Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds

arXiv:2204.00920 · cs.CV · Submitted 2022-04-02 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: AI Radio. Generated commentary on the latest Artificial Intelligence papers.

Tom: I'm Tom.

Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds proposes an end-to-end Point Cloud Circle Algebraic Fitting Network (Circle-Net) based on a synergy of deep circle-boundary point feature learning and weighted algebraic fitting to robustly and accurately fit circles in a deep learning fashion The major features of our novel circle extraction method include an end-to-end point cloud circle algebraic fitting network (Circle-Net) which is a fully automatic multi-circle extraction paradigm for joint circleboundary point classification and algebraic circle fitting <ref:2204.00920#pg6> Problem Motivation The shape of circle is one of fundamental geometric primitives of man-made engineering objects, making the extraction from scanned point clouds a quite important task in 3D geometry data processing Existing methods are sensitive to the quality of raw point clouds when classifying circleboundary points or require well-designed fitting functions when regressing circle parameters Circle extraction from point clouds mainly consists of two (individual) operations: (i) classifying initial circle-boundary points and (ii) fitting a series of repetitive circles from these promising circle-boundary points The main challenge in the first operation is that existing boundary/edge detection methods cannot effectively distinguish which points are boundary points or not since these circle primitives are usually distributed on the base surface as very plain features For the latter operation which aims to compute accurate parameters of the circles, typical methods include weighted leastsquares (WLS) fitting and RANSAC-based solutions Low-fidelity data makes existing parameter estimation methods difficult to design weight functions to measure the significance of each point for accurately fitting a circle Network Architecture and Learning Signals Circle-Net is designed with two cascaded sub-learning stages <ref:2204.00920#pg5> The first stage, Circle-boundary Point Classification, uses a transformer module to fuse local and global neighboring contexts of each point to detect all potential circle-boundary points <ref:2204.00920#pg6> This involves extracting four different deep features from the local patch and global patch using 3D CNN and 2D CNN networks, which are then fused by a Multi-Head Attention unit <ref:2204.00920#pg6> The second stage, Weight Estimation for Algebraic Circle Fitting, employs a neural network to estimate the weight of each detected circle-boundary point using a sigmoid activation function to limit the output values within the range of 0 and 1 <ref:2204.00920#pg5> This estimated weight is then used for weighted algebraic circle fitting in Eq.

Tom: 6 <ref:2204.00920#pg6> Joint Loss Formulation Circle-Net utilizes a joint loss function L which covers two parts, i.e., the circle-boundary point classification loss and the fitting loss, formulated as L = (1 − η) ∗ Lc + η ∗ Lf where η is a trade-off factor to balance the two terms <ref:2204.00920#pg4> The circle-boundary point classification loss, Lc, is formulated as a weighted cross-entropy loss to balance the proportion of circle-boundary points in a point cloud <ref:2204.00920#pg4> The fitting loss function, Lf, is formulated as the differences between K fitted circle parameters and the corresponding ground truths <ref:2204.00920#pg4> Experimental Results and Superiority Extensive experiments show that Circle-Net significantly outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in terms of both circleboundary point classification and circle fitting accuracy In comparison of detection results, our approach achieves better detection results compared to previous techniques on virtually-scanned point clouds <ref:2204.00920#pg2> Furthermore, the quantitative evaluation shows that our method achieves the lowest AD(c) and AD(r) among the five compared fitting approaches on the testing dataset <ref:2204.00920#pg2> The circle fitting results demonstrate that our method is closest to the ground truth circles, even when dealing with noisy or incomplete data <ref:2204.00920#pg3> For industrial application in quality inspection of drilling circles, our method achieves the lowest error, even compared with commercial inspection software <ref:2204.00920#pg8> Ablation Analysis and Conclusion Ablation experiments show that the transformer module improves the P recision of Variant 2 and Variant 5 by 3.98% and 4.43%, and the Recall by 5.83% and 3.4%, respectively <ref:2204.00920#pg2> The circle fitting results show that all the fitting results of Variant 3, Variant 4, Variant 5 and Full are more immune to the outliers when using the weight learning module <ref:2204.00920#pg3> The final application demonstrates the potential practical value in the field of 3D inspection <ref:2204.00920#pg8> Future work is our research interest to solve the traditional geometric optimization problem in a data-driven way, such as learning weights for geometric fitting <ref:2204.00920#pg2> The method can detect circle-boundary points more reliably and produce circle primitives more accurately Our method can detect the outer circles of rivets with a very low height automatically and accurately <ref:2204.00920#pg9> The quality of drilling is a vital factor affecting the riveting quality of aircraft <ref:2204.

Paper summary: Tom: So to wrap up this "Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds" paper, what we've seen is that they’ve put together a system, Circle-Net, that handles finding circle boundaries and then fitting those circles using learned weights. It’s designed to work end-to-end.

Jane: The title itself tells you the scope: it’s about deep algebraic fitting for multiple primitives, specifically circles, extracted from raw point clouds. The authors are essentially saying that instead of needing separate steps for boundary detection and parameter estimation with separate, often brittle methods, you can combine them into one network flow.

Lu: What this means for the field is that geometric fitting problems in three dee data processing can be approached more data-driven <ref:2204.00920#pg1>. They’ve shown they can detect circle-boundary points more reliably and produce circle primitives more accurately than prior methods on virtually scanned point clouds.

Meng: From my side, it suggests that for applications requiring high precision, like quality inspection of drilling or rivets, this network has the potential to reduce the human effort needed to manually tune those fitting functions significantly.

Lalam: The core contribution is their synergy: deep circle-boundary point feature learning followed by a weight estimation module that feeds into weighted algebraic fitting. It’s an automated paradigm for multi-circle extraction.

Tom: So the takeaway for listeners is that if you're working with messy three dee scan data and need precise circle parameters, this Circle-Net approach offers a strong, empirically validated solution compared to the existing state-of-the-art fitting methods <ref:2204.00920#pg1>.

Conclusion: Tom: So, this paper is about taking raw point clouds—those messy collections of dots from scanning something—and figuring out where circles are hiding in them, and then accurately calculating those circle parameters.

Jane: It sounds complicated, but the authors call their system Circle-Net. They’re using a two-step process: first classifying the points that look like circle boundaries, and second using weighted algebraic fitting to get the exact measurements of those circles.

Lu: The core idea is combining deep learning for finding these boundaries with a neural network that estimates how important each boundary point is for the final fit. It's an end-to-end system designed to handle multiple circles at once automatically.

Meng: From my side, I’m curious about the deployment part. If this works on raw data, does it still run fast enough when we're dealing with really dense industrial scans where things break down?

Tom: Well, the results show they beat existing methods for both finding the boundaries and fitting the circle parameters. They achieve very low error rates compared to other fitting approaches on testing datasets.

Jane: It means that instead of needing separate, hard-to-design detection rules and complicated manual fitting functions, we can use this deep learning network to automate the entire process robustly.

Lu: The ablation studies show that adding a transformer module actually improves the accuracy of finding those boundaries and makes the final fitting results more stable when there's noise or incomplete data.

Tom: It sounds like they’ve really gotten good at handling that noise, which is usually where these kinds of geometry extraction methods fail in real-world scenarios.

Jane: So, while they show great performance on test data, the real question for us is how reliable this system is when we take it out into a factory setting for things like quality inspection.

Lu: And that’s exactly what we need to look at next—how to make this kind of learned geometric fitting method truly ready for production environments.

Zeyong Wei, Honghua Chen, Hao Tang, Qian Xie, Mingqiang Wei, Jun Wang

Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics · University of Oxford

cs.CV

Submitted: 2022-04-02

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: Withdrawn due to unresolved authorship and contribution-attribution issues. The submitted author list and contribution statement were not confirmed in writing by all co-authors. All co-authors have been notified; the author list and contributions are being revised. A corrected version will be resubmitted after written agreement. No concerns about the data or conclusions.

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 90/100

The gist: Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds proposes an end-to-end Point Cloud Circle Algebraic Fitting Network (Circle-Net) based on a synergy of deep…

Key concepts

Circle-Net
A fully automatic network designed to extract multiple circles from point clouds. It uses two stages: first, classifying points as potential circle boundaries using a transformer module, and second, estimating weights for robust algebraic fitting of those detected points.
Circle-boundary Point Classification
The initial step where the network identifies which points in the raw data are likely to be on the edge of a circle. This is achieved by fusing local and global context features extracted from 3D CNNs and 2D CNNs using a Multi-Head Attention unit to detect complex boundary shapes.
Weighted Algebraic Fitting
The second stage where the network calculates the precise mathematical parameters (like center and radius) of the circles. It uses an estimated weight for each detected point to perform a weighted least-squares fitting, which helps make parameter estimation more robust against noisy or incomplete data.

Terminology

Summary

Deep Algebraic Fitting for Multiple Circle Primitives Extraction from Raw Point Clouds proposes an end-to-end Point Cloud Circle Algebraic Fitting Network (Circle-Net) based on a synergy of deep circle-boundary point feature learning and weighted algebraic fitting to robustly and accurately fit circles in a deep learning fashion The major features of our novel circle extraction method include an end-to-end point cloud circle algebraic fitting network (Circle-Net) which is a fully automatic multi-circle extraction paradigm for joint circleboundary point classification and algebraic circle fitting <ref:2204. p. 100920#pg6>

Problem Motivation

The shape of circle is one of fundamental geometric primitives of man-made engineering objects, making the extraction from scanned point clouds a quite important task in 3D geometry data processing Existing methods are sensitive to the quality of raw point clouds when classifying circleboundary points or require well-designed fitting functions when regressing circle parameters Circle extraction from point clouds mainly consists of two (individual) operations: (i) classifying initial circle-boundary points and (ii) fitting a series of repetitive circles from these promising circle-boundary points The main challenge in the first operation is that existing boundary/edge detection methods cannot effectively distinguish which points are boundary points or not since these circle primitives are usually distributed on the base surface as very plain features For the latter operation which aims to compute accurate parameters of the circles, typical methods include weighted leastsquares (WLS) fitting and RANSAC-based solutions Low-fidelity data makes existing parameter estimation methods difficult to design weight functions to measure the significance of each point for accurately fitting a circle

Network Architecture and Learning Signals

Circle-Net is designed with two cascaded sub-learning stages <ref:2204.00920#pg5> The first stage, Circle-boundary Point Classification, uses a transformer module to fuse local and global neighboring contexts of each point to detect all potential circle-boundary points <ref:2204. p. 100920#pg6> This involves extracting four different deep features from the local patch and global patch using 3D CNN and 2D CNN networks, which are then fused by a Multi-Head Attention unit <ref:2204. p. 500920#pg6> The second stage, Weight Estimation for Algebraic Circle Fitting, employs a neural network to estimate the weight of each detected circle-boundary point using a sigmoid activation function to limit the output values within the range of 0 and 1 <ref:2204. p. 700920#pg5> This estimated weight is then used for weighted algebraic circle fitting in Eq. p. 4 6 <ref:2204. p. 000920#pg6>

Joint Loss Formulation

Circle-Net utilizes a joint loss function L which covers two parts, i.e., the circle-boundary point classification loss and the fitting loss, formulated as L = (1 − η) ∗ Lc + η ∗ Lf where η is a trade-off factor to balance the two terms <ref:2204. p. 700920#pg4> The circle-boundary point classification loss, Lc, is formulated as a weighted cross-entropy loss to balance the proportion of circle-boundary points in a point cloud <ref:2204. p. 700920#pg4> The fitting loss function, Lf, is formulated as the differences between K fitted circle parameters and the corresponding ground truths <ref:2204. p. 700920#pg4>

Experimental Results and Superiority

Extensive experiments show that Circle-Net significantly outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in terms of both circleboundary point classification and circle fitting accuracy In comparison of detection results, our approach achieves better detection results compared to previous techniques on virtually-scanned point clouds <ref:2204.00920#pg2> Furthermore, the quantitative evaluation shows that our method achieves the lowest AD(c) and AD(r) among the five compared fitting approaches on the testing dataset <ref:2204. p. 900920#pg2> The circle fitting results demonstrate that our method is closest to the ground truth circles, even when dealing with noisy or incomplete data <ref:2204. p. 800920#pg3> For industrial application in quality inspection of drilling circles, our method achieves the lowest error, even compared with commercial inspection software <ref:2204. p. 100920#pg8>

Ablation Analysis and Conclusion

Ablation experiments show that the transformer module improves the P recision of Variant 2 and Variant 5 by 3.98% and 4.43%, and the Recall by 5. p. 983% and 3.4%, respectively <ref:2204. p. 000920#pg2> The circle fitting results show that all the fitting results of Variant 3, Variant 4, Variant 5 and Full are more immune to the outliers when using the weight learning module <ref:2204. p. 000920#pg3> The final application demonstrates the potential practical value in the field of 3D inspection <ref:2204. p. 000920#pg8> Future work is our research interest to solve the traditional geometric optimization problem in a data-driven way, such as learning weights for geometric fitting <ref:2204. p. 400920#pg2> The method can detect circle-boundary points more reliably and produce circle primitives more accurately Our method can detect the outer circles of rivets with a very low height automatically and accurately <ref:2204. p. 200920#pg9> The quality of drilling is a vital factor affecting the riveting quality of aircraft <ref:2204. p. 1

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. End-to-end circle extraction with Circle-Net can automatically detect all potential circle-boundary points and accurately compute circle parameters by combining deep learning with algebraic fitting to solve the problem of separating classification and fitting into a single, robust paradigm.

  2. The system can be made noise robust by using a neural network to predict point-wise weights for weighted algebraic fitting, which allows the method to avoid the influence of outliers during fitting when dealing with low-fidelity data like real-scanned point clouds.

  3. The Circle-Net architecture can be enhanced by replacing the transformer module with direct feature concatenation in Variant 3, and by incorporating attention modules from Hu et al (2018) in Variant 4 to improve circle boundary point classification accuracy.

  4. The system can achieve superior fitting accuracy over traditional methods like Hyper Al-Sharadqah et al (2009), LLS Coope (1993), RANSAC Fischler and Bolles (1981), RLTS Nurunnabi et al (2018), and PIE-NET Wang et al (2020) by leveraging the learned circle-boundary points as input to the algebraic fitting step.

  5. The system can be generalized to handle different circle sizes better by using an approximate radius as a hyper-parameter Rhyper during testing, which helps in avoiding missing circles whose size is very different from the training data.

Related papers