The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Tsallis form factors and the electroweak hierarchy problem

arXiv:2204.09916 · hep-ph, hep-ex, hep-th · Submitted 2022-04-21 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The Higgs boson as a self-similar system".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Towards a new solution to the hierarchy problem proposes that assuming a self-similar internal structure for the Higgs boson leads to replacing quadratic divergences with logarithmic ones in mass corrections, offering a new resolution to the hierarchy problem The Hierarchy Problem and SM Limitations The Standard Model faces a hierarchy problem where quantum fluctuations lead to corrections that are extremely large if the cutoff scale is very high.

Kai: The quadratic divergence for the Higgs squared mass corrections is given by a formula involving the cutoff, electroweak scale, and particle masses.

Mira: Theories beyond the Standard Model, such as Supersymmetric models and composite Higgs scenarios, attempt to cancel this fine-tuning problem.

Kai: In these new theories, for a large cutoff scale, the Higgs boson mass cannot be found due to this cancellation.

Title and authors: Kai: Moving on to the title and authors of "The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Tsallis form factors and the electroweak hierarchy problem," we see it immediately points to two major concepts colliding.

Mira: The title tells us they are looking at how the Higgs boson behaves as a self-similar system, which is their structural assumption, and then tying it directly to solving the electroweak hierarchy problem.

Lev: What does that mean in plain English? It means they're using a fractal-like internal structure for the Higgs to solve the fine-tuning issue related to its mass correction.

Kai: Precisely. They’re proposing that instead of assuming a simple point particle, they treat it as having an internal structure similar at different scales, and this assumption changes the math from quadratic divergences to logarithmic ones.

Mira: That's a significant mathematical shift because those quadratic divergences are what cause the hierarchy problem in the Standard Model when you consider high energy cutoffs.

Lev: So, how does this structural assumption translate into a concrete calculation for mass corrections? What is the mechanism they use?

Kai: They calculate the two-point function of the Higgs using a complete set of intermediate states at some scale level, which they write down in equation four as a sum over intermediate states.

Mira: That sum includes this self-similar partonic state, which they define as an eigenstate of four momentum P mu, and then they use translational invariance to simplify that expression.

Lev: So it’s about mapping the full quantum correlation function onto a simpler structure defined by these internal states at a specific scale.

Kai: Exactly. They then rewrite this correlation function using a spectral function representation, which is like looking at the system through different energy scales, and this leads to equation seven.

Mira: That spectral representation then allows them to introduce the self-similar partonic constituent states into the description of the scalar function, as shown in equation eight.

Lev: So they are using a spectral representation to explicitly show how those internal self-similar constituents influence the overall form factor calculation.

Kai: And that leads right into their main result, where they write down the distribution function f of U in equation fourteen and then derive that it follows Tsallis statistics in equation fifteen.

Mira: So, the core mechanism is this structural assumption leading directly to a specific statistical distribution for the internal partonic states, defined by the parameter q.

Lev: And that statistical form then gets plugged back into their main calculation in equation sixteen, which results in the two-point function being proportional to m squared over k squared.

Kai: That proportionality is what leads them to the Fourier transformation of the two-point function they are interested in, setting up what they call Ze f bar and f bar equals m squared h over k squared.

Mira: And that form then directly implies that the modified diagram yields a logarithmic divergence which gets canceled by a delta m square h correction.

Lev: So, this is the path: structure assumption leads to statistical distribution, which modifies the loop calculations to change quadratic divergences into logarithmic ones.

Kai: It’s a lot of machinery, but they are using it to show that the hierarchy problem might be naturally solved through this structural view of the Higgs boson.

Mira: The interesting part is that they're connecting this structural feature to observable data, like the Higgs transverse momentum distribution following Tsallis statistics.

Lev: It’s a strong link between deep theoretical structure and experimental phenomenology that we need to keep an eye on for real hardware simulations.

Kai: So, next we look at how they suggest improvements or extensions to this work, which is where things get more specific.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now let’s look at the summary of "The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Tsallis form factors and the electroweak hierarchy problem." They basically boil it down to this idea.

Mira: They summarize it by stating that by assuming the Higgs has a self-similar internal structure, they can replace quadratic divergences with logarithmic ones in mass corrections.

Lev: So, they are essentially saying their structural assumption is a natural way to resolve the hierarchy problem without requiring heavy fine-tuning of the cutoff scale.

Kai: Right. They also state that this leads to the partonic-like distribution following Tsallis statistics when they analyze the two-point correlation function.

Mira: That statistical behavior, defined by parameter q, is what they use to describe how internal states are distributed within the system.

Lev: The summary also points out that experimental data for Higgs transverse momentum distribution can be described by this self-similar statistical model, which is a key finding in terms of phenomenology.

Kai: And they state that when they fit the differential cross section for H gamma gamma, H to ZZ star, and H to bb bar decay channels with those specific parameters q equals one point seven nine plus or minus zero point thirteen and T naught equal to three point seven plus or minus zero point eight GeV.

Mira: That fitting result provides empirical evidence that the self-similar structure of the Higgs is present in the data they are analyzing.

Lev: So, for someone who only listens to this show, this means we’re looking at a theoretical mechanism that predicts specific statistical properties observable in particle collisions.

Kai: It connects the abstract structure of a complex system to concrete, measurable distributions like transverse momentum that can be seen by experimentalists.

Mira: It gives us a tangible link between the internal structure and the observed statistical behavior of the Higgs boson.

Lev: It’s important to remember that this isn't just theory; it’s an attempt to build a model that explains why we see what we see in terms of observable statistics.

Kai: The summary sets up the foundation for understanding how this structural assumption impacts both the mass corrections and the statistical properties of the Higgs.

Mira: It really frames it as a single theoretical framework attempting to solve two problems at once: naturalness and structure.

The paper's improvements: Lev: Now let’s talk about what improvements this paper suggests for this work, because it’s not just a summary; it shows where the next steps need to go.

Kai: They suggest incorporating Tsallis statistics into event generators for high energy collisions to model transverse momentum distributions of particles like Higgs bosons, which is a big step forward.

Mira: That would allow AI systems to better simulate and interpret experimental data from colliders like the CMS collaboration at thirteen TeV, using this statistical description <ref:2204.09916#pg3>.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, it’s about moving from just fitting data to building tools that can generate realistic event samples based on these Tsallis statistics.

Kai: That's right. It moves the focus toward simulating what real collisions actually look like at the LHC.

Mira: And they also suggest developing a framework for calculating the running of interaction coupling constants using the beta function and Callan-Symanzik equation, taking into account modified one-particle irreducible diagrams.

Lev: That would let AI models predict those tiny corrections to Higgs interactions based on self-similar structure effects, which is where we can look for subtle signs in data.

Kai: So, that’s using the self-similar structure to predict how the couplings change over energy scale, based on modified diagrams.

Mira: That would be a way to quantify those tiny corrections that are predicted by their model and see if they appear in precision measurements of coupling constants.

Lev: It's about building tools that can test the theoretical predictions against high-precision experimental data, and that requires careful handling of the modified one-particle irreducible diagrams.

Kai: And they also suggest implementing a method for analyzing Higgs two-point functions that incorporates a logarithmic divergence replacement with a finite term derived from the self-similar structure.

Mira: That method directly addresses the hierarchy problem by naturally replacing quadratic divergences with this finite term, without needing to restrict the confining scale to TeV energies.

Lev: So, this is about creating methods that bypass the fine-tuning issue by using a structural replacement for those problematic loop integrals.

Kai: It’s a lot of forward looking work that moves beyond just describing what was already done and into building tools for prediction and verification.

Conclusion: Mira: So, wrapping up this paper on "The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Tsallis form factors and the electroweak hierarchy problem." The main implication is that they propose a new solution to the hierarchy problem via this structural assumption.

Lev: They showed that assuming self-similar internal structure leads to replacing quadratic divergences with logarithmic ones in mass corrections.

Kai: And they confirmed this by showing the resulting distribution follows Tsallis statistics, with q equals one point seven nine plus or minus zero point thirteen for the transverse momentum data.

Mira: This statistical behavior gives empirical support that the self-similar structure of the Higgs is a feature of nature, not just a mathematical artifact.

Lev: The limitations they flag are that they haven't done the detailed calculations for the running of interaction coupling constants yet, which is where we can test if those tiny corrections are real.

Kai: So, to summarize this paper, it connects the abstract internal structure to measurable statistical properties of Higgs transverse momentum and suggests a pathway forward through improved event generators and coupling constant calculations.

Mira: The self-similar system idea provides a new theoretical framework for addressing naturalness by offering an alternative to fine-tuning.

Lev: We need to keep the focus on building tools that can test these predictions against high-precision experimental data, especially regarding those coupling constants.

Kai: It’s a solid piece of work that shows how structural ideas can lead to new statistical descriptions in particle physics experiments we can actually measure.

School of Particles and Accelerators, Institute Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM) · School of Physics, Damghan University

hep-ph, hep-ex, hep-th

Submitted: 2022-04-21

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: 15 pages, 7 figure

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 66/100

The gist: The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Towards a new solution to the hierarchy problem proposes that assuming a self-similar internal structure for the Higgs boson leads to replacing quadratic…

Key concepts

Hierarchy Problem
This is a major issue in particle physics where quantum fluctuations cause extremely large corrections to the Higgs boson's mass if the energy scale (cutoff) is very high. Standard theories struggle to explain why the observed Higgs mass isn't unnaturally large.
Self-Similar System
The idea that the Higgs boson has an internal structure that looks statistically similar across different scales, much like a fractal. This structure is modeled using statistical methods, suggesting its properties are governed by non-extensive Tsallis statistics.
Tsallis Statistics
A type of non-extensive statistical distribution used to describe the energy distribution of the internal constituents of the Higgs. This specific statistical framework successfully fits experimental data from Higgs decay channels, providing evidence for the self-similar structure.
Logarithmic Divergence
In this model, instead of quadratic divergences (which cause massive fine-tuning issues), the internal structure leads to logarithmic divergences in mass corrections. This means the Higgs mass prediction is naturally feasible without requiring extreme fine-tuning.

Terminology

Summary

The Higgs boson as a self-similar system: Towards a new solution to the hierarchy problem proposes that assuming a self-similar internal structure for the Higgs boson leads to replacing quadratic divergences with logarithmic ones in mass corrections, offering a new resolution to the hierarchy problem

The Hierarchy Problem and SM Limitations

The Standard Model faces a hierarchy problem where quantum fluctuations lead to corrections that are extremely large if the cutoff scale is very high. The quadratic divergence for the Higgs squared mass corrections is given by a formula involving the cutoff, electroweak scale, and particle masses. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this sense, in the SM, the hierarchy problem of scales between the weak and higher energy scales is more evident when considering quantum fluctuations to calculate the Higgs squared mass corrections [4] δm 2 h = Λ 2 v 2 m 2 h +2m 2 W +m 2 Z −4m 2 t +O(log Λ 2 m2 h ), (1) where Λ is the cutoff of the theory, i. , the highest accessible energy scale, v ≃ 246GeV is the electroweak (EW) symmetry breaking scale and mh, mW,Z, and mt denote the mass of Higgs, gauge boson and top quark particles.

Theories beyond the Standard Model, such as Supersymmetric models and composite Higgs scenarios, attempt to cancel this fine-tuning problem. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Theories beyond the SM may have an additional contribution to the Higgs mass such that it is finely adjusted to cancel δm 2 h . Supersymmetric models [5] and composite Higgs scenarios [6] are such endeavors to avoid this problem.

In these new theories, for a large cutoff scale, the Higgs boson mass cannot be found due to this cancellation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The fine-tuning in cancellation can be measured as [6] ∆ ≥ δm 2 h m2 h ∼ Λ 450GeV2 . (2) Therefore, in these new theories, for Λ ≫ TeV, the Higgs boson mass cannot be found due to the cancellation.

Modeling the Higgs as a Self-Similar System

The paper posits that the Higgs boson should be viewed not as an elementary particle but as a complex system with an internal structure exhibiting statistical self-similarity. This concept draws parallels with fractals studied in various fields, where self-similar systems have been used to model hadrons in strong interactions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Self-similar objects and patterns, known as fractals, have been widely studied in various areas of science including mathematics, biology and physics, as widely found in nature (not necessarily as exact fractals) [9]. In particle physics, especially in strong interactions, self-similar systems have been used to model hadrons which are composed of hadrons [10– 12].

The internal constituents of the Higgs are considered similar to the main system at a different level of scale. p. 0
Where the paper says it

That is the notion established in composite Higgs models [6–8], avoiding the hierarchy problem. In this paper, the Higgs boson is not considered as an elementary particle but a complex system with an internal structure which reveals a statistical self-similarity behavior in that constituents are similar to the main system at a different level of scale.

Derivation of Self-Similar Statistical Behavior

The two-point correlation function is analyzed using intermediate states, leading to an expression for the two-point function in terms of a spectral function. The self-similar partonic state is represented by a sum over internal states, and the resulting probability term includes a factor related to the partonic-like distribution. p. 1

Where the paper says it

self-similar partonic-like state at some energy scale, |ψ⟩, so that it has self-similar internal subsystems, |ψi⟩, similar but with different energy levels with respect to the system. Thus, Z = |⟨Ω|φ(0)|ψi⟩|2 is considered as the field strength renormalization of a representative self-similar Higgs state and the effect of self-similar subsystems is included in the new probability term ∑i |⟨ψi |ψ⟩|2 as ∑ i |⟨ψi |ψ⟩|2 = ∑ i ∏ i Z d 4 pi (2π) 4 |M|2 f (2π) 4 δ 4 ∑pi −k .

This distribution function is derived from a Maxwell distribution for an N-particle system, leading to an energy distribution that follows non-extensive Tsallis statistics. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Thus, for this system we can write f(U) = µ − 3N 2 Γ(3N/2) U 3N 2 −1 e − U µ = µ − 3N 2 Γ(3N/2) K 3N 2 −1 (1+x) 3N 2 α−α e − K µ (1+x) α , (14) and hence the internal distribution would be f(x) = Z dK µ − 3N 2 Γ(3N/2) K 3N 2 −1 (1+x) 3N 2 α−α e − K µ (1+x) α = (1+x) −α . (15) It is tempting substitute α = q/(q − 1) and x = (q − 1)ε/ε˜, and it can be seen the distribution, [1 + (q − 1)ε/ε˜] −q/(q−1) , follows the non-extensive Tsallis statistics, where q is the entropic factor of the system and for the limit q → 1 the Boltzmann-Gibbs is reproduced.

Implications for the Hierarchy Problem

The resulting statistical model allows the calculation of effective one-particle irreducible (1PI) diagrams to yield a logarithmic divergence in Higgs mass corrections. This scenario suggests that the prediction of the Higgs mass is naturally feasible without restricting the confining scale to be around the TeV, and without fine-tuning due to this divergence. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Then, connecting the modified factor to pertubative calculations, we show that the calculation of effective one-particle irreducible (1PI) diagrams leads to a logarithmic divergence in the Higgs mass corrections. Such a scenario can be resulted from a new QCD-like dynamics at high energies and hence not only is the prediction of the Higgs mass naturally feasible without restricting the given confining scale to be around the TeV, and without fine-tuning due to the logarithmic divergence, but also the hierarchy problem is addressed in this setup.

The distribution obtained obeys non-extensive Tsallis statistics, where the factor q is a measure of non-additivity. p. 2
Where the paper says it

DISCUSSION As already mentioned, the obtained distribution obeys the non-extensive Tsallis statistics. The non-extensivity can be realized from the non-additive entropy [17] and the factor q is a measure of non-additivity.

Experimental data for Higgs transverse momentum distribution can be described by this self-similar statistical model. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Assuming the Higgs boson as a system with a self-similar internal structure, we calculate its twopoint function and find that the quadratic divergence is replaced by a logarithmic one in the mass corrections. It is shown that the partonic-like distribution follows the Tsallis statistics and also high energy physics experimental data for the Higgs transverse momentum distribution can be described by a self-similar statistical model.

The combined measurement of differential cross section for H → γγ, H → ZZ∗ and H → bb¯ decay channels is fitted to the Tsallis function with parameters q = 1. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The combined measurement of differential cross section for H → γγ, H → ZZ∗ and H → bb¯ decay channels as a function of p H T is shown as black points with error bars [27]. Using the MINUIT package [29], the spectra are fitted to the Tsallis function for q = 1.

79 ± 0.13 and T0 = 3.7 ± 0.8GeV. The result suggests evidence for the self-similarity feature of the Higgs. p. 3
Where the paper says it

13 and T0 = 3. The result can be the evidence for the self-similarity feature of the Higgs and also using fitting parameters, more detailed investigation may constrain the mass spectrum of this type of particles in future high energy physics explorations.

The running of interaction coupling constants can also yield tiny corrections in this setup. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Another aspect of Higgs properties can be studied through the running of its interaction coupling constants by means of the beta function and the Callan-Symanzik equation. In the present setup, taking into account the modified 1PI diagrams, tiny corrections can be obtained and we leave detailed calculations associated with this feature of the model for a future work.

Conclusion and Future Work

The analysis shows that the effect of internal structure is included in a new probability term as sum i ψiψ⟩2 = sum i ψiψ⟩2. The Fourier transformation of the two-point function yields a result where the effect of internal structure is included in Ze ≡ Z˜f and ˜f = m2h/k2. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Eventually, we obtain the Fourier transformation of the twopoint function as follows Z d 4 x eip(x−y) ⟨Ω|Tφ(x)φ(y)|Ω⟩ ∼ iZe p 2 −m2 h +iε , (17) where the effect of the internal structure is included in Ze ≡ Z ˜f and ˜f = m 2 h /k 2 . In the perturbative method, analogous to the sum of 1PI diagrams, denoted by M, for this system the Higgs two-point function can be expressed as a geometric series of modified diagrams, Me , so that iZe p 2 −m2 h +iε ∼ i p 2 −m2 0h −Me (18) where Me can be attained from Eq.

This leads to Me = ˜fM, implying M(p → p) = ZeM. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Thereby, from Ze−1 ∼ 1 − δZe, we can find δZe = ˜f δZ = dMe /d p2 = ˜f dM/d p2 and hence Me = ˜fM. This result can be also consistently applied to the Lehmann-SymanzikZimmermann (LSZ) formula [21] in that the sum of 1PI insertions in the propagator is equal to that of amputated scattering diagrams, implying M(p → p) = ZeM = ZMe .

The calculation for the modified diagram yields a logarithmic divergence which is canceled by δm2h. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In the present work, based on the non-perturbative analysis of the two-point correlation function [19, 20], incorporating the Kallen–Lehmann spectral representation, we first obtain ¨ the two-point function of the Higgs with the self-similar internal structure, whose effects give rise to a modification to the field strength renormalization factor. Then, connecting the modified factor to pertubative calculations, we show that the calculation of effective one-particle irreducible (1PI) diagrams leads to a logarithmic divergence in the Higgs mass corrections.

Detailed calculations associated with the running of interaction coupling constants are left for future work. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Another aspect of Higgs properties can be studied through the running of its interaction coupling constants by means of the beta function and the Callan-Symanzik equation. In the present setup, taking into account the modified 1PI diagrams, tiny corrections can be obtained and we leave detailed calculations associated with this feature of the model for a future work.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate Tsallis statistics into event generators for high energy collisions to model transverse momentum distributions of particles like Higgs bosons, as described by fitting function (21). This allows AI systems to better simulate and interpret experimental data from colliders like the CMS collaboration at 13 TeV.

  2. Develop a framework for calculating the running of interaction coupling constants using the beta function and Callan-Symanzik equation, taking into account modified one-particle irreducible diagrams. This enables AI models to predict tiny corrections to Higgs interactions based on self-similar structure effects.

  3. Implement a method for analyzing Higgs two-point functions that incorporates a logarithmic divergence replacement with a finite term derived from the self-similar structure, as shown in Eq (20). This allows AI systems to naturally address the hierarchy problem without requiring fine-tuning or restricting the confining scale to TeV energies.

Abstract

We study the electroweak hierarchy problem for a composite Higgs boson with a statistically self-similar internal structure. Using the spectral representation of the Higgs propagator, we show that this structure can contribute only through momentum-dependent vertex functions. In a superstatistical model of the self-similar structure, a Gamma-distributed size of the constituents turns a Gaussian vertex form factor into the q-exponential (Tsallis) form factor F q(k E 2)=[1+(q-1)k E 2/M 2]-1/(q-1), where M is the compositeness scale and q-1=2/(3N) for an effective number N of constituents. These form factors interpolate between those of nonlocal field theories (q to1) and Lee--Wick-type models (q=2). For 1<q<2 every one-loop contribution to the Higgs mass is finite and heavy states decouple. For the benchmarks q=11/9, 4/3 and 5/3, tuning is negligible (Δ 1) for M up to about 1 -- 2 TeV, and remains mild (Δ at most 10) for M up to about 3 -- 5 TeV. The hierarchy problem is thus converted into the requirement of new composite dynamics near the TeV scale, testable at the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider through off-shell and high-momentum Higgs processes and searches for new states near M.

Sources

Related papers