Causal Inference with Missing Exposures and Missing Outcomes

summary

The gist

Missing data are ubiquitous in public health research When estimating causal effects, there are well-established methods to address bias to due missing outcomes The authors demonstrate how this…

In short

The authors extended causal inference methods to handle missing data in both exposures and outcomes. They introduced Counterfactual Strata Effects for populations affected by missingness or exposure, such as persons at risk. Using TMLE with Super Learner, they demonstrated robust estimation of these effects, showing minimal bias in simulations and real-world analysis.

Key concepts

Counterfactual Strata Effects
This is a type of causal question focusing on a specific group—the 'stratum'—that is either missing data or directly influenced by the exposure. It allows researchers to estimate the effect of an exposure on this particular sub-population, like people who are at risk for an outcome.
TMLE with Super Learner
This is a statistical method used to estimate causal effects. TMLE is a doubly robust procedure, meaning it provides reliable estimates even if some assumptions are slightly wrong. Combining it with Super Learner enhances its ability to handle complex data structures and improve accuracy in estimation.
Missingness DAGs
Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) are diagrams used to map out the relationships between variables in a study, especially when data is missing. These graphs help researchers identify potential sources of bias and determine if a causal effect can be reliably identified, guiding how to handle missing information.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Causal Inference with Missing Exposures and Missing Outcomes · Read on arXiv

Kirsten E. Landsiedel, Rachel Abbott, Atukunda Mucunguzi, Florence Mwangwa, Elijah Kakande, Edwin D. Charlebois, Carina Marquez, Moses R. Kamya†,∗, Laura B. Balzer

School of Public Health, University of California Berkeley · Division of HIV, Infectious Diseases and Global Medicine at University of California San Francisco Division of HIV Infectious Diseases and Global Medicine at University of California San Francisco Infectious Diseases Research Collaboration in Kampala Uganda Center for AIDS Prevention at University of California San Francisco Department of Medicine Makerere University in Kampala Uganda

Missing data are ubiquitous in public health research. When estimating causal effects, there are well-established methods to address bias to due missing outcomes. Commonly, causal estimands are defined under hypothetical interventions to "set" the exposure and to prevent missingness. We demonstrate how this framework can be extended to missing exposures. We further extend this framework to incorporate missingness on the baseline outcome, which induces missingness on the population of interest (e.g., persons at-risk). To do so, we highlight Counterfactual Strata Effects, a general class of causal estimands where the focus population is subject to missingness and/or impacted by the exposure. They are termed such because the estimand involves conditioning on a counterfactual variable.For each setting, we present the causal model, relevant counterfactuals, causal estimand, and identification result. We demonstrate with a real-data example to investigate the effect of alcohol consumption on the risk of incident tuberculosis (TB) infection in rural Uganda. We highlight the use of TMLE with Super Learner for estimation and inference and discuss the practical consequences of our approach.

DOI: 10.1093/aje/kwag281

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Statistics. The day in statistics: methods, theory and the inference under them.

Tom: I'm Tom.

Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Causal Inference with Missing Exposures and Missing Outcomes".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Missing data are ubiquitous in public health research When estimating causal effects, there are well-established methods to address bias to due missing outcomes The authors demonstrate how this framework can be extended to missing exposures.

Tom: They further extend this framework to incorporate missingness on the baseline outcome, which induces missingness on the population of interest (e.g., persons at-risk).

Jane: To do so, they highlight Counterfactual Strata Effects, a general class of causal estimands where the focus population is subject to missingness and/or impacted by the exposure.

Tom: Framework Extension The standard Causal Roadmap framework can be extended to address multi-source missingness in real-world (i.e., observational) settings.

Paper summary: Tom: This paper, "Causal Inference with Missing Exposures and Missing Outcomes," points out that missing data is everywhere in public health research. They show a framework to address bias when you're missing both the cause and the effect of something.

Jane: They extend methods already used for missing outcomes—where you don't know the final result—to include when the exposure itself is missing, which happens often in real-world studies.

Lu: The core idea they highlight is these Counterfactual Strata Effects, which is a general class of causal estimands where the focus population might be missing or directly affected by the exposure.

Meng: So what's the big claim here? They show how this framework can be applied to real data, specifically looking at alcohol use and incident tuberculosis infection in rural Uganda.

Tom: The paper uses this real-data example to investigate the effect of alcohol consumption on incident TB, highlighting that they use TMLE with Super Learner for their estimation.

Jane: That specific finding shows the method works in practice by giving a concrete number, but we have to remember they also admit their study design had some limitations.

Lu: They specifically note that their test focused on observational studies and didn't use multiple imputation, which is a very common way to fill in missing values when you're dealing with data.

Meng: So the simulation study confirms the theory works well, but they acknowledge that it doesn't solve all real-world data messiness by itself.

Tom: It’s a strong theoretical extension of how we define causal questions when data is messy, so now we need to see how robust these estimators actually are when you run them against messy production data.

Conclusion: Tom: So, looking at "Causal Inference with Missing Exposures and Missing Outcomes," the authors show us a way to find cause and effect even when you're missing data on both what caused it and what happened to it.

Jane: They take established ways of handling missing outcomes—like when you don't know the final result—and they stretch that method out to include missing exposures too, which is a major headache in real health research.

Meng: For someone shipping models, this means they give you a statistical way to define the effect even when there's that missing piece of information in your data stream.

Tom: They tested this with alcohol use and tuberculosis infection in Uganda, finding a specific risk increase of one point four nine for the risk ratio.

Jane: That specific result shows the method works in practice, giving us a concrete number for an intervention study, but we also saw some limitations in their study design itself.

Lu: Right, they admit that their test focused on observational studies and didn't use multiple imputation, which is a very common way to fill in missing values when you're dealing with data.

Tom: It’s a strong theoretical extension of how we define causal questions when data is messy, so now we need to look at how robust these estimators actually are when you run them against messy production data.

More episodes

← Home