A Fresh Look at the Calculation of Tunneling Actions including Gravitational Effects
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A Fresh Look at the Calculation of Tunneling Actions including Gravitational Effects".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper extends the calculation of tunneling actions to include gravitational effects by reformulating it as an elementary variational problem in field space, providing a new framework for understanding vacuum decay in cosmological settings and the string landscape The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is "This one-line simple result applies equally to AdS, Minkowski or dS vacua decays and reproduces the Hawking-Moss action in the appropriate cases" Reformulation of Tunneling Action The tunneling action is reformulated as a minimum of a functional SE
Vt: = 6π2 / m4 P ∫ R φ0 φ+ (D + V0 t)2 / (V2 t D)dφ This formalism incorporates gravitational effects into the standard calculation of tunneling actions, which previously relied on solving a differential equation in Euclidean space The action density is modified to include gravitational corrections as s(Vt) ≡ 6π2 κ2 (D + V0 t)2 / V2 t D where D is a generalization of the field derivative that includes gravitational corrections.
Kai: This new formulation is remarkably simple and applies to the decay of any type of vacua, including AdS, Minkowski, or dS vacua.
Mira: Euclidean Bounce in Curved Spacetime The standard Euclidean approach involves solving coupled differential equations for the instanton configuration in the presence of gravity Assuming O(4) symmetry, the most general metric is written as ds2 = gµνdxµ dxν = dξ2 + ρ(ξ)2 domega2/3.
Kai: The instanton action for the decay of the metastable φ+ (false) vacuum is obtained by finding an O(4)-symmetric bounce φb(r) that interpolates between the false vacuum and (the basin of) the true vacuum at φ−.
Paper summary: Kai: So to recap what we just covered, this paper introduces a new way to calculate tunneling actions by treating it as a variational problem in field space and including gravity effects into the action density through this new derivative D.
Mira: They emphasize that the main claim is the remarkable simplicity of this result, because it covers AdS, Minkowski, or dS vacuum decays with one single expression.
Lev: I'm interested in how they handle the geometry here. They reformulate the tunneling action as a minimum of SE of Vt t which involves six pi squared times m to the power of four times something called P R phi zero phi plus D plus V zero t squared over V squared t D dphi <ref:1808.00420#pg1>.
Kai: And that D is defined as something like the square root of (V zero t squared plus six times V minus Vt times Vt over m to the power of two) divided by one over two, which is a generalization of the field derivative.
Mira: The paper also discusses how this new formulation connects to the standard bounce method through an Euler-Lagrange equation that defines this tunneling potential Vt t.
Lev: They show that in some cases, like Minkowski and AdS vacua decays, the difference between this new action and the old bounce action is finite because the divergent parts cancel out when you regulate them correctly.
Kai: But for dS vacua, they extend Vt t outside of its instanton field range to show an equality between S of Vt t and the SE difference, reproducing that Hawking-Moss action in that limit.
Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the title, "A Fresh Look at the Calculation of Tunneling Actions including Gravitational Effects," it really suggests they are offering a new lens for looking at how these decays happen when gravity is involved.
Kai: I think what's interesting is that they didn't just tweak the old method; they completely reformulated it as an elementary variational problem in field space, which simplifies the whole setup.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you were trying to run simulations for this on real hardware, knowing that it applies universally across AdS, Minkowski, and dS vacua is useful because you don't have to build separate setups for each case.
Mira: The authors are basically saying that this approach reduces the problem to a similar variational one in field space without needing an auxiliary Euclidean space calculation.
Kai: It's powerful because it shows how you can calculate tunneling actions purely in field space, which is much cleaner than relying on an auxiliary Euclidean space setup.
Lev: They also show how the gravitational quenching of vacuum decay happens when you require that the derivative D should be real for some potentials, which translates into a specific inequality involving V plus zero and Vt t.
Mira: It sounds like the main implication is that this new formalism offers a universal formula for calculating tunneling actions across all these different cosmological settings.
Institut de Física d’Altes Energies (IFAE) · ICREA · Instituto de Física Teórica UAM/CSIC
hep-th, hep-ph
Submitted: 2018-08-01
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: 12 pages in double-column format. 8 figures. Small changes, errata fixed
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 104007 (2019)
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevD.100.104007
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 89/100
The gist: The paper extends the calculation of tunneling actions to include gravitational effects by reformulating it as an elementary variational problem in field space…
Key concepts
- Tunneling Action Reformulation
- The tunneling action is rewritten as a minimum of a functional SE[Vt] involving the field derivative D, which now includes gravitational corrections. This changes the standard calculation from solving differential equations in Euclidean space to minimizing this new functional directly in field space.
- Gravitational Corrections (s(Vt))
- The action density is modified to include gravitational effects via s(Vt) ≡ 6π² κ² (D + V₀ t)² / V² t D. This modification accounts for how gravity influences the tunneling process, making the formulation more general than previous methods.
- Tunneling Potential (Vt)
- An auxiliary function, Vt(φ), is introduced, defined as Vt(φ) ≡ V (φ) − 1/2 φ˙²b. This potential has properties similar to those in prior works and connects the new formulation to the standard bounce method through an Euler-Lagrange equation.
- Hawking-Moss Action Reproduction
- In the dS case, extending Vt outside its instanton range allows for an equality S[Vt] = ∆SE, which reproduces the Hawking-Moss action. This demonstrates that the new universal formula captures key results from standard gravitational tunneling calculations in specific cosmological settings.
Terminology
Summary
The paper extends the calculation of tunneling actions to include gravitational effects by reformulating it as an elementary variational problem in field space, providing a new framework for understanding vacuum decay in cosmological settings and the string landscape The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is This one-line simple result applies equally to AdS, Minkowski or dS vacua decays and reproduces the Hawking-Moss action in the appropriate cases
Reformulation of Tunneling Action
The tunneling action is reformulated as a minimum of a functional SE[Vt] = 6π2 / m4 P ∫ R φ0 φ+ (D + V0 t)2 / (V2 t D)dφ This formalism incorporates gravitational effects into the standard calculation of tunneling actions, which previously relied on solving a differential equation in Euclidean space The action density is modified to include gravitational corrections as s(Vt) ≡ 6π2 κ2 (D + V0 t)2 / V2 t D where D is a generalization of the field derivative that includes gravitational corrections. This new formulation is remarkably simple and applies to the decay of any type of vacua, including AdS, Minkowski, or dS vacua. p. 0
Euclidean Bounce in Curved Spacetime
The standard Euclidean approach involves solving coupled differential equations for the instanton configuration in the presence of gravity Assuming O(4) symmetry, the most general metric is written as ds2 = gµνdxµ dxν = dξ2 + ρ(ξ)2 domega2/3. The instanton action for the decay of the metastable φ+ (false) vacuum is obtained by finding an O(4)-symmetric bounce φb(r) that interpolates between the false vacuum and (the basin of) the true vacuum at φ−. p. 1 The Euclidean action SE[φ] is given by SE[φ] = Z ∫ d4x √g 1/2 gµν∂µφ∂νφ + V (φ) − R2κ / 2 + SGHY. p. 2
Tunneling Potential and Field Space Approach
The new method introduces an auxiliary function, Vt(φ), the ‘tunneling potential’, defined as Vt(φ) ≡ V (φ) − 1/2 φ˙2b. The properties of Vt(φ) are nearly the same as in previous works, such as being monotonic for non-compact bounces. p. 3 The connection between the new formulation and the standard bounce method is established through an Euler-Lagrange equation that defines Vt. p. 1 This leads to the differential equation (31) which takes the place of (7) in the new formulation of the tunneling problem for Minkowski and AdS vacua. p. 3
Comparison with Standard Results
The new action encapsulates in a single expression the difference of the bounce and background actions of the standard formulation, as shown by S[Vt] = ∆S old E ≡ SE[φb] − SE+. For Minkowski and AdS decays, this difference is found to be finite because the divergent contributions from the bounce action and background action cancel out when regulated appropriately. p. 2 In the dS case, an extension of Vt outside the instanton field range allows for an equality S[Vt] = ∆SE, reproducing the Hawking-Moss action in that limit. p. 4
Thin-Wall Limit and Gravitational Quenching
In the thin-wall limit, an analytical expression for the tunneling action can be obtained in terms of the wall tension σ [5, 7]. The gravitational quenching of vacuum decay can be understood as the impossibility of finding tunneling paths with real D for some potentials. p. 6 This condition is expressed by the inequality ∆V+0 ≡ V+ − V0 ≥ Z φ0 φ+ p6κ(V − Vt)(−Vt) dφ. p. 6 The critical value for decay being forbidden is determined by the requirement that D should be real, which translates into the inequality-V0√ t-Vt > p6κ(V − Vt). p. 9
Conclusion on Method Utility
The new approach is complementary to the bounce method and can be most useful not only in numerical applications but also in gaining theoretical insight in particular problems where such insight is more difficult to gather from the standard approach. It shows how to calculate tunneling actions purely in field space without reference to an auxiliary Euclidean space, reducing the problem to a similar variational problem with just a slightly more complicated action density. p. 6 The simplicity of this prescription is remarkable as it encompasses decays from all types of vacua in a single universal formula and reproduces the Hawking-Moss exponent in the appropriate limit. p. 7
References
[1] J.R. Espinosa, JCAP 07 (2018) 36, [hep-th/1805. p. 903680]
[2] S.R. Coleman, Phys. p. 9 Rev. D 15 (1977) 2929 Erratum: [Phys. p. 9 Rev. D 16 (1977) 1248]
[3] J. R. Espinosa and T. p. 9 Konstandin, JCAP 1901 (2019) 01, 051 [hep-th/1811. p. 909185]
[4] G.W. Gibbons and S. p. 2W. Hawking, Phys. p. 9 Rev. D 15 (1977) 2752; J. p. 9 W. York, Jr., Phys. Rev. Lett. 28 (1972) 1082
[5] S.R. Coleman and F. p. 0 De Luccia, Phys. p. 9 Rev. D 21 (1980) 3305
[6] S.W. Hawking and I. p. 0G. Moss, Phys Lett 110B (1982) 35
[7] E. J. Weinberg, “Classical solutions in quantum field theory: Solitons and Instantons in High Energy Physics,” Cambridge University Press, 2012
[8] J.C. Hackworth and E. p. 9J. Weinberg, Phys Rev D 71 (2005) 044014 [hep-th/0410142]
[9] G.H. Derrick, J Math Phys 5 (1964) 1252
[10] A.R. Brown and E. p. 9J. Weinberg, Phys Rev D 76 (2007) 064003 [hep-th/1811. p. 99999]
[11] X. Dong and D. p. 9 Harlow, JCAP 1111 (2013) 044 [hep-th/2307. p. 9xxxx]
[13] D. Poole and W. p. 9 Hereman, App Analysis 89 (2015) 433
[14] A. Masoumi, S. p. 9 Paban and E. p. 9 J. Weinberg, Phys Rev D 94 (2016) 2, 025023 [hep-th/1603. p. 9xxxx]
[15] J.R. Espinosa, J. p. 9F Fortin and M. p. 7 Tr´epanier, Phys Rev D 93 (2016) 12, 124067 [hep-th/1508. p. 9xxxx]
[16] A.R. Brown, Phys Rev D 97 (2018) 10, 105002 [hep-th/xxxx] <ref:1808. p. 9
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
AI system can calculate tunneling actions including gravitational effects by solving a simple variational problem in field space using a single functional SE[Vt]. This allows for fast and flexible numerical estimation of tunneling actions, including multifield potentials.
-
The system can generate potentials that admit analytic solutions to the tunneling problem by employing the new formulation in reverse gear to find Vt from a simple potential V.
-
AI systems can determine the Euclidean bounce action SE[phi] for vacuum decay in AdS, Minkowski, or dS vacua by solving coupled differential equations derived from Einstein's equations and the O(4)-symmetric metric.
-
The system can calculate the tunneling exponent DeltaSE using two different forms of the action, SE1 and SE2, which are shown to be equal for Minkowski and AdS decays.
-
AI systems can estimate the Hawking-Moss action by evaluating a specific case where Vt is very flat, showing how it relates to the non-instanton piece of the tunneling action.
-
The system can calculate the thin-wall limit of the tunneling action Stw, providing an analytical expression in terms of wall tension sigma and potential differences.
-
The AI can predict when vacuum decay is forbidden by checking if a condition derived from real D imposes constraints on V0t and Vt, specifically that
D should be real.
-
The system can determine the critical value kappa c for gravitational quenching, which is found by requiring the inequality-V0sqrt t-Vt > p6kappa(V-Vt) to hold.
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions