Inclusive Production Cross Sections at N3LO

arXiv:2209.06138 · hep-ph · Submitted 2022-09-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Inclusive Production Cross Sections at N3LO".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Inclusive cross sections play a variety of roles in high-energy phenomenology, ranging from precision tests of the SM to serving as standard candles for luminosity measurements The authors present for the first time the inclusive cross section for associated Higgs boson production with a massive gauge boson at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order in QCD The paper introduces n3loxs, a public, numerical program for the evaluation of inclusive cross sections at the third order in the strong coupling constant This tool allows to derive predictions for charged- and neutral-current Drell-Yan production, gluon- and bottom-quark-fusion Higgs boson production and Higgs boson associated production with a heavy gauge boson The authors discuss perturbative and parton distribution function (PDF) uncertainties of the aforementioned processes Phenomenological Results for Drell-Yan and Higgs Production The paper presents phenomenological results for SM processes using the code n3loxs These results are obtained at pp colliders, and for the first time, also at pp¯ colliders The study compares global PDF sets for a variety of processes including associated Higgs boson production and observes 1σ deviations among predictions for several processes Analysis of Scale and PDF Uncertainties The authors investigate scale uncertainties as a method of assessing theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders at different values of the center-of-mass energy and for pp and pp¯ collisions They compare the latest releases of major PDF sets against a nominal set, observing that various sets show overall rather good agreement with one another The study also includes a dedicated PDF+αS analysis at the 13 TeV LHC with their nominal PDF4LHC15 set Associated V H Production at N3LO The paper presents for the first time results for the fully inclusive cross section at N3LO for the production of a Higgs boson in association with a weak boson V = Z, W± in QCD They find that the third-order correction amounts to about ∼ 1% and is similar in size to the NNLO correction, similar to the case of Drell-Yan production The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2% The authors conclude that the inclusion of the third-order correction is vital for precise phenomenological predictions The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2% Their results will help benchmark precision QCD calculations and phenomenological studies at the LHC A n3loxs Program Details The program n3loxs allows the user to calculate up to N3LO in QCD the following observables: 1.

Kai: Neutral Drell-Yan differential production cross section Q2dσ/dQ2 as a function of the virtuality Q of the gauge boson, in the leptonic channel pp(pp¯) → γ∗/Z∗ → +− + X; 2.

Mira: Charged-current Drell-Yan differential production cross section Q2dσ/dQ2 as a function of the virtuality Q of the W boson, in the leptonic channel pp(pp¯) → W+ → +ν + X (pp(pp¯) → W− → −ν¯ + X); 3.

Kai: Higgs boson inclusive production cross section in the gluon fusion channel, gg → H + X, both for pp and pp¯ colliders; 4.

Title and authors: Kai: So, this paper is written by Julien Baglio, Claude Duhr, Bernhard Mistlberger, and Robert Szafrond. They’re bringing this work on inclusive cross sections at N3LO to the table for the community to see.

Mira: It’s interesting that they are presenting their first time the inclusive cross section for associated Higgs boson production with a massive gauge boson at N3LO in QCD, which is quite high order.

Lev: From my side, it’s important that this paper introduces n3loxs as a public numerical program. That tool allows people to actually derive these predictions themselves rather than just reading the final numbers.

Kai: Exactly. So the implication here is that we now have a way to get these high-order predictions for things like Higgsstrahlung production, pp versus pp bar collisions, and even binned Drell-Yan cross sections using this new tool.

Mira: It gives us a concrete way to benchmark the Standard Model predictions at this level of precision, which is crucial when we try to look for new physics.

Lev: It lets us see exactly where the current limits of our theory are, and where the next steps in theory need to be focused.

The paper's summary: Kai: So what they’re summarizing is that they found the third-order correction amounts to about one percent for the fully inclusive cross section at N3LO for Higgsstrahlung production, which is similar in size to the NNLO correction they saw in Drell-Yan production.

Mira: That one percent figure is pretty good news, especially since their current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically around two percent.

Lev: So even with the N3LO correction included, the overall uncertainty we see right now is still about two percent because of those other factors.

Kai: They also look at scale uncertainties as a way to assess what happens when you’re missing higher orders at different center-of-mass energies and for both pp and pp bar collisions.

Mira: And they compare various global PDF sets against a nominal set, observing that most sets show good agreement, but there are still some one sigma deviations among predictions for several processes.

Lev: This is a key point because the paper points out that the missing N3LO PDF sets are emerging as the biggest obstacle for improving precision phenomenology at hadron colliders.

The paper's improvements: Kai: One of the main things they suggest as an improvement is using this n3loxs program to do more than just get a single number. They can calculate differential cross sections for Drell-Yan processes in a given range, say between Q min and Q max, around the Z or W peak.

Mira: That’s useful for experimentalists because it lets them generate binned cross sections at N3LO precision for those specific regions of the invariant mass distribution.

Lev: And they also investigate scale variation as a method to assess theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders at different center-of-mass energies and collision types.

Kai: They mention that in most cases, the traditional seven point scale variation at NNLO doesn't capture the N3LO central value, so you have to be careful with uncertainty estimates based on scale variation alone.

Mira: They also perform a PDF plus alpha S analysis at the thirteen TeV LHC using their nominal PDF4LHC15 set, which they say is the dominant source of theoretical errors at this perturbative order in the QCD expansion.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the inclusion of this third-order correction is vital for making precise phenomenological predictions at the LHC. They found that current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically about two percent.

Mira: That means while N3LO is important, we still need better knowledge of those PDFs to push the precision further down to, say, one percent or less.

Lev: And this work with n3loxs gives us a benchmark for how these calculations scale and what the error budget actually looks like on real hardware.

Kai: So this paper "Inclusive Production Cross Sections at N3LO" is important because it provides a concrete tool and results that help us push the limits of precision QCD calculations right now.

Mira: It sets a clear benchmark for future work, especially concerning those missing third-order PDF sets they mentioned.

Lev: I think this is solid work that will certainly be used when we start designing error correction schemes for these kinds of high-precision measurements.

Julien Baglio, Claude Duhr, Bernhard Mistlberger, Robert Szafrond

Theoretical Physics Department, CERN · Bethe Center for Theoretical Physics, University of Bonn · SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Stanford University

hep-ph

Submitted: 2022-09-13

Updated: 2022-09-13

Comments: 53 pages, 20 figures, 12 tables. Associated public computer program to be found at https://github.com/jubaglio/n3loxs

Journal ref: J. High Energ. Phys. 2022, 66 (2022)

DOI: 10.1007/JHEP12(2022)066

Code: https://github.com/jubaglio/n3loxs

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 96/100

The gist: Inclusive cross sections play a variety of roles in high-energy phenomenology, ranging from precision tests of the SM to serving as standard candles for luminosity measurements The authors present…

Key concepts

n3loxs
A public numerical program designed to calculate inclusive cross sections up to the third order in the strong coupling constant (N3LO) in QCD. It can predict various processes including Drell-Yan production and Higgs boson associated production with heavy gauge bosons.
Inclusive Cross Section
A measure of the probability that a specific physical process occurs, calculated without regard to the exact details of the final state particles. This calculation is crucial for comparing theoretical predictions with experimental measurements at colliders like the LHC.
PDF Uncertainties
Uncertainties arising from our incomplete knowledge of how quarks and gluons inside protons and antiprotons share momentum. Comparing different global PDF sets helps quantify these uncertainties, which are a major source of error in N3LO predictions.
Scale Uncertainty
A theoretical uncertainty that arises because calculations are only performed to a certain order (like NNLO). Varying the arbitrary energy scales used in the calculation helps estimate the impact of missing higher-order terms, indicating where more precision is needed.

Terminology

Summary

Inclusive cross sections play a variety of roles in high-energy phenomenology, ranging from precision tests of the SM to serving as standard candles for luminosity measurements The authors present for the first time the inclusive cross section for associated Higgs boson production with a massive gauge boson at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order in QCD

Introduction to N3LO Computations

The paper introduces n3loxs, a public, numerical program for the evaluation of inclusive cross sections at the third order in the strong coupling constant This tool allows to derive predictions for charged- and neutral-current Drell-Yan production, gluon- and bottom-quark-fusion Higgs boson production and Higgs boson associated production with a heavy gauge boson The authors discuss perturbative and parton distribution function (PDF) uncertainties of the aforementioned processes

Phenomenological Results for Drell-Yan and Higgs Production

The paper presents phenomenological results for SM processes using the code n3loxs These results are obtained at pp colliders, and for the first time, also at pp¯ colliders The study compares global PDF sets for a variety of processes including associated Higgs boson production and observes 1σ deviations among predictions for several processes

Analysis of Scale and PDF Uncertainties

The authors investigate scale uncertainties as a method of assessing theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders at different values of the center-of-mass energy and for pp and pp¯ collisions They compare the latest releases of major PDF sets against a nominal set, observing that various sets show overall rather good agreement with one another The study also includes a dedicated PDF+αS analysis at the 13 TeV LHC with their nominal PDF4LHC15 set

Associated V H Production at N3LO

The paper presents for the first time results for the fully inclusive cross section at N3LO for the production of a Higgs boson in association with a weak boson V = Z, W± in QCD They find that the third-order correction amounts to about ∼ 1% and is similar in size to the NNLO correction, similar to the case of Drell-Yan production The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2%

Summary and Conclusion

The authors conclude that the inclusion of the third-order correction is vital for precise phenomenological predictions The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2% Their results will help benchmark precision QCD calculations and phenomenological studies at the LHC

A n3loxs Program Details

The program n3loxs allows the user to calculate up to N3LO in QCD the following observables: 1. Neutral Drell-Yan differential production cross section Q2dσ/dQ2 as a function of the virtuality Q of the gauge boson, in the leptonic channel pp(pp¯) → γ∗/Z∗ → +− + X; 2. p. 0 Charged-current Drell-Yan differential production cross section Q2dσ/dQ2 as a function of the virtuality Q of the W boson, in the leptonic channel pp(pp¯) → W+ → +ν + X (pp(pp¯) → W− → −ν¯ + X); 3. p. 0 Higgs boson inclusive production cross section in the gluon fusion channel, gg → H + X, both for pp and pp¯ colliders; 4. p. 0 Higgs boson inclusive production cross section in the bottom-quark fusion channel, in the five-flavor scheme, b¯b → H + X, both for pp and pp¯ colliders; 5. p. 2 Higgsstrahlung inclusive production cross section in the charged and neutral channels, pp(pp¯) → W±H + X and pp(pp¯) → ZH + X The user can also calculate binned cross sections for Drell-Yan processes in a given range for Q, that is the production cross section σ(Qmin ≤ Q ≤ Qmax)

Installation and Usage of n3loxs

The program requires a C++11 compatible compiler, Python 3.5 or higher, as well as the LHAPDF library already installed on the user machine The user can modify a handful of parameters to control the calculational framework, such as process Selector and perturbative order

Physical Parameters and Schemes

The default physical parameters are summarized in Appendix B, which includes values for v, mW, mZ, mH, mt, mb, ΓW and ΓZ The code uses nf = 5 for the number of massless quarks used in the perturbative coefficients as well as in the β functions and anomalous dimensions

Cross Section Calculations at Various Energies

The authors present inclusive cross sections at N3LO in QCD for Higgsstrahlung production, pp → V H, for c.m. energies √s = 7, 8, 14 TeV (LHC), 27 TeV (HE-HLC) and 100 TeV (FCC-hh) The results are presented in Tables 7, Table 8, and Table 9

Binned Drell-Yan Cross Sections

n3loxs can also calculate Drell-Yan cross sections in a given bin range of the invariantmass distribution Q1 ≤ Q ≤ Q2 Using eq. (19) we can produce the invariant-mass distribution in a binned form, in windows around the Z- or W-peak

Scale Variation and Uncertainty Estimates

The authors investigate scale uncertainties as a method of assessing theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders at different values of the center-of-mass energy and for pp and pp¯ collisions In most of the analyzed cases, the traditional 7-point scale variation at NNLO does not capture the N3LO central value As a consequence, uncertainty estimates for missing higher orders based on scale variation alone should be taken with a grain of salt, already at NNLO The size of these corrections is at the order of several percent for the production processes listed here

PDF Set Comparison

The authors compare N3LO predictions for different PDF sets, noting significant overall progress in the past years in determining the PDF and their uncertainties The missing N3LO PDF sets are emerging as the biggest obstacle for further improvement of precision phenomenology at the hadron colliders The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2%

Final Conclusion on Precision

The inclusion of the third-order correction is vital for precise phenomenological predictions The current theoretical uncertainty is dominated by the parametric and PDF uncertainties, which are typically at the order of 2% The results discussed in this article, together with the n3loxs code which is available as a repository at https://github.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of inclusive cross sections for associated Higgs boson production at N3LO using n3loxs allows AI systems to derive predictions for charged- and neutral-current Drell-Yan production, gluon- and bottom-quark-fusion Higgs boson production, and Higgs boson associated production with a heavy gauge boson.

  2. Implementation of the n3loxs program enables AI systems to perform an extensive study of the impact of the choice of PDF and associated PDF uncertainties on a variety of processes at N3LO, providing comparisons between different global PDF sets like PDF4LHC15, NNPDF31, and CT18.

  3. The ability to calculate binned cross sections for Drell-Yan processes in a given range allows AI systems to produce invariant-mass distributions around the Z or W peaks at the 13 TeV LHC with high precision up to N3LO in QCD.

  4. AI systems can utilize scale variation studies, such as the 7-point scale variation, to assess theoretical uncertainties due to missing higher orders and compare them against NNLO predictions for processes like gluon fusion Higgs production.

  5. The system can perform a PDF+alphaS analysis at the 13 TeV LHC with its nominal PDF4LHC15 set to obtain correlated PDF+alphaS uncertainty, which is stated as the dominant source of theoretical errors at this perturbative order in the QCD expansion.

Sources

Related papers