. And they also noticed that for small chi values, the distribution of gap widths shifts towards higher values and broadens as chi increases below zero point three five; there’s still variability in the mean gap frequencies even in those intermediate stealthiness values.

Mira: So they are showing a transition: from independent, narrow gaps at low stealthiness to highly overlapping, robust gaps above zero point three five. This observation extends their understanding of photonic bandgaps in disordered systems and gives us info on how robust these gaps are for practical applications.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests that the most important improvement is identifying the critical value of stealthiness, which they found to be around zero point three five. This value marks a transition where the statistical behavior of the gaps shifts entirely.

Mira: And they point out that for stealthiness values greater than or equal to zero point four, both the mean gap frequencies and their widths collapse into narrow distributions across all realizations. That’s a big piece of information because it implies robustness in the location and width of the bandgap features.

Lev: If we can reliably predict that this happens when chi is above zero point four, that means we can design materials knowing that the gap properties won't change much depending on how those scatterers are randomly distributed.

Kai: That’s exactly what they are pointing toward for practical use. They suggest that for finite pieces of 2D materials, you can always find a bandgap, but when chi is small, you can't reliably predict the location or width for any specific realization <ref:2302.02815#pg1>.

Mira: So the improvement suggested is this clear dichotomy: below zero point three five, it’s hard to predict the gap features for each sample; above zero point four, those features become robust and predictable regardless of the scatterer details.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up on "Bandgap fluctuations and robustness in two-dimensional hyperuniform dielectric materials," the paper shows us that the presence and behavior of bandgaps in these systems are heavily dependent on the stealthiness parameter chi. Low chi means gaps are weak and random across samples, while high chi above zero point four makes them strong and stable features.

Mira: That suggests that for engineering purposes, we should look at achieving a material where the stealthiness is consistently above zero point four to ensure you get robust bandgaps regardless of the manufacturing process. They also suggest looking at the normalized density of states to find precursors to these gaps, like a minimum as a precursor for the first gap when chi is low.

Lev: From my side, I think that critical value of zero point three five is important because it tells us exactly where we need to focus our simulation efforts when designing hardware; below it, the overhead of error correction might be too high because the features are too variable.

Kai: So in short, this paper gives us a way to predict robustness by measuring chi, and it highlights that above zero point four, those gap features are pretty stable across different patterns. It’s a solid piece of work on disordered systems.

Mira: We'll keep an eye on the future work they mentioned regarding TM versus TE polarizations and the effect of refractive index contrast on that critical chi value. That could open up new avenues for understanding how these gaps form under different physical constraints, which is where things get really interesting next.

LUIS S. FROUFE-PÉREZ, GEOFFROY AUBRY, FRANK SCHEFFOLD, SOFIA MAGKIRIADOU

Department of Physics, University of Fribourg · Université Côte d’Azur, CNRS, Institut de Physique de Nice

physics.class-ph, physics.optics

Submitted: 2023-02-03

Updated: 2026-11-18

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures. Luis S. Froufe-Pérez and Geoffroy J. Aubry have equal first authorship

Journal ref: Opt. Express 31, 18509 (2023)

DOI: 10.1364/OE.484232

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

The gist: We numerically study the statistical fluctuations of photonic band gaps in ensembles of stealthy hyperuniform disordered patterns This work extends our understanding of photonic bandgaps in…

Key concepts

Photonic Bandgaps
These are ranges of frequencies where light cannot propagate through a material, similar to how certain crystal structures block specific colors of light. The paper explores how these gaps form even in materials that lack perfect long-range order.
Stealthiness Parameter ($\chi$)
This parameter quantifies the degree of order in disordered hyperuniform materials. A low $\chi$ means high randomness, while a higher $\chi$ indicates a more uniform structure. It is used to measure how 'stealthy' the pattern is.
Robustness of Bandgaps
This refers to how stable the bandgap features are when you create many different random versions (realizations) of the same material. The findings show that gaps only become robust—meaning they are reliably located and have consistent widths—when $\chi \geq 0.4$.

Terminology

Summary

We numerically study the statistical fluctuations of photonic band gaps in ensembles of stealthy hyperuniform disordered patterns This work extends our understanding of photonic bandgaps in disordered systems and provides information on the robustness of gaps in practical applications

Introduction to Photonic Band Gaps

The propagation of light depends on a material’s internal structure Among these, one of the most celebrated is the existence of photonic bandgaps [1, 2] Photonic band gaps in crystalline dielectric materials have been extensively discussed, since there the symmetries of the lattices can directly lead to forbidden states for light of certain frequencies However, according to recent studies, order is not required for the formation of photonic bandgaps, as they have also been observed in disordered materials [3] A class of those are known as disordered hyperuniform materials [5–10], characterized by the lack of long-range density fluctuations [9] The degree of order in disordered hyperuniform materials can be quantified by the stealthiness parameter, chi [11].

Quantifying Stealthiness and System Variability

In two dimensions, when chi = 0, the system is random leading to large density fluctuations as chi approaches 0.5 the system becomes more and more uniform while remaining isotropic For chi & 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The degree of order in disordered hyperuniform materials can be quantified by the stealthiness parameter, 𝜒 [11]: In two dimensions, when 𝜒 = 0, the system is random leading to large density fluctuations; as 𝜒 approaches 0. 5 the system becomes more and more uniform while remaining isotropic.

5 isotropy is gradually lost and structures become crystalline [11]. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For 𝜒 & 0. 5 isotropy is gradually lost and structures become crystalline [11].

The understanding of photonic bandgaps in crystals is greatly facilitated by the fact that they are uniquely defined However, the same is not true for disordered materials. p. 0
Where the paper says it

5 isotropy is gradually lost and structures become crystalline [11]. The understanding of photonic bandgaps in crystals is greatly facilitated by the fact that they are uniquely defined: given (i) a unit cell, (ii) the fundamental blocks that decorate the lattice points (e.

Hyperuniform structures have no primitive vectors, and even if the value of chi is specified there are many possible realizations of a point pattern [11]. p. 0
Where the paper says it

However, the same is not true for disordered materials. Hyperuniform structures have no primitive vectors, and even if the value of 𝜒 is specified there are many possible realizations of a point pattern [11].

Simulation Methodology and Key Findings

We generate 500 different 2D point patterns for each value of chi = 0.10 up to 0.50, in steps of 0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

10 up to 0. 50, in steps of 0.

05 as described in ref. p. 2
Where the paper says it

50, in steps of 0. 05 as described in ref.

[8]. We compute the bands for TM modes by direct diagonalization using 8000 planewaves [2]. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Each point pattern was generated using periodic boundary conditions, and we therefore can use the supercell method to compute the states [2]. We compute the bands for TM modes by direct diagonalization using 8000 planewaves [2].

We find that we can always define a bandgap, but for small values of chi. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We find that we can always define a bandgap. For small values of 𝜒 .

0.2, however, the gaps are very narrow. p. 1
Where the paper says it

For small values of 𝜒 . 2, however, the gaps are very narrow.

Interestingly, we observe a transition at chi ∼ 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

However, for the same value of 𝜒, initially there is still a large variability in the gap widths and central frequencies, so that on average there is no gap. Interestingly, we observe a transition at 𝜒 ∼ 0.

4 where the gaps become wide and robust and also a second gap appears. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Interestingly, we observe a transition at 𝜒 ∼ 0. 4 where the gaps become wide and robust and also a second gap appears.

Robustness of Bandgaps

For chi = 0.10, the largest gaps do not overlap from sample to sample. p. 3

Where the paper says it

In this representation, we see that for 𝜒 = 0. 10, the largest gaps do not overlap from sample to sample.

As chi increases, but still below 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

As 𝜒 increases, the gap width also increases. However, for the same value of 𝜒, initially there is still a large variability in the gap widths and central frequencies, so that on average there is no gap.

35, the distribution of gap widths shifts to higher values and broadens Similarly, there is still variability in the gaps’ mean frequencies for intermediate chi-values. p. 3
Where the paper says it

As 𝜒 increases, but still below 0. 35, the distribution of gap widths shifts to higher values and broadens (see blue histograms in Fig.

It is only when chi reaches chi ≥ 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Similarly, there is still variability in the gaps’ mean frequencies for intermediate 𝜒-values (see green histograms in Fig. It is only when 𝜒 reaches 𝜒 ≥ 0.

4 that, remarkably, both the mean gap frequencies and their widths collapse into narrow distributions: the bandgaps are very similar among different realizations of stealthy hyperuniform patterns. p. 3
Where the paper says it

It is only when 𝜒 reaches 𝜒 ≥ 0. 4 that, remarkably, both the mean gap frequencies and their widths collapse into narrow distributions: the bandgaps are very similar among different realizations of stealthy hyperuniform patterns.

This behavior can be seen clearly in Fig. p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 that, remarkably, both the mean gap frequencies and their widths collapse into narrow distributions: the bandgaps are very similar among different realizations of stealthy hyperuniform patterns. This behavior can be seen clearly in Fig.

2 where the dark green region shows that all gaps overlap with a lower and an upper bandedge that fluctuate much less in the chi = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

This behavior can be seen clearly in Fig. 2 where the dark green region shows that all gaps overlap with a lower and an upper bandedge that fluctuate much less in the 𝜒 = 0.

50 case than in the chi = 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

2 where the dark green region shows that all gaps overlap with a lower and an upper bandedge that fluctuate much less in the 𝜒 = 0. 50 case than in the 𝜒 = 0.

35 case.

Conclusion on Practical Applications

For finite pieces of 2D materials we can always find a bandgap. However, when chi is small, it is difficult to predict the location and width of the bandgap for each realization. p. 5

Where the paper says it

We find that for finite pieces of 2D materials we can always find a bandgap. However, when 𝜒 is small, it is difficult to predict the location and width of the bandgap for each realization.

On the other hand, for chi ≥ 0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The gaps can be wider or very narrow, and their central frequencies can be found over a wide range of values. On the other hand, for 𝜒 ≥ 0.

4, the location and width of the bandgap are robust features of the system regardless of the details of the scatterers’ distribution. p. 5
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, for 𝜒 ≥ 0. 4, the location and width of the bandgap are robust features of the system regardless of the details of the scatterers’ distribution.

Thus, it is likely that these features are also robust to perturbations or imperfections, when it comes to practical realization of bandgap materials. p. 5
Where the paper says it

4, the location and width of the bandgap are robust features of the system regardless of the details of the scatterers’ distribution. Thus, it is likely that these features are also robust to perturbations or imperfections, when it comes to practical realization of bandgap materials.

Future Directions

To complete the picture, it would be interesting to analyze band gaps in both TM and TE polarizations, as well as to investigate the effect of the refractive index contrast on the critical value of chi. Interestingly, we observe a sharp change in the bandgap statistics at chi & 0. p. 5

Where the paper says it

However, we assume that differences in system parameters do not qualitatively change the picture. Interestingly, we observe a sharp change in the bandgap statistics at 𝜒 & 0.

35 which raises the question whether our observations could be described by a (critical) phase transition—a topic for future work. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Interestingly, we observe a sharp change in the bandgap statistics at 𝜒 & 0. 35 which raises the question whether our observations could be described by a (critical) phase transition—a topic for future work.

We have not discussed the influence of system size, as all of our systems were composed of around 200 scatterers. p. 5
Where the paper says it

35 which raises the question whether our observations could be described by a (critical) phase transition—a topic for future work. Finally, in the present work we have not discussed the influence of system size, as all of our systems were composed of around 200 scatterers.

An interesting contribution was made recently in this direction, where the authors investigated the behavior of photonic bandgaps in disordered hyperuniform systems of increasing system size and extrapolated to the thermodynamic limit, finding, similarly to our results, a critical chi value above which bandgaps are robust [12]. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Would our observations be relevant for larger systems? An interesting contribution was made recently in this direction, where the authors investigated the behavior of photonic bandgaps in disordered hyperuniform systems of increasing system size and extrapolated to the thermodynamic limit, finding, similarly to our results, a critical 𝜒 value above which bandgaps are robust [12].

If true, this approach would provide a new method to study larger disordered hyperuniform systems. p. 5
Where the paper says it

If these have overlapping gaps, then it might be reasonable to expect that these gaps will be present for the entire system, whereas if the smaller sub-systems only have non-overlapping gaps, then perhaps no gap would appear overall. If true, this approach would provide a new method to study larger disordered hyperuniform systems, a task that is at present limited by the computational complexity that comes with lack of periodicity.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Robust Bandgap Prediction for Disordered Systems: The improved system can predict whether a photonic bandgap will be robust to statistical variability by analyzing stealthiness parameter chi. For chi greater than or equal to 0.40, the system can reliably identify that the location and width of the bandgap are robust features of the system regardless of the details of the scatterers’ distribution.

  2. Ensemble Gap Characterization: The improved AI can characterize ensemble properties by analyzing distributions of bandgap statistics across different stealthiness values. Specifically, it can determine that for small chi values, the gaps are very narrow, whereas for chi greater than or equal to 0.4, both the mean gap frequencies and their widths collapse into narrow distributions.

  3. Density of States Interpretation: The improved system can interpret the normalized density of states (nDOS) to identify precursors to bandgaps in disordered systems. It can distinguish between a minimum as a precursor for the first gap at low chi values and a shoulder as a precursor for the second gap, or conversely, detect when the nDOS of the ensemble remains 0 over a large frequency range indicating the presence of robust gaps.

Abstract

We numerically study the statistical fluctuations of photonic band gaps in ensembles of stealthy hyperuniform disordered patterns. We find that at low stealthiness, where correlations are weak, band gaps of different system realizations appear over a wide frequency range, are narrow, and generally do not overlap. Interestingly, above a critical value of stealthiness χ 0.35, the bandgaps become large and overlap significantly from realization to realization, while a second gap appears. These observations extend our understanding of photonic bandgaps in disordered systems and provide information on the robustness of gaps in practical applications.

Related papers