One-Loop Corrections to the Two-Body Decays of the Neutral Higgs Bosons in the Complex NMSSM

arXiv:1907.12060 · hep-ph · Submitted 2019-07-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "One-Loop Corrections to the Two-Body Decays of the Neutral Higgs Bosons in the Complex NMSSM".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Detailed Research Summary: One-Loop Corrections to Two-Body Decays of Neutral Higgs Bosons in Complex NMSSM This research focuses on providing complete next-to-leading order (SUSY-)electroweak corrections to the on-shell and non-loop induced neutral Higgs boson decays within the framework of the CP-violating Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric extension of the Standard Model (NMSSM).

Kai: The primary objective is to achieve the highest possible precision for NMSSM Higgs boson decays and branching ratios, thereby enhancing sensitivity in searches for New Physics at current and future colliders.

Mira: Theoretical Framework and Methodology: The calculations are performed within the complex NMSSM, preserving a Z 3 symmetry at tree level.

Kai: The work meticulously details the renormalization procedures for the Higgs, chargino/neutralino, and squark sectors, employing a combination of on-shell (OS) and dimensional regularization (DR) schemes.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "One-Loop Corrections to the Two-Body Decays of the Neutral Higgs Bosons in the Complex NMSSM". It’s by Baglio, Dao, and M¨uhlleitner. The title itself tells you exactly what’s going on: one loop corrections to decays of neutral Higgs bosons in a specific supersymmetric model called the Complex NMSSM.

Mira: Exactly. What that means for us is that we're getting more precise predictions for how these Higgs particles decay, especially when we include those quantum loop effects we usually ignore at the tree level. It’s about pushing the precision boundary on Higgs physics.

Lev: For a listener, it means taking a standard prediction and adding the small corrections from virtual particles moving around in loops. It’s about getting closer to the real measurements from experiments like ATLAS and CMS >

Kai: Right, so it’s not just about finding new particles; it’s about making sure our predictions for the Higgs we already found are super sharp, especially in models like the NMSSM where there are lots of Higgs bosons.

Mira: And the authors are tackling this by going into detail on how to handle these corrections across all sectors—the Higgs, the charginos and neutralinos, and even those squarks. It’s a comprehensive look at the necessary math for high precision >

Lev: I mean, when you get that much detail about renormalization procedures for every single sector, it tells me what’s actually needed to run these calculations on real hardware later >

The paper's summary: Kai: This paper is doing a deep dive into how to calculate the complete next-to-leading order SUSY electroweak corrections for neutral Higgs boson decays in the Complex NMSSM. They are using a specific program called NMSSMCALCEW to do this work.

Mira: They set up the framework by first introducing the tree level stuff, which is what’s relevant for their computation, and then moving into one loop calculations in section three >

Lev: So they’re describing how to handle the renormalization of all those sectors—the Higgs mass mixing, neutralino and chargino masses, and squark masses—while also calculating the loop corrections to all those things >

Kai: The goal here is to get the full set of one-loop corrections for decays into Higgs pairs like H to HH, as well as next-to-leading order SUSY electroweak corrections for decays into all those Standard Model final states >

Mira: And they also include state of the art QCD corrections for any final states that involve colored particles, which is important because we can’t ignore those strong force effects >

Lev: It seems like the core idea they are pushing here is getting a more accurate picture of these branching ratios, even though it’s complicated to implement on a real computer >

Kai: Exactly. The results they present are based on scanning the NMSSM parameter space and comparing things with and without these higher-order corrections to see the relative change in branching ratios >

The paper's improvements: Mira: They show that the relative changes in branching ratios, which they call delta BR SEW plus SQCD, are generally between zero percent and ten percent across most channels, with some cases hitting up to one hundred percent >

Kai: That’s a big number. But they point out that the relative vertex corrections for things like b bar b final states are actually below ten percent, and for decays into tau tau or c bar c, it’s even lower at less than five percent >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that suggests the new implementation is giving us a much tighter handle on these theoretical errors compared to previous versions of the code >

Mira: They also highlight scheme dependence, showing that the on-shell scheme is often more important than dimensional regularization for those decays involving electroweakinos >

Kai: And they mention something specific about the Z H factor. In most cases where there’s a big change in branching ratio, it seems to be primarily due to that wave-function renormalization factor >

Lev: That means we can focus our error analysis on that specific piece of physics, but they also admit that in some rare scenarios, they see a cancellation between the SUSY electroweak and SUSY QCD corrections and the Z H correction >

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "One-Loop Corrections to the Two-Body Decays of the Neutral Higgs Bosons in the Complex NMSSM", it confirms that this new implementation, NMSSMCALCEW, gives us a significantly more accurate description of neutral NMSSM Higgs boson decays >

Mira: The higher-order corrections are really crucial especially when branching ratios are approaching one hundred percent, and they say the largest remaining uncertainty comes from the variation between different renormalization schemes >

Lev: From my side, it’s good to see that we can quantify how much missing physics is left, even if some of that uncertainty is tied to scheme choice >

Kai: So what this means for us is that we have a tool that’s much better for predicting Higgs observables in this complex NMSSM space, which helps us search for new physics at colliders >

Mira: It’s a step forward in precision, and it shows that incorporating these higher-order terms isn't just academic; it really impacts what we can expect from experimental searches >

Lev: I just think having this level of detail on the loop corrections gives us a better roadmap for where to focus our next computational efforts, even if some of that uncertainty is tied to scheme choice >

Julien Baglio, Thi Nhung Dao, Margarete M¨uhlleitner

Institute for Theoretical Physics, Eberhard Karls University T¨ubingen · Institute For Interdisciplinary Research in Science and Education, ICISE · Karlsruhe Institute of Technology

hep-ph

Submitted: 2019-07-28

Updated: 2019-07-28

Comments: 59 pages, 24 figures

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 960

DOI: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-020-08520-8

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: One-Loop Corrections to Two-Body Decays of Neutral Higgs Bosons in Complex NMSSM This research focuses on providing complete next-to-leading order (SUSY-)electroweak corrections to the on-shell and…

Key concepts

Complex NMSSM
This is an extension of the Standard Model that includes supersymmetry but adds complex numbers to certain fields. This framework allows for richer physics, including CP violation, which is important for understanding how Higgs bosons decay and interact.
One-Loop Corrections
These are calculations involving quantum fluctuations where particles briefly pop into existence and then annihilate. The paper calculates these one-loop effects to refine the predictions of Higgs boson decays beyond the simplest tree-level approximations, increasing accuracy.
$Z_H$ Factor
This factor is a wave-function renormalization term that arises in loop corrections. It plays a key role in determining how much the decay rate changes. The paper shows it is often responsible for large relative changes in branching ratios for heavy Higgs bosons.
On-Shell (OS) vs. Dimensional Regularization (DR)
These are different mathematical methods used to handle calculations involving quantum corrections. OS keeps the particle mass fixed, while DR uses a different regularization technique. The paper finds that the choice between these two schemes matters for certain decay channels.

Terminology

Summary

One-Loop Corrections to Two-Body Decays of Neutral Higgs Bosons in Complex NMSSM

This research focuses on providing complete next-to-leading order (SUSY-)electroweak corrections to the on-shell and non-loop induced neutral Higgs boson decays within the framework of the CP-violating Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric extension of the Standard Model (NMSSM). The primary objective is to achieve the highest possible precision for NMSSM Higgs boson decays and branching ratios, thereby enhancing sensitivity in searches for New Physics at current and future colliders. p. 0

Theoretical Framework and Methodology:

The calculations are performed within the complex NMSSM, preserving a Z 3 symmetry at tree level. The work meticulously details the renormalization procedures for the Higgs, chargino/neutralino, and squark sectors, employing a combination of on-shell (OS) and dimensional regularization (DR) schemes. p. 2 Mass matrices for Higgs bosons, neutralinos, and charginos are derived from the NMSSM Lagrangian following Electroweak Symmetry Breaking (EWSB). p. 1

The study encompasses complete one-loop corrections to decays into Higgs boson pairs (H to HH) alongside next-to-leading order (SUSY-)electroweak corrections to decays into all tree-level induced Standard Model final states. p. 1 This includes non-SM pairs such as gauge and Higgs boson final states, chargino and neutralino pairs, and squarks. p. 1 Furthermore, the paper incorporates state-of-the-art QCD corrections for colored final states. p. 0

Implementation and Code Development:

These complex calculations are implemented in a dedicated Fortran code named NMSSMCALCEW, which has been developed to incorporate state-of-the-art QCD corrections alongside the newly calculated SUSY-(EW) corrections. The goal of this new implementation is to provide a more accurate description compared to previous versions (e. p. 0g., NMSSMCALC). p. 0 A key feature of the new code is the inclusion of the Z H factor with full momentum dependence, which renders loop-corrected masses on-shell, addressing limitations in prior versions. p. 1 The code allows users to select specific renormalization schemes for loop-corrected electroweakino masses (OS1, OS2, or DRbar) via options like 'ischhXX' in the input file bhdecay.in.

Key Findings and Results:

The paper presents numerical results derived from scanning the NMSSM parameter space, comparing results with and without these higher-order corrections. The relative change in branching ratios (delta SEW(+ SQCD)(H i to X j X k)) is quantified to demonstrate the impact of the new calculations. p. 0

  • Dominant Decays: For the lightest CP-even Higgs boson (H 1), the dominant decays are into b bar b bar, c c bar, tau tau, and gg.

  • Magnitude of Corrections: The relative changes in branching ratios between the old implementation and the new one are generally found to be between 0% and 10%, with some cases reaching up to 100%. Relative vertex corrections are notably below 10% for b b bar final states and below 5% for decays into tau tau and c c bar. p. 0

  • Scheme Dependence: The analysis highlights the importance of the on-shell scheme (OS) over the dimensional regularization (DR) scheme in certain decay channels, particularly those involving electroweakinos. The relative differences between the Denner and EMT descriptions are found to be at the per mille level for all investigated decays. p. 7

  • Role of Z H Factor: In most cases exhibiting large relative branching ratio changes (delta BR(H i to f f bar)), the effect is primarily attributed to the wave-function renormalization factor (Z H). However, some rare scenarios show a cancellation between SUSY-EW/SUSY-QCD corrections and Z H correction. p. 0

  • Heavy Higgs Bosons: The analysis of heavy Higgs bosons indicates that relative changes in branching ratios are mostly positive and can reach 100% for certain decays, largely driven by the Z H factor in conjunction with NLO electroweak corrections.

  • CP Asymmetry: The CP asymmetry is shown to appear at tree level due to the imaginary part of the WFR factor Z H and tree-level couplings (g i tildeq q tilde*k). Loop corrections to this asymmetry range between 18% and-9% in the OS scheme, while in [the DR scheme] it is 33%. p. 7

Conclusion:

The paper concludes that the new implementation (NMSSMCALCEW) provides a significantly more accurate description of neutral NMSSM Higgs boson decays. The higher-order corrections are crucial, especially in regions where branching ratios approach 100%, and the largest remaining uncertainty is estimated from the variation between different renormalization schemes. p. 1

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Integration of two-loop calculations into NMSSMCALC allows for precision predictions of Higgs boson masses by determining the zeros of the determinant of the two-point function Gamma h (p2). This enables AI systems to predict Higgs boson mass spectra with per mille level accuracy, as shown in Section 3.99.

  2. Implementation of mixed on-shell OS and DR renormalization schemes for the Higgs sector allows AI systems to calculate the complete next-to-leading order (SUSY-)electroweak corrections to the neutral NMSSM Higgs boson decays at the highest possible precision, contributing to searching for New Physics at colliders.

  3. Calculation of loop-corrected fermion masses in both OS1 and OS2 schemes using DR input parameters allows AI systems to determine the loop-corrected masses for the neutralino and charginos, providing a robust framework for analyzing electroweakino sector phenomenology across different renormalization schemes.

  4. The ability to calculate relative changes in branching ratios, such as delta BR(H1ff) = BRSEW(+SQCD)ZH(H1 -> ff) - BRtreeRl(H1 -> ff), allows AI systems to quantify the importance of the improvement of the branching ratios by the Z H factor and the SEW(+SQCD) corrections.

  5. The analysis of relative differences between OS and DR decay widths, delta Gamma = ΓOSZH - ΓDRZH, allows AI systems to assess the reduction of the theoretical error due to missing higher-order corrections when including both QCD and EW corrections.

Sources

Related papers