Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities

arXiv:2107.04047 · cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.supr-con, gr-qc, hep-th · Submitted 2021-07-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: Today's paper: "Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities".

Mira: The gist The spatial modulation of the Fermi velocity for gapless Dirac electrons in quantum materials is mathematically equivalent to the problem of massless fermions on a certain class of…

Kai: First, who's behind it and why it matters.

Title and authors: Kai: The paper sets up this whole framework by looking at how these Dirac electrons behave when they are subject to what they call artificial quenched gravity. It focuses on the idea that these electrons aren't just moving in flat space, but the geometry itself is being warped by some external coupling.

Mira: Basically, the authors define a Hamiltonian and an action for this system, and then they map it onto a gravitational setup using a vielbein formalism to define an action involving massless Dirac fermions on a two plusone-dimensional spacetime manifold <ref:2107.04047#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: What they are doing is studying the null geodesics on these manifolds, which correspond to trajectories of massless particles, and how those trajectories behave near curvature singularities like nematic singularity walls.

Mira: They find that when null geodesics hit these nematic singularity walls, they don't just pass through; they get perfectly collimated to a local transit angle defined by the vectors v1 and v2. That's a key part of the paper.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest some ways to improve this picture, like studying different submodels, such as the isotropic power-law model where v(r) is proportional to r with an alpha greater than zero.

Mira: For that isotropic model, they find that geodesics heading toward the singularity are always captured and those heading away always escape, which gives them a clear picture of trapping versus escaping behavior in that specific geometry.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "Geodesic geometry of two plusone-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities," they show how these singularities can trap null geodesics into stable or metastable orbits characterized by repeated transits <ref:2107.04047#pg1,Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched>.

Mira: This has implications for understanding how low-dimensional Dirac materials might exhibit features related to quasi-one-dimensionality, especially when looking at 2D dirty d-wave superconductivity <ref:2107.04047#pg1>.

Lev: From a hardware standpoint, if you were trying to simulate this on real quantum hardware, the geometry described by the xy-factored model leads all geodesics toward nematic singularity walls before they might get captured by an isotropic singularity.

Kai: That means that for those geometries, you have a clear boundary where the dynamics change dramatically.

Mira: And that’s what leads us into looking at how these geometrical effects link to pairing enhancement in superconductors and whether we can model how states gravitationally bound to these domain wall horizons could connect to quasi-1D physics <ref:2107.04047#pg1>.

Lev: If those bound orbits are stable, you're talking about some kind of persistent state, which would be really hard for error correction protocols to manage unless the trapping mechanism is very robust.

Kai: So in the paper "Geodesic geometry of two plusone-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities," they give us a picture of how spacetime curvature affects these electrons through geodesic lensing and collimation at singularity walls <ref:2107.04047#pg1,Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched>.

Mira: And they show that while nematic walls can trap geodesics, isotropic singularities can actually capture them asymptotically.

Lev: The limitations they point out are that the method itself is built on this specific mapping to gravity, so if the underlying physics of the coupling isn't perfectly modeled by that stress tensor component, you lose that geometric picture entirely.

Kai: It sounds like a lot of foundational work connecting material properties directly to general relativity concepts for these Dirac systems.

Mira: Exactly. But the next step is seeing how this links to experimental observables, and that’s where we need to look at these quantum treatments of toy models, especially the circular nematic power-law model with alpha equals two.

S. M. Davis, M. S. Foster

University of Maryland · Rice University

cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.supr-con, gr-qc, hep-th

Submitted: 2021-07-08

Updated: 2022-06-10

Comments: v2: Added quantum calculations for singular geometries, 47 pages, 16 figures, published version

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 12, 204 (2022)

DOI: 10.21468/SciPostPhys.12.6.204

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: The gist The spatial modulation of the Fermi velocity for gapless Dirac electrons in quantum materials is mathematically equivalent to the problem of massless fermions on a certain class of curved

Key concepts

Spatial Modulation of Fermi Velocity
This refers to how the speed at which Dirac electrons move changes across different spatial directions within a quantum material. Mathematically, this physical phenomenon is equivalent to describing massless particles moving within a specific type of curved spacetime geometry, allowing physicists to use general relativity tools.
Nematic Singularity Walls
These are specific types of curvature singularities in the model where the electronic energy band structure flattens along one direction. They act as boundaries or 'walls' for the massless fermions, forcing particles approaching them to adjust their trajectory and speed.
Null Geodesics
These represent the paths taken by massless particles, analogous to light rays in spacetime. The paper analyzes how these paths bend and interact with the curved geometry of the material, focusing on how they are collimated or trapped by singularities.

Terminology

Summary

The gist The spatial modulation of the Fermi velocity for gapless Dirac electrons in quantum materials is mathematically equivalent to the problem of massless fermions on a certain class of curved spacetime manifolds.

Model and Analogy to Gravitation

The study focuses on a 2+1-dimensional massless Dirac model in the presence of artificial quenched gravity, which involves perturbations that mimic gravity by coupling to the spatial-spatial components of the stress tensor and preserve time-reversal symmetry. The Hamiltonian is defined as H = -i/2 X a,b=1,2 Z d 2x v b a (x) h ψ¯(x) ˆσ a ←→∂b ψ(x) i, (1) and the action is given by S = i Z dt Z d 2x  ψ¯(t, x)∂tψ(t, x) + 1/2 X a,b=1,2 v b a (x) h ψ¯(t, x) ←→∂b ψ(t, x) i, (3a) = i Z dt Z d 2x ψ¯(t, x) ∂t + v1(x) · σˆ ∂1 + 1/2 ∂1v1(x) · σˆ + v2(x) · σˆ ∂2 + 1/2 ∂2v2(x) · σˆ ψ(t, x), (3b). The mapping to gravity involves using the vielbein formalism [9] to define the action for a system of massless Dirac fermions on a 2+1-dimensional spacetime as S = Z p g d 3x ψ¯(x)E µ A (x)ˆγ A i∂µ − 1/2 ω BC µ (x)SˆBC ψ(x), (5). Consistency between the Dirac Hamiltonian in Eq. (1) and the action in Eq. (5) requires setting E0 A6=0 = 0, due to the absence of time-space mixing terms. With this choice, temporal flatness is enforced by the condition pg E 0 0 ≡ 1. This leads to a quenched gravitational metric in Eq. (11c) which is defined by the mapping dictionary E 0 A = 1/p v1 × v2, and gµν → [E 0 A = 1/p v1 × v2 (1, 0, 0; 0 v 1/v 2; 0 v 2/v 2) (38).

Curvature and Singularities

The metric in Eq. (11c) becomes ill-defined at points where the cross-product v1×v2 vanishes, which corresponds to a failure of the temporal flatness condition and the non-invertibility of the inverse metric. The Ricci scalar curvature takes the form R = N v b a, ∂v d c v1 × v2 3, (12). Singularities are characterized in terms of Dirac cone geometry; nematic singularities correspond to nonzero v [Eq. (13)] and give rise to a local Dirac canyon, while isotropic singularities correspond to v = 0, and locally flatten the entire Dirac cone. Nematic singularities can only be formed by the breaking of rotational symmetry of the electron band structure.

Geodesics

The main focus is on null geodesics on the manifolds defined by Eq. (11c), which are governed by the geodesic equation d/2x µ ds2 = -Γ µ αβ[x(s)] dxα ds dxβ ds, (19). Null geodesics correspond to trajectories followed by massless particles, and they have a conserved spacetime interval gµν[x(s)]dxµ/ds dxν ds ≡ ∆, where null geodesics correspond to ∆ = 0. The temporal first integral for time along a geodesic is dt/ds = (E/m) v1[x(s)] × v2[x(s)] (24). A reparametrization by global time yields the gravitational time-dilation factor γ(x) ≡ 1/(v1(x) × v2(x)) (25). The geodesic equation in terms of global time coordinate is given by Eq. (27a).

Geodesic Collimation at Nematic Singularities

Null geodesics impinging on a nematic singularity are driven to pass through at the direction defined by the angle θˆ∗ and at the speed v (30a–c). This is because for φ to have a finite derivative at the singularity, it must be driven to ˆv so that at the singularity, φˆ is parallel to the vectors v1, v2. The geodesic equation thus locks the speed of the geodesic through the singularity to v (30a–c).

Submodels and Solvable Manifolds

The paper studies several solvable manifolds, including the isotropic power-law model with v(r) = rα for α > 0 (5.1). For this model, geodesics that start out heading towards the singularity are always captured and those that start out heading away always escape. The xy-factored model provides a class of models where all geodesics asymptote towards nematic singularity walls, and run along these walls until finally being captured by an isotropic singularity.

Quantum Treatments of Toy Models

The paper investigates the quantum dynamics for toy models, finding that in the dreibein wall geometries, while all geodesics are bounded for the linear wall, only some are bounded for the tanh wall. In contrast, in the circular nematic power-law model with α = 2, all quantum density asymptotically accumulates at the origin, mimicking the behavior of the geodesics.

Conclusion

The effects of “artificial” quenched gravity on 2D massless Dirac carriers could have important consequences for understanding and manipulating low-dimensional Dirac materials. Isotropic singularities can asymptotically capture geodesics that pass sufficiently close, while null geodesics can traverse nematic singularity domain walls but experience a geodesic collimation effect that fixes their transit velocity. These domain walls can exhibit a horizon effect, trapping null geodesics as bound states that perpetually lens back and forth across the nematic singularity line.

The paper is an excellent, fastidious and diligent researcher. Any mistake I make can cost millions of dollars. The paper is titled Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities. REFERENCES

--- Page 1 ---

SciPost Physics Submission

Geodesic geometry of 2+1-D Dirac materials subject to artificial, quenched gravitational singularities S. M. Davis1, M. S. Foster,1 Condensed Matter Theory Center and Joint Quantum Institute, Department of Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA 2 Department of Physics and Astronomy and Rice Center for Quantum Materials, Rice University, Houston, Texas 77005, June 13, 2022 Abstract The spatial modulation of the Fermi velocity for gapless Dirac electrons in quantum materials is mathematically equivalent to the problem of massless fermions on a certain class of curved spacetime manifolds. We study null geodesic lensing through these manifolds, which are dominated by curvature singularities, such as nematic singularity walls (where the Dirac cone flattens along one direction). Null geodesics lens across these walls, but do so by perfectly collimating to a local transit angle. Nevertheless, nematic walls can trap null geodesics into stable or metastable orbits characterized by repeated transits. We speculate about the role of induced one-dimensionality for such bound orbits in 2D dirty d-wave superconductivity Abstract The spatial modulation of the Fermi velocity for gapless Dirac electrons in quantum materials is mathematically equivalent to the problem of massless fermions on a certain class of curved spacetime manifolds. We study null geodesic lensing through these manifolds, which are dominated by curvature singularities, such as nematic singularity walls (where the Dirac cone flattens along one direction). Null geodesics lens across these walls, but do so by perfectly collimating to a local transit angle. Nevertheless, nematic walls can trap null geodesics into stable or metastable orbits characterized by repeated transits.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform semiclassical approximations of quantum dynamics by treating null geodesics as bicharacteristics for both the curved-space Dirac equation and the associated wave equations. This allows for a geometric optics viewpoint of a generic field equation, which is crucial for understanding the semiclassical approach to QGD.

  2. Improved AI can model and predict phenomena in 2D Dirac materials by simulating the effects of artificial quenched gravity (QG). Specifically, it can determine that Isotropic singularities are strongly attractive and asymptotically capture geodesics, while nematic singularities do not capture geodesics; instead, they drive all impinging geodesics to a unique velocity.

  3. Improved AI can analyze the phase diagram of Dirac superconductors by linking nematic singularity walls to pairing enhancement. It can model how states gravitationally bound to domain wall horizons could provide a link to quasi-1D physics and how pairing enhancement due to nematic singularity walls could create a negative feedback loop, terminating when the gap has hardened sufficiently.

  4. Improved AI can perform quantum state analysis in specific toy models by solving the time-dependent curved-space Dirac equation for geometries like the xy-factored orthogonal model, yielding solutions that are in extremely close correspondence with the geodesic picture.

Sources

Related papers