Global Fit of Modified Quark Couplings to EW Gauge Bosons and Vector-Like Quarks in Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Global Fit of Modified Quark Couplings to EW Gauge Bosons and Vector-Like Quarks in Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly".
Title and authors: Kai: We just talked about the setup for this paper, focusing on those two main tensions in the Cabibbo angle and how they point towards modified W couplings and vector-like quarks as potential solutions.
Mira: The summary boils down to a global fit of all dimension-six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that generate modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks, while also looking at models with vector-like quarks as candidates for a way to complete the theory at tree level.
Lev: So, it’s not just about fitting one measurement; it’s about performing this combined analysis across all the relevant flavor observables.
Kai: They specifically look at how these modified couplings impact different CKM elements and how that feeds back into electroweak precision observables and low-energy parity violation.
Mira: The paper finds that the SU(two)L doublet vector-like quark Q is the best fit candidate because it naturally generates the right-handed W u d and W u s couplings that align with what we see in our data <ref:2212.06862#pg1>.
Lev: But they stress that this isn't a complete picture; to get all the tensions resolved, you need more than just this single Q particle.
Kai: They suggest that a full explanation for the Cabibbo angle determination requires at least two vector-like quarks, either through modifying left-handed and right-handed W couplings together, or by having separate modifications for left and right couplings.
Mira: The core idea is that this single Q particle isn't enough to solve the problem entirely; you need a richer structure of new physics in the quark sector.
Lev: It’s like building a bridge where one beam isn't enough to support the whole load; you need multiple supporting structures interacting correctly.
Kai: And they show that by performing this global fit, we can consistently assess whether any specific new physics hypothesis actually agrees with all the data we have on hand.
Mira: So, the summary is that this paper sets up a rigorous way to test if these modified W couplings and vector-like quarks are the right direction to address these persistent flavor anomalies.
Lev: It lays out exactly what kind of new physics structure we should expect if we want to fix the CKM unitarity deficit and the Vus tensions simultaneously.
Kai: And it gives us a clear path forward by identifying which specific quark model, like the SU(two)L doublet Q, is most promising based on what the data prefers <ref:2212.06862#pg1>.
The paper's summary: Mira: Now let’s look at how this work suggests improving the analysis itself, because even a good result can be improved by better tools.
Kai: They suggest using improved AI to perform these global fits to Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that generate modified W couplings by efficiently sampling likelihoods with MCMC libraries like PyMultiNest and corner software for visualization.
Lev: That makes sense computationally; sampling likelihoods this way helps us explore the parameter space much more effectively than traditional methods.
Mira: And this improved system can consistently assess the agreement of a new physics hypothesis with data by performing that combined analysis including all those dimension-six SMEFT operators modifying W couplings.
Kai: It also allows the AI to identify vector-like quarks as prime candidates for UV completion by studying models where they can affect W quark couplings at tree level, and it must perform a global fit that includes flavour observables like loop effects in delta F equal two processes.
Lev: Including those loop effects is crucial because we need to make sure the new physics doesn't just look good on one set of data but holds up when we look at flavor changing processes too.
Mira: Furthermore, the improved system can determine effective CKM elements by using the Cabibbo angle determination at each parameter point in parameters space, taking into account those new physics effects before calculating V u d and V u s using the SM Lagrangian's unitarity of the CKM matrix.
Kai: That sounds like a very systematic way to isolate the NP contribution to those CKM elements point by point.
Lev: It’s a strong method because it separates the effect of new physics from what we expect from the Standard Model structure.
Mira: The system can distinguish between different new physics scenarios by testing various CKM unitarity tests, like combinations of measurements such as beta and kaon decays, which can reveal deviations between one point sigma and three point three sigma discrepancies.
Kai: That allows us to pinpoint exactly where a specific NP model is failing or succeeding against the existing experimental constraints.
Lev: And one final improvement they suggest is performing one loop matching for the four quark operators that contribute to D zero minus D zero mixing using matchmakereft to calculate those effects on that process, which they show in appendix A.
Mira: That loop matching calculation is a necessary step because it connects the effective theory directly to concrete, measurable quantities like D zero minus D zero mixing rates.
Lev: It grounds the abstract SMEFT operators in physical, calculable predictions for particle decays and mixing phenomena.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So to wrap up the paper "Global Fit of Modified Quark Couplings to EW Gauge Bosons and Vector-Like Quarks in Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly," we see a strong case for modifying quark couplings to solve the Cabibbo angle anomalies.
Mira: The main implication is that this approach requires a global fit because you can't solve these tensions by just looking at one measurement in isolation; you need to see how it affects everything else.
Lev: The paper strongly suggests that the SU(two)L doublet vector-like quark Q is the preferred candidate for generating the necessary modifications to W couplings based on current CKM data <ref:2212.06862#pg1>.
Kai: And we have this detailed analysis showing that a full explanation requires at least two vector-like quarks, either through left and right coupling modifications, to fully reconcile all the observed tensions.
Mira: It shows us what kind of new physics structure is needed to consistently explain these discrepancies while staying within the bounds of electroweak precision observables.
Lev: For me, it’s interesting because it’s a concrete proposal on how to build a model that addresses flavor anomalies without immediately running into too many other problems in the precision sectors.
Kai: It points us towards focusing our experimental efforts on testing these specific modified couplings and searching for the vector-like quarks they predict.
Mira: We'll keep an eye on this paper as more constraints come in, because it lays down a clear structure for what new physics should look like if these anomalies are indeed solved by quark couplings.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve been looking at the paper "Global Fit of Modified Quark Couplings to EW Gauge Bosons and Vector-Like Quarks in Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly." Basically, they did a massive global fit on all those dimension six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that change how quarks interact with W bosons.
Mira: Right. And they found that the best fit points to this specific vector-like quark Q as the most promising new physics candidate because it naturally generates the right handed couplings we see in our data for W u d and W u s interactions.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that means if we were building hardware to test this, we’d be focusing on measuring those specific coupling modifications at high fidelity.
Kai: It’s not just about the Q quark alone though because they stress that a full explanation for those Cabibbo angle tensions requires at least two vector-like quarks in total.
Mira: Exactly. They show that you need either modifying both left and right handed couplings, or having separate modifications for the left W u d coupling and the right W u s coupling to get everything into agreement.
Lev: That’s a big thing for the hardware overhead; needing two species means more channels to measure at once, which increases the complexity of your error correction codes.
Kai: They also included one loop matching calculation using matchmakereft for the four quark operators that affect D zero minus D zero mixing.
Mira: That loop calculation is important because it connects these abstract effective operators directly to something we can measure in particle decay processes, like D zero minus D zero mixing rates.
Lev: So they’re not just doing theory; they’re connecting the math to a concrete observable that you could eventually look for in an experiment.
Kai: To wrap up, this work gives us a clear roadmap on what kind of new physics structure we need to expect if we want to solve these persistent flavor anomalies.
Mira: It tells us that the SU(2L) doublet Q is strongly favored by CKM measurements, but it still has bounds from electroweak precision observables because those right handed Z couplings are also induced <ref:2212.06862#pg1>.
Lev: And for me, this whole paper is a solid blueprint for how to design the next generation of flavor physics experiments.
Kai: It’s a detailed look at how we can use global fits with AI to screen these models efficiently and see which ones actually hold up against all the data.
Mira: So, they’ve shown that solving the Cabibbo angle mystery isn't a single particle solution; it needs a richer structure involving multiple vector-like quarks.
Lev: That leaves us wondering what kind of constraints we’ll put on these new particles if we build them out in the lab.
Kai: We’ll be taking that discussion right into our next segment, where we look at some results from anomalous gluon dynamics in Higgs production.
Andreas Crivellin, Matthew Kirk, Teppei Kitahara, Federico Mesciac
Physik-Institut, University of Zurich · Paul Scherrer Institut PSI · Departament de Física Quàntica i Astrofísica (FQA), Institut de Ciències del Cosmos (ICCUB), Universitat de Barcelona · IAR & KMI, Nagoya University · KEK Theory Center, IPNS, KEK, Tsukuba · CAS Key Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, Institute of Theoretical Physics CAS
hep-ph, hep-ex
Submitted: 2022-12-13
Updated: 2026-11-17
Comments: 46 pages, 16 figures. v2: Added references, minor numerical changes due to bug in code, conclusions unchanged. v3: journal version, minor clarifications added. v4: Sign error in Z-d-d couplings in eq 3.3 corrected (no other changes)
Journal ref: JHEP03(2023)234
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 56/100
The gist: Global fit of modified quark couplings to EW gauge bosons and vector-like quarks in light of the Cabibbo angle anomaly is a combined analysis performed to assess new physics hypotheses that can solve…
Key concepts
- Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
- This refers to two main tensions in determining the Cabibbo angle from different particle decays. One tension is a 3-sigma disagreement between measurements of |Vus| from Kµ2, K'3, and τ decays. The second involves a deficit in CKM unitarity when combining these results with beta decay data.
- SMEFT and Vector-Like Quarks
- The analysis uses Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT) to explore dimension-six operators that modify W boson couplings to quarks. It specifically investigates vector-like quarks as potential new physics candidates because they can directly alter these W-quark couplings at the tree level.
- SU(2)L Doublet Q
- The analysis favors a specific type of vector-like quark, the SU(2)L doublet Q. This specific model is unique because it naturally generates modifications to right-handed W couplings, which aligns best with the data regarding CKM measurements.
- Right-Handed Charged Currents
- The study identifies modified right-handed charged currents (specifically W-u-d and W-u-s couplings) as the simplest scenario that successfully brings various flavor determinations into agreement without violating other constraints like electroweak precision observables.
Terminology
Summary
Global fit of modified quark couplings to EW gauge bosons and vector-like quarks in light of the Cabibbo angle anomaly is a combined analysis performed to assess new physics hypotheses that can solve tensions related to the Cabibbo angle, which can be explained by modifications of W boson couplings to quarks. p. 0 Prepared for submission to JHEP PSI-PR-22-37, ZU-TH-61/22, KEK-TH-2480
Global Fit of Modified Quark Couplings to
EW Gauge Bosons and Vector-Like Quarks in
Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
Andreas Crivellin,a,b Matthew Kirk,c Teppei Kitahara,d,e,f Federico Mesciac
aPhysik-Institut, Universität Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zürich, Switzerland
bPaul Scherrer Institut, 5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland
cDepartament de Física Quàntica i Astrofísica (FQA), Institut de Ciències del Cosmos
(ICCUB), Universitat de Barcelona (UB), Spain
d
IAR & KMI, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464–8602, Japan
eKEK Theory Center, IPNS, KEK, Tsukuba 305–0801, Japan
fCAS Key Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, ITP, CAS, Beijing 100190, China
E-mail: andreas. crivellin@cern.Where the paper says it
Current Status of Anomalies
The Cabibbo Angle Anomaly consists of two tensions related to the determination of the Cabibbo angle. First, the different determinations of Vus from Kµ2, K'3, and τ decays disagree at the 3σ level. Second, using the average of these results in combination with β decays, a deficit in first-row CKM unitarity appears with a significance of again about 3σ. p. 2 tensions related to the determination of the Cabibbo angle: First, the different
determinations of |Vus| from Kµ2
, K`3
, and τ decays disagree at the 3σ level. Second,
using the average of these results in combination with β decays, a deficit in first-row
Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) unitarity appears with a significance at the 3σ
level. Second, using the average of these results in combination with β decays (including
super-allowed β decays and neutron decay), a deficit in first-row CKM unitarity
with a significance of again about 3σ is found. These discrepancies, known as the
Cabibbo Angle anomaly, can in principle be solved by modifications of W boson
couplings to quarks.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
SMEFT and Vector-Like Quarks Setup
The analysis performs a combined analysis for all dimension-six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that generate modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks. The study then looks at models with vector-like quarks, which are prime candidates for a corresponding UV completion as they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level. p. 0 In order to consistently
assess the agreement of a new physics hypothesis with data, we perform a combined
analysis for all dimension-six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that
generate modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks. We then study
models with vector-like quarks, which are prime candidates for a corresponding UV
completion as they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level, and we perform a
global fit including flavour observables (in particular loop effects in ∆F = 2 processes).Where the paper says it
Analysis of SMEFT Results
The global fit results show that the best fit can be obtained for the SU(2)L doublet vector-like quark Q as it can generate right-handed W-u-d and W-u-s couplings as preferred by data. The analysis explores scenarios with modifications of right-handed W-u-s couplings which provide the best improvement relative to the SM. p. 0 We then study
models with vector-like quarks, which are prime candidates for a corresponding UV
completion as they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level, and we perform a
global fit including flavour observables (in particular loop effects in ∆F = 2 processes). We find that the best fit can be obtained for the SU(2)L doublet vector-like quark Q
as it can generate right-handed W-u-d and W-u-s couplings as preferred by data.Where the paper says it
Vector-Like Quark Models
The paper examines various representations of vector-like quarks coupling to first and second generation quarks in general. The SU(2)L doublet Q is unique in generating modifications to the right-handed W couplings and is strongly favored by the CKM measurements. p. 0 We then study
models with vector-like quarks, which are prime candidates for a corresponding UV
completion as they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level, and we perform a
global fit including flavour observables (in particular loop effects in ∆F = 2 processes). We find that the best fit can be obtained for the SU(2)L doublet vector-like quark Q
as it can generate right-handed W-u-d and W-u-s couplings as preferred by data. tensions related to the determination of the Cabibbo angle: First, the different
determinations of |Vus| from Kµ2
, K`3
, and τ decays disagree at the 3σ level. Second,
using the average of these results in combination with β decays, a deficit in first-row
Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) unitarity appears with a significance at the 3σ
level.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform global fits to Standard Model Effective Field Theory SMEFT operators generating modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks by efficiently sampling likelihoods using MCMC libraries like PyMultiNest with corner software for visualization.
-
The improved system can consistently assess the agreement of a new physics hypothesis with data by performing a combined analysis that includes dimension-six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that generate modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks.
-
The AI can identify vector-like quarks as prime candidates for UV completion by studying models where they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level, and it must perform a global fit including flavour observables, such as loop effects in delta F = 2 processes.
-
The system can determine effective CKM elements by using the Cabibbo angle determination at each parameter point in parameters space using Kmu2/piu2 as input and taking into account the NP effects before calculating Vud and Vus using the unitarity of the CKM matrix of the SM Lagrangian.
-
The improved AI can distinguish between different NP scenarios by testing various CKM unitarity tests, such as those defined by combinations of best measurements like beta and kaon decays, which can reveal deviations between 1.8 sigma and 3.3 sigma discrepancies.
-
The system can analyze the preference for right-handed charged currents (both in W-u-d and W-u-s couplings) as the simplest scenario that brings all main determinations into agreement without conflicting with electroweak precision or flavour observables, favored by 3.2 sigma (2.7 sigma) in the best 2-D (1-D) scenario.
-
The AI can screen vector-like quark models based on their representations, such as the SU(2L) doublet Q, which is unique in generating modifications to right-handed W couplings and is strongly favored by CKM measurements but faces bounds from EWPO and PV as modified right-handed Z couplings to quarks are also induced.
-
The system can determine that a full explanation of the tensions in the Cabibbo angle determination requires at least two vector-like quarks, either through modifications of left-handed W-u-d and a right-handed W-u-s coupling, or by a modified left-handed W-u-d coupling and a right-handed W u s coupling.
-
The AI can perform one loop matching for the four quarks operators contributing to D0–D0 mixing using matchmakereft to calculate relevant effects on D0–D0 mixing, which is shown in Appendix A.
Abstract
There are two tensions related to the Cabibbo angle of the CKM matrix. First, the determinations of V us from K μ2, K 3, and τ decays disagree at the 3σ level. Second, using the average of these results in combination with β decays (including super-allowed β decays and neutron decay), a deficit in first-row CKM unitarity with a significance of again about 3σ is found. These discrepancies, known as the Cabibbo Angle anomaly, can in principle be solved by modifications of W boson couplings to quarks. However, due to SU(2) L invariance, Z couplings to quarks are also modified and flavour changing neutral currents can occur. In order to consistently assess the agreement of a new physics hypothesis with data, we perform a combined analysis for all dimension-six Standard Model Effective Field Theory operators that generate modified W couplings to first and second generation quarks. We then study models with vector-like quarks, which are prime candidates for a corresponding UV completion as they can affect W-quark couplings at tree level, and we perform a global fit including flavour observables (in particular loop effects in ΔF=2 processes). We find that the best fit can be obtained for the SU(2) L doublet vector-like quark Q as it can generate right-handed W - u - d and W - u - s couplings as preferred by data.
Sources
- Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
- Observation of a new boson at a mass of 125 GeV with the CMS experiment at the LHC
- Mounting Evidence for the Violation of Lepton Flavor Universality
- Beyond the Standard Model with Lepton Flavor Universality Violation
- Unveiling Hidden Physics at the LHC
- The CKM unitarity problem: A trace of new physics at the TeV scale?
- On the Statistical Treatment of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
- Joint lattice QCD - dispersion theory analysis confirms the quark-mixing top-row unitarity deficit
- Global Fit to Modified Neutrino Couplings and the Cabibbo-Angle Anomaly
- Modified lepton couplings and the Cabibbo-angle anomaly
- Global Electroweak Fit and Vector-Like Leptons in Light of the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
- Cabibbo anomaly versus electroweak precision tests: An exploration of extensions of the Standard Model
- Beta decays as sensitive probes of lepton flavor universality
- Explaining $b\to s\ell^+\ell^-$ and the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly with a Vector Triplet
- Are the CKM anomalies induced by vector-like quarks? Limits from flavor changing and Standard Model precision tests
- The Fermi constant from muon decay versus electroweak fits and CKM unitarity
- Testing Lepton Flavor Universality with Pion, Kaon, Tau, and Beta Decays
- Scrutinizing CKM unitarity with a new measurement of the $K_{\mu 3}/K_{\mu 2}$ branching fraction
- First row CKM unitarity
- Explaining the Cabibbo Angle Anomaly
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses